|
64 | 64 | \end{prop} |
65 | 65 |
|
66 | 66 | \begin{proof} |
67 | | -For the forward direction, let $\Gamma$ entail $!A$ and suppose to the |
| 67 | +For the forward direction, suppose $\Gamma \Entails !A$ and suppose to the |
68 | 68 | contrary that there is a !!{structure} $\Struct M$ so that $\Sat{M}{\Gamma |
69 | 69 | \cup \{ \lnot !A \}}$. Since $\Sat{M}{\Gamma}$ and $\Gamma \Entails |
70 | 70 | !A$, $\Sat{M}{!A}$. Also, since $\Sat{M}{\Gamma\cup \{ \lnot !A \}}$, |
71 | 71 | $\Sat{M}{\lnot !A}$, so we have both $\Sat{M}{!A}$ and $\Sat/{M}{!A}$, |
72 | 72 | a contradiction. Hence, there can be no such !!{structure} $\Struct M$, so |
73 | 73 | $\Gamma \cup \{ !A \}$ is unsatisfiable. |
74 | 74 |
|
75 | | -For the reverse direction, let $\Gamma \cup \{ \lnot !A \}$. So for |
76 | | -every !!{structure} $\Struct M$, either $\Sat/{M}{\Gamma}$ or |
77 | | -$\Sat{M}{!A}$. Hence, for every !!{structure} $\Struct M$ with |
78 | | -$\Sat{M}{\Gamma}$, $\Sat{M}{!A}$, so $\Gamma \Entails !A$. |
| 75 | +For the reverse direction, suppose $\Gamma \cup \{ \lnot !A \}$ is |
| 76 | +unsatisfiable. So for every !!{structure} $\Struct M$, either |
| 77 | +$\Sat/{M}{\Gamma}$ or $\Sat{M}{!A}$. Hence, for every !!{structure} |
| 78 | +$\Struct M$ with $\Sat{M}{\Gamma}$, $\Sat{M}{!A}$, so $\Gamma \Entails |
| 79 | +!A$. |
79 | 80 | \end{proof} |
80 | 81 |
|
81 | 82 | \begin{prob} |
|
98 | 99 | Suppose that $\Gamma \subseteq \Gamma'$ and $\Gamma \Entails !A$. Let |
99 | 100 | $\Struct M$ be such that $\Sat{M}{\Gamma'}$; then $\Sat{M}{\Gamma}$, |
100 | 101 | and since $\Gamma \Entails !A$, we get that $\Sat{M}{!A}$. Hence, |
101 | | -whenever $\Sat{M}{\Gamma}$, $\Sat{M}{!A}$, so $\Gamma' \Entails !A$. |
| 102 | +whenever $\Sat{M}{\Gamma'}$, $\Sat{M}{!A}$, so $\Gamma' \Entails !A$. |
102 | 103 | \end{proof} |
103 | 104 |
|
104 | 105 |
|
|
0 commit comments