From 8fcbcf5b98a5c32c538fdf233b648624925002d2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "github-actions[bot]" Date: Sun, 26 Jul 2026 07:16:58 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 1/5] feat(ggplot2): implement swarm-basic --- plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R | 102 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 102 insertions(+) create mode 100644 plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R diff --git a/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..975b34e076 --- /dev/null +++ b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +#' anyplot.ai +#' swarm-basic: Basic Swarm Plot +#' Library: ggplot2 | R 4.4 +#' Quality: pending | Created: 2026-07-26 + +library(ggplot2) +library(dplyr) +library(ragg) +library(scales) + +set.seed(42) + +# --- Theme tokens ------------------------------------------------------------ +THEME <- Sys.getenv("ANYPLOT_THEME", "light") +PAGE_BG <- if (THEME == "light") "#FAF8F1" else "#1A1A17" +INK <- if (THEME == "light") "#1A1A17" else "#F0EFE8" +INK_SOFT <- if (THEME == "light") "#4A4A44" else "#B8B7B0" +IMPRINT_PALETTE <- c("#009E73", "#C475FD", "#4467A3", "#BD8233", + "#AE3030", "#2ABCCD", "#954477", "#99B314") + +# --- Data ---------------------------------------------------------------- +# Reaction times across a cognitive-load experiment (psychology research) +conditions <- c("Baseline", "Low Load", "High Load", "Time Pressure") +means <- c(420, 460, 540, 580) +sds <- c(45, 50, 65, 70) +n_per_condition <- 45 + +reaction_df <- bind_rows(lapply(seq_along(conditions), function(i) { + tibble::tibble( + condition = conditions[i], + reaction_time = rnorm(n_per_condition, mean = means[i], sd = sds[i]) + ) +})) %>% + mutate(condition = factor(condition, levels = conditions)) + +# --- Swarm layout ---------------------------------------------------------- +# Bin observations along the value axis, then rank within each bin so +# points that fall close in value are spread symmetrically around the +# category's center line - a lightweight beeswarm approximation built +# entirely from geom_point (ggplot2 has no native beeswarm geom). +bin_width <- diff(range(reaction_df$reaction_time)) / 24 +point_spacing <- 0.05 +max_offset <- 0.42 + +reaction_df <- reaction_df %>% + mutate(value_bin = round(reaction_time / bin_width)) %>% + group_by(condition, value_bin) %>% + mutate( + bin_rank = rank(reaction_time, ties.method = "first"), + bin_n = n(), + x_offset = pmin(pmax((bin_rank - (bin_n + 1) / 2) * point_spacing, -max_offset), max_offset) + ) %>% + ungroup() %>% + mutate(condition_x = as.numeric(condition) + x_offset) + +condition_means <- reaction_df %>% + group_by(condition) %>% + summarise(mean_rt = mean(reaction_time), x_pos = as.numeric(condition[1]), .groups = "drop") + +# --- Plot ------------------------------------------------------------------ +p <- ggplot(reaction_df, aes(x = condition_x, y = reaction_time)) + + geom_point(aes(color = condition), size = 2.6, alpha = 0.85) + + geom_point( + data = condition_means, + aes(x = x_pos, y = mean_rt), + shape = 18, size = 3.4, color = INK, alpha = 0.9 + ) + + scale_color_manual(values = IMPRINT_PALETTE[seq_along(conditions)], guide = "none") + + scale_x_continuous( + breaks = seq_along(conditions), + labels = conditions, + expand = expansion(mult = c(0.1, 0.1)) + ) + + labs( + title = "swarm-basic · r · ggplot2 · anyplot.ai", + x = "Experimental Condition", + y = "Reaction Time (ms)" + ) + + theme_minimal(base_size = 8) + + theme( + plot.background = element_rect(fill = PAGE_BG, color = PAGE_BG), + panel.background = element_rect(fill = PAGE_BG, color = NA), + panel.grid.major.x = element_blank(), + panel.grid.minor = element_blank(), + panel.grid.major.y = element_line(color = scales::alpha(INK, 0.15), linewidth = 0.3), + axis.title = element_text(color = INK, size = 10), + axis.text = element_text(color = INK_SOFT, size = 8), + axis.ticks = element_blank(), + axis.line = element_line(color = INK_SOFT, linewidth = 0.3), + plot.title = element_text(color = INK, size = 12) + ) + +# --- Save -------------------------------------------------------------- +ggsave( + filename = sprintf("plot-%s.png", THEME), + plot = p, + device = ragg::agg_png, + width = 8, + height = 4.5, + units = "in", + dpi = 400 +) From 49e5cf69c94fcd3b79786c5798cc972c840f3bf4 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "github-actions[bot]" Date: Sun, 26 Jul 2026 07:17:07 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 2/5] chore(ggplot2): add metadata for swarm-basic --- plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml | 21 +++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 21 insertions(+) create mode 100644 plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml diff --git a/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml b/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0c9b8dcc46 --- /dev/null +++ b/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +# Per-library metadata for ggplot2 implementation of swarm-basic +# Auto-generated by impl-generate.yml + +library: ggplot2 +language: r +specification_id: swarm-basic +created: '2026-07-26T07:17:07Z' +updated: '2026-07-26T07:17:07Z' +generated_by: claude-sonnet +workflow_run: 30192366615 +issue: 974 +language_version: 4.4.1 +library_version: 3.5.1 +preview_url_light: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/swarm-basic/r/ggplot2/plot-light.png +preview_url_dark: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/swarm-basic/r/ggplot2/plot-dark.png +preview_html_light: null +preview_html_dark: null +quality_score: null +review: + strengths: [] + weaknesses: [] From 719f0224ea6c52a96c3cb38cb9a42b5fc3f1ce7a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "github-actions[bot]" Date: Sun, 26 Jul 2026 07:22:22 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 3/5] chore(ggplot2): update quality score 87 and review feedback for swarm-basic --- plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R | 4 +- plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml | 241 +++++++++++++++++- 2 files changed, 236 insertions(+), 9 deletions(-) diff --git a/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R index 975b34e076..c5c549e72d 100644 --- a/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R +++ b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ #' anyplot.ai #' swarm-basic: Basic Swarm Plot -#' Library: ggplot2 | R 4.4 -#' Quality: pending | Created: 2026-07-26 +#' Library: ggplot2 3.5.1 | R 4.4.1 +#' Quality: 87/100 | Created: 2026-07-26 library(ggplot2) library(dplyr) diff --git a/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml b/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml index 0c9b8dcc46..dc40793f40 100644 --- a/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml +++ b/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml @@ -1,11 +1,8 @@ -# Per-library metadata for ggplot2 implementation of swarm-basic -# Auto-generated by impl-generate.yml - library: ggplot2 language: r specification_id: swarm-basic created: '2026-07-26T07:17:07Z' -updated: '2026-07-26T07:17:07Z' +updated: '2026-07-26T07:22:22Z' generated_by: claude-sonnet workflow_run: 30192366615 issue: 974 @@ -15,7 +12,237 @@ preview_url_light: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/swarm-bas preview_url_dark: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/swarm-basic/r/ggplot2/plot-dark.png preview_html_light: null preview_html_dark: null -quality_score: null +quality_score: 87 review: - strengths: [] - weaknesses: [] + strengths: + - Custom-built swarm/beeswarm approximation (value-binning + rank-based symmetric + x-offset) — a genuine technical achievement given ggplot2 has no native beeswarm + geom, and the code comments explain the approach clearly. + - Correct Imprint palette usage in canonical order across the 4 categories, with + theme-adaptive chrome (backgrounds, ink tokens) correctly threaded through both + light and dark renders. + - Per-category mean markers (diamond shape) directly answer the spec's suggestion + to add a mean/median indicator, and correctly recolor for theme (dark ink on light + bg, light ink on dark bg). + - Clean, KISS-structured single-pass code, reproducible via set.seed(42), correct + ragg::agg_png device and plot-{THEME}.png output naming. + - Realistic, neutral psychology reaction-time dataset with a clear, monotonically + increasing difficulty narrative across the four experimental conditions. + weaknesses: + - Overlapping same-color points in dense clusters (e.g. Low Load ~470-500ms, High + Load ~508-555ms) blend into solid bands because markers have no edge/stroke. Add + a subtle stroke (e.g. shape=21, fill=condition color, color=PAGE_BG or 'white', + stroke~0.3) so individual points stay visually separated in dense regions, per + the style guide's overlapping-marker guidance. + - At n=45 points per condition (just under the 'sparse <50' threshold), marker size + (2.6) only matches the medium-density default. Bump to ~3.0-3.2 combined with + the edge stroke above for more prominence per the data-density heuristic. + - No visual connector or annotation makes the increasing-reaction-time trend across + conditions explicit beyond the diamond mean markers — a subtle mean-to-mean guide + line or brief callout would sharpen the data storytelling. + image_description: |- + Light render (plot-light.png): + Background: Warm off-white, matches #FAF8F1 — not pure white. + Chrome: Title "swarm-basic · r · ggplot2 · anyplot.ai" in dark ink top-left, axis titles "Experimental Condition" (x) and "Reaction Time (ms)" (y) in dark ink, tick labels in a softer dark-grey ink, thin horizontal grid lines only, L-shaped axis line at bottom/left. All text is clearly readable against the light background. + Data: Four swarm clusters (Baseline, Low Load, High Load, Time Pressure) colored in Imprint order — green (#009E73), lavender (#C475FD), blue (#4467A3), ochre (#BD8233) — with a black diamond mean marker per cluster. Points are round, semi-transparent, and clearly visible against the cream background; reaction times visibly increase left to right across conditions. + Legibility verdict: PASS + + Dark render (plot-dark.png): + Background: Warm near-black, matches #1A1A17 — not pure black. + Chrome: Same title and axis titles now in light/near-white ink, tick labels in a lighter soft grey, grid lines subtle and still visible against the dark surface. No dark-on-dark or light-on-light failures observed — all text is legible. + Data: Same four cluster colors as the light render (green, lavender, blue, ochre) — confirmed identical hex data colors between themes. The mean diamond marker correctly flips from black (light theme) to white (dark theme) to stay visible against the darker background. + Legibility verdict: PASS + criteria_checklist: + visual_quality: + score: 26 + max: 30 + items: + - id: VQ-01 + name: Text Legibility + score: 7 + max: 8 + passed: true + comment: All text explicitly sized and readable in both themes; no overlap + with data + - id: VQ-02 + name: No Overlap + score: 4 + max: 6 + passed: true + comment: Text does not overlap, but same-color markers without an edge stroke + blend into solid bands in the densest value bins (e.g. High Load ~508-555ms) + - id: VQ-03 + name: Element Visibility + score: 5 + max: 6 + passed: true + comment: Markers and mean diamonds clearly visible; size (2.6) is only the + medium-density default for n=45 per group, just under the sparse threshold + - id: VQ-04 + name: Color Accessibility + score: 2 + max: 2 + passed: true + comment: Adequate contrast, no red-green-only encoding, redundant with x-position + - id: VQ-05 + name: Layout & Canvas + score: 4 + max: 4 + passed: true + comment: Correct 3200x1800 canvas, balanced margins, nothing clipped + - id: VQ-06 + name: Axis Labels & Title + score: 2 + max: 2 + passed: true + comment: Descriptive axis titles with units (ms) + - id: VQ-07 + name: Palette Compliance + score: 2 + max: 2 + passed: true + comment: Canonical Imprint order, correct theme-adaptive backgrounds in both + renders + design_excellence: + score: 13 + max: 20 + items: + - id: DE-01 + name: Aesthetic Sophistication + score: 6 + max: 8 + passed: true + comment: Custom beeswarm-approximation layout and mean markers show above-default + craft + - id: DE-02 + name: Visual Refinement + score: 3 + max: 6 + passed: true + comment: Spines/grid subtle and minimal, but missing recommended white/bg + edge stroke on overlapping markers + - id: DE-03 + name: Data Storytelling + score: 4 + max: 6 + passed: true + comment: Clear increasing-difficulty trend and mean markers, but no explicit + connector/annotation reinforcing it + spec_compliance: + score: 15 + max: 15 + items: + - id: SC-01 + name: Plot Type + score: 5 + max: 5 + passed: true + comment: Faithful swarm/beeswarm approximation + - id: SC-02 + name: Required Features + score: 4 + max: 4 + passed: true + comment: Consistent point sizes, mean markers, color-coded categories, clear + spacing + - id: SC-03 + name: Data Mapping + score: 3 + max: 3 + passed: true + comment: Category on x, reaction time on y, all points shown + - id: SC-04 + name: Title & Legend + score: 3 + max: 3 + passed: true + comment: Correct mandated title format; legend correctly omitted as redundant + with x-axis category labels + data_quality: + score: 15 + max: 15 + items: + - id: DQ-01 + name: Feature Coverage + score: 6 + max: 6 + passed: true + comment: Individual points, distribution shape via swarm spread, and mean + markers all present + - id: DQ-02 + name: Realistic Context + score: 5 + max: 5 + passed: true + comment: Plausible, neutral cognitive-load reaction-time experiment + - id: DQ-03 + name: Appropriate Scale + score: 4 + max: 4 + passed: true + comment: Reaction times and spreads are realistic for the domain + code_quality: + score: 10 + max: 10 + items: + - id: CQ-01 + name: KISS Structure + score: 3 + max: 3 + passed: true + comment: No functions/classes, single linear pipeline + - id: CQ-02 + name: Reproducibility + score: 2 + max: 2 + passed: true + comment: set.seed(42) + - id: CQ-03 + name: Clean Imports + score: 2 + max: 2 + passed: true + comment: ggplot2, dplyr, ragg, scales all actually used + - id: CQ-04 + name: Code Elegance + score: 2 + max: 2 + passed: true + comment: Appropriate complexity for a manual beeswarm layout, no fake UI + - id: CQ-05 + name: Output & API + score: 1 + max: 1 + passed: true + comment: ggsave with ragg::agg_png and plot-{THEME}.png naming + library_mastery: + score: 8 + max: 10 + items: + - id: LM-01 + name: Idiomatic Usage + score: 4 + max: 5 + passed: true + comment: Standard dplyr/ggplot2 grammar throughout + - id: LM-02 + name: Distinctive Features + score: 4 + max: 5 + passed: true + comment: Hand-built value-binning beeswarm approximation is a distinctive + workaround for ggplot2's missing native geom + verdict: APPROVED +impl_tags: + dependencies: [] + techniques: + - layer-composition + - manual-ticks + patterns: + - data-generation + - groupby-aggregation + - iteration-over-groups + dataprep: + - binning + styling: + - alpha-blending From 781a879b074c85b3783d874f701ae2157a2490ef Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "github-actions[bot]" Date: Sun, 26 Jul 2026 07:24:51 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 4/5] fix(ggplot2): address review feedback for swarm-basic Attempt 1/4 - fixes based on AI review --- plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R | 13 ++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 10 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R index c5c549e72d..fcdb8b2fa0 100644 --- a/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R +++ b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R @@ -1,7 +1,6 @@ #' anyplot.ai #' swarm-basic: Basic Swarm Plot #' Library: ggplot2 3.5.1 | R 4.4.1 -#' Quality: 87/100 | Created: 2026-07-26 library(ggplot2) library(dplyr) @@ -59,13 +58,21 @@ condition_means <- reaction_df %>% # --- Plot ------------------------------------------------------------------ p <- ggplot(reaction_df, aes(x = condition_x, y = reaction_time)) + - geom_point(aes(color = condition), size = 2.6, alpha = 0.85) + + geom_point( + aes(fill = condition), shape = 21, size = 3.1, stroke = 0.3, + color = PAGE_BG, alpha = 0.85 + ) + + geom_line( + data = condition_means, + aes(x = x_pos, y = mean_rt), + color = scales::alpha(INK, 0.4), linewidth = 0.5, linetype = "dashed" + ) + geom_point( data = condition_means, aes(x = x_pos, y = mean_rt), shape = 18, size = 3.4, color = INK, alpha = 0.9 ) + - scale_color_manual(values = IMPRINT_PALETTE[seq_along(conditions)], guide = "none") + + scale_fill_manual(values = IMPRINT_PALETTE[seq_along(conditions)], guide = "none") + scale_x_continuous( breaks = seq_along(conditions), labels = conditions, From 2c64fdb6f3bc89290bc4d8357f0a56caf8aa5201 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "github-actions[bot]" Date: Sun, 26 Jul 2026 07:31:37 +0000 Subject: [PATCH 5/5] chore(ggplot2): update quality score 84 and review feedback for swarm-basic --- plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R | 1 + plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml | 168 +++++++++--------- 2 files changed, 89 insertions(+), 80 deletions(-) diff --git a/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R index fcdb8b2fa0..fd486ebb0a 100644 --- a/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R +++ b/plots/swarm-basic/implementations/r/ggplot2.R @@ -1,6 +1,7 @@ #' anyplot.ai #' swarm-basic: Basic Swarm Plot #' Library: ggplot2 3.5.1 | R 4.4.1 +#' Quality: 84/100 | Created: 2026-07-26 library(ggplot2) library(dplyr) diff --git a/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml b/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml index dc40793f40..41c11d7a7e 100644 --- a/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml +++ b/plots/swarm-basic/metadata/r/ggplot2.yaml @@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ library: ggplot2 language: r specification_id: swarm-basic created: '2026-07-26T07:17:07Z' -updated: '2026-07-26T07:22:22Z' +updated: '2026-07-26T07:31:37Z' generated_by: claude-sonnet workflow_run: 30192366615 issue: 974 @@ -12,49 +12,52 @@ preview_url_light: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/swarm-bas preview_url_dark: https://storage.googleapis.com/anyplot-images/plots/swarm-basic/r/ggplot2/plot-dark.png preview_html_light: null preview_html_dark: null -quality_score: 87 +quality_score: 84 review: strengths: - - Custom-built swarm/beeswarm approximation (value-binning + rank-based symmetric - x-offset) — a genuine technical achievement given ggplot2 has no native beeswarm - geom, and the code comments explain the approach clearly. - - Correct Imprint palette usage in canonical order across the 4 categories, with - theme-adaptive chrome (backgrounds, ink tokens) correctly threaded through both - light and dark renders. - - Per-category mean markers (diamond shape) directly answer the spec's suggestion - to add a mean/median indicator, and correctly recolor for theme (dark ink on light - bg, light ink on dark bg). - - Clean, KISS-structured single-pass code, reproducible via set.seed(42), correct - ragg::agg_png device and plot-{THEME}.png output naming. - - Realistic, neutral psychology reaction-time dataset with a clear, monotonically - increasing difficulty narrative across the four experimental conditions. + - Clever custom beeswarm layout built entirely from geom_point (bin the value axis, + then rank and symmetrically offset points within each bin) since ggplot2 has no + native beeswarm geom — a genuine library-mastery technique. + - 'Imprint palette applied correctly in canonical order with first series #009E73; + theme-adaptive chrome (background, ink, grid) flips correctly between light and + dark while data colors stay identical.' + - 'Strong spec compliance: correct title format, descriptive axis labels with units, + per-category mean markers, clear spacing between category groups, and a realistic + psychology reaction-time dataset with plausible escalating means across cognitive-load + conditions.' + - Correct 3200×1800 canvas, theme_minimal with spines/heavy grid stripped, generous + whitespace, and explicit font sizes throughout. weaknesses: - - Overlapping same-color points in dense clusters (e.g. Low Load ~470-500ms, High - Load ~508-555ms) blend into solid bands because markers have no edge/stroke. Add - a subtle stroke (e.g. shape=21, fill=condition color, color=PAGE_BG or 'white', - stroke~0.3) so individual points stay visually separated in dense regions, per - the style guide's overlapping-marker guidance. - - At n=45 points per condition (just under the 'sparse <50' threshold), marker size - (2.6) only matches the medium-density default. Bump to ~3.0-3.2 combined with - the edge stroke above for more prominence per the data-density heuristic. - - No visual connector or annotation makes the increasing-reaction-time trend across - conditions explicit beyond the diamond mean markers — a subtle mean-to-mean guide - line or brief callout would sharpen the data storytelling. + - The dashed mean-trend connector (geom_line over condition_means, color = scales::alpha(INK, + 0.4)) does not render at all in either theme — pixel-level inspection of both + PNGs found zero line pixels anywhere between the four mean-diamond markers, only + the diamonds themselves are visible. This is dead/non-functional code; either + fix the rendering (verify the 8-digit alpha hex string is honoured by the ragg + device, check the layer isn't being clipped or dropped) or remove the geom_line + layer entirely since the diamond markers alone already satisfy the spec's 'subtle + mean marker' note. + - Points overlap fairly densely in the Low Load / High Load / Time Pressure clusters + at fill alpha 0.85, making some individual observations hard to distinguish at + the busiest bins — slightly smaller point_spacing increments or a touch more alpha + reduction would improve separation. + - No legend for the categorical fill (guide = "none") — acceptable here since x-axis + tick labels already identify each category, but worth confirming this is the intended + encoding rather than leftover from copying a legend-bearing pattern. image_description: |- Light render (plot-light.png): - Background: Warm off-white, matches #FAF8F1 — not pure white. - Chrome: Title "swarm-basic · r · ggplot2 · anyplot.ai" in dark ink top-left, axis titles "Experimental Condition" (x) and "Reaction Time (ms)" (y) in dark ink, tick labels in a softer dark-grey ink, thin horizontal grid lines only, L-shaped axis line at bottom/left. All text is clearly readable against the light background. - Data: Four swarm clusters (Baseline, Low Load, High Load, Time Pressure) colored in Imprint order — green (#009E73), lavender (#C475FD), blue (#4467A3), ochre (#BD8233) — with a black diamond mean marker per cluster. Points are round, semi-transparent, and clearly visible against the cream background; reaction times visibly increase left to right across conditions. + Background: Warm off-white, matches #FAF8F1 target, not pure white. + Chrome: Title "swarm-basic · r · ggplot2 · anyplot.ai" top-left in dark ink; axis titles "Experimental Condition" (x) and "Reaction Time (ms)" (y) in dark ink; tick labels in soft grey-ink; subtle horizontal gridlines only. All clearly readable against the light background. + Data: Four category swarms (Baseline, Low Load, High Load, Time Pressure) as filled circles with light-background-colored strokes, colors #009E73 (green), #C475FD (lavender), #4467A3 (blue), #BD8233 (ochre) in canonical Imprint order, first series correctly green. A dark diamond mean-marker sits at the center of each swarm. No dashed connector line between the diamonds is visible despite being present in the code (see weaknesses). Legibility verdict: PASS Dark render (plot-dark.png): - Background: Warm near-black, matches #1A1A17 — not pure black. - Chrome: Same title and axis titles now in light/near-white ink, tick labels in a lighter soft grey, grid lines subtle and still visible against the dark surface. No dark-on-dark or light-on-light failures observed — all text is legible. - Data: Same four cluster colors as the light render (green, lavender, blue, ochre) — confirmed identical hex data colors between themes. The mean diamond marker correctly flips from black (light theme) to white (dark theme) to stay visible against the darker background. + Background: Warm near-black, matches #1A1A17 target, not pure black. + Chrome: Same title and axis titles now in light ink (#F0EFE8), tick labels in lighter soft-ink (#B8B7B0), gridlines subtle against the dark background. No dark-on-dark text anywhere — all chrome is clearly legible. + Data: Identical swatch of four colors (#009E73, #C475FD, #4467A3, #BD8233) to the light render, confirming data colors are unchanged between themes; mean diamonds now render as light markers against the dark background (theme-correctly flipped from dark in light mode). Same missing connector line as in the light render. Legibility verdict: PASS criteria_checklist: visual_quality: - score: 26 + score: 24 max: 30 items: - id: VQ-01 @@ -62,49 +65,52 @@ review: score: 7 max: 8 passed: true - comment: All text explicitly sized and readable in both themes; no overlap - with data + comment: Explicit font sizes throughout; all text readable in both themes, + no dark-on-dark or light-on-light. - id: VQ-02 name: No Overlap score: 4 max: 6 passed: true - comment: Text does not overlap, but same-color markers without an edge stroke - blend into solid bands in the densest value bins (e.g. High Load ~508-555ms) + comment: No text collisions; data points overlap noticeably in the denser + High Load / Time Pressure clusters. - id: VQ-03 name: Element Visibility - score: 5 + score: 3 max: 6 - passed: true - comment: Markers and mean diamonds clearly visible; size (2.6) is only the - medium-density default for n=45 per group, just under the sparse threshold + passed: false + comment: Swarm markers and mean diamonds are clearly visible, but the intended + dashed mean-trend connector line does not render at all (confirmed via pixel + inspection of both renders). - id: VQ-04 name: Color Accessibility score: 2 max: 2 passed: true - comment: Adequate contrast, no red-green-only encoding, redundant with x-position + comment: Imprint palette hues are distinct and CVD-safe; no red-green as sole + signal. - id: VQ-05 name: Layout & Canvas score: 4 max: 4 passed: true - comment: Correct 3200x1800 canvas, balanced margins, nothing clipped + comment: Canvas gate passed (3200x1800); title and axis proportions balanced, + nothing cut off. - id: VQ-06 name: Axis Labels & Title score: 2 max: 2 passed: true - comment: Descriptive axis titles with units (ms) + comment: Descriptive axis labels with units (ms). - id: VQ-07 name: Palette Compliance score: 2 max: 2 passed: true - comment: Canonical Imprint order, correct theme-adaptive backgrounds in both - renders + comment: 'First series #009E73, canonical Imprint order, correct theme-adaptive + backgrounds in both renders.' design_excellence: - score: 13 + score: 14 max: 20 items: - id: DE-01 @@ -112,22 +118,23 @@ review: score: 6 max: 8 passed: true - comment: Custom beeswarm-approximation layout and mean markers show above-default - craft + comment: Custom beeswarm binning algorithm and polished diamond mean markers + show real design effort. - id: DE-02 name: Visual Refinement - score: 3 + score: 5 max: 6 passed: true - comment: Spines/grid subtle and minimal, but missing recommended white/bg - edge stroke on overlapping markers + comment: Spines removed, grid limited to subtle horizontal lines, generous + whitespace. - id: DE-03 name: Data Storytelling - score: 4 + score: 3 max: 6 - passed: true - comment: Clear increasing-difficulty trend and mean markers, but no explicit - connector/annotation reinforcing it + passed: false + comment: Escalating trend across conditions is visible from swarm position/color + alone, but the intended trend-connector guide line is invisible, weakening + the storytelling device. spec_compliance: score: 15 max: 15 @@ -137,52 +144,52 @@ review: score: 5 max: 5 passed: true - comment: Faithful swarm/beeswarm approximation + comment: Correct swarm/beeswarm plot via custom binned-offset layout. - id: SC-02 name: Required Features score: 4 max: 4 passed: true - comment: Consistent point sizes, mean markers, color-coded categories, clear - spacing + comment: Per-category mean markers, color-coded categories, clear group spacing, + appropriately sized points. - id: SC-03 name: Data Mapping score: 3 max: 3 passed: true - comment: Category on x, reaction time on y, all points shown + comment: Category on x, reaction time on y, correct and complete. - id: SC-04 name: Title & Legend score: 3 max: 3 passed: true - comment: Correct mandated title format; legend correctly omitted as redundant - with x-axis category labels + comment: Title matches mandated format; legend intentionally omitted since + categories are already labeled on the x-axis. data_quality: - score: 15 + score: 14 max: 15 items: - id: DQ-01 name: Feature Coverage - score: 6 + score: 5 max: 6 passed: true - comment: Individual points, distribution shape via swarm spread, and mean - markers all present + comment: Shows full distribution shape, density, and an outlier per condition. - id: DQ-02 name: Realistic Context score: 5 max: 5 passed: true - comment: Plausible, neutral cognitive-load reaction-time experiment + comment: Cognitive-load reaction-time experiment is realistic and neutral. - id: DQ-03 name: Appropriate Scale score: 4 max: 4 passed: true - comment: Reaction times and spreads are realistic for the domain + comment: 300-700ms range and escalating means are sensible for psychology + RT data. code_quality: - score: 10 + score: 9 max: 10 items: - id: CQ-01 @@ -190,31 +197,31 @@ review: score: 3 max: 3 passed: true - comment: No functions/classes, single linear pipeline + comment: No functions/classes, straightforward pipeline. - id: CQ-02 name: Reproducibility score: 2 max: 2 passed: true - comment: set.seed(42) + comment: set.seed(42) used. - id: CQ-03 name: Clean Imports score: 2 max: 2 passed: true - comment: ggplot2, dplyr, ragg, scales all actually used + comment: ggplot2, dplyr, ragg, scales all actually used. - id: CQ-04 name: Code Elegance - score: 2 + score: 1 max: 2 - passed: true - comment: Appropriate complexity for a manual beeswarm layout, no fake UI + passed: false + comment: Non-functional geom_line layer that renders nothing is dead code. - id: CQ-05 name: Output & API score: 1 max: 1 passed: true - comment: ggsave with ragg::agg_png and plot-{THEME}.png naming + comment: Saves plot-{THEME}.png via ragg::agg_png. library_mastery: score: 8 max: 10 @@ -224,20 +231,20 @@ review: score: 4 max: 5 passed: true - comment: Standard dplyr/ggplot2 grammar throughout + comment: Idiomatic dplyr + ggplot2 grammar composition. - id: LM-02 name: Distinctive Features score: 4 max: 5 passed: true - comment: Hand-built value-binning beeswarm approximation is a distinctive - workaround for ggplot2's missing native geom + comment: Manual bin-and-rank beeswarm approximation is a distinctive technique + given ggplot2 has no native beeswarm geom. verdict: APPROVED impl_tags: dependencies: [] techniques: - - layer-composition - manual-ticks + - layer-composition patterns: - data-generation - groupby-aggregation @@ -246,3 +253,4 @@ impl_tags: - binning styling: - alpha-blending + - edge-highlighting