Skip to content

W1-7: Review Wave 1 for Lean idiomaticity #7

@arademaker

Description

@arademaker

Description

Persona: Leonardo de Moura (Lean Critic)

Final review of all Wave 1 code for Lean 4 idiomaticity. This is a gate — Wave 1 is not complete until this review passes.

Review checklist

  • Naming conventions: Follow Mathlib style (camelCase for defs, snake_case for theorems)
  • Type design: Are we using dependent types effectively? Any unnecessary Nat where Fin or BitVec would be better?
  • Tactic style: Are proofs clean? No unnecessary unfold chains? Using simp, omega, ring_nf where appropriate?
  • API design: Are public definitions well-typed and composable?
  • Module structure: Are imports minimal? Use #min_imports to verify
  • CLAUDE.md: Update toolchain version to v4.28.0-rc1, update phase status

Documents to update

  • doc/HOL-Light-to-Lean-Execution.md — reflect any design changes
  • doc/architecture-reflections.md — update with new automation insights
  • doc/bignum-plan.md — update current state metrics

Acceptance Criteria

  • All Wave 1 code reviewed
  • No Lean anti-patterns remaining
  • Documentation updated
  • CLAUDE.md updated

Dependencies

  • W1-5 (all other Wave 1 work must be complete)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    persona:demouraLeonardo de Moura - Lean Criticwave-1Wave 1: Consolidate Foundations

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions