Skip to content

Commit 3d47957

Browse files
Add Parliamentary Procedure to the list of decision-making methodologies detailed here
1 parent 8b31338 commit 3d47957

1 file changed

Lines changed: 31 additions & 7 deletions

File tree

decision-making.md

Lines changed: 31 additions & 7 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,15 +1,39 @@
11
#Decision-making
22

3-
There are at least two popular approaches:
3+
There are several popular approaches to decision-making, some of which are detailed here:
44
* Do-ocracy is an organizational methodology where each individual chooses his/her own role and/or task and does it autonomously or in a team. In this model, accountability sticks to the actor who implements a task/role, not who is officially assigned.
5-
* The main advantages of this approach: big motivation and rapid implementation.
6-
* Disadvantages are burn out of team core.
7-
* Consensus is an organizational approach where decisions are made by agreement of a whole group of actors.
8-
* Benefits are sustainability and deep understanding tack and roles by each member of collective.
9-
* Drawbacks: Very time-consuming and not flexible.
5+
* Advantages:
6+
* Fosters a culture of participation and motivates community members to take on responsibilities for the good of the group.
7+
* Can lead to much more rapid implementation, as there is little in the way of process to curtail progress on tasks.
8+
* Allows those who want to accomplish something to simply start working toward their goals.
9+
* Disadvantages:
10+
* Burnout of team core, especially when people volunteer for too many jobs/tasks.
11+
* If some key contributors volunteer for a large portion of the tasks, they may begin to resent others for not contributing as much.
12+
* Some may volunteer to perform a task without the required expertise to complete it, yet there may be no mechanism for taking the volunteer off that self-assigned task.
13+
* Consensus is an organizational approach where decisions are made by the unanimous agreement of a whole group of actors.
14+
* Advantages:
15+
* Reduces social hierarchy, as all members' votes are required to progress forward.
16+
* Increases participation by all members of a group.
17+
* Imposes a natural limit on risky or controversial changes.
18+
are sustainability and deep understanding tack and roles by each member of collective.
19+
* Prevents minority viewpoints within a group from being overrun.
20+
* Disadvantages:
21+
* Extremely time-consuming, as a single dissenter can prevent forward progress.
22+
* Difficult to overturn previously-made decisions as members who espoused those ideas initially may be unwilling to recant.
23+
* Can cause social pressure on all participants to reach quicker decisions, paradoxically resulting in some groups speeding too quickly toward decision-making.
24+
* Parliamentary Procedure is a highly organized system of decision-making, governed by a fixed set of rules (such as Robert's Rules of Order).
25+
* Advantages:
26+
* Highly structured set of rules governs discussion, preventing personal attacks and the like from becoming commonplace, and reducing ambiguity.
27+
* Generally requires a quorum of members present, to prevent the risk of a clandestine meeting held to push through a small group's agenda.
28+
* Majority voting provides a clear, objective way to measure when a decision has been reached when a question is called to a vote.
29+
* Disadvantages:
30+
* Minority viewpoints can be overridden by votes, leading to a situation where an unscrupulous majority group could seize complete control over the body.
31+
* Discussion can become interrupted by the process moving too quickly to a vote.
32+
* People may feel less personally invested in the outcome from the other two systems (especially where they voted against the decision that was reached).
1033

11-
**Option: The better way is to combine the methods.
1234

1335
##References
1436
* https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do-ocracy
1537
* https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consensus
38+
* http://meatballwiki.org/wiki/ConsensusDecisionMaking
39+
* https://communitywiki.org/wiki/ParliamentaryProcedure

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)