Maybe this could be a different kind of (private) project? Would be nice if it were reviewable in this interface, i.e., you could mark up the PDF, look at the code, data, etc., exactly how it would look if published.
Barring that, can it be easier to mark up a PDF and convert that into text with line numbers or automatic quoting?
A file format (header can tell us what PDF file it refers to by relative path), which should be able to be directly pasted into a web form, but the PDF viewer can read/write comments to/from this text file:
% the-paper.pdf
## Overall summary
## Major comments
Line 10: "What's
## Minor comments
1. Line 33: Something.
2. Line 55, "a quote here": My comment here.
Maybe this could be a different kind of (private) project? Would be nice if it were reviewable in this interface, i.e., you could mark up the PDF, look at the code, data, etc., exactly how it would look if published.
Barring that, can it be easier to mark up a PDF and convert that into text with line numbers or automatic quoting?
A file format (header can tell us what PDF file it refers to by relative path), which should be able to be directly pasted into a web form, but the PDF viewer can read/write comments to/from this text file: