Task: 12864 (Verified-400)
The prompt is inconsistent with the golden answer in two ways:
-
"dates" that don't exist. The prompt says "retrieve corresponding
dates from Column B on sheet 2 by matching Column D on sheet 1." But the
value actually returned (Sheet1 Column B, header "Deal Name") is
Monthly / Daily / Quarterly — these are reporting frequencies, and
there are no dates anywhere in the workbook. The word "dates" mislabels
the lookup target and makes the task ambiguous.
-
Column C is requested but absent from the golden. The prompt says "I
require the associated data from both Column B and C on sheet 2." The
golden's Sheet2 has no Column C at all (not even a header) — it fills
only Sheet2!B2:B12 with
=INDEX(Sheet1!B$2:B$17, MATCH($A2, Sheet1!$D$2:$D$17, 0)).
answer_position is 'Sheet2'!B2:B12, so scoring only checks Column B — that
part is self-consistent and scoreable. But the prompt's references to "dates"
and "Column C" match neither the data nor the golden, which makes the intended
task ambiguous.
Suggested fix:
- Replace "dates" with "deal name" (the actual header of the looked-up
column, Sheet1!B1 / Sheet2!B1), so the prompt matches the workbook's own
labels and the golden. (If a value-accurate term is preferred, the values are
reporting frequencies, e.g. "reporting frequency".)
- Either drop the "Column C" clause, or extend the golden to include the
Column C the prompt asks for.
Task:
12864(Verified-400)The prompt is inconsistent with the golden answer in two ways:
"dates" that don't exist. The prompt says "retrieve corresponding
dates from Column B on sheet 2 by matching Column D on sheet 1." But the
value actually returned (Sheet1 Column B, header "Deal Name") is
Monthly/Daily/Quarterly— these are reporting frequencies, andthere are no dates anywhere in the workbook. The word "dates" mislabels
the lookup target and makes the task ambiguous.
Column C is requested but absent from the golden. The prompt says "I
require the associated data from both Column B and C on sheet 2." The
golden's
Sheet2has no Column C at all (not even a header) — it fillsonly
Sheet2!B2:B12with=INDEX(Sheet1!B$2:B$17, MATCH($A2, Sheet1!$D$2:$D$17, 0)).answer_positionis'Sheet2'!B2:B12, so scoring only checks Column B — thatpart is self-consistent and scoreable. But the prompt's references to "dates"
and "Column C" match neither the data nor the golden, which makes the intended
task ambiguous.
Suggested fix:
column,
Sheet1!B1/Sheet2!B1), so the prompt matches the workbook's ownlabels and the golden. (If a value-accurate term is preferred, the values are
reporting frequencies, e.g. "reporting frequency".)
Column C the prompt asks for.