diff --git a/docs/reference/trajectory-assessment.md b/docs/reference/trajectory-assessment.md index 75a55e9a23..92ffccc949 100644 --- a/docs/reference/trajectory-assessment.md +++ b/docs/reference/trajectory-assessment.md @@ -279,6 +279,36 @@ Ancestor response usage is deduplicated, but processing inherited context again is new cost. Analysis-job usage is separate from solver and native-evaluation cost. Never impute missing dollars from an unverified model price. +### Select evidence around the research decision + +For a mechanism or attribution question, a submission neighborhood is a locator; +the relevant decision can span earlier turns. Within the authorized history, +follow the hypothesis through candidate design, comparison, selection and actual +subsequent work. Include the source-bound baselines and candidate versions, +inputs and budgets, completed results with regressions or failures, and the +action that used or rejected them. Keep missing links unknown. Nearby messages +and a reported plan alone do not establish this chain. + +Describe this coverage in `selection.rule` and bind the selected literal ranges +through the existing episode `source_ids`. Early/middle/late sampling can still +locate useful episodes; it does not establish that their immediate neighbors +contain the experiments behind a decision. A judgment of insufficient supplied +evidence does not establish that the experiment never happened in the run. + +Before proposing another comparison, reconcile it with applicable recorded +designs and outcomes. Prioritize a missing condition, unresolved counterexample +or necessary repeat when earlier comparisons already address part of the +question. Preserve their input, timing and reuse limitations; local evidence +can refine a hypothesis without allocating a native gain or proving a framework +effect. Keep measured late gains visible while their mechanism remains open. + +Choose bounded excerpts that preserve the decision and its limitations. Reuse +source references instead of repeating transport wrappers or replacing original +evidence with a model summary. Added evidence belongs in an explicit successor +pack; preserve the previous report, failures and usage. These are curator +judgments, beyond automatic citation-range validation, and grant no analysis or +experiment execution authority. + ## Producer and consumer boundary ### Continuing a frozen analysis