Skip to content

Add a triage/fast-path: full pipeline is ~29x cost / ~35x time for trivial work #5

@n1arash

Description

@n1arash

Summary

For trivial work the full pipeline costs ~29× the money and ~35× the time of a plain claude -p session, and over-engineers the change. The gate/plan/grill/slice ceremony is pure overhead for a one-liner.

Evidence (dogfood campaign — F5 head-to-head)

plain baseline full pipeline ratio
cost $0.111 $3.23 ~29×
wall 53.7 s 1861 s ~35×
result correct, in-scope correct, but over-built

Why it matters

The pipeline's value is gates + verification for risky change. For trivial change it's pure overhead and it over-builds. Routing one-liners through the full pipeline is a poor default.

Proposed fix

  • Add a triage / fast-path that recognizes trivial requests and condenses or skips gates.
  • And/or ship product guidance to route one-liners to a plain session.
  • Note: this is partly a consequence of the turn-budget and over-decomposition issues; fixing those shrinks the gap but won't close it — the gate ceremony itself is the rest.

Acceptance criteria

  • A triage step classifies request size/risk before committing to the full pipeline.
  • Trivial requests take a condensed path (fewer gates / single slice).
  • Cost and wall-clock for the F5-class request drop materially vs the current full pipeline.
  • Risky/non-trivial requests still receive the full gate treatment.

Source: dogfood/ITERATION_REPORT.md MAJOR-4; dogfood/METRICS.md head-to-head.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    area:costCost / time efficiencyarea:pipelineScheduler / gates / decomposition pipelinedogfoodSurfaced by the self-driving dogfood campaignenhancementNew feature or requestmajorMajor — significant impact on cost, reliability, or correctness

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions