From 21ee3c577db713caf6dcbab81da2ae869bcbd2a9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 10:48:10 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 01/37] =?UTF-8?q?chore:=20start=20session=20=E2=80=94=20is?= =?UTF-8?q?sue-382?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 214 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 214 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/steering.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..db70072c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -0,0 +1,214 @@ +# Goal + +Add BM25 full-text search as a pre-filter stage before the semantic search in the QA workflow, +so that queries containing Nablarch-specific terms (class names, annotations, method names) can +complete without invoking the LLM-backed semantic search, reducing per-query cost. +Remove the `keyword-search` workflow from all skill versions (v6, v5, v1.4, v1.3, v1.2) +because it overlaps in naming and purpose with the new BM25 stage. + +The design source is `docs/reports/cost-optimization-nabledge.md` §4. +The mechanism is: run BM25 (existing `keyword-search.sh`) first; generate an answer from its +results; run the Step-6 hallucination verifier; if PASS complete without semantic search; +if FAIL fall back to semantic search and proceed as today. +The BM25 query terms are extracted by the LLM from the user's question. + +--- + +# Acceptance criteria + +- `workflows/qa.md` in v6 has a BM25 pre-search step before Step 3 (semantic search): + - LLM extracts Nablarch-specific terms from the question + - `keyword-search.sh` is invoked with those terms + - If hits exist, an answer is generated and verified with Step 6 logic + - PASS → return answer without running semantic search + - FAIL or no hits → fall through to semantic search (existing Step 3–8) +- v6 benchmark: all 34 scenarios pass (zero regression vs current baseline) +- v6 benchmark: cost per query is lower than the previous run baseline +- The same `qa.md` change is applied identically to v5, v1.4, v1.3, v1.2 +- `workflows/keyword-search.md` is removed from all five versions +- `scripts/keyword-search.sh` is retained (it is the BM25 engine used by the new step) +- `SKILL.md` routing for `keyword-search` command is removed from all five versions +- `docs/search-design.md` is updated to reflect the new QA flow and removal of keyword-search workflow +- CHANGELOG `[Unreleased]` updated in v6 (and v5 if applicable) per `.claude/rules/changelog.md` + +--- + +# Assumptions + +- `keyword-search.sh` already implements BM25-style keyword scanning and is the right engine + (confirmed: it does case-insensitive substring AND/OR matching over all knowledge JSON) +- The Step-6 verifier in `qa.md` is reusable as-is for BM25 results — no structural change needed +- v5, v1.4, v1.3, v1.2 skills have identical `qa.md` structure (step numbers, step-6 verifier) + and need only the same BM25 block inserted at the same position +- Benchmark tooling (`tools/tests/` or equivalent) can measure v6 cost and accuracy +- `keyword-search` command routing in SKILL.md must be removed; the `keyword-search.sh` script stays +- No change to `semantic-search.md` or `read-sections.sh` + +--- + +# Rules + +- commit and push every change; one completion marker per task +- Apply qa.md changes to all five versions in one commit (not split by version) per `.claude/rules/nabledge-skill.md` +- Never edit RBKC-generated files (knowledge JSON, index.md, classes.md) +- Run benchmark before and after v6 qa.md change; record both numbers +- verify is the quality gate — if benchmark shows regression, fix qa.md, never weaken verify + +--- + +# Tasks + +### #1: Establish v6 benchmark baseline + +**Purpose**: Record current v6 benchmark pass count and cost so post-change results have a +comparison point. + +**Prerequisites**: none + +**Steps**: + +- [ ] Locate the benchmark runner command for v6 (check `tools/tests/` or project docs) +- [ ] Run the benchmark and capture: scenario pass count, total cost, execution time +- [ ] Save results to `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` +- [ ] Commit and push `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` +- [ ] Self-check: baseline.md contains pass count, cost, and execution time for all 34 scenarios + +**Completion criteria**: + +- `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` exists and contains v6 benchmark pass count, cost per query (or total), and execution time +- The recorded pass count is the pre-change reference used in task #3 comparison + +--- + +### #2: Design the BM25 pre-search step for qa.md + +**Purpose**: Define the exact wording and placement of the new BM25 step in `qa.md` before +writing any code, following the design-before-implementation rule. + +**Prerequisites**: none (can run parallel to #1) + +**Steps**: + +- [ ] Draft the BM25 step as a standalone markdown block: term extraction logic, script invocation, answer generation, verifier reuse, PASS/FAIL branching +- [ ] Consult Software Engineer expert (subagent) to review the draft for correctness and edge cases +- [ ] Revise based on findings +- [ ] Save final draft to `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` +- [ ] User review — present draft and ask for approval before implementation +- [ ] Self-check: draft covers all branches (no hits, PASS, FAIL), reuses Step-6 verifier, does not duplicate existing steps + +**Completion criteria**: + +- `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` exists with the full step text +- User has approved the draft +- All branches (no BM25 hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback) are explicitly specified + +--- + +### #3: Implement BM25 step in v6 qa.md and verify benchmark + +**Purpose**: Insert the approved BM25 step into v6 `qa.md` and confirm no benchmark regression +and cost reduction. + +**Prerequisites**: #1 (baseline), #2 (approved draft) + +**Steps**: + +- [ ] Insert the approved BM25 step into `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` before the current Step 3 +- [ ] Renumber subsequent steps if needed +- [ ] Run v6 benchmark; record pass count, cost, execution time +- [ ] Compare against baseline: all 34 scenarios pass, cost is lower +- [ ] Save comparison to `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` +- [ ] Software Engineer expert review (subagent) +- [ ] User review +- [ ] Commit and push `qa.md` change + benchmark result + +**Completion criteria**: + +- `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` contains the BM25 pre-search step +- v6 benchmark: 34/34 scenarios pass +- v6 benchmark: cost per query lower than baseline +- `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` documents both numbers + +--- + +### #4: Roll out qa.md change to v5, v1.4, v1.3, v1.2 + +**Purpose**: Apply the same BM25 step to the remaining four skill versions. + +**Prerequisites**: #3 (v6 change verified and approved) + +**Steps**: + +- [ ] Confirm each version's `qa.md` step structure matches v6 (same step numbers, same Step-6 verifier) +- [ ] Apply identical BM25 block to v5, v1.4, v1.3, v1.2 `qa.md` files +- [ ] Note any version-specific differences (e.g. processing type list) and adjust accordingly +- [ ] Software Engineer expert review (subagent) +- [ ] User review +- [ ] Commit and push all four files in one commit + +**Completion criteria**: + +- `.claude/skills/nabledge-{5,1.4,1.3,1.2}/workflows/qa.md` each contain the BM25 pre-search step +- The BM25 block is structurally identical to v6 (path/version substitutions only) + +--- + +### #5: Remove keyword-search workflow and routing from all versions + +**Purpose**: Delete `workflows/keyword-search.md` and its SKILL.md routing entry from all five +versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. + +**Prerequisites**: #3 (v6 qa.md verified — confirms keyword-search.sh is retained, only the workflow is removed) + +**Steps**: + +- [ ] Delete `workflows/keyword-search.md` from v6, v5, v1.4, v1.3, v1.2 +- [ ] Remove the `keyword-search ""` routing line from each version's `SKILL.md` +- [ ] Confirm `scripts/keyword-search.sh` is NOT deleted (it is used by the new BM25 step) +- [ ] Software Engineer expert review (subagent) +- [ ] User review +- [ ] Commit and push all deletions and SKILL.md edits in one commit + +**Completion criteria**: + +- `workflows/keyword-search.md` does not exist in any of the five skill directories +- Each version's `SKILL.md` has no routing for `keyword-search` command +- `scripts/keyword-search.sh` still exists in v6 (and other versions if present) + +--- + +### #6: Update docs/search-design.md and CHANGELOG + +**Purpose**: Keep documentation in sync with the implementation changes. + +**Prerequisites**: #3, #5 + +**Steps**: + +- [ ] Update `docs/search-design.md`: remove keyword-search workflow entry from the workflow table and workflow section; add description of the BM25 pre-search step in the QA workflow section +- [ ] Add entry to `[Unreleased]` in `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/plugin/CHANGELOG.md` per `.claude/rules/changelog.md` +- [ ] Add entry to `[Unreleased]` in `.claude/skills/nabledge-5/plugin/CHANGELOG.md` if applicable +- [ ] Technical Writer expert review (subagent) +- [ ] User review +- [ ] Commit and push + +**Completion criteria**: + +- `docs/search-design.md` no longer references `keyword-search` workflow; QA workflow section describes BM25 pre-search +- `CHANGELOG [Unreleased]` has a user-facing entry for the BM25 addition and keyword-search removal + +--- + +# Decisions + +(none yet) + +--- + +# State + +- **Status**: not suspended +- **Date**: 2026-06-25 +- **Last completed**: (none) +- **Next**: #1 Establish v6 benchmark baseline +- **Notes**: baseline (#1) and design (#2) can run in parallel From 5891f463a9fe77c5901a6a4d2806cae20f15a79c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 10:54:51 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 02/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20revise=20steering=20=E2=80=94=20d?= =?UTF-8?q?rop=20baseline=20re-run,=20add=20BM25=20engine=20decision,=20ad?= =?UTF-8?q?d=20incremental=20test=20steps?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 62 +++++++++++++++++++++++---------------- 1 file changed, 36 insertions(+), 26 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index db70072c8..dab1e220b 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -58,76 +58,86 @@ The BM25 query terms are extracted by the LLM from the user's question. # Tasks -### #1: Establish v6 benchmark baseline +### #1: Confirm existing benchmark baseline -**Purpose**: Record current v6 benchmark pass count and cost so post-change results have a -comparison point. +**Purpose**: Identify which existing benchmark result to use as the pre-change reference, +so no re-run is needed and the comparison is anchored to a real prior measurement. **Prerequisites**: none **Steps**: -- [ ] Locate the benchmark runner command for v6 (check `tools/tests/` or project docs) -- [ ] Run the benchmark and capture: scenario pass count, total cost, execution time -- [ ] Save results to `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` +- [ ] Review `tools/benchmark/results/` — identify the most recent completed run with crossrun-summary or baseline.json +- [ ] Record the label, scenario pass count, p50 cost, and p50 execution time in `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` - [ ] Commit and push `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` -- [ ] Self-check: baseline.md contains pass count, cost, and execution time for all 34 scenarios +- [ ] Self-check: baseline.md names the exact run label and contains pass count, p50 cost, p50 execution time **Completion criteria**: -- `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` exists and contains v6 benchmark pass count, cost per query (or total), and execution time -- The recorded pass count is the pre-change reference used in task #3 comparison +- `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` exists and names the run label used as baseline +- It contains pass count (out of 34), p50 cost per query, and p50 execution time from that run --- ### #2: Design the BM25 pre-search step for qa.md **Purpose**: Define the exact wording and placement of the new BM25 step in `qa.md` before -writing any code, following the design-before-implementation rule. +writing any code. Key open questions to resolve: (a) use existing `keyword-search.sh` as-is +(substring, no new library) or introduce a true BM25 library (rank-bm25 etc., requires user +setup); (b) how the LLM extracts search terms from the question; (c) exact PASS/FAIL branching +into the fallback path. **Prerequisites**: none (can run parallel to #1) **Steps**: -- [ ] Draft the BM25 step as a standalone markdown block: term extraction logic, script invocation, answer generation, verifier reuse, PASS/FAIL branching -- [ ] Consult Software Engineer expert (subagent) to review the draft for correctness and edge cases +- [ ] Research: check whether `docs/reports/cost-optimization-nabledge.md` §4 used the existing script or a separate BM25 library for the "21/32 complete" measurement +- [ ] Decide on engine (existing script vs new library) — if new library, document the user setup step required +- [ ] Draft the BM25 step as a standalone markdown block: term extraction, script invocation, answer generation, verifier reuse, PASS/FAIL branching +- [ ] Consult Software Engineer expert (subagent) to review for correctness and edge cases - [ ] Revise based on findings - [ ] Save final draft to `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` -- [ ] User review — present draft and ask for approval before implementation -- [ ] Self-check: draft covers all branches (no hits, PASS, FAIL), reuses Step-6 verifier, does not duplicate existing steps +- [ ] User review — present draft (including engine decision and any setup impact) and ask for approval before implementation +- [ ] Self-check: draft covers all branches (no hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback), user setup impact documented **Completion criteria**: - `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` exists with the full step text +- Engine choice (existing script or new library) is stated with rationale +- If a new library is needed, the user setup step is documented - User has approved the draft - All branches (no BM25 hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback) are explicitly specified --- -### #3: Implement BM25 step in v6 qa.md and verify benchmark +### #3: Implement BM25 step in v6 qa.md and verify incrementally -**Purpose**: Insert the approved BM25 step into v6 `qa.md` and confirm no benchmark regression -and cost reduction. +**Purpose**: Insert the approved BM25 step into v6 `qa.md` and verify correctness +incrementally — single scenario first, then path-coverage sample, then full 3-run benchmark +— following the HOW-TO-RUN.md procedure. **Prerequisites**: #1 (baseline), #2 (approved draft) **Steps**: -- [ ] Insert the approved BM25 step into `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` before the current Step 3 -- [ ] Renumber subsequent steps if needed -- [ ] Run v6 benchmark; record pass count, cost, execution time -- [ ] Compare against baseline: all 34 scenarios pass, cost is lower -- [ ] Save comparison to `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` +- [ ] Insert the approved BM25 step into `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` before the current Step 3; renumber subsequent steps if needed +- [ ] **Phase A (1 scenario)**: run `pre-01` via `run_qa --scenario-ids pre-01`; confirm exit 0, answer.md non-empty, BM25 path exercised; delete tmp dir after +- [ ] **Path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios)**: select scenarios that cover BM25-complete path, BM25-FAIL→fallback path, and no-hits path; run them; inspect `workflow_details.json` to confirm each path behaved as designed; fix qa.md if any path misbehaves +- [ ] **Phase B/C full benchmark**: 3 runs × 34 scenarios per HOW-TO-RUN.md; generate per-run reports and crossrun-summary; commit each run immediately after completion +- [ ] Phase E regression check: compare against baseline from #1 +- [ ] Save comparison summary to `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` - [ ] Software Engineer expert review (subagent) - [ ] User review -- [ ] Commit and push `qa.md` change + benchmark result +- [ ] Commit and push `qa.md` change + benchmark results **Completion criteria**: - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` contains the BM25 pre-search step -- v6 benchmark: 34/34 scenarios pass -- v6 benchmark: cost per query lower than baseline -- `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` documents both numbers +- Phase A: single-scenario run exits 0 and BM25 path is exercised +- Path-coverage sample: all three paths (BM25-complete, BM25-FAIL→fallback, no-hits) confirmed working +- Full benchmark (3 runs): regression check CLEAN vs baseline from #1 +- Full benchmark: p50 cost per query lower than baseline p50 +- `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` documents the comparison --- From 75df1c7b206c59613ae6f92e1903537666ceec85 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 11:09:57 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 03/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20revise=20steering=20#2=20?= =?UTF-8?q?=E2=80=94=20BM25=20library=20selection=20is=20required,=20not?= =?UTF-8?q?=20optional?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 27 +++++++++++++-------------- 1 file changed, 13 insertions(+), 14 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index dab1e220b..f3c7043a9 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -79,34 +79,33 @@ so no re-run is needed and the comparison is anchored to a real prior measuremen --- -### #2: Design the BM25 pre-search step for qa.md +### #2: Select BM25 library and design the BM25 pre-search step for qa.md -**Purpose**: Define the exact wording and placement of the new BM25 step in `qa.md` before -writing any code. Key open questions to resolve: (a) use existing `keyword-search.sh` as-is -(substring, no new library) or introduce a true BM25 library (rank-bm25 etc., requires user -setup); (b) how the LLM extracts search terms from the question; (c) exact PASS/FAIL branching -into the fallback path. +**Purpose**: Select a BM25 library, get user approval on the choice and any setup impact, +then define the exact wording and placement of the new BM25 step in `qa.md` before writing +any code. The existing `keyword-search.sh` (substring matching, no scoring) is not BM25 and +will not be used as the BM25 engine. **Prerequisites**: none (can run parallel to #1) **Steps**: -- [ ] Research: check whether `docs/reports/cost-optimization-nabledge.md` §4 used the existing script or a separate BM25 library for the "21/32 complete" measurement -- [ ] Decide on engine (existing script vs new library) — if new library, document the user setup step required -- [ ] Draft the BM25 step as a standalone markdown block: term extraction, script invocation, answer generation, verifier reuse, PASS/FAIL branching +- [ ] Survey candidate BM25 libraries (e.g. rank-bm25, bm25s, Whoosh): license, pip install size, Python version compatibility, maintenance status +- [ ] Identify the user setup impact: which library to `pip install`, whether it must be added to a requirements file, whether setup scripts need updating +- [ ] Present library comparison and recommended choice to user; get approval before proceeding +- [ ] Draft the BM25 step as a standalone markdown block: index build, term extraction by LLM from question, BM25 query, answer generation from hits, Step-6 verifier reuse, PASS/FAIL branching into semantic-search fallback - [ ] Consult Software Engineer expert (subagent) to review for correctness and edge cases - [ ] Revise based on findings - [ ] Save final draft to `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` -- [ ] User review — present draft (including engine decision and any setup impact) and ask for approval before implementation -- [ ] Self-check: draft covers all branches (no hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback), user setup impact documented +- [ ] User review — present full draft and get approval before implementation +- [ ] Self-check: library choice approved, all branches (no hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback) specified, setup steps documented **Completion criteria**: +- BM25 library selected and user-approved, with setup steps documented - `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` exists with the full step text -- Engine choice (existing script or new library) is stated with rationale -- If a new library is needed, the user setup step is documented -- User has approved the draft - All branches (no BM25 hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback) are explicitly specified +- User has approved the draft --- From f58b6a41cbfb79d92b7699a4e06fe756725d4d5d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 11:15:49 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 04/37] docs: record benchmark baseline for issue-382 Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/baseline.md | 45 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 45 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/baseline.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/baseline.md b/.rn/issue-382/baseline.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ab030901f --- /dev/null +++ b/.rn/issue-382/baseline.md @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +# Benchmark Baseline for Issue-382 + +## Run Label + +`20260612-1404-baseline-current` + +Source: `tools/benchmark/results/20260612-1404-baseline-current/` + +This is the most recent completed benchmark run that precedes issue-382 work. It has both +`crossrun-summary.md` and `baseline.json`, making it the authoritative pre-change reference. + +## Metrics (3 runs × 34 scenarios = 102 evaluations) + +| Metric | Value | +|---|---| +| Scenario pass count (answer_correctness = 1.0) | 25 / 34 | +| P50 cost per query | $0.682 | +| P50 execution time | 118s | + +### Scenario pass count derivation + +Scenarios with answer_correctness mean < 1.0 (9 scenarios): + +| Scenario | answer_correctness mean | +|---|---| +| qa-19 | 0.067 | +| qa-17 | 0.100 | +| qa-01 | 0.667 | +| qa-12 | 0.800 | +| qa-18 | 0.900 | +| oos-qa-01 | 0.933 | +| impact-01 | 0.967 | +| impact-06 | 0.967 | +| pre-03 | 0.933 | + +Passing = 34 - 9 = **25 / 34** + +### Full performance summary + +| Metric | Mean | P50 | P95 | Max | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| Execution time | 141s | 118s | 266s | 347s | +| Cost per query | $0.733 | $0.682 | $1.132 | $1.438 | + +Source: `tools/benchmark/results/20260612-1404-baseline-current/crossrun-summary.md` From 170d5b15cd4e63d6f613aef78354e6c14081f939 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 11:17:28 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 05/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20complete=20task=20#1=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20confirm=20benchmark=20baseline?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/checks/task-1.md | 25 +++++++++++++++++++++++++ .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 14 +++++++------- 2 files changed, 32 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/checks/task-1.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-1.md b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-1.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a96922553 --- /dev/null +++ b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-1.md @@ -0,0 +1,25 @@ +# task-1 Completion Check + +## Completion Criteria + +| Criterion | Self-check | Evidence | QA | QA Evidence | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` exists and names the run label | OK | File created at `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md`; run label `20260612-1404-baseline-current` stated in the "Run Label" section | | | +| Contains pass count (out of 34) | OK | "25 / 34" — derived from 34 minus 9 scenarios with answer_correctness < 1.0, cross-checked against quality-report.md which states "前版 9件" | | | +| Contains p50 cost per query | OK | $0.682 — from `crossrun-summary.md` table row: コスト P50 = $0.682 | | | +| Contains p50 execution time | OK | 118s — from `crossrun-summary.md` table row: 実行時間 P50 = 118s | | | + +## QA Expert Review + +| Aspect | Verdict | Evidence / Improvement | +|---|---|---| +| Pass count accuracy | OK | All 9 failing scenarios verified against `baseline.json`; arithmetic 34-9=25 correct | +| P50 cost accuracy | OK | crossrun-summary.md shows $0.682 at P50 — exact match | +| P50 execution time accuracy | OK | crossrun-summary.md shows 118s at P50 — exact match | +| Run label / recency | OK | More recent run (20260616) lacks `baseline.json`; selection criterion documented and valid | +| Completion criteria met | OK | All four required items present and numerically correct | + +## Overall Verdict +- Self-check: OK +- QA: OK +- Ready for user review: Yes diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index f3c7043a9..63f1b5792 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -67,10 +67,10 @@ so no re-run is needed and the comparison is anchored to a real prior measuremen **Steps**: -- [ ] Review `tools/benchmark/results/` — identify the most recent completed run with crossrun-summary or baseline.json -- [ ] Record the label, scenario pass count, p50 cost, and p50 execution time in `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` -- [ ] Commit and push `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` -- [ ] Self-check: baseline.md names the exact run label and contains pass count, p50 cost, p50 execution time +- [x] Review `tools/benchmark/results/` — identify the most recent completed run with crossrun-summary or baseline.json +- [x] Record the label, scenario pass count, p50 cost, and p50 execution time in `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` +- [x] Commit and push `.rn/issue-382/baseline.md` +- [x] Self-check: baseline.md names the exact run label and contains pass count, p50 cost, p50 execution time **Completion criteria**: @@ -218,6 +218,6 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - **Status**: not suspended - **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: (none) -- **Next**: #1 Establish v6 benchmark baseline -- **Notes**: baseline (#1) and design (#2) can run in parallel +- **Last completed**: #1 Confirm existing benchmark baseline +- **Next**: #2 Select BM25 library and design pre-search step +- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current; pass 25/34, p50 cost $0.682, p50 time 118s From 45a12be771bc4c3a1b728023d205227f32af264b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 12:40:39 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 06/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20add=20bm25-step-draft.md=20?= =?UTF-8?q?=E2=80=94=20library=20selection=20and=20qa.md=20step=20design?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md | 149 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 149 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md b/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8d474b950 --- /dev/null +++ b/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md @@ -0,0 +1,149 @@ +# BM25 Pre-Search — Research & Draft + +## Section 1: Library Comparison + +| Library | License | Latest version | Last release | Python min | Install size (approx) | Notes | +|---------|---------|---------------|--------------|------------|----------------------|-------| +| **rank-bm25** | Apache 2.0 | 0.2.2 | Feb 2022 | unspecified (py3) | ~8.5 KB + numpy | Pure Python + numpy. No index persistence — re-indexes on every call. Maintainer's own README flags it as unsuitable for large-scale use. ~2 QPS. Effectively unmaintained (4+ years). | +| **bm25s** | MIT | 0.3.9 | May 2026 | Python 3.8 | ~100 KB + numpy | Pure Python + numpy sparse matrices. Supports index save/load (build once, reload fast). Memory-mapped loading available. ~573 QPS. Actively maintained with multiple 2026 releases. | +| **Whoosh** | BSD 2-clause | 2.7.4 | Apr 2016 | unspecified | ~468 KB, no deps | Pure Python, zero dependencies. Last release 2016 (10 years); Python 3.12+ compatibility uncertain. Requires an on-disk index directory. Effectively a dead project. | + +### Recommendation: **bm25s** + +bm25s is the only actively maintained library of the three (multiple releases in 2026), and its index save/load feature is critical for on-demand bash-script invocation over ~50,000–200,000 sections — build the index once on first run, reload it in milliseconds on subsequent calls. Its sole mandatory dependency is numpy, which is already present in most Python environments used by nabledge's target users. + +--- + +## Section 1b: Index Lifecycle + +**When the index is built**: On first invocation of `bm25-search.sh`, the script builds the BM25 index from `knowledge/*.json` and saves it to a fixed path (e.g. `scripts/.bm25-index/`). Subsequent calls reload the saved index without rebuilding. + +**When to rebuild**: After `rbkc.sh create` regenerates the knowledge files, the index becomes stale. The script detects staleness by comparing the index mtime to the newest JSON mtime and rebuilds automatically — no manual intervention is needed. + +**User setup impact**: `pip install bm25s` must be added to the skill's setup script (`tools/setup/setup-6-cc.sh` and equivalent files for other versions). No additional manual step is needed at query time; index management is handled entirely by `bm25-search.sh`. + +--- + +## Section 2: BM25 Step Draft + +> **Renumbering note**: This draft shows only the new BM25 step. The existing Steps 3–8 in `qa.md` will be renumbered to Steps 4–9 during implementation (task #3). Any internal cross-references within those existing steps (e.g. "go to Step 3", "Step 7") will be updated at that time. + +The following step is intended to be inserted into `qa.md` **between Step 2 (hear processing_type/purpose) and the current Step 3 (semantic search)**. The current Step 3 through Step 8 numbering shifts by one after insertion; this draft uses the new numbering (Step 3 = BM25, Step 4 = former Step 3, …, Step 9 = former Step 8). + +--- + +## Step 3: BM25 pre-search + +Attempt a fast BM25-ranked search before semantic search. If BM25 returns a verified answer, skip semantic search entirely. + +### Step 3-1: Extract BM25-effective terms + +From the user's question, extract terms that will **narrow the result set** in BM25 search — terms specific enough to appear in only a small number of knowledge files. + +**Criterion**: Extract a term if it is a concrete identifier (class name, annotation name, method name, configuration file name, SQL ID, component name) that appears verbatim in the Nablarch knowledge base. The test is: "Would a keyword match on this term return a small, focused set of pages?" + +**Source rule**: Take terms **as they appear in the question** — do not infer synonyms, related terms, or paraphrases. The only permitted modification is correcting an obvious typo or misspelling (e.g. `UniversalDoa` → `UniversalDao`) so the term matches the knowledge base. + +**Extract** (concrete identifiers, low document frequency): +`UniversalDao`, `@InjectForm`, `batchUpdate`, `SqlPStatement`, `web-component-configuration.xml`, `SQLID`, `RoutesMapping`, `BatchAction`, etc. + +**Do NOT extract** (broad terms, high document frequency — would match too many pages and dilute scores): +- Abstract concepts: `バリデーション`, `トランザクション`, `Handler`, `Action` +- General Java: `List`, `String`, `try-catch`, `Exception` +- Natural language filler: `使い方`, `方法`, `について` +- Do NOT add synonyms, related identifiers, or guessed class names not present in the question. + +Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). + +**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), skip immediately to Step 4 (semantic search). + +--- + +### Step 3-2: BM25 search + +Execute the BM25 search script with the extracted terms: + +```bash +bash scripts/bm25-search.sh [term2] ... +``` + +Replace ``, `[term2]` etc. with the terms from `bm25_terms`. + +The script outputs a JSON array. Each element is a section hit with a BM25 score: + +```json +[ + { + "file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "section_title": "batchUpdateメソッドの使い方", + "score": 12.45 + }, + ... +] +``` + +**If the output array is empty** (`[]`), set `bm25_sections = []` and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). + +**If the script exits non-zero** for any reason (index build failure, missing dependency, unexpected error), treat the result as empty and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). + +Otherwise, save the array as `bm25_raw`. Take the top 20 entries by score. + +Convert to the `selected_sections` format: + +```json +[ + {"file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", "section_id": "s3", "relevance": "high"} +] +``` + +Save as `bm25_sections`. + +--- + +### Step 3-3: Read section content + +From `bm25_sections`, build the argument list: for each section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. + +```bash +bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... +``` + +Save the output as `bm25_content`. + +**If `bm25_content` is empty or contains only `FILE_NOT_FOUND` / `SECTION_NOT_FOUND` entries**, skip to Step 4 (semantic search). + +--- + +### Step 3-4: Generate answer from BM25 hits + +Generate the answer using **exactly the same format, constraints, and rules as Step 5** (answer generation). Substitute `bm25_content` for `sections_content`. Save as `bm25_answer_text`. + +- If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. +- For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. + +--- + +### Step 3-5: Verify BM25 answer + +Apply the same verification procedure as Step 6 (hallucination check), using `bm25_answer_text` as the answer and `bm25_content` as the sections. + +Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. Use the same claim categories and boundary rules as Step 6. + +If any claim is unsupported, set `bm25_verify = FAIL`. Otherwise set `bm25_verify = PASS`. + +--- + +### Step 3-6: Handle BM25 verify result + +**If `bm25_verify = PASS`**: + +Set `final_answer = bm25_answer_text`. + +Skip Steps 4–8. Go directly to Step 9 (Output). + +**If `bm25_verify = FAIL`**: + +Discard `bm25_answer_text`. Proceed to Step 4 (semantic search) with no modifications. + +--- From ee90311103dde691079b20b91a360be0d998cb82 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 12:41:17 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 07/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20complete=20task=20#2=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20BM25=20library=20selection=20and=20step=20design?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/checks/task-2.md | 26 +++++++++++++++++++++++ .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 38 ++++++++++++++++++++++------------ 2 files changed, 51 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/checks/task-2.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-2.md b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-2.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0737b4314 --- /dev/null +++ b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-2.md @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +# task-2 Completion Check + +## Completion Criteria + +| Criterion | Self-check | Evidence | QA | QA Evidence | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| BM25 library selected and user-approved, with setup steps documented | OK | bm25s selected; user approved; setup impact (pip install bm25s in setup scripts) documented in bm25-step-draft.md Section 1b | OK | Library comparison verified against PyPI metadata; setup impact documented | +| `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` exists with full step text | OK | File committed at SHA 45a12be7 | OK | All 6 sub-steps (3-1 through 3-6) present and complete | +| All branches (no BM25 hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback) explicitly specified | OK | Step 3-1 empty→skip, Step 3-2 empty/error→skip, Step 3-3 empty content→skip, Step 3-6 PASS/FAIL branches | OK | Verified all branch conditions present with no gaps | +| User has approved the draft | OK | User confirmed "k" after reviewing library selection and step design including term extraction discussion | OK | | + +## QA Expert Review + +| Aspect | Verdict | Evidence / Improvement | +|---|---|---| +| Branch correctness | OK | Step 3-6 "Skip Steps 4–8, go to Step 9" — consistent after fix | +| Step numbering note | OK | Renumbering note added to Section 2 | +| Index lifecycle | OK | Section 1b covers build-on-first-run, auto-staleness-detect, setup-script requirement | +| Script error path | OK | Step 3-2 explicit non-zero exit → skip to Step 4 | +| Empty bm25_content guard | OK | Step 3-3 guard present | +| Term extraction correctness | OK | Step 3-1 revised: extract as-is from question, typo-correct only, no synonyms | + +## Overall Verdict +- Self-check: OK +- QA: OK (Software Engineer re-review PASS after 6-finding fix round) +- Ready for user review: Yes — user approved diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 63f1b5792..a6c0d256d 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -90,15 +90,15 @@ will not be used as the BM25 engine. **Steps**: -- [ ] Survey candidate BM25 libraries (e.g. rank-bm25, bm25s, Whoosh): license, pip install size, Python version compatibility, maintenance status -- [ ] Identify the user setup impact: which library to `pip install`, whether it must be added to a requirements file, whether setup scripts need updating -- [ ] Present library comparison and recommended choice to user; get approval before proceeding -- [ ] Draft the BM25 step as a standalone markdown block: index build, term extraction by LLM from question, BM25 query, answer generation from hits, Step-6 verifier reuse, PASS/FAIL branching into semantic-search fallback -- [ ] Consult Software Engineer expert (subagent) to review for correctness and edge cases -- [ ] Revise based on findings -- [ ] Save final draft to `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` -- [ ] User review — present full draft and get approval before implementation -- [ ] Self-check: library choice approved, all branches (no hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback) specified, setup steps documented +- [x] Survey candidate BM25 libraries (e.g. rank-bm25, bm25s, Whoosh): license, pip install size, Python version compatibility, maintenance status +- [x] Identify the user setup impact: which library to `pip install`, whether it must be added to a requirements file, whether setup scripts need updating +- [x] Present library comparison and recommended choice to user; get approval before proceeding +- [x] Draft the BM25 step as a standalone markdown block: index build, term extraction by LLM from question, BM25 query, answer generation from hits, Step-6 verifier reuse, PASS/FAIL branching into semantic-search fallback +- [x] Consult Software Engineer expert (subagent) to review for correctness and edge cases +- [x] Revise based on findings +- [x] Save final draft to `.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md` +- [x] User review — present full draft and get approval before implementation +- [x] Self-check: library choice approved, all branches (no hits, PASS, FAIL→fallback) specified, setup steps documented **Completion criteria**: @@ -210,7 +210,19 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. # Decisions -(none yet) +## D-1: BM25 library — bm25s +- **Issue**: Which Python BM25 library to use for `bm25-search.sh` +- **Conclusion**: `bm25s` (MIT, v0.3.9, May 2026) +- **Rationale**: Only actively maintained option; index save/load eliminates per-call rebuild cost +- **Evidence**: rank-bm25 last released Feb 2022, ~2 QPS, no persistence; Whoosh last released Apr 2016, Python 3.12 compatibility uncertain; bm25s multiple 2026 releases, ~573 QPS, native save/load +- **Sources**: PyPI metadata, bm25-step-draft.md Section 1 + +## D-2: BM25 term extraction — cut from question as-is, typo-correct only +- **Issue**: How the LLM extracts search terms for BM25 from the user's question +- **Conclusion**: Extract concrete identifiers verbatim from the question text; correct obvious typos; do not add synonyms, related terms, or paraphrases +- **Rationale**: BM25 scores on exact/substring match — inferred or related terms increase document frequency and dilute hit quality +- **Evidence**: BM25 scoring degrades when query terms appear in many documents; synonyms/paraphrases are not in the question and would not match the knowledge JSON verbatim +- **Sources**: bm25-step-draft.md Step 3-1 discussion --- @@ -218,6 +230,6 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - **Status**: not suspended - **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: #1 Confirm existing benchmark baseline -- **Next**: #2 Select BM25 library and design pre-search step -- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current; pass 25/34, p50 cost $0.682, p50 time 118s +- **Last completed**: #2 Select BM25 library and design BM25 pre-search step +- **Next**: #3 Implement BM25 step in v6 qa.md and verify incrementally +- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s); bm25s selected (D-1); term extraction: cut from question as-is, typo-correct only (D-2) From 6886fb8b78d98987a27cd81638e0950e3cde35c7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 12:45:37 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 08/37] feat: add bm25-search.sh for BM25 pre-search in nabledge-6 Add scripts/bm25-search.sh that wraps bm25s Python library. Builds index from knowledge/*.json on first run, saves to scripts/.bm25-index/, and reloads on subsequent calls. Detects staleness by comparing index mtime to newest JSON mtime. Returns top-20 sections as JSON array with file, section_id, section_title, and score fields. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../skills/nabledge-6/scripts/bm25-search.sh | 167 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 167 insertions(+) create mode 100755 .claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/bm25-search.sh diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/bm25-search.sh b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/bm25-search.sh new file mode 100755 index 000000000..12be3119e --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/bm25-search.sh @@ -0,0 +1,167 @@ +#!/bin/bash +# BM25 pre-search over nabledge-6 knowledge files. +# +# - Builds a bm25s index from all knowledge/*.json section titles+content on first run +# - Saves index to scripts/.bm25-index/; reloads on subsequent runs +# - Detects staleness by comparing index mtime to newest JSON mtime; rebuilds if stale +# - Returns top-20 sections by BM25 score +# +# Arguments: one or more search terms +# Output: JSON array to stdout — [{file, section_id, section_title, score}, ...] +# Empty array [] if no hits or no arguments. +# Exit code: non-zero on error (missing bm25s, index build failure, etc.) + +set -euo pipefail + +SCRIPT_DIR="$(cd "$(dirname "$0")" && pwd)" +SKILL_DIR="$(cd "$SCRIPT_DIR/.." && pwd)" +KNOWLEDGE_DIR="${KNOWLEDGE_DIR:-$SKILL_DIR/knowledge}" +INDEX_DIR="$SCRIPT_DIR/.bm25-index" + +if [ $# -eq 0 ]; then + echo "[]" + exit 0 +fi + +python3 - "$KNOWLEDGE_DIR" "$INDEX_DIR" "$@" << 'PYEOF' +import sys +import json +import os +import time +from pathlib import Path + +knowledge_dir = Path(sys.argv[1]) +index_dir = Path(sys.argv[2]) +terms = sys.argv[3:] + +if not terms: + print(json.dumps([], ensure_ascii=False)) + sys.exit(0) + +try: + import bm25s + import numpy as np +except ImportError as e: + print(f"Error: {e}. Run: pip install bm25s", file=sys.stderr) + sys.exit(1) + +INDEX_FILE = index_dir / "index.bm25s" +META_FILE = index_dir / "meta.json" + + +# Token pattern: match sequences of word characters including CJK characters and underscores. +# \w+ covers ASCII identifiers; 　-鿿 covers CJK ideographs and common Japanese ranges. +# This is used as the token_pattern for bm25s.tokenize. +TOKEN_PATTERN = r'(?u)[\w　-鿿]+' + + +def get_newest_json_mtime(knowledge_dir: Path) -> float: + """Return the mtime of the most recently modified JSON file.""" + mtimes = [p.stat().st_mtime for p in knowledge_dir.rglob("*.json")] + return max(mtimes) if mtimes else 0.0 + + +def load_sections(knowledge_dir: Path) -> tuple[list[dict], list[str]]: + """Load all sections from knowledge JSON files. Returns (section_meta, corpus).""" + section_meta = [] + corpus = [] + for json_path in sorted(knowledge_dir.rglob("*.json")): + try: + data = json.loads(json_path.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + except Exception: + continue + if data.get("no_knowledge_content"): + continue + rel_path = json_path.relative_to(knowledge_dir).as_posix() + for sec in data.get("sections", []): + sid = sec.get("id", "") + if not sid: + continue + title = sec.get("title", "") + content = sec.get("content", "") + text = f"{title} {content}" + section_meta.append({ + "file": rel_path, + "section_id": sid, + "section_title": title, + }) + corpus.append(text) + return section_meta, corpus + + +def build_index(knowledge_dir: Path, index_dir: Path) -> tuple[object, list[dict]]: + """Build and save BM25 index. Returns (retriever, section_meta).""" + section_meta, corpus = load_sections(knowledge_dir) + if not corpus: + raise RuntimeError("No sections found in knowledge directory") + + tokenized = bm25s.tokenize(corpus, token_pattern=TOKEN_PATTERN, stopwords=None, show_progress=False) + retriever = bm25s.BM25() + retriever.index(tokenized, show_progress=False) + + index_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + retriever.save(str(INDEX_FILE)) + + newest_mtime = get_newest_json_mtime(knowledge_dir) + meta = { + "section_meta": section_meta, + "built_at": time.time(), + "newest_json_mtime": newest_mtime, + "count": len(section_meta), + } + META_FILE.write_text(json.dumps(meta, ensure_ascii=False), encoding="utf-8") + + return retriever, section_meta + + +def is_index_stale(knowledge_dir: Path) -> bool: + """Return True if the index needs to be rebuilt.""" + if not INDEX_FILE.exists() or not META_FILE.exists(): + return True + try: + meta = json.loads(META_FILE.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + saved_mtime = meta.get("newest_json_mtime", 0) + current_mtime = get_newest_json_mtime(knowledge_dir) + return current_mtime > saved_mtime + except Exception: + return True + + +def load_index(index_dir: Path) -> tuple[object, list[dict]]: + """Load saved BM25 index and metadata.""" + retriever = bm25s.BM25.load(str(INDEX_FILE), load_corpus=False) + meta = json.loads(META_FILE.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) + return retriever, meta["section_meta"] + + +# Build or reload index +if is_index_stale(knowledge_dir): + retriever, section_meta = build_index(knowledge_dir, index_dir) +else: + retriever, section_meta = load_index(index_dir) + +if not section_meta: + print(json.dumps([], ensure_ascii=False)) + sys.exit(0) + +# Search +query = " ".join(terms) +tokenized_query = bm25s.tokenize([query], token_pattern=TOKEN_PATTERN, stopwords=None, show_progress=False) +top_k = min(20, len(section_meta)) +results, scores = retriever.retrieve(tokenized_query, k=top_k, show_progress=False) + +# results shape: (n_queries, k), scores shape: (n_queries, k) +output = [] +for idx, score in zip(results[0], scores[0]): + if score <= 0: + continue + meta = section_meta[int(idx)] + output.append({ + "file": meta["file"], + "section_id": meta["section_id"], + "section_title": meta["section_title"], + "score": round(float(score), 4), + }) + +print(json.dumps(output, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2)) +PYEOF From e9879f7900da6c865509ef175875925b001556ec Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 12:46:40 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 09/37] feat: add BM25 pre-search step to nabledge-6 qa.md MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Insert Step 3 (BM25 pre-search) between Step 2 (ask user) and the former Step 3 (semantic search). Renumber former Steps 3-8 to Steps 4-9 and update all internal cross-references (Step 5→6 in answer generation pointer, Step 6→7 in verify pointer, Step 8→9 in output pointer). BM25 path: extract narrow terms → bm25-search.sh → read-sections.sh → generate answer → verify → if PASS skip Steps 4-8 to Step 9. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md | 130 ++++++++++++++++++++-- 1 file changed, 123 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md index cb136e706..9047409d6 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md @@ -127,7 +127,123 @@ Proceed to Step 3. --- -## Step 3: Semantic search +## Step 3: BM25 pre-search + +Attempt a fast BM25-ranked search before semantic search. If BM25 returns a verified answer, skip semantic search entirely. + +### Step 3-1: Extract BM25-effective terms + +From the user's question, extract terms that will **narrow the result set** in BM25 search — terms specific enough to appear in only a small number of knowledge files. + +**Criterion**: Extract a term if it is a concrete identifier (class name, annotation name, method name, configuration file name, SQL ID, component name) that appears verbatim in the Nablarch knowledge base. The test is: "Would a keyword match on this term return a small, focused set of pages?" + +**Source rule**: Take terms **as they appear in the question** — do not infer synonyms, related terms, or paraphrases. The only permitted modification is correcting an obvious typo or misspelling (e.g. `UniversalDoa` → `UniversalDao`) so the term matches the knowledge base. + +**Extract** (concrete identifiers, low document frequency): +`UniversalDao`, `@InjectForm`, `batchUpdate`, `SqlPStatement`, `web-component-configuration.xml`, `SQLID`, `RoutesMapping`, `BatchAction`, etc. + +**Do NOT extract** (broad terms, high document frequency — would match too many pages and dilute scores): +- Abstract concepts: `バリデーション`, `トランザクション`, `Handler`, `Action` +- General Java: `List`, `String`, `try-catch`, `Exception` +- Natural language filler: `使い方`, `方法`, `について` +- Do NOT add synonyms, related identifiers, or guessed class names not present in the question. + +Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). + +**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), skip immediately to Step 4 (semantic search). + +--- + +### Step 3-2: BM25 search + +Execute the BM25 search script with the extracted terms: + +```bash +bash scripts/bm25-search.sh [term2] ... +``` + +Replace ``, `[term2]` etc. with the terms from `bm25_terms`. + +The script outputs a JSON array. Each element is a section hit with a BM25 score: + +```json +[ + { + "file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "section_title": "batchUpdateメソッドの使い方", + "score": 12.45 + }, + ... +] +``` + +**If the output array is empty** (`[]`), set `bm25_sections = []` and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). + +**If the script exits non-zero** for any reason (index build failure, missing dependency, unexpected error), treat the result as empty and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). + +Otherwise, save the array as `bm25_raw`. Take the top 20 entries by score. + +Convert to the `selected_sections` format: + +```json +[ + {"file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", "section_id": "s3", "relevance": "high"} +] +``` + +Save as `bm25_sections`. + +--- + +### Step 3-3: Read section content + +From `bm25_sections`, build the argument list: for each section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. + +```bash +bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... +``` + +Save the output as `bm25_content`. + +**If `bm25_content` is empty or contains only `FILE_NOT_FOUND` / `SECTION_NOT_FOUND` entries**, skip to Step 4 (semantic search). + +--- + +### Step 3-4: Generate answer from BM25 hits + +Generate the answer using **exactly the same format, constraints, and rules as Step 6** (answer generation). Substitute `bm25_content` for `sections_content`. Save as `bm25_answer_text`. + +- If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. +- For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. + +--- + +### Step 3-5: Verify BM25 answer + +Apply the same verification procedure as Step 7 (hallucination check), using `bm25_answer_text` as the answer and `bm25_content` as the sections. + +Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. Use the same claim categories and boundary rules as Step 7. + +If any claim is unsupported, set `bm25_verify = FAIL`. Otherwise set `bm25_verify = PASS`. + +--- + +### Step 3-6: Handle BM25 verify result + +**If `bm25_verify = PASS`**: + +Set `final_answer = bm25_answer_text`. + +Skip Steps 4–8. Go directly to Step 9 (Output). + +**If `bm25_verify = FAIL`**: + +Discard `bm25_answer_text`. Proceed to Step 4 (semantic search) with no modifications. + +--- + +## Step 4: Semantic search Execute `workflows/semantic-search.md` with: - `{question}` = user's question with hearing result appended: @@ -138,7 +254,7 @@ Save the returned `selected_sections` array as `selected_sections`. --- -## Step 4: Read section content +## Step 5: Read section content From `selected_sections`, select sections to read: 1. All `high` sections first (body sections and Javadoc together) @@ -157,7 +273,7 @@ If `selected_sections` is empty, set `sections_content = ""`. --- -## Step 5: Generate answer +## Step 6: Generate answer If `sections_content` is empty, output immediately: ``` @@ -195,7 +311,7 @@ Save as `answer_text`. --- -## Step 6: Verify answer +## Step 7: Verify answer Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `answer_text` are supported by `sections_content`. @@ -230,14 +346,14 @@ If any claim is unsupported, set `verify_result = FAIL` and record `issues` (lis --- -## Step 7: Handle verify result +## Step 8: Handle verify result **If PASS**: Set `final_answer = answer_text`. -**If FAIL**: Re-run Step 5 once with the additional constraint: do not include any of the `issues` claims in the answer. Save the result as `final_answer`. +**If FAIL**: Re-run Step 6 once with the additional constraint: do not include any of the `issues` claims in the answer. Save the result as `final_answer`. --- -## Step 8: Output +## Step 9: Output Output `final_answer` to the user. From 86a2b1fbb0782a247352b834c7fa414f81a8aea2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 12:53:01 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 10/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20fix=20step-number=20refs=20in=20b?= =?UTF-8?q?m25-step-draft.md=20(Step=205=E2=86=926,=20Step=206=E2=86=927)?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md | 6 +++--- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md b/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md index 8d474b950..847bdc726 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md @@ -117,7 +117,7 @@ Save the output as `bm25_content`. ### Step 3-4: Generate answer from BM25 hits -Generate the answer using **exactly the same format, constraints, and rules as Step 5** (answer generation). Substitute `bm25_content` for `sections_content`. Save as `bm25_answer_text`. +Generate the answer using **exactly the same format, constraints, and rules as Step 6** (answer generation). Substitute `bm25_content` for `sections_content`. Save as `bm25_answer_text`. - If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. - For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. @@ -126,9 +126,9 @@ Generate the answer using **exactly the same format, constraints, and rules as S ### Step 3-5: Verify BM25 answer -Apply the same verification procedure as Step 6 (hallucination check), using `bm25_answer_text` as the answer and `bm25_content` as the sections. +Apply the same verification procedure as Step 7 (hallucination check), using `bm25_answer_text` as the answer and `bm25_content` as the sections. -Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. Use the same claim categories and boundary rules as Step 6. +Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. Use the same claim categories and boundary rules as Step 7. If any claim is unsupported, set `bm25_verify = FAIL`. Otherwise set `bm25_verify = PASS`. From a736f8c2a8c24299211ce619f9b8589394e94a30 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 13:05:43 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 11/37] =?UTF-8?q?chore:=20remove=20bm25-step-draft.md=20?= =?UTF-8?q?=E2=80=94=20decisions=20in=20steering.md,=20impl=20in=20qa.md?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md | 149 ------------------------------- 1 file changed, 149 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md b/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md deleted file mode 100644 index 847bdc726..000000000 --- a/.rn/issue-382/bm25-step-draft.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,149 +0,0 @@ -# BM25 Pre-Search — Research & Draft - -## Section 1: Library Comparison - -| Library | License | Latest version | Last release | Python min | Install size (approx) | Notes | -|---------|---------|---------------|--------------|------------|----------------------|-------| -| **rank-bm25** | Apache 2.0 | 0.2.2 | Feb 2022 | unspecified (py3) | ~8.5 KB + numpy | Pure Python + numpy. No index persistence — re-indexes on every call. Maintainer's own README flags it as unsuitable for large-scale use. ~2 QPS. Effectively unmaintained (4+ years). | -| **bm25s** | MIT | 0.3.9 | May 2026 | Python 3.8 | ~100 KB + numpy | Pure Python + numpy sparse matrices. Supports index save/load (build once, reload fast). Memory-mapped loading available. ~573 QPS. Actively maintained with multiple 2026 releases. | -| **Whoosh** | BSD 2-clause | 2.7.4 | Apr 2016 | unspecified | ~468 KB, no deps | Pure Python, zero dependencies. Last release 2016 (10 years); Python 3.12+ compatibility uncertain. Requires an on-disk index directory. Effectively a dead project. | - -### Recommendation: **bm25s** - -bm25s is the only actively maintained library of the three (multiple releases in 2026), and its index save/load feature is critical for on-demand bash-script invocation over ~50,000–200,000 sections — build the index once on first run, reload it in milliseconds on subsequent calls. Its sole mandatory dependency is numpy, which is already present in most Python environments used by nabledge's target users. - ---- - -## Section 1b: Index Lifecycle - -**When the index is built**: On first invocation of `bm25-search.sh`, the script builds the BM25 index from `knowledge/*.json` and saves it to a fixed path (e.g. `scripts/.bm25-index/`). Subsequent calls reload the saved index without rebuilding. - -**When to rebuild**: After `rbkc.sh create` regenerates the knowledge files, the index becomes stale. The script detects staleness by comparing the index mtime to the newest JSON mtime and rebuilds automatically — no manual intervention is needed. - -**User setup impact**: `pip install bm25s` must be added to the skill's setup script (`tools/setup/setup-6-cc.sh` and equivalent files for other versions). No additional manual step is needed at query time; index management is handled entirely by `bm25-search.sh`. - ---- - -## Section 2: BM25 Step Draft - -> **Renumbering note**: This draft shows only the new BM25 step. The existing Steps 3–8 in `qa.md` will be renumbered to Steps 4–9 during implementation (task #3). Any internal cross-references within those existing steps (e.g. "go to Step 3", "Step 7") will be updated at that time. - -The following step is intended to be inserted into `qa.md` **between Step 2 (hear processing_type/purpose) and the current Step 3 (semantic search)**. The current Step 3 through Step 8 numbering shifts by one after insertion; this draft uses the new numbering (Step 3 = BM25, Step 4 = former Step 3, …, Step 9 = former Step 8). - ---- - -## Step 3: BM25 pre-search - -Attempt a fast BM25-ranked search before semantic search. If BM25 returns a verified answer, skip semantic search entirely. - -### Step 3-1: Extract BM25-effective terms - -From the user's question, extract terms that will **narrow the result set** in BM25 search — terms specific enough to appear in only a small number of knowledge files. - -**Criterion**: Extract a term if it is a concrete identifier (class name, annotation name, method name, configuration file name, SQL ID, component name) that appears verbatim in the Nablarch knowledge base. The test is: "Would a keyword match on this term return a small, focused set of pages?" - -**Source rule**: Take terms **as they appear in the question** — do not infer synonyms, related terms, or paraphrases. The only permitted modification is correcting an obvious typo or misspelling (e.g. `UniversalDoa` → `UniversalDao`) so the term matches the knowledge base. - -**Extract** (concrete identifiers, low document frequency): -`UniversalDao`, `@InjectForm`, `batchUpdate`, `SqlPStatement`, `web-component-configuration.xml`, `SQLID`, `RoutesMapping`, `BatchAction`, etc. - -**Do NOT extract** (broad terms, high document frequency — would match too many pages and dilute scores): -- Abstract concepts: `バリデーション`, `トランザクション`, `Handler`, `Action` -- General Java: `List`, `String`, `try-catch`, `Exception` -- Natural language filler: `使い方`, `方法`, `について` -- Do NOT add synonyms, related identifiers, or guessed class names not present in the question. - -Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). - -**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), skip immediately to Step 4 (semantic search). - ---- - -### Step 3-2: BM25 search - -Execute the BM25 search script with the extracted terms: - -```bash -bash scripts/bm25-search.sh [term2] ... -``` - -Replace ``, `[term2]` etc. with the terms from `bm25_terms`. - -The script outputs a JSON array. Each element is a section hit with a BM25 score: - -```json -[ - { - "file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", - "section_id": "s3", - "section_title": "batchUpdateメソッドの使い方", - "score": 12.45 - }, - ... -] -``` - -**If the output array is empty** (`[]`), set `bm25_sections = []` and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). - -**If the script exits non-zero** for any reason (index build failure, missing dependency, unexpected error), treat the result as empty and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). - -Otherwise, save the array as `bm25_raw`. Take the top 20 entries by score. - -Convert to the `selected_sections` format: - -```json -[ - {"file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", "section_id": "s3", "relevance": "high"} -] -``` - -Save as `bm25_sections`. - ---- - -### Step 3-3: Read section content - -From `bm25_sections`, build the argument list: for each section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. - -```bash -bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... -``` - -Save the output as `bm25_content`. - -**If `bm25_content` is empty or contains only `FILE_NOT_FOUND` / `SECTION_NOT_FOUND` entries**, skip to Step 4 (semantic search). - ---- - -### Step 3-4: Generate answer from BM25 hits - -Generate the answer using **exactly the same format, constraints, and rules as Step 6** (answer generation). Substitute `bm25_content` for `sections_content`. Save as `bm25_answer_text`. - -- If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. -- For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. - ---- - -### Step 3-5: Verify BM25 answer - -Apply the same verification procedure as Step 7 (hallucination check), using `bm25_answer_text` as the answer and `bm25_content` as the sections. - -Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. Use the same claim categories and boundary rules as Step 7. - -If any claim is unsupported, set `bm25_verify = FAIL`. Otherwise set `bm25_verify = PASS`. - ---- - -### Step 3-6: Handle BM25 verify result - -**If `bm25_verify = PASS`**: - -Set `final_answer = bm25_answer_text`. - -Skip Steps 4–8. Go directly to Step 9 (Output). - -**If `bm25_verify = FAIL`**: - -Discard `bm25_answer_text`. Proceed to Step 4 (semantic search) with no modifications. - ---- From a3ab32ae34b33b9117e8e494fb6c2c6810b2e5d5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 13:07:07 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 12/37] refactor: extract BM25 pre-search to workflows/full-text-search.md Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md | 178 ++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 178 insertions(+) create mode 100644 .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..715508257 --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md @@ -0,0 +1,178 @@ +# Full-Text Search Workflow + +BM25 pre-search: attempts a fast keyword-based search and returns either a verified answer or a fallback signal. + +## Input + +- `{question}`: User's question text. +- `{processing_type}`: Processing type determined in qa.md Step 1 (may be null). + +## Output + +One of two results: + +```json +{"status": "complete", "final_answer": ""} +``` +BM25 produced a verified answer. The caller should use `final_answer` as-is and skip semantic search. + +```json +{"status": "fallback"} +``` +BM25 found nothing useful or verification failed. The caller should proceed to semantic search. + +--- + +## Step 1: Extract BM25-effective terms + +From the user's question, extract terms that will **narrow the result set** in BM25 search — terms specific enough to appear in only a small number of knowledge files. + +**Criterion**: Extract a term if it is a concrete identifier (class name, annotation name, method name, configuration file name, SQL ID, component name) that appears verbatim in the Nablarch knowledge base. The test is: "Would a keyword match on this term return a small, focused set of pages?" + +**Source rule**: Take terms **as they appear in the question** — do not infer synonyms, related terms, or paraphrases. The only permitted modification is correcting an obvious typo or misspelling (e.g. `UniversalDoa` → `UniversalDao`) so the term matches the knowledge base. + +**Extract** (concrete identifiers, low document frequency): +`UniversalDao`, `@InjectForm`, `batchUpdate`, `SqlPStatement`, `web-component-configuration.xml`, `SQLID`, `RoutesMapping`, `BatchAction`, etc. + +**Do NOT extract** (broad terms, high document frequency — would match too many pages and dilute scores): +- Abstract concepts: `バリデーション`, `トランザクション`, `Handler`, `Action` +- General Java: `List`, `String`, `try-catch`, `Exception` +- Natural language filler: `使い方`, `方法`, `について` +- Do NOT add synonyms, related identifiers, or guessed class names not present in the question. + +Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). + +**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), return `{"status": "fallback"}` immediately. + +--- + +## Step 2: BM25 search + +Execute the BM25 search script with the extracted terms: + +```bash +bash scripts/bm25-search.sh [term2] ... +``` + +Replace ``, `[term2]` etc. with the terms from `bm25_terms`. + +The script outputs a JSON array. Each element is a section hit with a BM25 score: + +```json +[ + { + "file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "section_title": "batchUpdateメソッドの使い方", + "score": 12.45 + }, + ... +] +``` + +**If the output array is empty** (`[]`), return `{"status": "fallback"}`. + +**If the script exits non-zero** for any reason (index build failure, missing dependency, unexpected error), return `{"status": "fallback"}`. + +Otherwise, save the array as `bm25_raw`. Take the top 20 entries by score. + +Convert to the `selected_sections` format: + +```json +[ + {"file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", "section_id": "s3", "relevance": "high"} +] +``` + +Save as `bm25_sections`. + +--- + +## Step 3: Read section content + +From `bm25_sections`, build the argument list: for each section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. + +```bash +bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... +``` + +Save the output as `bm25_content`. + +**If `bm25_content` is empty or contains only `FILE_NOT_FOUND` / `SECTION_NOT_FOUND` entries**, return `{"status": "fallback"}`. + +--- + +## Step 4: Generate answer from BM25 hits + +Generate a Japanese answer from `bm25_content`. Use the same answer format as qa.md Step 6: + +**Answer format**: + +**結論**: Direct answer to the question (1–2 sentences) +- Include specific method names, class names, and approaches +- Do not parrot back the question + +**根拠**: Code examples, configuration examples, or spec information that backs the conclusion +- Show code/config examples in code blocks +- Priority: implementation example > configuration example > API spec > conceptual explanation +- If using multiple sections, organize along the implementation flow +- Quote code examples from sections verbatim (do not modify) + +**注意点**: Constraints, resource management, common mistakes +- Omit this section if nothing applies + +参照: Only sections actually cited in the answer (file.json:sN format, omit category path) + +Additional constraints: +- If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. +- For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. +- Stay within 500 tokens (up to 800 for complex questions). + +Save as `bm25_answer_text`. + +--- + +## Step 5: Verify BM25 answer + +Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. + +**Extract these claim categories** (Nablarch-specific claims): + +| Category | Examples | +|----------|---------| +| API names | "UniversalDao.deferメソッド", "@InjectForm アノテーション" | +| Class names | "DatabaseRecordReader", "BatchAction" | +| Configuration method | "web-component-configuration.xmlに設定", "コンポーネント定義ファイルに記述" | +| Behavior spec | "遅延ロードはDB接続をストリーミングする", "バリデーションエラー時にステータスコード400を返す" | +| Constraints | "closeしないとリソースリーク", "Formのプロパティは全てString型" | +| Parameters | "-requestPathで指定", "SQLID" | + +**Do NOT extract** (general knowledge): + +| Category | Examples | +|----------|---------| +| General Java | "Beanクラスを作成する", "try-with-resourcesを使う" | +| General programming | "バリデーションを実行する", "エラーメッセージを表示する" | +| Flow description | "まず〜して、次に〜する" | +| General web concepts | "HTTPリクエスト", "JSONレスポンス" | + +For each extracted claim, judge in order: +1. Directly stated in section content → supported +2. Direct paraphrase of section content (paraphrase/abbreviation/synonym) → supported +3. Attribute/behavior/constraint not explicitly stated → unsupported + +Boundary rule: Inference is valid only for direct paraphrases. Attributes, behaviors, or constraints not explicitly stated are unsupported even if technically plausible. + +If any claim is unsupported, set `bm25_verify = FAIL`. Otherwise set `bm25_verify = PASS`. + +--- + +## Step 6: Handle verify result + +**If `bm25_verify = PASS`**: + +Return `{"status": "complete", "final_answer": ""}`. + +**If `bm25_verify = FAIL`**: + +Return `{"status": "fallback"}`. From 60bd529661fce532e68517bfdecd4db464446018 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 13:07:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 13/37] refactor: qa.md Step 3 calls full-text-search.md workflow Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md | 114 +--------------------- 1 file changed, 5 insertions(+), 109 deletions(-) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md index 9047409d6..6034ad5a3 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md @@ -129,117 +129,13 @@ Proceed to Step 3. ## Step 3: BM25 pre-search -Attempt a fast BM25-ranked search before semantic search. If BM25 returns a verified answer, skip semantic search entirely. +Execute `workflows/full-text-search.md` with: +- `{question}` = user's question text +- `{processing_type}` = processing_type (null if not determined) -### Step 3-1: Extract BM25-effective terms +If the returned `status` is `"complete"`: set `final_answer` to the returned `final_answer` value and skip to Step 9 (Output). -From the user's question, extract terms that will **narrow the result set** in BM25 search — terms specific enough to appear in only a small number of knowledge files. - -**Criterion**: Extract a term if it is a concrete identifier (class name, annotation name, method name, configuration file name, SQL ID, component name) that appears verbatim in the Nablarch knowledge base. The test is: "Would a keyword match on this term return a small, focused set of pages?" - -**Source rule**: Take terms **as they appear in the question** — do not infer synonyms, related terms, or paraphrases. The only permitted modification is correcting an obvious typo or misspelling (e.g. `UniversalDoa` → `UniversalDao`) so the term matches the knowledge base. - -**Extract** (concrete identifiers, low document frequency): -`UniversalDao`, `@InjectForm`, `batchUpdate`, `SqlPStatement`, `web-component-configuration.xml`, `SQLID`, `RoutesMapping`, `BatchAction`, etc. - -**Do NOT extract** (broad terms, high document frequency — would match too many pages and dilute scores): -- Abstract concepts: `バリデーション`, `トランザクション`, `Handler`, `Action` -- General Java: `List`, `String`, `try-catch`, `Exception` -- Natural language filler: `使い方`, `方法`, `について` -- Do NOT add synonyms, related identifiers, or guessed class names not present in the question. - -Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). - -**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), skip immediately to Step 4 (semantic search). - ---- - -### Step 3-2: BM25 search - -Execute the BM25 search script with the extracted terms: - -```bash -bash scripts/bm25-search.sh [term2] ... -``` - -Replace ``, `[term2]` etc. with the terms from `bm25_terms`. - -The script outputs a JSON array. Each element is a section hit with a BM25 score: - -```json -[ - { - "file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", - "section_id": "s3", - "section_title": "batchUpdateメソッドの使い方", - "score": 12.45 - }, - ... -] -``` - -**If the output array is empty** (`[]`), set `bm25_sections = []` and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). - -**If the script exits non-zero** for any reason (index build failure, missing dependency, unexpected error), treat the result as empty and skip to Step 4 (semantic search). - -Otherwise, save the array as `bm25_raw`. Take the top 20 entries by score. - -Convert to the `selected_sections` format: - -```json -[ - {"file": "component/libraries/universal-dao.json", "section_id": "s3", "relevance": "high"} -] -``` - -Save as `bm25_sections`. - ---- - -### Step 3-3: Read section content - -From `bm25_sections`, build the argument list: for each section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. - -```bash -bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... -``` - -Save the output as `bm25_content`. - -**If `bm25_content` is empty or contains only `FILE_NOT_FOUND` / `SECTION_NOT_FOUND` entries**, skip to Step 4 (semantic search). - ---- - -### Step 3-4: Generate answer from BM25 hits - -Generate the answer using **exactly the same format, constraints, and rules as Step 6** (answer generation). Substitute `bm25_content` for `sections_content`. Save as `bm25_answer_text`. - -- If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. -- For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. - ---- - -### Step 3-5: Verify BM25 answer - -Apply the same verification procedure as Step 7 (hallucination check), using `bm25_answer_text` as the answer and `bm25_content` as the sections. - -Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. Use the same claim categories and boundary rules as Step 7. - -If any claim is unsupported, set `bm25_verify = FAIL`. Otherwise set `bm25_verify = PASS`. - ---- - -### Step 3-6: Handle BM25 verify result - -**If `bm25_verify = PASS`**: - -Set `final_answer = bm25_answer_text`. - -Skip Steps 4–8. Go directly to Step 9 (Output). - -**If `bm25_verify = FAIL`**: - -Discard `bm25_answer_text`. Proceed to Step 4 (semantic search) with no modifications. +If the returned `status` is `"fallback"`: proceed to Step 4 (semantic search). --- From 9644567039f06348b7a570ee907146b535870892 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 13:11:31 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 14/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20task-3=20in=20progress=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20Phase=20A=20done,=20refactored=20to=20full-text-search.md?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md | 18 ++++++++++++++++++ .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 13 ++++++++----- 2 files changed, 26 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4047c6b6e --- /dev/null +++ b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +# task-3 Completion Check + +## Completion Criteria + +| Criterion | Self-check | Evidence | QA | QA Evidence | +|---|---|---|---|---| +| qa.md contains BM25 pre-search step | OK | `## Step 3: BM25 pre-search` present in qa.md as a concise workflow call (no inline sub-steps); calls `workflows/full-text-search.md` | | | +| Existing steps renumbered correctly (all cross-refs updated) | OK | Steps 4–9 in qa.md unchanged; Step 1 "proceed to Step 3" and Step 2 "Proceed to Step 3" unchanged; no broken cross-refs | | | +| bm25-search.sh exists and outputs valid JSON | OK | Unchanged from previous task — `bash scripts/bm25-search.sh UniversalDao` returns valid JSON array with score fields | | | +| Phase A: pre-01 exits 0 and BM25 path exercised | OK | Refactor only — no runtime behavior change; qa.md Step 3 now delegates to full-text-search.md which contains the same logic | | | + +## QA Expert Review +(leave blank — coordinator fills) + +## Overall Verdict +- Self-check: OK — `full-text-search.md` created with all 6 BM25 steps; qa.md Step 3 is now a concise workflow call; Steps 4–9 unchanged +- QA: +- Ready for user review: diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index a6c0d256d..4e9ede18d 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -119,8 +119,9 @@ incrementally — single scenario first, then path-coverage sample, then full 3- **Steps**: -- [ ] Insert the approved BM25 step into `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` before the current Step 3; renumber subsequent steps if needed -- [ ] **Phase A (1 scenario)**: run `pre-01` via `run_qa --scenario-ids pre-01`; confirm exit 0, answer.md non-empty, BM25 path exercised; delete tmp dir after +- [x] Insert the approved BM25 step into `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` before the current Step 3; renumber subsequent steps if needed +- [x] **Phase A (1 scenario)**: run `pre-01` via `run_qa --scenario-ids pre-01`; confirm exit 0, answer.md non-empty, BM25 path exercised; delete tmp dir after +- [x] Refactor: extract BM25 step to `workflows/full-text-search.md`; qa.md Step 3 becomes a concise workflow call (mirrors semantic-search.md pattern) - [ ] **Path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios)**: select scenarios that cover BM25-complete path, BM25-FAIL→fallback path, and no-hits path; run them; inspect `workflow_details.json` to confirm each path behaved as designed; fix qa.md if any path misbehaves - [ ] **Phase B/C full benchmark**: 3 runs × 34 scenarios per HOW-TO-RUN.md; generate per-run reports and crossrun-summary; commit each run immediately after completion - [ ] Phase E regression check: compare against baseline from #1 @@ -230,6 +231,8 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - **Status**: not suspended - **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: #2 Select BM25 library and design BM25 pre-search step -- **Next**: #3 Implement BM25 step in v6 qa.md and verify incrementally -- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s); bm25s selected (D-1); term extraction: cut from question as-is, typo-correct only (D-2) +- **Status**: paused +- **Date**: 2026-06-25 +- **Last completed**: #2 (design). #3 in progress — Phase A done, refactor to full-text-search.md done +- **Next**: #3 path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios covering BM25-complete, FAIL→fallback, no-hits paths) +- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s). bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. bm25-search.sh and full-text-search.md committed. qa.md Step 3 now calls full-text-search.md. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). Next: run path-coverage sample — suggest scenarios with Nablarch class names (BM25-complete candidate), abstract question (no-hits candidate), and one where BM25 should fail verify (fallback candidate); inspect workflow_details.json for each path. From 92f8f1f8f28c601f148ca41f9206e2fcfb167469 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 13:43:16 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 15/37] refactor: extract qa.md into focused workflows (hearing/generate-answer/verify-answer) Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md | 114 +------- .../nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md | 72 +++++ .../skills/nabledge-6/workflows/hearing.md | 131 ++++++++++ .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md | 247 ++++-------------- .../nabledge-6/workflows/semantic-search.md | 4 +- .../nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md | 57 ++++ 6 files changed, 325 insertions(+), 300 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md create mode 100644 .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/hearing.md create mode 100644 .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md index 715508257..0f4e2702b 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md @@ -1,25 +1,24 @@ # Full-Text Search Workflow -BM25 pre-search: attempts a fast keyword-based search and returns either a verified answer or a fallback signal. +BM25 keyword search. Returns matching sections. ## Input - `{question}`: User's question text. -- `{processing_type}`: Processing type determined in qa.md Step 1 (may be null). ## Output -One of two results: - ```json -{"status": "complete", "final_answer": ""} +{"selected_sections": [...]} ``` -BM25 produced a verified answer. The caller should use `final_answer` as-is and skip semantic search. + +or ```json -{"status": "fallback"} +{"selected_sections": []} ``` -BM25 found nothing useful or verification failed. The caller should proceed to semantic search. + +Empty array when no BM25 terms found, script returns no hits, or script exits non-zero. --- @@ -42,7 +41,7 @@ From the user's question, extract terms that will **narrow the result set** in B Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). -**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), return `{"status": "fallback"}` immediately. +**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), return `{"selected_sections": []}` immediately. --- @@ -70,9 +69,9 @@ The script outputs a JSON array. Each element is a section hit with a BM25 score ] ``` -**If the output array is empty** (`[]`), return `{"status": "fallback"}`. +**If the output array is empty** (`[]`), return `{"selected_sections": []}`. -**If the script exits non-zero** for any reason (index build failure, missing dependency, unexpected error), return `{"status": "fallback"}`. +**If the script exits non-zero** for any reason (index build failure, missing dependency, unexpected error), return `{"selected_sections": []}`. Otherwise, save the array as `bm25_raw`. Take the top 20 entries by score. @@ -84,95 +83,10 @@ Convert to the `selected_sections` format: ] ``` -Save as `bm25_sections`. - ---- - -## Step 3: Read section content +All BM25 hits use `"relevance": "high"`. -From `bm25_sections`, build the argument list: for each section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. +Return: -```bash -bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... +```json +{"selected_sections": [...]} ``` - -Save the output as `bm25_content`. - -**If `bm25_content` is empty or contains only `FILE_NOT_FOUND` / `SECTION_NOT_FOUND` entries**, return `{"status": "fallback"}`. - ---- - -## Step 4: Generate answer from BM25 hits - -Generate a Japanese answer from `bm25_content`. Use the same answer format as qa.md Step 6: - -**Answer format**: - -**結論**: Direct answer to the question (1–2 sentences) -- Include specific method names, class names, and approaches -- Do not parrot back the question - -**根拠**: Code examples, configuration examples, or spec information that backs the conclusion -- Show code/config examples in code blocks -- Priority: implementation example > configuration example > API spec > conceptual explanation -- If using multiple sections, organize along the implementation flow -- Quote code examples from sections verbatim (do not modify) - -**注意点**: Constraints, resource management, common mistakes -- Omit this section if nothing applies - -参照: Only sections actually cited in the answer (file.json:sN format, omit category path) - -Additional constraints: -- If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. -- For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. -- Stay within 500 tokens (up to 800 for complex questions). - -Save as `bm25_answer_text`. - ---- - -## Step 5: Verify BM25 answer - -Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `bm25_answer_text` are supported by `bm25_content`. - -**Extract these claim categories** (Nablarch-specific claims): - -| Category | Examples | -|----------|---------| -| API names | "UniversalDao.deferメソッド", "@InjectForm アノテーション" | -| Class names | "DatabaseRecordReader", "BatchAction" | -| Configuration method | "web-component-configuration.xmlに設定", "コンポーネント定義ファイルに記述" | -| Behavior spec | "遅延ロードはDB接続をストリーミングする", "バリデーションエラー時にステータスコード400を返す" | -| Constraints | "closeしないとリソースリーク", "Formのプロパティは全てString型" | -| Parameters | "-requestPathで指定", "SQLID" | - -**Do NOT extract** (general knowledge): - -| Category | Examples | -|----------|---------| -| General Java | "Beanクラスを作成する", "try-with-resourcesを使う" | -| General programming | "バリデーションを実行する", "エラーメッセージを表示する" | -| Flow description | "まず〜して、次に〜する" | -| General web concepts | "HTTPリクエスト", "JSONレスポンス" | - -For each extracted claim, judge in order: -1. Directly stated in section content → supported -2. Direct paraphrase of section content (paraphrase/abbreviation/synonym) → supported -3. Attribute/behavior/constraint not explicitly stated → unsupported - -Boundary rule: Inference is valid only for direct paraphrases. Attributes, behaviors, or constraints not explicitly stated are unsupported even if technically plausible. - -If any claim is unsupported, set `bm25_verify = FAIL`. Otherwise set `bm25_verify = PASS`. - ---- - -## Step 6: Handle verify result - -**If `bm25_verify = PASS`**: - -Return `{"status": "complete", "final_answer": ""}`. - -**If `bm25_verify = FAIL`**: - -Return `{"status": "fallback"}`. diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..426ae4633 --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,72 @@ +# Generate Answer Workflow + +Reads selected sections and generates a Japanese answer. + +## Input + +- `{question}`: User's question (natural Japanese text). +- `{processing_type}`: Processing type (one of the 7 processing types, or null). +- `{selected_sections}`: Array of section pointers in `{"file": "...", "section_id": "...", "relevance": "..."}` format. +- `{excluded_claims}`: (Optional) List of claim strings to exclude from the answer. If not provided or empty, no exclusions apply. + +## Output + +- `answer_text`: Generated answer string. + +--- + +## Step 1: Read section content + +From `selected_sections`, select sections to read: +1. All `high` sections first (body sections and Javadoc together) +2. Then `partial` sections to fill remaining slots +3. Maximum 20 entries total, counting body sections and Javadoc together + +Build the argument list: for each selected section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. + +```bash +bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... +``` + +Save the output as `sections_content`. + +If `selected_sections` is empty, set `sections_content = ""`. + +--- + +## Step 2: Generate answer + +If `sections_content` is empty, output immediately: +``` +この情報は知識ファイルに含まれていません。 +``` +and stop. + +Otherwise, generate a Japanese answer following the steps below. + +1. Read all sections in `sections_content`. +2. If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. +3. Identify the information that directly answers the question. For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. +4. If `{excluded_claims}` is provided and non-empty, do not include any of the following claims in the answer: `{excluded_claims}`. +5. Write the answer in the format below. Stay within 500 tokens (up to 800 for complex questions). + +**Answer format**: + +**結論**: Direct answer to the question (1–2 sentences) +- Include specific method names, class names, and approaches +- Do not parrot back the question + +**根拠**: Code examples, configuration examples, or spec information that backs the conclusion +- Show code/config examples in code blocks +- Priority: implementation example > configuration example > API spec > conceptual explanation +- If using multiple sections, organize along the implementation flow +- Quote code examples from sections verbatim (do not modify) + +**注意点**: Constraints, resource management, common mistakes +- Omit this section if nothing applies + +参照: Only sections actually cited in the answer (file.json:sN format, omit category path) + +Note: General Java/programming knowledge (try-catch, Bean, getter/setter, etc.) may be used alongside knowledge sections. + +Save as `answer_text`. diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/hearing.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/hearing.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..20386cbad --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/hearing.md @@ -0,0 +1,131 @@ +# Hearing Workflow + +Classifies the question and asks the user if needed. + +## Input + +- `{question}`: User's question (natural Japanese text) + +## Output + +- `processing_type`: one of the 7 processing types, or null +- `purpose`: one of the 6 purpose categories + +--- + +## Step 1: Classify question + +From the question, determine `processing_type` and `purpose` independently. + +### Determine processing_type + +Judge which processing type the question belongs to. Use the names and technical terms below as reference: + +Processing types: +- ウェブアプリケーション +- RESTfulウェブサービス +- Nablarchバッチ +- Jakartaバッチ +- テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング +- HTTPメッセージング +- MOMメッセージング + +Judgment: +- Question clearly belongs to one processing type → `processing_type = ` +- Question is cross-functional (testing framework, i18n, logging, common utilities) → `processing_type = null` +- Otherwise → `processing_type = UNCLEAR` + +Note: Common concepts (transactions, validation, DB access, SQL) are NOT cross-functional if their configuration/implementation differs per processing type. + +### Determine purpose + +Judge the purpose from the question. Reference categories: + +Purpose categories: +- 実装したい +- 仕組み・動作を理解したい +- 不具合・エラーを調査したい +- テストを書きたい +- バージョンアップしたい +- セキュリティ対応したい + +- Purpose is clear from the question → `purpose = ` +- Cannot determine from the question → `purpose = UNCLEAR` + +### Result + +If both `processing_type` and `purpose` are determined (not UNCLEAR) → proceed to output. + +If either is UNCLEAR → proceed to Step 2. + +--- + +## Step 2: Ask user if needed + +If both `processing_type` and `purpose` are already determined in Step 1, skip to output. + +Otherwise, ask only about what is UNCLEAR. + +**If both processing_type and purpose are UNCLEAR**, output both questions together in one message: + +``` +いくつか確認させてください。 + +どの処理方式の質問ですか？ +1. ウェブアプリケーション +2. RESTfulウェブサービス +3. Nablarchバッチ +4. Jakartaバッチ +5. テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング +6. HTTPメッセージング +7. MOMメッセージング +8. その他（処理方式に依存しない） + +質問の目的は？ +1. 実装したい +2. 仕組み・動作を理解したい +3. 不具合・エラーを調査したい +4. テストを書きたい +5. バージョンアップしたい +6. セキュリティ対応したい +7. その他 +``` + +**If only processing_type is UNCLEAR**, output: + +``` +どの処理方式の質問ですか？ + +1. ウェブアプリケーション +2. RESTfulウェブサービス +3. Nablarchバッチ +4. Jakartaバッチ +5. テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング +6. HTTPメッセージング +7. MOMメッセージング +8. その他（処理方式に依存しない） +``` + +**If only purpose is UNCLEAR**, output: + +``` +質問の目的は？ + +1. 実装したい +2. 仕組み・動作を理解したい +3. 不具合・エラーを調査したい +4. テストを書きたい +5. バージョンアップしたい +6. セキュリティ対応したい +7. その他 +``` + +Wait for the user's response. Then set: +- `processing_type`: from Step 1 or user's selection (「その他」or 8 → null) +- `purpose`: from Step 1 or user's selection (「その他」or 8 → 実装したい) + +--- + +## Output + +Return `processing_type` and `purpose`. diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md index 6034ad5a3..75dc9182c 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md @@ -12,244 +12,93 @@ Answer in Japanese (Markdown) --- -## Step 1: Classify question +## Step 1 -From the question, determine `processing_type` and `purpose` independently. +Execute `workflows/hearing.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question -### Determine processing_type - -Judge which processing type the question belongs to. Use the names and technical terms below as reference: - -Processing types: -- ウェブアプリケーション -- RESTfulウェブサービス -- Nablarchバッチ -- Jakartaバッチ -- テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング -- HTTPメッセージング -- MOMメッセージング - -Judgment: -- Question clearly belongs to one processing type → `processing_type = ` -- Question is cross-functional (testing framework, i18n, logging, common utilities) → `processing_type = null` -- Otherwise → `processing_type = UNCLEAR` - -Note: Common concepts (transactions, validation, DB access, SQL) are NOT cross-functional if their configuration/implementation differs per processing type. - -### Determine purpose - -Judge the purpose from the question. Reference categories: - -Purpose categories: -- 実装したい -- 仕組み・動作を理解したい -- 不具合・エラーを調査したい -- テストを書きたい -- バージョンアップしたい -- セキュリティ対応したい - -- Purpose is clear from the question → `purpose = ` -- Cannot determine from the question → `purpose = UNCLEAR` - -### Result - -If both `processing_type` and `purpose` are determined (not UNCLEAR) → proceed to Step 3. - -If either is UNCLEAR → proceed to Step 2. +Save result as `processing_type`, `purpose`. --- -## Step 2: Ask user if needed - -If both `processing_type` and `purpose` are already determined in Step 1, skip to the build step below. - -Otherwise, ask only about what is UNCLEAR. - -**If both processing_type and purpose are UNCLEAR**, output both questions together in one message: - -``` -いくつか確認させてください。 - -どの処理方式の質問ですか？ -1. ウェブアプリケーション -2. RESTfulウェブサービス -3. Nablarchバッチ -4. Jakartaバッチ -5. テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング -6. HTTPメッセージング -7. MOMメッセージング -8. その他（処理方式に依存しない） - -質問の目的は？ -1. 実装したい -2. 仕組み・動作を理解したい -3. 不具合・エラーを調査したい -4. テストを書きたい -5. バージョンアップしたい -6. セキュリティ対応したい -7. その他 -``` - -**If only processing_type is UNCLEAR**, output: - -``` -どの処理方式の質問ですか？ - -1. ウェブアプリケーション -2. RESTfulウェブサービス -3. Nablarchバッチ -4. Jakartaバッチ -5. テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング -6. HTTPメッセージング -7. MOMメッセージング -8. その他（処理方式に依存しない） -``` - -**If only purpose is UNCLEAR**, output: - -``` -質問の目的は？ - -1. 実装したい -2. 仕組み・動作を理解したい -3. 不具合・エラーを調査したい -4. テストを書きたい -5. バージョンアップしたい -6. セキュリティ対応したい -7. その他 -``` +## Step 2 -Wait for the user's response. Then set: -- `processing_type`: from Step 1 or user's selection (「その他」or 8 → null) -- `purpose`: from Step 1 or user's selection (「その他」or 8 → 実装したい) +Execute `workflows/full-text-search.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question -Proceed to Step 3. +Save `selected_sections` as `bm25_sections`. --- -## Step 3: BM25 pre-search - -Execute `workflows/full-text-search.md` with: -- `{question}` = user's question text -- `{processing_type}` = processing_type (null if not determined) +## Step 3 -If the returned `status` is `"complete"`: set `final_answer` to the returned `final_answer` value and skip to Step 9 (Output). +If `bm25_sections` is empty, skip to Step 5. -If the returned `status` is `"fallback"`: proceed to Step 4 (semantic search). +Execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question +- `{processing_type}` = processing_type +- `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections ---- +Save result as `answer_text`. -## Step 4: Semantic search +Execute `workflows/verify-answer.md`: +- `{answer_text}` = answer_text +- `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections -Execute `workflows/semantic-search.md` with: -- `{question}` = user's question with hearing result appended: - - If `processing_type` is not null: `"{user's question}（処理方式: {processing_type}）（目的: {purpose}）"` - - If `processing_type` is null: `"{user's question}（目的: {purpose}）"` +If result is `"PASS"`, set `final_answer = answer_text` and skip to Step 7. -Save the returned `selected_sections` array as `selected_sections`. +If result is `"FAIL"`, proceed to Step 4. --- -## Step 5: Read section content +## Step 4 -From `selected_sections`, select sections to read: -1. All `high` sections first (body sections and Javadoc together) -2. Then `partial` sections to fill remaining slots -3. Maximum 20 entries total, counting body sections and Javadoc together - -Build the argument list: for each selected section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. - -```bash -bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... -``` +(BM25 verify failed — fall through to semantic search) -Save the output as `sections_content`. +--- -If `selected_sections` is empty, set `sections_content = ""`. +## Step 5 ---- +Execute `workflows/semantic-search.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question +- `{processing_type}` = processing_type +- `{purpose}` = purpose -## Step 6: Generate answer +Save `selected_sections` as `sem_sections`. -If `sections_content` is empty, output immediately: +If `sem_sections` is empty, output: ``` この情報は知識ファイルに含まれていません。 ``` and stop. -Otherwise, generate a Japanese answer following the steps below. - -1. Read all sections in `sections_content`. -2. If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. -3. Identify the information that directly answers the question. For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. -4. Write the answer in the format below. Stay within 500 tokens (up to 800 for complex questions). - -**Answer format**: - -**結論**: Direct answer to the question (1–2 sentences) -- Include specific method names, class names, and approaches -- Do not parrot back the question - -**根拠**: Code examples, configuration examples, or spec information that backs the conclusion -- Show code/config examples in code blocks -- Priority: implementation example > configuration example > API spec > conceptual explanation -- If using multiple sections, organize along the implementation flow -- Quote code examples from sections verbatim (do not modify) - -**注意点**: Constraints, resource management, common mistakes -- Omit this section if nothing applies - -参照: Only sections actually cited in the answer (file.json:sN format, omit category path) - -Note: General Java/programming knowledge (try-catch, Bean, getter/setter, etc.) may be used alongside knowledge sections. - -Save as `answer_text`. - --- -## Step 7: Verify answer - -Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `answer_text` are supported by `sections_content`. +## Step 6 -**Extract these claim categories** (Nablarch-specific claims): +Execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question +- `{processing_type}` = processing_type +- `{selected_sections}` = sem_sections -| Category | Examples | -|----------|---------| -| API names | "UniversalDao.deferメソッド", "@InjectForm アノテーション" | -| Class names | "DatabaseRecordReader", "BatchAction" | -| Configuration method | "web-component-configuration.xmlに設定", "コンポーネント定義ファイルに記述" | -| Behavior spec | "遅延ロードはDB接続をストリーミングする", "バリデーションエラー時にステータスコード400を返す" | -| Constraints | "closeしないとリソースリーク", "Formのプロパティは全てString型" | -| Parameters | "-requestPathで指定", "SQLID" | +Save result as `answer_text`. -**Do NOT extract** (general knowledge): - -| Category | Examples | -|----------|---------| -| General Java | "Beanクラスを作成する", "try-with-resourcesを使う" | -| General programming | "バリデーションを実行する", "エラーメッセージを表示する" | -| Flow description | "まず〜して、次に〜する" | -| General web concepts | "HTTPリクエスト", "JSONレスポンス" | - -For each extracted claim, judge in order: -1. Directly stated in section content → supported -2. Direct paraphrase of section content (paraphrase/abbreviation/synonym) → supported -3. Attribute/behavior/constraint not explicitly stated → unsupported - -Boundary rule: Inference is valid only for direct paraphrases. Attributes, behaviors, or constraints not explicitly stated are unsupported even if technically plausible. - -If any claim is unsupported, set `verify_result = FAIL` and record `issues` (list of unsupported claims). Otherwise `verify_result = PASS`. - ---- +Execute `workflows/verify-answer.md`: +- `{answer_text}` = answer_text +- `{selected_sections}` = sem_sections -## Step 8: Handle verify result +If result is `"PASS"`, set `final_answer = answer_text` and proceed to Step 7. -**If PASS**: Set `final_answer = answer_text`. +If result is `"FAIL"`, execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question +- `{processing_type}` = processing_type +- `{selected_sections}` = sem_sections +- `{excluded_claims}` = verify result issues -**If FAIL**: Re-run Step 6 once with the additional constraint: do not include any of the `issues` claims in the answer. Save the result as `final_answer`. +Set `final_answer` to the result. --- -## Step 9: Output +## Step 7 -Output `final_answer` to the user. +Output `final_answer`. diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/semantic-search.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/semantic-search.md index f432588bd..823b43480 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/semantic-search.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/semantic-search.md @@ -5,6 +5,8 @@ Searches knowledge files and returns relevant sections for the question. ## Input - `{question}`: User's question. +- `{processing_type}`: Processing type (one of the 7 processing types, or null). +- `{purpose}`: Purpose category (one of the 6 purpose categories). ## Output @@ -24,7 +26,7 @@ Pointer JSON: 1. Read `knowledge/index.md` (relative to skill root). Save content as `index_content`. 2. Read the question. Write one sentence: what does the user want to know? -3. Extract constraints: if the question contains `（処理方式: X）`, note X as the processing type constraint. If it contains `（目的: X）`, note X as the purpose. +3. Read `{processing_type}` as the processing type constraint. Read `{purpose}` as the purpose. 4. For each page in `index_content`, apply this decision procedure and collect all candidates: - Does this page cover the exact feature, component, or topic the question is asking about? → **candidate** - Does this page cover a feature that directly solves the technical problem in the question? → **candidate** diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..878bb5fee --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +# Verify Answer Workflow + +Verifies that all Nablarch-specific claims in the answer are supported by the sections. + +## Input + +- `{answer_text}`: Generated answer string. +- `{selected_sections}`: Array of section pointers used to generate the answer. + +## Output + +```json +{"result": "PASS"} +``` + +or + +```json +{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["claim1", "claim2"]} +``` + +--- + +## Step 1: Verify answer + +Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `{answer_text}` are supported by the content of `{selected_sections}`. + +**Extract these claim categories** (Nablarch-specific claims): + +| Category | Examples | +|----------|---------| +| API names | "UniversalDao.deferメソッド", "@InjectForm アノテーション" | +| Class names | "DatabaseRecordReader", "BatchAction" | +| Configuration method | "web-component-configuration.xmlに設定", "コンポーネント定義ファイルに記述" | +| Behavior spec | "遅延ロードはDB接続をストリーミングする", "バリデーションエラー時にステータスコード400を返す" | +| Constraints | "closeしないとリソースリーク", "Formのプロパティは全てString型" | +| Parameters | "-requestPathで指定", "SQLID" | + +**Do NOT extract** (general knowledge): + +| Category | Examples | +|----------|---------| +| General Java | "Beanクラスを作成する", "try-with-resourcesを使う" | +| General programming | "バリデーションを実行する", "エラーメッセージを表示する" | +| Flow description | "まず〜して、次に〜する" | +| General web concepts | "HTTPリクエスト", "JSONレスポンス" | + +For each extracted claim, judge in order: +1. Directly stated in section content → supported +2. Direct paraphrase of section content (paraphrase/abbreviation/synonym) → supported +3. Attribute/behavior/constraint not explicitly stated → unsupported + +Boundary rule: Inference is valid only for direct paraphrases. Attributes, behaviors, or constraints not explicitly stated are unsupported even if technically plausible. + +If any claim is unsupported, return `{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["", "", ...]}` listing all unsupported claims. + +Otherwise return `{"result": "PASS"}`. From cc1fd89b5f3f78465b9df9f9eef2c18ab0758f82 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 14:03:54 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 16/37] fix: verify-answer reads full pages instead of section pointers Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md | 41 +++++++++++++++---- 1 file changed, 32 insertions(+), 9 deletions(-) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md index 878bb5fee..5179e1c6a 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md @@ -1,11 +1,11 @@ # Verify Answer Workflow -Verifies that all Nablarch-specific claims in the answer are supported by the sections. +Verifies that all Nablarch-specific claims in the answer are supported by the source pages, and that no required content is missing from the answer. ## Input - `{answer_text}`: Generated answer string. -- `{selected_sections}`: Array of section pointers used to generate the answer. +- `{selected_sections}`: Array of section pointers in `{"file": "...", "section_id": "...", "relevance": "..."}` format. Used only to identify which pages to read. ## Output @@ -16,14 +16,18 @@ Verifies that all Nablarch-specific claims in the answer are supported by the se or ```json -{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["claim1", "claim2"]} +{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["", ...]} ``` --- -## Step 1: Verify answer +## Step 1: Read pages -Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `{answer_text}` are supported by the content of `{selected_sections}`. +Extract the unique `file` values from `{selected_sections}`. For each unique file path, read the full page file at `knowledge/{file}`. Save all page contents as `page_contents`. + +## Step 2: Verify claims + +Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `{answer_text}` are supported by `page_contents`. **Extract these claim categories** (Nablarch-specific claims): @@ -46,12 +50,31 @@ Check that all Nablarch-specific claims in `{answer_text}` are supported by the | General web concepts | "HTTPリクエスト", "JSONレスポンス" | For each extracted claim, judge in order: -1. Directly stated in section content → supported -2. Direct paraphrase of section content (paraphrase/abbreviation/synonym) → supported +1. Directly stated in page content → supported +2. Direct paraphrase of page content (paraphrase/abbreviation/synonym) → supported 3. Attribute/behavior/constraint not explicitly stated → unsupported Boundary rule: Inference is valid only for direct paraphrases. Attributes, behaviors, or constraints not explicitly stated are unsupported even if technically plausible. -If any claim is unsupported, return `{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["", "", ...]}` listing all unsupported claims. +## Step 3: Check for missing MUST content + +Check whether `page_contents` contains information that directly answers the question but is absent from `{answer_text}`. + +Specifically: if a page section contains a concrete implementation method, required configuration, or explicit constraint that is directly relevant to the question AND is not reflected in the answer in any form, flag it as a missing item. + +Do NOT flag: +- Background or conceptual content +- Content the answer correctly omitted as out of scope +- Content that is present in the answer in paraphrased form + +## Step 4: Return result -Otherwise return `{"result": "PASS"}`. +If any claim from Step 2 is unsupported OR any missing item found in Step 3: +```json +{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["", ...]} +``` + +Otherwise: +```json +{"result": "PASS"} +``` From 2f584461a4420399d6f6ec8ac85b26a1b2789702 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 14:04:28 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 17/37] =?UTF-8?q?fix:=20add=20{question}=20input=20to=20ve?= =?UTF-8?q?rify-answer.md=20=E2=80=94=20needed=20for=20missing-content=20c?= =?UTF-8?q?heck?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md | 2 ++ .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md | 1 + 2 files changed, 3 insertions(+) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md index 75dc9182c..6b7ea3e6a 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md @@ -42,6 +42,7 @@ Execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: Save result as `answer_text`. Execute `workflows/verify-answer.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question - `{answer_text}` = answer_text - `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections @@ -84,6 +85,7 @@ Execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: Save result as `answer_text`. Execute `workflows/verify-answer.md`: +- `{question}` = user's question - `{answer_text}` = answer_text - `{selected_sections}` = sem_sections diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md index 5179e1c6a..ee06cc971 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/verify-answer.md @@ -4,6 +4,7 @@ Verifies that all Nablarch-specific claims in the answer are supported by the so ## Input +- `{question}`: User's question (natural Japanese text). - `{answer_text}`: Generated answer string. - `{selected_sections}`: Array of section pointers in `{"file": "...", "section_id": "...", "relevance": "..."}` format. Used only to identify which pages to read. From 1e84ac70659a16bb7b294563e454c9fa7657314b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 15:01:14 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 18/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20task-3=20design=20redesign=20in=20?= =?UTF-8?q?progress=20=E2=80=94=20check-answerable=20pattern=20agreed?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md | 13 +++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 13 insertions(+) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md index 4047c6b6e..c992b16a2 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md @@ -16,3 +16,16 @@ - Self-check: OK — `full-text-search.md` created with all 6 BM25 steps; qa.md Step 3 is now a concise workflow call; Steps 4–9 unchanged - QA: - Ready for user review: + +--- + +## Self-check: Task 3 (Phase B refactor) + +| # | File | Self-check | Evidence | +|---|------|-----------|----------| +| 1 | `hearing.md` | PASS | Has `## Input` / `## Output` headers. Contains all 7 processing types (ウェブアプリケーション, RESTfulウェブサービス, Nablarchバッチ, Jakartaバッチ, テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング, HTTPメッセージング, MOMメッセージング) and all 6 purpose categories (実装したい, 仕組み・動作を理解したい, 不具合・エラーを調査したい, テストを書きたい, バージョンアップしたい, セキュリティ対応したい). Output section states `processing_type` and `purpose`. | +| 2 | `full-text-search.md` | PASS | No `read-sections.sh` call, no answer generation, no verify logic. Returns `{"selected_sections": [...]}` only. Section format `{"file": "...", "section_id": "...", "relevance": "high"}` matches semantic-search.md output format. All BM25 hits use `"relevance": "high"`. | +| 3 | `semantic-search.md` | PASS | I/F updated: `{processing_type}` and `{purpose}` are explicit inputs. Phase A step 3 now reads `{processing_type}` and `{purpose}` directly — no longer parses `（処理方式: X）` from question string. Phases A–E all intact. | +| 4 | `generate-answer.md` | PASS | Calls `bash scripts/read-sections.sh` in Step 1. Handles `{excluded_claims}` in Step 2 item 4: "If `{excluded_claims}` is provided and non-empty, do not include any of the following claims in the answer." Generates answer in correct 結論/根拠/注意点/参照 format. | +| 5 | `verify-answer.md` | PASS | Outputs `{"result": "PASS"}` or `{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["claim1", "claim2"]}` exactly as specified. Claim extraction tables and judgment rules preserved verbatim from qa.md Step 7. | +| 6 | `qa.md` | PASS | No logic duplicated from WFs. Each WF call site contains only variable assignments. Flow matches 7-step spec: Step 1 hearing, Step 2 full-text-search, Step 3 BM25 generate+verify (PASS→Step7, FAIL→Step4), Step 4 fallthrough comment, Step 5 semantic-search, Step 6 semantic generate+verify with retry on FAIL, Step 7 output. | From 64d46f1ffce161842630c110b32e2918057cae2e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 15:01:35 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 19/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20pause=20task-3=20=E2=80=94=20chec?= =?UTF-8?q?k-answerable=20pattern=20agreed,=20qa.md=20final=20flow=20recor?= =?UTF-8?q?ded?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 26 +++++++++++++++++++++----- 1 file changed, 21 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 4e9ede18d..f137ed00a 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -229,10 +229,26 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. # State -- **Status**: not suspended -- **Date**: 2026-06-25 - **Status**: paused - **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: #2 (design). #3 in progress — Phase A done, refactor to full-text-search.md done -- **Next**: #3 path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios covering BM25-complete, FAIL→fallback, no-hits paths) -- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s). bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. bm25-search.sh and full-text-search.md committed. qa.md Step 3 now calls full-text-search.md. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). Next: run path-coverage sample — suggest scenarios with Nablarch class names (BM25-complete candidate), abstract question (no-hits candidate), and one where BM25 should fail verify (fallback candidate); inspect workflow_details.json for each path. +- **Last completed**: #2 (design). #3 in progress — workflow redesign agreed and partially implemented +- **Next**: #3 — implement `check-answerable.md` and update qa.md to final agreed flow +- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s). bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). + Workflow redesign status (commits up to 2f584461): + - hearing.md ✅ 新規 + - full-text-search.md ✅ BM25検索のみ、selected_sections返却 + - semantic-search.md ✅ 明示パラメータ化 + - generate-answer.md ✅ 新規（read-sections.sh使用、{findings}で再生成） + - verify-answer.md ✅ ページ全体読み取り、ハルシ+脱落検証、{question}入力あり + - check-answerable.md ❌ 未作成（次のアクション） + - qa.md ❌ 最終フローに未更新 + 最終合意フロー（qa.md）: + Step 1: hearing.md {question} → processing_type, purpose + Step 2: full-text-search.md {question} → sections + Step 3: check-answerable.md {question}, {sections} → OK→Step5 / NG→Step4 + Step 4: semantic-search.md {question},{processing_type},{purpose} → sections + Step 5: generate-answer.md {question},{processing_type},{sections} → answer_text + Step 6: verify-answer.md {question},{answer_text},{sections} → OK→Step7 / NG→Step5(1回のみ,{findings}付き) + Step 7: output + generate-answer.mdの{excluded_claims}は{findings}にリネーム要。 + path-coverage sampleはwf実装完了後に実施。 From ecaa61514ac5bad8de1adc3694d6cc2ad53f27b8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 15:46:20 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 20/37] refactor: rename {excluded_claims} to {findings} in generate-answer.md Aligns parameter name with verify-answer.md's output field name. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md | 4 ++-- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md index 426ae4633..1a0c19b7e 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/generate-answer.md @@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ Reads selected sections and generates a Japanese answer. - `{question}`: User's question (natural Japanese text). - `{processing_type}`: Processing type (one of the 7 processing types, or null). - `{selected_sections}`: Array of section pointers in `{"file": "...", "section_id": "...", "relevance": "..."}` format. -- `{excluded_claims}`: (Optional) List of claim strings to exclude from the answer. If not provided or empty, no exclusions apply. +- `{findings}`: (Optional) List of issues from a previous verify-answer run (unsupported claims, missing items). If provided, exclude those claims and address the missing items. If not provided or empty, no exclusions apply. ## Output @@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ Otherwise, generate a Japanese answer following the steps below. 1. Read all sections in `sections_content`. 2. If `processing_type` is not null, focus on approaches that match that type. 3. Identify the information that directly answers the question. For any gap in the sections, write "この情報は知識ファイルの対象範囲外です" — do not infer. -4. If `{excluded_claims}` is provided and non-empty, do not include any of the following claims in the answer: `{excluded_claims}`. +4. If `{findings}` is provided and non-empty, exclude any claims flagged in `{findings}` and address the missing items listed there. 5. Write the answer in the format below. Stay within 500 tokens (up to 800 for complex questions). **Answer format**: From db5e01ae6c34a9caf44f22fe4a7284b78a1172f1 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 15:46:28 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 21/37] feat: implement check-answerable.md and update qa.md to final BM25 flow MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Adds check-answerable.md workflow that judges whether BM25 hits are sufficient to answer the question. Updates qa.md to the agreed flow: Step 1 hearing → Step 2 full-text-search → Step 3 check-answerable (OK→Step5 / NG→Step4) → Step 4 semantic-search → Step 5 generate-answer → Step 6 verify-answer (FAIL→regenerate with {findings}) → Step 7 output. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../nabledge-6/workflows/check-answerable.md | 59 +++++++++++++++++++ .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md | 52 +++++++--------- 2 files changed, 80 insertions(+), 31 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/check-answerable.md diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/check-answerable.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/check-answerable.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..91e6c6cdc --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/check-answerable.md @@ -0,0 +1,59 @@ +# Check Answerable Workflow + +Judges whether the provided sections contain sufficient information to answer the question, without generating an answer. + +## Input + +- `{question}`: User's question (natural Japanese text). +- `{sections}`: Array of section pointers in `{"file": "...", "section_id": "...", "relevance": "..."}` format. + +## Output + +```json +{"result": "OK"} +``` + +or + +```json +{"result": "NG"} +``` + +--- + +## Step 1: Check for empty sections + +If `{sections}` is empty, return `{"result": "NG"}` immediately. + +--- + +## Step 2: Read section content + +From `{sections}`, select up to 10 sections to read: +1. All `high` sections first +2. Then `partial` sections to fill remaining slots + +Build the argument list: for each selected section, `"{file}:{section_id}"`. + +```bash +bash scripts/read-sections.sh "file1.json:s1" "file2.json:s3" ... +``` + +Save the output as `sections_content`. + +--- + +## Step 3: Judge answerability + +Read `sections_content` and `{question}`. + +Judge: Do the sections contain a concrete implementation method, required configuration, or explicit specification that directly answers the question? + +**Return `{"result": "OK"}`** if the sections contain sufficient information to write a complete, supported answer to the question. + +**Return `{"result": "NG"}`** if: +- The sections are not relevant to the question +- The sections mention the topic but lack the concrete detail needed for a complete answer +- The sections contain only conceptual background without actionable specifics + +Do not generate an answer — only judge sufficiency. diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md index 6b7ea3e6a..1104fc88c 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md @@ -26,46 +26,30 @@ Save result as `processing_type`, `purpose`. Execute `workflows/full-text-search.md`: - `{question}` = user's question -Save `selected_sections` as `bm25_sections`. +Save result's `selected_sections` as `bm25_sections`. --- ## Step 3 -If `bm25_sections` is empty, skip to Step 5. - -Execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: +Execute `workflows/check-answerable.md`: - `{question}` = user's question -- `{processing_type}` = processing_type -- `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections +- `{sections}` = bm25_sections -Save result as `answer_text`. +If result is `"OK"`, proceed to Step 5. -Execute `workflows/verify-answer.md`: -- `{question}` = user's question -- `{answer_text}` = answer_text -- `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections - -If result is `"PASS"`, set `final_answer = answer_text` and skip to Step 7. - -If result is `"FAIL"`, proceed to Step 4. +If result is `"NG"`, proceed to Step 4. --- ## Step 4 -(BM25 verify failed — fall through to semantic search) - ---- - -## Step 5 - Execute `workflows/semantic-search.md`: - `{question}` = user's question - `{processing_type}` = processing_type - `{purpose}` = purpose -Save `selected_sections` as `sem_sections`. +Save result's `selected_sections` as `sem_sections`. If `sem_sections` is empty, output: ``` @@ -73,34 +57,40 @@ If `sem_sections` is empty, output: ``` and stop. +Set `bm25_sections` = `sem_sections` and proceed to Step 5. + --- -## Step 6 +## Step 5 Execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: - `{question}` = user's question - `{processing_type}` = processing_type -- `{selected_sections}` = sem_sections +- `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections Save result as `answer_text`. +--- + +## Step 6 + Execute `workflows/verify-answer.md`: - `{question}` = user's question - `{answer_text}` = answer_text -- `{selected_sections}` = sem_sections +- `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections -If result is `"PASS"`, set `final_answer = answer_text` and proceed to Step 7. +If result is `"PASS"`, proceed to Step 7. -If result is `"FAIL"`, execute `workflows/generate-answer.md`: +If result is `"FAIL"`, execute `workflows/generate-answer.md` once more: - `{question}` = user's question - `{processing_type}` = processing_type -- `{selected_sections}` = sem_sections -- `{excluded_claims}` = verify result issues +- `{selected_sections}` = bm25_sections +- `{findings}` = verify result issues -Set `final_answer` to the result. +Save the result as `answer_text`. Proceed to Step 7. --- ## Step 7 -Output `final_answer`. +Output `answer_text`. From fcbcc7c52e992ec4dd04e2f41b3058ae66924e0a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 16:02:18 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 22/37] feat: update benchmark infra for new qa.md BM25+check-answerable flow Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- tools/benchmark/prompts/e2e-prompt.md | 49 ++++++++++------------- tools/benchmark/scripts/run_qa.py | 12 ++++-- tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py | 57 ++++++++++++++++----------- 3 files changed, 65 insertions(+), 53 deletions(-) diff --git a/tools/benchmark/prompts/e2e-prompt.md b/tools/benchmark/prompts/e2e-prompt.md index 3df4424cd..2d487f797 100644 --- a/tools/benchmark/prompts/e2e-prompt.md +++ b/tools/benchmark/prompts/e2e-prompt.md @@ -5,15 +5,15 @@ Follow the workflow and additional instructions below, then answer the question. ### Additional instructions -**Step 1 and Step 2**: Skip both steps. The question already contains the hearing result (`（処理方式: X）（目的: Y）`). Start from Step 3. +**Step 1**: Skip. The question already contains the hearing result (`（処理方式: X）（目的: Y）`). Start from Step 2. -**Step 3**: While executing semantic-search.md, for each page record why it was selected or skipped, and record its `source`. For each section record why it was selected (high/partial) or skipped. +**Step 2**: While executing full-text-search.md, record the BM25 terms extracted and the sections found. -`source` indicates which phase selected this page: `"index"` if only Phase A (index.md) selected it, `"classes"` if only Phase B (classes.md) selected it, `"both"` if both phases selected it. This must reflect the actual phase membership from Phase C merge (index_pages / class_pages), not a guess. +**Step 3**: While executing check-answerable.md, record whether the result is OK or NG. -**Step 4**: Save the section IDs passed to read-sections.sh as `read_sections`. +**Step 4**: If semantic-search.md ran (check-answerable result was NG), record the sections found. If it did not run, record `ran: false` and `selected_sections: []`. -**Step 8**: Output the following lines in this exact order: +**Step 7**: Output the following lines in this exact order: 1. The line `### Answer` (plain text, verbatim) 2. final_answer 3. The line `<<>>` (plain text, verbatim — do not rename, wrap in HTML tags, or omit) @@ -25,34 +25,27 @@ Do not use HTML `
` elements. Output the three delimiter lines as plain <<>> ```json { - "step3": { - "selected_pages": [ - {"path": "", "source": "", "reason": ""} - ], - "excluded_pages": [ - {"path": "", "reason": ""} - ], - "selected_sections": [ - {"file": "", "section_id": "", "relevance": "", "reason": ""} - ], - "excluded_sections": [ - {"file": "", "section_id": "", "reason": ""} + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": ["", "..."], + "bm25_sections": [ + {"file": "", "section_id": "", "relevance": ""} ] }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "" + }, "step4": { - "read_sections": [ - "" + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + {"file": "", "section_id": ""} ] }, - "step8": { - "answer_sections": { - "used": [ - {"ref": "", "reason": ""} - ], - "unused": [ - {"ref": "", "reason": ""} - ] - } + "step6": { + "verify_result": "", + "regenerated": false } } ``` diff --git a/tools/benchmark/scripts/run_qa.py b/tools/benchmark/scripts/run_qa.py index 463127fec..eaa598470 100644 --- a/tools/benchmark/scripts/run_qa.py +++ b/tools/benchmark/scripts/run_qa.py @@ -189,7 +189,7 @@ def run_qa_scenario( "--model", "sonnet", "--output-format", "json", "--no-session-persistence", - "--allowedTools", "Bash(bash scripts/keyword-search.sh *) Bash(bash scripts/read-sections.sh *) Read", + "--allowedTools", "Bash(bash scripts/keyword-search.sh *) Bash(bash scripts/bm25-search.sh *) Bash(bash scripts/read-sections.sh *) Read", ], input=prompt, capture_output=True, @@ -264,10 +264,16 @@ def run_qa_all( json.dumps(evaluation, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2), encoding="utf-8" ) - selected = result["workflow_details"].get("step3", {}).get("selected_sections", []) + wd = result["workflow_details"] + sections_used = ( + wd.get("step5", {}).get("sections_used") + or wd.get("step2", {}).get("bm25_sections") + or wd.get("step4", {}).get("selected_sections") + or [] + ) scenario_summaries.append({ "id": result["scenario_id"], - "search_sections": len(selected), + "search_sections": len(sections_used), }) except Exception as exc: exc_type = type(exc).__name__ diff --git a/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py b/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py index 61081daca..5211c69d8 100644 --- a/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py +++ b/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py @@ -103,22 +103,27 @@ def test_no_unreplaced_placeholders(self): SAMPLE_WORKFLOW_DETAILS = { - "step3": { - "selected_pages": [ - {"path": "path/to/file.json", "source": "index", "reason": "relevant page"} + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": ["バッチ", "アーキテクチャ"], + "bm25_sections": [ + {"file": "path/to/file.json", "section_id": "s1", "relevance": "high"} ], - "excluded_pages": [], - "selected_sections": [ - {"file": "path/to/file.json", "section_id": "s1", "relevance": "high", "reason": "key section"} + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK", + }, + "step4": { + "ran": False, + "selected_sections": [], + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + {"file": "path/to/file.json", "section_id": "s1"} ], - "excluded_sections": [], }, - "step4": {"read_sections": ["path/to/file.json:s1"]}, - "step8": { - "answer_sections": { - "used": [{"ref": "path/to/file.json:s1", "reason": "used in answer"}], - "unused": [], - } + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": False, }, } @@ -144,22 +149,24 @@ def test_parses_answer_text(self): def test_parses_workflow_details(self): response = self._make_response("回答テキスト") result = parse_qa_response(response) + assert "step2" in result["workflow_details"] assert "step3" in result["workflow_details"] assert "step4" in result["workflow_details"] - assert "step8" in result["workflow_details"] + assert "step5" in result["workflow_details"] + assert "step6" in result["workflow_details"] - def test_parses_selected_pages(self): + def test_parses_bm25_sections(self): response = self._make_response("回答テキスト") result = parse_qa_response(response) - pages = result["workflow_details"]["step3"]["selected_pages"] - assert pages[0]["path"] == "path/to/file.json" - assert pages[0]["source"] == "index" + sections = result["workflow_details"]["step2"]["bm25_sections"] + assert sections[0]["section_id"] == "s1" + assert sections[0]["relevance"] == "high" - def test_parses_selected_sections(self): + def test_parses_check_answerable_result(self): response = self._make_response("回答テキスト") result = parse_qa_response(response) - sections = result["workflow_details"]["step3"]["selected_sections"] - assert sections[0]["section_id"] == "s1" + check_result = result["workflow_details"]["step3"]["check_answerable_result"] + assert check_result == "OK" def test_raises_on_missing_workflow_details(self): response = "回答だけで WORKFLOW_DETAILS_JSON マーカーがない" @@ -299,7 +306,12 @@ def test_returns_workflow_details(self): (Path(skill_dir, "workflows") / "qa.md").write_text("# QA", encoding="utf-8") with patch("subprocess.run", return_value=self._make_mock_proc()): result = run_qa_scenario(SAMPLE_SCENARIO, skill_dir) - assert "step3" in result["workflow_details"] + wd = result["workflow_details"] + assert "step2" in wd + assert "step3" in wd + assert "step4" in wd + assert "step5" in wd + assert "step6" in wd def test_returns_answer(self): with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as skill_dir: @@ -363,6 +375,7 @@ def test_uses_allowed_tools_as_specified(self): allowed_tools_idx = cmd.index("--allowedTools") allowed_tools_value = cmd[allowed_tools_idx + 1] assert "Bash(bash scripts/keyword-search.sh *)" in allowed_tools_value + assert "Bash(bash scripts/bm25-search.sh *)" in allowed_tools_value assert "Bash(bash scripts/read-sections.sh *)" in allowed_tools_value assert "Read" in allowed_tools_value From 5423ab942cb98d08f5cf1864c8cb8c8cc299c962 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 16:05:40 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 23/37] fix: add cascade-fallback/regeneration tests and qa.md NG-fallback wording Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md | 2 +- tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py | 103 ++++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 104 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md index 1104fc88c..b348de06e 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md @@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ Execute `workflows/check-answerable.md`: If result is `"OK"`, proceed to Step 5. -If result is `"NG"`, proceed to Step 4. +Otherwise, proceed to Step 4. --- diff --git a/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py b/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py index 5211c69d8..a4fd2d515 100644 --- a/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py +++ b/tools/benchmark/tests/test_run_qa.py @@ -213,6 +213,21 @@ def test_answer_marker_absent_falls_back_to_full_text_before_workflow_details(se result = parse_qa_response(response) assert result["answer"] == "レガシー回答テキスト" + def test_parses_step6_fail_and_regenerated(self): + """parse_qa_response must handle step6.verify_result=FAIL and step6.regenerated=True.""" + fail_details = { + **SAMPLE_WORKFLOW_DETAILS, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "FAIL", + "regenerated": True, + }, + } + response = self._make_response("再生成された回答", fail_details) + result = parse_qa_response(response) + assert result["workflow_details"]["step6"]["verify_result"] == "FAIL" + assert result["workflow_details"]["step6"]["regenerated"] is True + assert result["answer"] == "再生成された回答" + class TestSaveE2eResults: def _make_data(self, **overrides): @@ -567,6 +582,94 @@ def test_saves_evaluation_json(self): eval_data = json.loads(eval_path.read_text()) assert eval_data["scenario_id"] == "pre-01" + def test_search_sections_cascade_falls_through_to_bm25_when_step5_absent(self): + """When step5.sections_used is absent (NG path: semantic search ran), cascade falls through + to step2.bm25_sections and search_sections reflects the bm25_sections count.""" + # Simulate semantic-search path: check-answerable said NG so step5.sections_used is absent, + # but step2.bm25_sections is present (it was the initial BM25 result). + ng_path_details = { + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": ["バッチ"], + "bm25_sections": [ + {"file": "a.json", "section_id": "s1"}, + {"file": "b.json", "section_id": "s2"}, + {"file": "c.json", "section_id": "s3"}, + ], + }, + "step3": {"check_answerable_result": "NG"}, + "step4": {"ran": True, "selected_sections": [{"file": "d.json", "section_id": "s4"}]}, + # step5 absent: generate-answer was not reached (e.g., sem_sections was empty) + "step6": {"verify_result": "PASS", "regenerated": False}, + } + details_json = json.dumps(ng_path_details, ensure_ascii=False) + valid_response = ( + "テスト回答\n\n" + "<<>>\n" + f"```json\n{details_json}\n```\n" + "<<>>\n" + ) + claude_out = json.dumps({ + "result": valid_response, + "duration_ms": 10000, "duration_api_ms": 9000, "num_turns": 3, + "total_cost_usd": 0.01, + "usage": {"input_tokens": 5000, "output_tokens": 1000, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0}, + }) + mock_proc = type("P", (), {"returncode": 0, "stdout": claude_out, "stderr": ""})() + + with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmpdir: + skill_dir = self._setup_skill_dir(tmpdir) + scenarios_path = self._setup_scenarios(tmpdir) + output_dir = Path(tmpdir) / "results" + with patch("subprocess.run", return_value=mock_proc), \ + patch("tools.benchmark.scripts.run_qa.evaluate_scenario", return_value=self.FAKE_EVAL): + summary = run_qa_all( + str(scenarios_path), str(skill_dir), output_dir=str(output_dir), + ) + + scenario_entry = summary["scenarios"][0] + # Cascade: step5 absent → falls through to step2.bm25_sections (3 items) + assert scenario_entry["search_sections"] == 3 + + def test_search_sections_zero_when_all_steps_absent_or_empty(self): + """When step5, step2.bm25_sections, and step4.selected_sections are all absent/empty, + search_sections should be 0.""" + empty_details = { + "step2": {"bm25_terms": [], "bm25_sections": []}, + "step3": {"check_answerable_result": "NG"}, + "step4": {"ran": True, "selected_sections": []}, + # step5 absent + "step6": {"verify_result": "PASS", "regenerated": False}, + } + details_json = json.dumps(empty_details, ensure_ascii=False) + valid_response = ( + "テスト回答\n\n" + "<<>>\n" + f"```json\n{details_json}\n```\n" + "<<>>\n" + ) + claude_out = json.dumps({ + "result": valid_response, + "duration_ms": 10000, "duration_api_ms": 9000, "num_turns": 3, + "total_cost_usd": 0.01, + "usage": {"input_tokens": 5000, "output_tokens": 1000, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 0, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 0}, + }) + mock_proc = type("P", (), {"returncode": 0, "stdout": claude_out, "stderr": ""})() + + with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as tmpdir: + skill_dir = self._setup_skill_dir(tmpdir) + scenarios_path = self._setup_scenarios(tmpdir) + output_dir = Path(tmpdir) / "results" + with patch("subprocess.run", return_value=mock_proc), \ + patch("tools.benchmark.scripts.run_qa.evaluate_scenario", return_value=self.FAKE_EVAL): + summary = run_qa_all( + str(scenarios_path), str(skill_dir), output_dir=str(output_dir), + ) + + scenario_entry = summary["scenarios"][0] + assert scenario_entry["search_sections"] == 0 + class TestRunE2eAllErrorHandling: """Tests for error handling in run_qa_all: failures are isolated per scenario.""" From 082dee136e0f1dd552df3d388f193569fc359aea Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 16:45:10 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 24/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20update=20steering.md=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20pre-benchmark=20stabilization=20loop,=20review-08=20issue=20?= =?UTF-8?q?noted?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 38 +++++++++++++++----------------------- 1 file changed, 15 insertions(+), 23 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index f137ed00a..fe8ef44a3 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -122,19 +122,21 @@ incrementally — single scenario first, then path-coverage sample, then full 3- - [x] Insert the approved BM25 step into `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` before the current Step 3; renumber subsequent steps if needed - [x] **Phase A (1 scenario)**: run `pre-01` via `run_qa --scenario-ids pre-01`; confirm exit 0, answer.md non-empty, BM25 path exercised; delete tmp dir after - [x] Refactor: extract BM25 step to `workflows/full-text-search.md`; qa.md Step 3 becomes a concise workflow call (mirrors semantic-search.md pattern) -- [ ] **Path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios)**: select scenarios that cover BM25-complete path, BM25-FAIL→fallback path, and no-hits path; run them; inspect `workflow_details.json` to confirm each path behaved as designed; fix qa.md if any path misbehaves -- [ ] **Phase B/C full benchmark**: 3 runs × 34 scenarios per HOW-TO-RUN.md; generate per-run reports and crossrun-summary; commit each run immediately after completion +- [x] **Path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios)**: 8 scenarios inspected; Paths A/B/C confirmed; review-08 flagged (BM25 extracted Japanese concept words — fix needed in full-text-search.md) +- [ ] **Pre-benchmark stabilization loop**: run 1 full run (34 scenarios); inspect workflow_details.json for each scenario; fix any misbehavior in workflows; repeat until stable (no unexpected BM25 term extraction, all paths correct, verify PASS rate acceptable); delete intermediate runs after each fix cycle +- [ ] **Phase B/C full benchmark**: once stable, 3 runs × 34 scenarios per HOW-TO-RUN.md; generate per-run reports and crossrun-summary; commit each run immediately after completion - [ ] Phase E regression check: compare against baseline from #1 - [ ] Save comparison summary to `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` - [ ] Software Engineer expert review (subagent) - [ ] User review -- [ ] Commit and push `qa.md` change + benchmark results +- [ ] Commit and push workflow changes + benchmark results **Completion criteria**: - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` contains the BM25 pre-search step - Phase A: single-scenario run exits 0 and BM25 path is exercised - Path-coverage sample: all three paths (BM25-complete, BM25-FAIL→fallback, no-hits) confirmed working +- Pre-benchmark stabilization: all 34 scenarios behave as designed (no unexpected BM25 term extraction, verify PASS rate stable) - Full benchmark (3 runs): regression check CLEAN vs baseline from #1 - Full benchmark: p50 cost per query lower than baseline p50 - `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` documents the comparison @@ -231,24 +233,14 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - **Status**: paused - **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: #2 (design). #3 in progress — workflow redesign agreed and partially implemented -- **Next**: #3 — implement `check-answerable.md` and update qa.md to final agreed flow +- **Last completed**: #3 in progress — workflow fully implemented and benchmark infra updated; pre-benchmark stabilization next +- **Next**: #3 — fix full-text-search.md (Japanese concept words extracted in review-08); run 1 full benchmark run; inspect all 34 workflow_details.json; fix until stable; then proceed to 3-run benchmark - **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s). bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). - Workflow redesign status (commits up to 2f584461): - - hearing.md ✅ 新規 - - full-text-search.md ✅ BM25検索のみ、selected_sections返却 - - semantic-search.md ✅ 明示パラメータ化 - - generate-answer.md ✅ 新規（read-sections.sh使用、{findings}で再生成） - - verify-answer.md ✅ ページ全体読み取り、ハルシ+脱落検証、{question}入力あり - - check-answerable.md ❌ 未作成（次のアクション） - - qa.md ❌ 最終フローに未更新 - 最終合意フロー（qa.md）: - Step 1: hearing.md {question} → processing_type, purpose - Step 2: full-text-search.md {question} → sections - Step 3: check-answerable.md {question}, {sections} → OK→Step5 / NG→Step4 - Step 4: semantic-search.md {question},{processing_type},{purpose} → sections - Step 5: generate-answer.md {question},{processing_type},{sections} → answer_text - Step 6: verify-answer.md {question},{answer_text},{sections} → OK→Step7 / NG→Step5(1回のみ,{findings}付き) - Step 7: output - generate-answer.mdの{excluded_claims}は{findings}にリネーム要。 - path-coverage sampleはwf実装完了後に実施。 + Workflow implementation complete (all committed): + - check-answerable.md ✅ 新規作成 + - qa.md ✅ 最終7ステップフロー + - generate-answer.md ✅ {findings}リネーム + - benchmark infra ✅ bm25-search.sh in allowedTools, e2e-prompt schema updated, 168 tests pass + Known issue from 8-scenario inspection: + - review-08: full-text-search.md が「DBストア」「HIDDENストア」「セッション変数」（日本語概念語）を抽出 → Do NOT extract リストに日本語概念語の明示が必要 + Intermediate run `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-161851/` (8 scenarios, incomplete) — inspect remaining issues then delete before 1-run benchmark. From a0ee91caaaad7e2f2459ed829630e60a3f358d77 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 17:42:10 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 25/37] wip: save task-3 check file and path-coverage notes Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md | 32 ++++++++------------ .rn/issue-382/path-coverage.md | 55 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 2 files changed, 67 insertions(+), 20 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .rn/issue-382/path-coverage.md diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md index c992b16a2..ac8caa5f2 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md @@ -4,28 +4,20 @@ | Criterion | Self-check | Evidence | QA | QA Evidence | |---|---|---|---|---| -| qa.md contains BM25 pre-search step | OK | `## Step 3: BM25 pre-search` present in qa.md as a concise workflow call (no inline sub-steps); calls `workflows/full-text-search.md` | | | -| Existing steps renumbered correctly (all cross-refs updated) | OK | Steps 4–9 in qa.md unchanged; Step 1 "proceed to Step 3" and Step 2 "Proceed to Step 3" unchanged; no broken cross-refs | | | -| bm25-search.sh exists and outputs valid JSON | OK | Unchanged from previous task — `bash scripts/bm25-search.sh UniversalDao` returns valid JSON array with score fields | | | -| Phase A: pre-01 exits 0 and BM25 path exercised | OK | Refactor only — no runtime behavior change; qa.md Step 3 now delegates to full-text-search.md which contains the same logic | | | +| bm25-search.sh in allowedTools | OK | `run_qa.py` line 192: `"Bash(bash scripts/bm25-search.sh *)"` added to `--allowedTools`; `test_uses_allowed_tools_as_specified` asserts it and passes | | | +| e2e-prompt.md step numbers match new qa.md | OK | Step 1 (skip hearing), Step 2 (BM25 search), Step 3 (check-answerable), Step 4 (semantic-search, conditional), Step 7 (output) — matches new qa.md flow | | | +| workflow_details schema updated to new structure | OK | `SAMPLE_WORKFLOW_DETAILS` updated to step2/step3/step4/step5/step6; `test_parses_workflow_details`, `test_parses_bm25_sections`, `test_parses_check_answerable_result`, `test_returns_workflow_details` all assert new keys | | | +| All tests pass | OK | `python3 -m pytest tools/benchmark/tests/ -x -q` → 168 passed after fixes | | | ## QA Expert Review -(leave blank — coordinator fills) -## Overall Verdict -- Self-check: OK — `full-text-search.md` created with all 6 BM25 steps; qa.md Step 3 is now a concise workflow call; Steps 4–9 unchanged -- QA: -- Ready for user review: - ---- +| Aspect | Verdict | Evidence / Improvement | +|---|---|---| +| Meaningful tests/verification | OK | Cascade fallback test added (step5 absent→bm25 fallback, all-empty→0); step6 FAIL+regenerated test added; 168 tests pass | +| Edge case coverage | OK | 4 findings raised; 3 fixed (cascade test, regeneration test, qa.md "Otherwise" wording); 1 invalid (early-stop→MarkerError is existing behavior, not regression) | -## Self-check: Task 3 (Phase B refactor) +## Overall Verdict -| # | File | Self-check | Evidence | -|---|------|-----------|----------| -| 1 | `hearing.md` | PASS | Has `## Input` / `## Output` headers. Contains all 7 processing types (ウェブアプリケーション, RESTfulウェブサービス, Nablarchバッチ, Jakartaバッチ, テーブルをキューとして使ったメッセージング, HTTPメッセージング, MOMメッセージング) and all 6 purpose categories (実装したい, 仕組み・動作を理解したい, 不具合・エラーを調査したい, テストを書きたい, バージョンアップしたい, セキュリティ対応したい). Output section states `processing_type` and `purpose`. | -| 2 | `full-text-search.md` | PASS | No `read-sections.sh` call, no answer generation, no verify logic. Returns `{"selected_sections": [...]}` only. Section format `{"file": "...", "section_id": "...", "relevance": "high"}` matches semantic-search.md output format. All BM25 hits use `"relevance": "high"`. | -| 3 | `semantic-search.md` | PASS | I/F updated: `{processing_type}` and `{purpose}` are explicit inputs. Phase A step 3 now reads `{processing_type}` and `{purpose}` directly — no longer parses `（処理方式: X）` from question string. Phases A–E all intact. | -| 4 | `generate-answer.md` | PASS | Calls `bash scripts/read-sections.sh` in Step 1. Handles `{excluded_claims}` in Step 2 item 4: "If `{excluded_claims}` is provided and non-empty, do not include any of the following claims in the answer." Generates answer in correct 結論/根拠/注意点/参照 format. | -| 5 | `verify-answer.md` | PASS | Outputs `{"result": "PASS"}` or `{"result": "FAIL", "issues": ["claim1", "claim2"]}` exactly as specified. Claim extraction tables and judgment rules preserved verbatim from qa.md Step 7. | -| 6 | `qa.md` | PASS | No logic duplicated from WFs. Each WF call site contains only variable assignments. Flow matches 7-step spec: Step 1 hearing, Step 2 full-text-search, Step 3 BM25 generate+verify (PASS→Step7, FAIL→Step4), Step 4 fallthrough comment, Step 5 semantic-search, Step 6 semantic generate+verify with retry on FAIL, Step 7 output. | +- Self-check: OK +- QA: OK (after fix round) +- Ready for user review: Yes diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/path-coverage.md b/.rn/issue-382/path-coverage.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2f425ef82 --- /dev/null +++ b/.rn/issue-382/path-coverage.md @@ -0,0 +1,55 @@ +# Path Coverage: qa.md workflow + +**Date**: 2026-06-25 +**Workflow**: `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/qa.md` +**Scenarios run**: pre-03, pre-01, pre-02, oos-qa-01 + +## Results Table + +| Scenario | BM25 terms | BM25 hits | check-answerable | semantic ran | verify | regenerated | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| pre-03 | `UniversalDao` | 20 | OK | No | PASS | No | +| pre-01 | `requestPath` | 17 | OK | No | PASS | No | +| pre-02 | (none) | 0 | NG | Yes (8 hits) | PASS | No | +| oos-qa-01 | `WebSocket` | 1 | NG | Yes (0 hits) | N/A | No | + +## Path Coverage + +| Path | Description | Observed | Scenario | +|---|---|---|---| +| Path A | BM25 hits + check-answerable OK (no semantic) | YES | pre-03, pre-01 | +| Path B | BM25 hits + check-answerable NG → semantic ran | YES (partial) | oos-qa-01 (BM25 found 1 marginal hit, check-answerable=NG, semantic returned empty) | +| Path C | No BM25 terms → semantic ran | YES | pre-02 (bm25_terms=[], semantic returned 8 hits) | +| Path D | verify FAIL → regeneration | NOT OBSERVED | None of the 4 scenarios triggered this | + +## Notes + +### Path B detail +`oos-qa-01` had 1 BM25 hit (WebSocket mention in a migration doc), but check-answerable correctly +judged NG (insufficient content to answer). Semantic search then ran but found 0 sections. +The workflow correctly stopped (step5 sections_used=[], verify=N/A — not regenerated or answered). +This covers the "semantic fallback returns empty → stop" sub-path of step 4. + +### Path D not covered +None of the 4 scenarios produced a verify FAIL. To exercise Path D, a scenario would need to +generate an answer that fails the verify check — likely requires a question where the selected +sections are marginally relevant and the generated answer makes claims not backed by the content. + +### check-answerable behavior +- pre-02: `bm25_terms=[]` (no extractable identifiers) → check-answerable correctly returns NG +- oos-qa-01: `bm25_sections=1` (only a migration doc mention) → check-answerable correctly returns NG + The step 3 check is doing the right thing: not just counting hits, but evaluating whether + the content is sufficient to answer the question. + +## Assessment: Is qa.md behaving correctly? + +**Yes, for the paths exercised.** + +1. **Step 2 (BM25)**: Correctly extracts concrete identifiers (`UniversalDao`, `requestPath`, `WebSocket`) and returns empty terms for abstract Japanese questions (`バリデーション`). +2. **Step 3 (check-answerable)**: Correctly distinguishes between sufficient BM25 content (pre-03: 20 hits on the right docs → OK) and insufficient (oos-qa-01: 1 marginal hit → NG). +3. **Step 4 (semantic fallback)**: Correctly triggered on NG; returns content for in-scope abstract question (pre-02); returns empty for out-of-scope (oos-qa-01). +4. **Step 5/6 (generate + verify)**: Answers pass verify in all cases where content was available. Workflow correctly skips generate+verify when sections_used is empty (oos-qa-01 verify=N/A). +5. **Stop path (oos-qa-01)**: Out-of-scope question correctly terminates with no answer rather than hallucinating. + +**Gap**: Path D (verify FAIL → regeneration) was not exercised. This path exists in the workflow +but was not triggered by any of these 4 scenarios. From 92c2c35625ff53784ccfdfd4a26c475ef9906173 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 17:45:47 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 26/37] feat: redesign full-text-search.md term extraction using component page title lookup MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Pass the full component page title list (libraries/handlers/adapters, 130 files) to LLM as a translation table. LLM maps question concepts to Nablarch-specific terms by finding related page titles and extracting their hyphenated keywords. Example: "バリデーション" → sees libraries-bean-validation in titles → uses "bean-validation" as BM25 search term. This eliminates the need for LLM to know Nablarch-specific terminology a priori. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md | 169 ++++++++++++++++-- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 26 ++- 2 files changed, 176 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md index 0f4e2702b..fa8877327 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md @@ -22,26 +22,171 @@ Empty array when no BM25 terms found, script returns no hits, or script exits no --- -## Step 1: Extract BM25-effective terms +## Step 1: Extract BM25 search terms using page title lookup -From the user's question, extract terms that will **narrow the result set** in BM25 search — terms specific enough to appear in only a small number of knowledge files. +Use the **Component page title list** below as a translation table to map the question's concepts to Nablarch-specific terms. -**Criterion**: Extract a term if it is a concrete identifier (class name, annotation name, method name, configuration file name, SQL ID, component name) that appears verbatim in the Nablarch knowledge base. The test is: "Would a keyword match on this term return a small, focused set of pages?" +**Process**: -**Source rule**: Take terms **as they appear in the question** — do not infer synonyms, related terms, or paraphrases. The only permitted modification is correcting an obvious typo or misspelling (e.g. `UniversalDoa` → `UniversalDao`) so the term matches the knowledge base. +1. Read the question and identify its topic (e.g., "バリデーション", "セッション", "DB操作", "ファイル入出力"). +2. Scan the page title list and find titles whose terms relate to that topic. +3. From the matching titles, extract BM25 search terms: + - Use hyphen-separated parts of the title (e.g., `libraries-bean-validation` → `bean-validation`) + - Or the full filename (e.g., `handlers-SessionStoreHandler` → `SessionStoreHandler`) +4. Also include any concrete identifiers that appear **verbatim** in the question (class name, annotation, method name, configuration file name). -**Extract** (concrete identifiers, low document frequency): -`UniversalDao`, `@InjectForm`, `batchUpdate`, `SqlPStatement`, `web-component-configuration.xml`, `SQLID`, `RoutesMapping`, `BatchAction`, etc. +**Do NOT extract** broad words from the question: +- Abstract concepts: `バリデーション`, `トランザクション`, `ハンドラ`, `データ変換` +- General Java terms: `List`, `String`, `Exception`, `try-catch` +- Natural language filler: `使い方`, `方法`, `について`, `実装` -**Do NOT extract** (broad terms, high document frequency — would match too many pages and dilute scores): -- Abstract concepts: `バリデーション`, `トランザクション`, `Handler`, `Action` -- General Java: `List`, `String`, `try-catch`, `Exception` -- Natural language filler: `使い方`, `方法`, `について` -- Do NOT add synonyms, related identifiers, or guessed class names not present in the question. +**Examples**: + +| Question | Matching titles | BM25 terms to use | +|---|---|---| +| RESTのバリデーション実装を教えて | `libraries-bean-validation`, `handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler` | `bean-validation`, `jaxrs-bean-validation` | +| セッションのストア選択基準を知りたい | `libraries-session-store`, `handlers-SessionStoreHandler` | `session-store`, `SessionStoreHandler` | +| UniversalDaoで検索する方法 | `libraries-universal-dao` (and verbatim: `UniversalDao`) | `universal-dao`, `UniversalDao` | +| ファイル入出力の実装方法 | `libraries-data-format`, `libraries-data-bind`, `libraries-data-io-functional-comparison` | `data-format`, `data-bind` | + +**Component page title list**: + +``` +adapters-adaptors +adapters-doma-adaptor +adapters-jaxrs-adaptor +adapters-jsr310-adaptor +adapters-lettuce-adaptor +adapters-log-adaptor +adapters-mail-sender-freemarker-adaptor +adapters-mail-sender-thymeleaf-adaptor +adapters-mail-sender-velocity-adaptor +adapters-micrometer-adaptor +adapters-redishealthchecker-lettuce-adaptor +adapters-redisstore-lettuce-adaptor +adapters-router-adaptor +adapters-slf4j-adaptor +adapters-web-thymeleaf-adaptor +adapters-webspheremq-adaptor +handlers-HttpErrorHandler +handlers-InjectForm +handlers-ServiceAvailabilityCheckHandler +handlers-SessionStoreHandler +handlers-batch +handlers-body-convert-handler +handlers-common +handlers-cors-preflight-request-handler +handlers-csrf-token-verification-handler +handlers-data-read-handler +handlers-database-connection-management-handler +handlers-dbless-loop-handler +handlers-duplicate-process-check-handler +handlers-file-record-writer-dispose-handler +handlers-forwarding-handler +handlers-global-error-handler +handlers-handlers +handlers-health-check-endpoint-handler +handlers-hot-deploy-handler +handlers-http-access-log-handler +handlers-http-character-encoding-handler +handlers-http-messaging +handlers-http-messaging-error-handler +handlers-http-messaging-request-parsing-handler +handlers-http-messaging-response-building-handler +handlers-http-request-java-package-mapping +handlers-http-response-handler +handlers-http-rewrite-handler +handlers-jaxrs-access-log-handler +handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler +handlers-jaxrs-response-handler +handlers-keitai-access-handler +handlers-loop-handler +handlers-main +handlers-message-reply-handler +handlers-message-resend-handler +handlers-messaging-context-handler +handlers-mom-messaging +handlers-multi-thread-execution-handler +handlers-multipart-handler +handlers-nablarch-tag-handler +handlers-normalize-handler +handlers-on-double-submission +handlers-on-error +handlers-on-errors +handlers-permission-check-handler +handlers-post-resubmit-prevent-handler +handlers-process-resident-handler +handlers-process-stop-handler +handlers-request-handler-entry +handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping +handlers-request-thread-loop-handler +handlers-resource-mapping +handlers-rest +handlers-retry-handler +handlers-secure-handler +handlers-session-concurrent-access-handler +handlers-standalone +handlers-status-code-convert-handler +handlers-thread-context-clear-handler +handlers-thread-context-handler +handlers-transaction-management-handler +handlers-use-token +handlers-web +handlers-web-interceptor +libraries-authorization-permission-check +libraries-bean-util +libraries-bean-validation +libraries-code +libraries-create-example +libraries-data-bind +libraries-data-converter +libraries-data-format +libraries-data-io-functional-comparison +libraries-database +libraries-database-functional-comparison +libraries-database-management +libraries-date +libraries-db-double-submit +libraries-exclusive-control +libraries-failure-log +libraries-file-path-management +libraries-format +libraries-format-definition +libraries-generator +libraries-http-access-log +libraries-http-system-messaging +libraries-jaxrs-access-log +libraries-libraries +libraries-libraries-permission-check +libraries-log +libraries-mail +libraries-message +libraries-messaging-log +libraries-mom-system-messaging +libraries-multi-format-example +libraries-nablarch-validation +libraries-performance-log +libraries-repository +libraries-role-check +libraries-service-availability +libraries-session-store +libraries-sql-log +libraries-stateless-web-app +libraries-static-data-cache +libraries-system-messaging +libraries-tag +libraries-tag-reference +libraries-transaction +libraries-universal-dao +libraries-update-example +libraries-utility +libraries-validation +libraries-validation-functional-comparison +``` Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). -**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no narrow-enough terms found), return `{"selected_sections": []}` immediately. +**If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no relevant titles found and no verbatim identifiers in the question), return `{"selected_sections": []}` immediately. --- diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index fe8ef44a3..171d14d3f 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -233,14 +233,26 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - **Status**: paused - **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: #3 in progress — workflow fully implemented and benchmark infra updated; pre-benchmark stabilization next -- **Next**: #3 — fix full-text-search.md (Japanese concept words extracted in review-08); run 1 full benchmark run; inspect all 34 workflow_details.json; fix until stable; then proceed to 3-run benchmark +- **Last completed**: #3 in progress — workflow implemented; BM25 term extraction design discussion held; new design agreed +- **Next**: #3 — redesign full-text-search.md with new term extraction approach (see Notes), then run 1-run pre-benchmark stabilization loop - **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s). bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). Workflow implementation complete (all committed): - - check-answerable.md ✅ 新規作成 + - check-answerable.md ✅ - qa.md ✅ 最終7ステップフロー - generate-answer.md ✅ {findings}リネーム - - benchmark infra ✅ bm25-search.sh in allowedTools, e2e-prompt schema updated, 168 tests pass - Known issue from 8-scenario inspection: - - review-08: full-text-search.md が「DBストア」「HIDDENストア」「セッション変数」（日本語概念語）を抽出 → Do NOT extract リストに日本語概念語の明示が必要 - Intermediate run `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-161851/` (8 scenarios, incomplete) — inspect remaining issues then delete before 1-run benchmark. + - benchmark infra ✅ 168 tests pass + + **New term extraction design (agreed in conversation, not yet implemented):** + 現在: 質問から具体的識別子（クラス名等）をルールベースで抽出 + 新設計: component配下のページタイトル一覧（約1,000トークン）＋質問をLLMに渡し、 + 関連しそうなページのタイトルの語をBM25タームとして使う。 + 「バリデーション」→ タイトル一覧に `libraries-bean-validation` がある → `bean-validation` をターム化。 + 言い換えはページタイトルが教えてくれる設計。 + 実験結果（4シナリオ × 10回試行）: + - review-08（セッションストア）: 3回目でヒット（単語分割が有効） + - pre-02（バリデーション）: 9回目で `InjectForm` にたどり着いた（ページタイトルがあれば1回目で引ける） + - pre-03（UniversalDao）: 10回目にファイル名直指定でやっと（s3は概念説明セクション、質問意図との対応要確認） + - oos-qa-01（WebSocket）: 10回粘って正しくgave_up + + Intermediate results in `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-16*/` — delete before next benchmark run. + processing-pattern等はcomponent以外なので対象外かどうか未確定。 From a0d6fae309fefae8a72c9cdfd54e2982b45f907e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Thu, 25 Jun 2026 18:38:13 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 27/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20update=20steering.md=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20fts-hints.md=20design=20agreed,=204-scenario=20experiment=20?= =?UTF-8?q?results=20recorded?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 45 ++++++++++++++++++++++++--------------- 1 file changed, 28 insertions(+), 17 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 171d14d3f..3831f6e04 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -233,26 +233,37 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - **Status**: paused - **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: #3 in progress — workflow implemented; BM25 term extraction design discussion held; new design agreed -- **Next**: #3 — redesign full-text-search.md with new term extraction approach (see Notes), then run 1-run pre-benchmark stabilization loop +- **Last completed**: #3 in progress — full-text-search.md redesigned with page-title lookup approach (committed); 4-scenario experiment confirmed 1-shot term extraction working +- **Next**: #3 (new sub-task) — implement fts-hints.md generation in RBKC, then run pre-benchmark stabilization loop - **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s). bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). Workflow implementation complete (all committed): - check-answerable.md ✅ - qa.md ✅ 最終7ステップフロー - generate-answer.md ✅ {findings}リネーム - benchmark infra ✅ 168 tests pass - - **New term extraction design (agreed in conversation, not yet implemented):** - 現在: 質問から具体的識別子（クラス名等）をルールベースで抽出 - 新設計: component配下のページタイトル一覧（約1,000トークン）＋質問をLLMに渡し、 - 関連しそうなページのタイトルの語をBM25タームとして使う。 - 「バリデーション」→ タイトル一覧に `libraries-bean-validation` がある → `bean-validation` をターム化。 - 言い換えはページタイトルが教えてくれる設計。 - 実験結果（4シナリオ × 10回試行）: - - review-08（セッションストア）: 3回目でヒット（単語分割が有効） - - pre-02（バリデーション）: 9回目で `InjectForm` にたどり着いた（ページタイトルがあれば1回目で引ける） - - pre-03（UniversalDao）: 10回目にファイル名直指定でやっと（s3は概念説明セクション、質問意図との対応要確認） - - oos-qa-01（WebSocket）: 10回粘って正しくgave_up - - Intermediate results in `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-16*/` — delete before next benchmark run. - processing-pattern等はcomponent以外なので対象外かどうか未確定。 + - full-text-search.md ✅ ページタイトルリスト埋め込み済み（ファイル名ベース、暫定） + + **fts-hints.md設計（会話で合意済み、未実装）:** + - 目的: index.mdから特定カテゴリのページタイトルを抽出してBM25ターム変換ヒントとして提供 + - ファイル名: `fts-hints.md`（full-text-search hints） + - 生成: RBKCで `generate_index_md()` の直後に生成（scripts/create/index.py に関数追加、run.py 3箇所に呼び出し追加） + - 対象カテゴリ: component/*, processing-pattern/*, development-tools/*, guide/*, setup/*（約1,900トークン） + - フォーマット: index.md同様 `## カテゴリ` + `### ページタイトル`（path/セクション行は不要） + - verifyへの影響: なし（.mdファイルはJSONスキャン対象外）、設計書に除外対象として明記のみ + - 設計書への追記: rbkc-converter-design.md §5-4として追加 + + **full-text-search.mdの更新が必要:** + 現在は `full-text-search.md` にファイル名ベースのリストを埋め込んでいる。 + fts-hints.md実装後は `cat scripts/fts-hints.md` 等で動的に読み込む方式に変更し、埋め込みリストを廃止する。 + + **実験結果（fts-hints.md方式の効果確認済み）:** + - pre-02（バリデーション）: bean-validation, nablarch-validation, InjectForm → 1回目でBM25-complete PASS ✅ + - review-08（セッションストア）: session-store, SessionStoreHandler → 1回目でBM25-complete PASS ✅ + - pre-03（UniversalDao）: universal-dao, UniversalDao → 1回目でBM25-complete PASS ✅ + - oos-qa-01（WebSocket）: WebSocket → NG→セマンティックfallback ✅（正しいパス） + + **作業前の必須手順（ユーザー指示）:** + 再開後に作業を始める前に、rbkcで全バージョン（v6/v5/v1.4/v1.3/v1.2）を実行してFAIL 0件・変更差分なしを確認すること。 + + **削除待ち:** `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-16*/`（中間結果）、`アクション**`、`ステップ`（空ファイル） + **.lw/nab-official/:** v1.2〜v6のシンボリックリンク作成済み（メインリポジトリの .lw/nab-official/* を指す） From a0c1ac709ed1824cdcbc70536f74da045638d79e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 07:40:15 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 28/37] =?UTF-8?q?docs:=20reconcile=20steering.md=20?= =?UTF-8?q?=E2=80=94=20clear=20State=20section=20for=20resume?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 37 +------------------------------------ 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 36 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 3831f6e04..0ef352e21 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -231,39 +231,4 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. # State -- **Status**: paused -- **Date**: 2026-06-25 -- **Last completed**: #3 in progress — full-text-search.md redesigned with page-title lookup approach (committed); 4-scenario experiment confirmed 1-shot term extraction working -- **Next**: #3 (new sub-task) — implement fts-hints.md generation in RBKC, then run pre-benchmark stabilization loop -- **Notes**: baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s). bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). - Workflow implementation complete (all committed): - - check-answerable.md ✅ - - qa.md ✅ 最終7ステップフロー - - generate-answer.md ✅ {findings}リネーム - - benchmark infra ✅ 168 tests pass - - full-text-search.md ✅ ページタイトルリスト埋め込み済み（ファイル名ベース、暫定） - - **fts-hints.md設計（会話で合意済み、未実装）:** - - 目的: index.mdから特定カテゴリのページタイトルを抽出してBM25ターム変換ヒントとして提供 - - ファイル名: `fts-hints.md`（full-text-search hints） - - 生成: RBKCで `generate_index_md()` の直後に生成（scripts/create/index.py に関数追加、run.py 3箇所に呼び出し追加） - - 対象カテゴリ: component/*, processing-pattern/*, development-tools/*, guide/*, setup/*（約1,900トークン） - - フォーマット: index.md同様 `## カテゴリ` + `### ページタイトル`（path/セクション行は不要） - - verifyへの影響: なし（.mdファイルはJSONスキャン対象外）、設計書に除外対象として明記のみ - - 設計書への追記: rbkc-converter-design.md §5-4として追加 - - **full-text-search.mdの更新が必要:** - 現在は `full-text-search.md` にファイル名ベースのリストを埋め込んでいる。 - fts-hints.md実装後は `cat scripts/fts-hints.md` 等で動的に読み込む方式に変更し、埋め込みリストを廃止する。 - - **実験結果（fts-hints.md方式の効果確認済み）:** - - pre-02（バリデーション）: bean-validation, nablarch-validation, InjectForm → 1回目でBM25-complete PASS ✅ - - review-08（セッションストア）: session-store, SessionStoreHandler → 1回目でBM25-complete PASS ✅ - - pre-03（UniversalDao）: universal-dao, UniversalDao → 1回目でBM25-complete PASS ✅ - - oos-qa-01（WebSocket）: WebSocket → NG→セマンティックfallback ✅（正しいパス） - - **作業前の必須手順（ユーザー指示）:** - 再開後に作業を始める前に、rbkcで全バージョン（v6/v5/v1.4/v1.3/v1.2）を実行してFAIL 0件・変更差分なしを確認すること。 - - **削除待ち:** `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-16*/`（中間結果）、`アクション**`、`ステップ`（空ファイル） - **.lw/nab-official/:** v1.2〜v6のシンボリックリンク作成済み（メインリポジトリの .lw/nab-official/* を指す） + From 722345a3c943396f1f1a77b5c36dd5064e172195 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 08:01:49 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 29/37] feat: generate fts-hints.md in RBKC and load dynamically in full-text-search.md Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md | 53 +++++++ .../nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md | 143 +----------------- tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py | 76 +++++++++- tools/rbkc/scripts/run.py | 5 +- 4 files changed, 139 insertions(+), 138 deletions(-) create mode 100644 .claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..383b5ccd2 --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md @@ -0,0 +1,53 @@ +# FTS Hints + +## component/libraries + +### ハンドラによる認可チェック +### BeanUtil +### Bean Validation +### コード管理 +### 登録機能での実装例 +### データバインド +### 様々なフォーマットのデータへのアクセス +### 汎用データフォーマット +### データバインドと汎用データフォーマットの比較表 +### ユニバーサルDAOとJakarta Persistenceとの機能比較 +### データベースアクセス +### データベースアクセス(JDBCラッパー) +### 日付管理 +### データベースを使用した二重サブミット防止 +### 排他制御 +### 障害ログの出力 +### ファイルパス管理 +### フォーマット定義ファイルの記述ルール +### フォーマッタ +### サロゲートキーの採番 +### HTTPアクセスログの出力 +### HTTPメッセージング +### HTTPアクセスログ（RESTfulウェブサービス用）の出力 +### 認可チェック +### Nablarchが提供するライブラリ +### ログ出力 +### メール送信 +### メッセージ管理 +### メッセージングログの出力 +### MOMメッセージング +### +### Nablarch Validation +### パフォーマンスログの出力 +### システムリポジトリ +### アノテーションによる認可チェック +### サービス提供可否チェック +### セッションストア +### SQLログの出力 +### Webアプリケーションをステートレスにする +### 静的データのキャッシュ +### システム間メッセージング +### タグリファレンス +### Jakarta Server Pagesカスタムタグ +### トランザクション管理 +### ユニバーサルDAO +### 更新機能での実装例 +### 汎用ユーティリティ +### Bean ValidationとNablarch Validationの機能比較 +### 入力値のチェック diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md index fa8877327..b25cd6385 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md @@ -24,7 +24,13 @@ Empty array when no BM25 terms found, script returns no hits, or script exits no ## Step 1: Extract BM25 search terms using page title lookup -Use the **Component page title list** below as a translation table to map the question's concepts to Nablarch-specific terms. +Read the FTS hints file to get the current page title list: + +```bash +cat scripts/fts-hints.md +``` + +Use this list as a translation table to map the question's concepts to Nablarch-specific terms. **Process**: @@ -49,141 +55,6 @@ Use the **Component page title list** below as a translation table to map the qu | UniversalDaoで検索する方法 | `libraries-universal-dao` (and verbatim: `UniversalDao`) | `universal-dao`, `UniversalDao` | | ファイル入出力の実装方法 | `libraries-data-format`, `libraries-data-bind`, `libraries-data-io-functional-comparison` | `data-format`, `data-bind` | -**Component page title list**: - -``` -adapters-adaptors -adapters-doma-adaptor -adapters-jaxrs-adaptor -adapters-jsr310-adaptor -adapters-lettuce-adaptor -adapters-log-adaptor -adapters-mail-sender-freemarker-adaptor -adapters-mail-sender-thymeleaf-adaptor -adapters-mail-sender-velocity-adaptor -adapters-micrometer-adaptor -adapters-redishealthchecker-lettuce-adaptor -adapters-redisstore-lettuce-adaptor -adapters-router-adaptor -adapters-slf4j-adaptor -adapters-web-thymeleaf-adaptor -adapters-webspheremq-adaptor -handlers-HttpErrorHandler -handlers-InjectForm -handlers-ServiceAvailabilityCheckHandler -handlers-SessionStoreHandler -handlers-batch -handlers-body-convert-handler -handlers-common -handlers-cors-preflight-request-handler -handlers-csrf-token-verification-handler -handlers-data-read-handler -handlers-database-connection-management-handler -handlers-dbless-loop-handler -handlers-duplicate-process-check-handler -handlers-file-record-writer-dispose-handler -handlers-forwarding-handler -handlers-global-error-handler -handlers-handlers -handlers-health-check-endpoint-handler -handlers-hot-deploy-handler -handlers-http-access-log-handler -handlers-http-character-encoding-handler -handlers-http-messaging -handlers-http-messaging-error-handler -handlers-http-messaging-request-parsing-handler -handlers-http-messaging-response-building-handler -handlers-http-request-java-package-mapping -handlers-http-response-handler -handlers-http-rewrite-handler -handlers-jaxrs-access-log-handler -handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler -handlers-jaxrs-response-handler -handlers-keitai-access-handler -handlers-loop-handler -handlers-main -handlers-message-reply-handler -handlers-message-resend-handler -handlers-messaging-context-handler -handlers-mom-messaging -handlers-multi-thread-execution-handler -handlers-multipart-handler -handlers-nablarch-tag-handler -handlers-normalize-handler -handlers-on-double-submission -handlers-on-error -handlers-on-errors -handlers-permission-check-handler -handlers-post-resubmit-prevent-handler -handlers-process-resident-handler -handlers-process-stop-handler -handlers-request-handler-entry -handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping -handlers-request-thread-loop-handler -handlers-resource-mapping -handlers-rest -handlers-retry-handler -handlers-secure-handler -handlers-session-concurrent-access-handler -handlers-standalone -handlers-status-code-convert-handler -handlers-thread-context-clear-handler -handlers-thread-context-handler -handlers-transaction-management-handler -handlers-use-token -handlers-web -handlers-web-interceptor -libraries-authorization-permission-check -libraries-bean-util -libraries-bean-validation -libraries-code -libraries-create-example -libraries-data-bind -libraries-data-converter -libraries-data-format -libraries-data-io-functional-comparison -libraries-database -libraries-database-functional-comparison -libraries-database-management -libraries-date -libraries-db-double-submit -libraries-exclusive-control -libraries-failure-log -libraries-file-path-management -libraries-format -libraries-format-definition -libraries-generator -libraries-http-access-log -libraries-http-system-messaging -libraries-jaxrs-access-log -libraries-libraries -libraries-libraries-permission-check -libraries-log -libraries-mail -libraries-message -libraries-messaging-log -libraries-mom-system-messaging -libraries-multi-format-example -libraries-nablarch-validation -libraries-performance-log -libraries-repository -libraries-role-check -libraries-service-availability -libraries-session-store -libraries-sql-log -libraries-stateless-web-app -libraries-static-data-cache -libraries-system-messaging -libraries-tag -libraries-tag-reference -libraries-transaction -libraries-universal-dao -libraries-update-example -libraries-utility -libraries-validation -libraries-validation-functional-comparison -``` - Save the extracted terms as `bm25_terms` (list of strings). **If `bm25_terms` is empty** (no relevant titles found and no verbatim identifiers in the question), return `{"selected_sections": []}` immediately. diff --git a/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py b/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py index 83ef7d254..f68838cf9 100644 --- a/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py +++ b/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py @@ -1,14 +1,18 @@ """Index generator for RBKC. -Generates index.md from knowledge JSON files: +Generates index.md and fts-hints.md from knowledge JSON files: - ``index.md`` — Markdown format for semantic search (Stage 1 page selection). Format: H2 per category → H3 per file → list of section IDs and titles. +- ``fts-hints.md`` — BM25 term translation hints for full-text search. + Contains page titles from selected component categories. + Format: H2 per category → H3 per page title. Files with ``no_knowledge_content: true`` are excluded. Public API: generate_index_md(knowledge_dir, output_path) -> None + generate_fts_hints_md(knowledge_dir, output_path) -> None """ from __future__ import annotations @@ -112,3 +116,73 @@ def generate_index_md(knowledge_dir: Path, output_path: Path) -> None: output_path.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) output_path.write_text("\n".join(lines), encoding="utf-8") + + +# Target second-level category names under ``component/`` for FTS hints. +_FTS_HINTS_SUBCATEGORIES = frozenset([ + "libraries", + "processing-pattern", + "development-tools", + "guide", + "setup", +]) + + +def generate_fts_hints_md(knowledge_dir: Path, output_path: Path) -> None: + """Write ``fts-hints.md`` to *output_path* from knowledge JSON files. + + Scans *knowledge_dir* for JSON files in categories that start with + ``component/`` and whose second path component is one of: + ``libraries``, ``processing-pattern``, ``development-tools``, + ``guide``, ``setup``. + + Files with ``no_knowledge_content: true``, files under ``assets/``, + and files under ``javadoc/`` are excluded. + + Format: H2 per category → H3 per page title (title field or file stem). + + Args: + knowledge_dir: Root directory containing knowledge JSON files. + output_path: Destination path for ``fts-hints.md``. + """ + files_by_category: dict[str, list[str]] = {} + + for json_path in sorted(knowledge_dir.rglob("*.json")): + if json_path.stem.startswith("index") or json_path.stem.startswith("terms"): + continue + rel = json_path.relative_to(knowledge_dir) + parts = rel.parts + if "assets" in parts: + continue + if "javadoc" in parts: + continue + if len(parts) < 2: + continue + top_level = parts[0] + second_level = parts[1] + # Only include categories under component/ with a matching subcategory. + if top_level != "component": + continue + if second_level not in _FTS_HINTS_SUBCATEGORIES: + continue + category = "/".join(parts[:2]) + try: + data = _load_json(json_path) + except (json.JSONDecodeError, OSError): + continue + if data.get("no_knowledge_content") is True: + continue + title = data.get("title", json_path.stem) + files_by_category.setdefault(category, []).append(title) + + lines = ["# FTS Hints", ""] + + for category in sorted(files_by_category.keys()): + lines.append(f"## {category}") + lines.append("") + for title in files_by_category[category]: + lines.append(f"### {title}") + lines.append("") + + output_path.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) + output_path.write_text("\n".join(lines), encoding="utf-8") diff --git a/tools/rbkc/scripts/run.py b/tools/rbkc/scripts/run.py index 9c8f45593..72e6de21c 100644 --- a/tools/rbkc/scripts/run.py +++ b/tools/rbkc/scripts/run.py @@ -34,7 +34,7 @@ from scripts.create.differ import diff_snapshot, load_snapshot, make_snapshot, save_snapshot from scripts.create.docs import generate_docs from scripts.create.classes import generate_classes_md -from scripts.create.index import generate_index_md +from scripts.create.index import generate_index_md, generate_fts_hints_md from scripts.create.javadoc import javadoc_generate from scripts.create.resolver import collect_asset_refs, copy_assets from scripts.common.labels import build_label_doc_map, build_label_map # noqa: F401 @@ -264,6 +264,7 @@ def create( copy_assets(all_asset_refs, output_dir) generate_index_md(output_dir, output_dir / "index.md") + generate_fts_hints_md(output_dir, output_dir.parent / "scripts" / "fts-hints.md") generate_classes_md(output_dir, output_dir / "classes.md") generate_docs(output_dir, docs_dir, version) @@ -316,6 +317,7 @@ def update( copy_assets(changed_asset_refs, output_dir) generate_index_md(output_dir, output_dir / "index.md") + generate_fts_hints_md(output_dir, output_dir.parent / "scripts" / "fts-hints.md") generate_classes_md(output_dir, output_dir / "classes.md") generate_docs(output_dir, output_dir.parent / "docs", version) @@ -359,6 +361,7 @@ def delete( count += 1 generate_index_md(output_dir, output_dir / "index.md") + generate_fts_hints_md(output_dir, output_dir.parent / "scripts" / "fts-hints.md") generate_classes_md(output_dir, output_dir / "classes.md") generate_docs(output_dir, output_dir.parent / "docs", version) From 394983c8dcf9659609390005bfe08b852ab78501 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 08:08:07 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 30/37] fix: fts-hints.md uses file stems not JSON titles for BM25 term lookup Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md | 98 +++++++++---------- tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py | 5 +- 2 files changed, 51 insertions(+), 52 deletions(-) diff --git a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md index 383b5ccd2..3c9198b7a 100644 --- a/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md +++ b/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md @@ -2,52 +2,52 @@ ## component/libraries -### ハンドラによる認可チェック -### BeanUtil -### Bean Validation -### コード管理 -### 登録機能での実装例 -### データバインド -### 様々なフォーマットのデータへのアクセス -### 汎用データフォーマット -### データバインドと汎用データフォーマットの比較表 -### ユニバーサルDAOとJakarta Persistenceとの機能比較 -### データベースアクセス -### データベースアクセス(JDBCラッパー) -### 日付管理 -### データベースを使用した二重サブミット防止 -### 排他制御 -### 障害ログの出力 -### ファイルパス管理 -### フォーマット定義ファイルの記述ルール -### フォーマッタ -### サロゲートキーの採番 -### HTTPアクセスログの出力 -### HTTPメッセージング -### HTTPアクセスログ（RESTfulウェブサービス用）の出力 -### 認可チェック -### Nablarchが提供するライブラリ -### ログ出力 -### メール送信 -### メッセージ管理 -### メッセージングログの出力 -### MOMメッセージング -### -### Nablarch Validation -### パフォーマンスログの出力 -### システムリポジトリ -### アノテーションによる認可チェック -### サービス提供可否チェック -### セッションストア -### SQLログの出力 -### Webアプリケーションをステートレスにする -### 静的データのキャッシュ -### システム間メッセージング -### タグリファレンス -### Jakarta Server Pagesカスタムタグ -### トランザクション管理 -### ユニバーサルDAO -### 更新機能での実装例 -### 汎用ユーティリティ -### Bean ValidationとNablarch Validationの機能比較 -### 入力値のチェック +### libraries-authorization-permission-check +### libraries-bean-util +### libraries-bean-validation +### libraries-code +### libraries-create-example +### libraries-data-bind +### libraries-data-converter +### libraries-data-format +### libraries-data-io-functional-comparison +### libraries-database-functional-comparison +### libraries-database-management +### libraries-database +### libraries-date +### libraries-db-double-submit +### libraries-exclusive-control +### libraries-failure-log +### libraries-file-path-management +### libraries-format-definition +### libraries-format +### libraries-generator +### libraries-http-access-log +### libraries-http-system-messaging +### libraries-jaxrs-access-log +### libraries-libraries-permission-check +### libraries-libraries +### libraries-log +### libraries-mail +### libraries-message +### libraries-messaging-log +### libraries-mom-system-messaging +### libraries-multi-format-example +### libraries-nablarch-validation +### libraries-performance-log +### libraries-repository +### libraries-role-check +### libraries-service-availability +### libraries-session-store +### libraries-sql-log +### libraries-stateless-web-app +### libraries-static-data-cache +### libraries-system-messaging +### libraries-tag-reference +### libraries-tag +### libraries-transaction +### libraries-universal-dao +### libraries-update-example +### libraries-utility +### libraries-validation-functional-comparison +### libraries-validation diff --git a/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py b/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py index f68838cf9..cdcd142ff 100644 --- a/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py +++ b/tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py @@ -139,7 +139,7 @@ def generate_fts_hints_md(knowledge_dir: Path, output_path: Path) -> None: Files with ``no_knowledge_content: true``, files under ``assets/``, and files under ``javadoc/`` are excluded. - Format: H2 per category → H3 per page title (title field or file stem). + Format: H2 per category → H3 per file stem (e.g. ``libraries-bean-validation``). Args: knowledge_dir: Root directory containing knowledge JSON files. @@ -172,8 +172,7 @@ def generate_fts_hints_md(knowledge_dir: Path, output_path: Path) -> None: continue if data.get("no_knowledge_content") is True: continue - title = data.get("title", json_path.stem) - files_by_category.setdefault(category, []).append(title) + files_by_category.setdefault(category, []).append(json_path.stem) lines = ["# FTS Hints", ""] From 874dfe66bccc609489d1356fcbb801fac372a55e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 10:15:34 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 31/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20update=20steering.md=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20fts-hints.md=20implemented,=20stabilization=20loop=20procedu?= =?UTF-8?q?re=20clarified?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md | 24 ++++++------------------ .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 32 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 2 files changed, 37 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md index ac8caa5f2..95937e9c3 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/checks/task-3.md @@ -2,22 +2,10 @@ ## Completion Criteria -| Criterion | Self-check | Evidence | QA | QA Evidence | -|---|---|---|---|---| -| bm25-search.sh in allowedTools | OK | `run_qa.py` line 192: `"Bash(bash scripts/bm25-search.sh *)"` added to `--allowedTools`; `test_uses_allowed_tools_as_specified` asserts it and passes | | | -| e2e-prompt.md step numbers match new qa.md | OK | Step 1 (skip hearing), Step 2 (BM25 search), Step 3 (check-answerable), Step 4 (semantic-search, conditional), Step 7 (output) — matches new qa.md flow | | | -| workflow_details schema updated to new structure | OK | `SAMPLE_WORKFLOW_DETAILS` updated to step2/step3/step4/step5/step6; `test_parses_workflow_details`, `test_parses_bm25_sections`, `test_parses_check_answerable_result`, `test_returns_workflow_details` all assert new keys | | | -| All tests pass | OK | `python3 -m pytest tools/benchmark/tests/ -x -q` → 168 passed after fixes | | | - -## QA Expert Review - -| Aspect | Verdict | Evidence / Improvement | +| Criterion | Self-check | Evidence | |---|---|---| -| Meaningful tests/verification | OK | Cascade fallback test added (step5 absent→bm25 fallback, all-empty→0); step6 FAIL+regenerated test added; 168 tests pass | -| Edge case coverage | OK | 4 findings raised; 3 fixed (cascade test, regeneration test, qa.md "Otherwise" wording); 1 invalid (early-stop→MarkerError is existing behavior, not regression) | - -## Overall Verdict - -- Self-check: OK -- QA: OK (after fix round) -- Ready for user review: Yes +| `generate_fts_hints_md` added to `index.py` | OK | Function defined at bottom of `tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py`; filters `component/{libraries,processing-pattern,development-tools,guide,setup}`; excludes `assets/`, `javadoc/`, `no_knowledge_content: true` | +| `run.py` imports and calls `generate_fts_hints_md` in 3 places | OK | Import updated to `from scripts.create.index import generate_index_md, generate_fts_hints_md`; 3 calls added in `create()`, `update()`, `delete()` — each outputs to `output_dir.parent / "scripts" / "fts-hints.md"` | +| `fts-hints.md` generated at correct path | OK | `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md` exists after `rbkc create 6`; contains `### libraries-bean-validation` (file-stem format, fixed from initial Japanese-title version) | +| verify v6 passes with no regressions | OK | `python -m scripts.run verify 6` → `All files verified OK` (only pre-existing WARNs for javadoc_map miss) | +| `full-text-search.md` updated to use `cat scripts/fts-hints.md` | OK | Static "Component page title list" block removed; replaced with `cat scripts/fts-hints.md` bash command before the Process steps | diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 0ef352e21..4364cca0b 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -231,4 +231,34 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. # State - +- **Status**: paused +- **Date**: 2026-06-26 +- **Last completed**: #3 sub-task — fts-hints.md RBKC generation implemented and pushed (commits 722345a3, 394983c8). full-text-search.md updated to `cat scripts/fts-hints.md` dynamic loading. +- **Next**: #3 — pre-benchmark stabilization loop (全34シナリオ実行 → 全 workflow_details.json 個別確認 → ユーザーゲート → 本実行 run-1/2/3) +- **Notes**: + - baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s) + - bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). + - RBKC run dir: `tools/rbkc/` → `/home/tie303177/venv/bin/python -m scripts.run ` + - 作業前の必須手順: rbkc verify 全バージョン (1.2/1.3/1.4/5/6) を実行してFAIL 0件確認。前回確認済み。 + + **fts-hints.md 実装済み（コミット済み）:** + - `tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py` に `generate_fts_hints_md()` 追加（ファイルステムベース） + - `tools/rbkc/scripts/run.py` に3箇所呼び出し追加（output_dir.parent/"scripts"/"fts-hints.md"） + - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md` 生成済み（ファイルステム形式、例: `### libraries-bean-validation`） + - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md` 更新済み（静的リスト廃止 → `cat scripts/fts-hints.md`） + + **stabilization run の反省:** + 前回 stabilization run（削除済み）では全 workflow_details.json を個別確認せず集計のみで「安定」と判定した。 + 次回 stabilization run では全34件の workflow_details.json を個別確認し、ユーザーに提示してから本実行に進むこと。 + + **pre-benchmark stabilization loop 手順:** + 1. 全34シナリオ実行: `/home/tie303177/venv/bin/python -m tools.benchmark.scripts.run_qa --scenarios tools/benchmark/scenarios/qa.json --skill-dir .claude/skills/nabledge-6` + 2. 全34件の workflow_details.json を確認: + - bm25_terms が質問に対して適切か + - check_answerable 判定が正しいか + - 予期しない BM25 term 抽出がないか + 3. 確認結果をユーザーに提示 → ユーザーゲート待ち + 4. 承認後に本実行（run-1/2/3） + 5. 中間 stabilization 結果は削除 + + **削除待ち:** `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-175755/`（中間結果）、`{run-label}/`（空ディレクトリ） From 957e09bae950b40591db4454d44cc3ed7ab8897c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 10:27:09 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 32/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20update=20steering.md=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20benchmark=20must=20follow=20HOW-TO-RUN.md=20strictly?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 26 +++++++++++++------------- 1 file changed, 13 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 4364cca0b..cb71ac040 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -247,18 +247,18 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md` 生成済み（ファイルステム形式、例: `### libraries-bean-validation`） - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md` 更新済み（静的リスト廃止 → `cat scripts/fts-hints.md`） - **stabilization run の反省:** - 前回 stabilization run（削除済み）では全 workflow_details.json を個別確認せず集計のみで「安定」と判定した。 - 次回 stabilization run では全34件の workflow_details.json を個別確認し、ユーザーに提示してから本実行に進むこと。 - - **pre-benchmark stabilization loop 手順:** - 1. 全34シナリオ実行: `/home/tie303177/venv/bin/python -m tools.benchmark.scripts.run_qa --scenarios tools/benchmark/scenarios/qa.json --skill-dir .claude/skills/nabledge-6` - 2. 全34件の workflow_details.json を確認: - - bm25_terms が質問に対して適切か - - check_answerable 判定が正しいか - - 予期しない BM25 term 抽出がないか - 3. 確認結果をユーザーに提示 → ユーザーゲート待ち - 4. 承認後に本実行（run-1/2/3） - 5. 中間 stabilization 結果は削除 + **ベンチマーク実行ルール（厳守）:** + ベンチマーク実行は `tools/benchmark/HOW-TO-RUN.md` のアクション単位で進める。 + HOW-TO-RUN.md に存在しない手順・フェーズを自己流で追加・省略してはならない。 + 各ステップ完了後にユーザーへ報告し、次のステップへ進む前に確認を取ること。 + + **次の具体的な手順（HOW-TO-RUN.md に従う）:** + 1. Phase A-1: 1シナリオ動作確認（A-1-1実行 → A-1-2受入確認をユーザーに提示 → A-1-3削除） + 2. ユーザーゲート: Phase A 完了をユーザーに報告し、Phase B 開始の承認を得る + 3. Phase B run-1: B-1-1実行 → B-1-2リネーム → B-1-3受入確認をユーザーに提示 + 4. B-2タイムアウト回収（エラーあれば） → B-3レポート生成 → B-4コミット・プッシュ + 5. ユーザーゲート: run-1 結果（workflow_details.json 全件確認含む）をユーザーに提示し承認を得る + 6. run-2, run-3 も同様に各ステップ完了後にユーザーゲート + 7. Phase C crossrun-summary 生成 → Phase E 退行チェック → ユーザーゲート **削除待ち:** `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-175755/`（中間結果）、`{run-label}/`（空ディレクトリ） From 168b3b850c2e11e6e682680b811fe6a360b7760a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 10:28:19 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 33/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20update=20steering.md=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20replace=20transcribed=20benchmark=20steps=20with=20HOW-TO-RU?= =?UTF-8?q?N.md=20reference?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 18 ++---------------- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 16 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index cb71ac040..5261fa8f3 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -123,9 +123,7 @@ incrementally — single scenario first, then path-coverage sample, then full 3- - [x] **Phase A (1 scenario)**: run `pre-01` via `run_qa --scenario-ids pre-01`; confirm exit 0, answer.md non-empty, BM25 path exercised; delete tmp dir after - [x] Refactor: extract BM25 step to `workflows/full-text-search.md`; qa.md Step 3 becomes a concise workflow call (mirrors semantic-search.md pattern) - [x] **Path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios)**: 8 scenarios inspected; Paths A/B/C confirmed; review-08 flagged (BM25 extracted Japanese concept words — fix needed in full-text-search.md) -- [ ] **Pre-benchmark stabilization loop**: run 1 full run (34 scenarios); inspect workflow_details.json for each scenario; fix any misbehavior in workflows; repeat until stable (no unexpected BM25 term extraction, all paths correct, verify PASS rate acceptable); delete intermediate runs after each fix cycle -- [ ] **Phase B/C full benchmark**: once stable, 3 runs × 34 scenarios per HOW-TO-RUN.md; generate per-run reports and crossrun-summary; commit each run immediately after completion -- [ ] Phase E regression check: compare against baseline from #1 +- [ ] **Phase A–E benchmark**: follow `tools/benchmark/HOW-TO-RUN.md` action by action; present results to user at each step boundary and wait for approval before proceeding - [ ] Save comparison summary to `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` - [ ] Software Engineer expert review (subagent) - [ ] User review @@ -247,18 +245,6 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md` 生成済み（ファイルステム形式、例: `### libraries-bean-validation`） - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md` 更新済み（静的リスト廃止 → `cat scripts/fts-hints.md`） - **ベンチマーク実行ルール（厳守）:** - ベンチマーク実行は `tools/benchmark/HOW-TO-RUN.md` のアクション単位で進める。 - HOW-TO-RUN.md に存在しない手順・フェーズを自己流で追加・省略してはならない。 - 各ステップ完了後にユーザーへ報告し、次のステップへ進む前に確認を取ること。 - - **次の具体的な手順（HOW-TO-RUN.md に従う）:** - 1. Phase A-1: 1シナリオ動作確認（A-1-1実行 → A-1-2受入確認をユーザーに提示 → A-1-3削除） - 2. ユーザーゲート: Phase A 完了をユーザーに報告し、Phase B 開始の承認を得る - 3. Phase B run-1: B-1-1実行 → B-1-2リネーム → B-1-3受入確認をユーザーに提示 - 4. B-2タイムアウト回収（エラーあれば） → B-3レポート生成 → B-4コミット・プッシュ - 5. ユーザーゲート: run-1 結果（workflow_details.json 全件確認含む）をユーザーに提示し承認を得る - 6. run-2, run-3 も同様に各ステップ完了後にユーザーゲート - 7. Phase C crossrun-summary 生成 → Phase E 退行チェック → ユーザーゲート + **ベンチマーク実行:** `tools/benchmark/HOW-TO-RUN.md` を参照。手順はそこに書いてある。 **削除待ち:** `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-175755/`（中間結果）、`{run-label}/`（空ディレクトリ） From e4d45cca779e762e738a2d659fab37f9bfd96779 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 10:29:03 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 34/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20update=20steering.md=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20split=20benchmark=20into=20stabilization=20run=20and=20full?= =?UTF-8?q?=20benchmark=20steps?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 3 ++- 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 5261fa8f3..92de3e006 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -123,7 +123,8 @@ incrementally — single scenario first, then path-coverage sample, then full 3- - [x] **Phase A (1 scenario)**: run `pre-01` via `run_qa --scenario-ids pre-01`; confirm exit 0, answer.md non-empty, BM25 path exercised; delete tmp dir after - [x] Refactor: extract BM25 step to `workflows/full-text-search.md`; qa.md Step 3 becomes a concise workflow call (mirrors semantic-search.md pattern) - [x] **Path-coverage sample (3–5 scenarios)**: 8 scenarios inspected; Paths A/B/C confirmed; review-08 flagged (BM25 extracted Japanese concept words — fix needed in full-text-search.md) -- [ ] **Phase A–E benchmark**: follow `tools/benchmark/HOW-TO-RUN.md` action by action; present results to user at each step boundary and wait for approval before proceeding +- [ ] **Stabilization run (1 run, not the full benchmark)**: execute HOW-TO-RUN.md Phase A (A-1-1 → A-1-2 → A-1-3) then Phase B run-1 only (B-1-1 → B-1-2 → B-1-3 → B-2 → B-3 → B-4); present each step result to user and wait for approval before proceeding; after run-1 complete, present all 34 workflow_details.json to user and wait for approval that workflow behavior is stable +- [ ] **Full benchmark (3 runs)**: after stabilization approved, execute HOW-TO-RUN.md Phase B run-2 and run-3, then Phase C and Phase E; follow each action in order; present results to user at each step boundary and wait for approval before proceeding - [ ] Save comparison summary to `.rn/issue-382/benchmark-result.md` - [ ] Software Engineer expert review (subagent) - [ ] User review From d562f333debafe9733e036b1c54d37981b239714 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 10:43:16 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 35/37] =?UTF-8?q?wip:=20update=20steering.md=20=E2=80=94?= =?UTF-8?q?=20State=20updated=20for=20session=20suspend?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .rn/issue-382/steering.md | 16 +++------------- 1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-) diff --git a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md index 92de3e006..634e2c9b9 100644 --- a/.rn/issue-382/steering.md +++ b/.rn/issue-382/steering.md @@ -232,20 +232,10 @@ versions, as the workflow is superseded and confusingly named. - **Status**: paused - **Date**: 2026-06-26 -- **Last completed**: #3 sub-task — fts-hints.md RBKC generation implemented and pushed (commits 722345a3, 394983c8). full-text-search.md updated to `cat scripts/fts-hints.md` dynamic loading. -- **Next**: #3 — pre-benchmark stabilization loop (全34シナリオ実行 → 全 workflow_details.json 個別確認 → ユーザーゲート → 本実行 run-1/2/3) +- **Last completed**: #3 sub-task — fts-hints.md RBKC generation implemented and pushed (commits 722345a3, 394983c8). full-text-search.md updated to `cat scripts/fts-hints.md` dynamic loading. Steering task steps clarified. +- **Next**: #3 — Stabilization run (Phase A + B run-1 per HOW-TO-RUN.md) - **Notes**: - baseline = 20260612-1404-baseline-current (25/34, p50 $0.682, 118s) - bm25s installed in /home/tie303177/venv. .bm25-index/ is runtime-generated (untracked, gitignored). - RBKC run dir: `tools/rbkc/` → `/home/tie303177/venv/bin/python -m scripts.run ` - - 作業前の必須手順: rbkc verify 全バージョン (1.2/1.3/1.4/5/6) を実行してFAIL 0件確認。前回確認済み。 - - **fts-hints.md 実装済み（コミット済み）:** - - `tools/rbkc/scripts/create/index.py` に `generate_fts_hints_md()` 追加（ファイルステムベース） - - `tools/rbkc/scripts/run.py` に3箇所呼び出し追加（output_dir.parent/"scripts"/"fts-hints.md"） - - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/fts-hints.md` 生成済み（ファイルステム形式、例: `### libraries-bean-validation`） - - `.claude/skills/nabledge-6/workflows/full-text-search.md` 更新済み（静的リスト廃止 → `cat scripts/fts-hints.md`） - - **ベンチマーク実行:** `tools/benchmark/HOW-TO-RUN.md` を参照。手順はそこに書いてある。 - - **削除待ち:** `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-175755/`（中間結果）、`{run-label}/`（空ディレクトリ） + - 削除待ち: `tools/benchmark/results/20260625-175755/`（中間結果）、`{run-label}/`（空ディレクトリ） From 14eda86b7639e820f09230fe92cbb6b9f5474581 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: kiyotis Date: Fri, 26 Jun 2026 16:18:33 +0900 Subject: [PATCH 36/37] chore: save 20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25 run-1 (benchmark + report) Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 --- .../run-1/impact-01/answer.md | 75 ++ .../run-1/impact-01/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/impact-01/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/impact-01/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/impact-01/workflow_details.json | 137 +++ .../run-1/impact-03/answer.md | 33 + .../run-1/impact-03/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/impact-03/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/impact-03/trace.json | 82 ++ .../run-1/impact-03/workflow_details.json | 91 ++ .../run-1/impact-06/answer.md | 73 ++ .../run-1/impact-06/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/impact-06/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/impact-06/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/impact-06/workflow_details.json | 137 +++ .../run-1/impact-08/answer.md | 42 + .../run-1/impact-08/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/impact-08/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/impact-08/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/impact-08/workflow_details.json | 89 ++ .../run-1/oos-impact-01/answer.md | 34 + .../run-1/oos-impact-01/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/oos-impact-01/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/oos-impact-01/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/oos-impact-01/workflow_details.json | 147 ++++ .../run-1/oos-qa-01/answer.md | 14 + .../run-1/oos-qa-01/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/oos-qa-01/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/oos-qa-01/trace.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/oos-qa-01/workflow_details.json | 28 + .../run-1/pre-01/answer.md | 64 ++ .../run-1/pre-01/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/pre-01/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/pre-01/trace.json | 69 ++ .../run-1/pre-01/workflow_details.json | 145 ++++ .../run-1/pre-02/answer.md | 77 ++ .../run-1/pre-02/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/pre-02/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/pre-02/trace.json | 68 ++ .../run-1/pre-02/workflow_details.json | 154 ++++ .../run-1/pre-03/answer.md | 72 ++ .../run-1/pre-03/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/pre-03/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/pre-03/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/pre-03/workflow_details.json | 161 ++++ .../run-1/qa-01/answer.md | 26 + .../run-1/qa-01/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-01/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-01/trace.json | 85 ++ .../run-1/qa-01/workflow_details.json | 79 ++ .../run-1/qa-02/answer.md | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-02/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-02/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-02/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-02/workflow_details.json | 100 +++ .../run-1/qa-03/answer.md | 48 ++ .../run-1/qa-03/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-03/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-03/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-03/workflow_details.json | 145 ++++ .../run-1/qa-04/answer.md | 94 ++ .../run-1/qa-04/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-04/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-04/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-04/workflow_details.json | 265 ++++++ .../run-1/qa-05/answer.md | 34 + .../run-1/qa-05/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-05/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-05/trace.json | 96 +++ .../run-1/qa-05/workflow_details.json | 80 ++ .../run-1/qa-06/answer.md | 64 ++ .../run-1/qa-06/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-06/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-06/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-06/workflow_details.json | 63 ++ .../run-1/qa-07/answer.md | 45 + .../run-1/qa-07/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-07/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-07/trace.json | 69 ++ .../run-1/qa-07/workflow_details.json | 62 ++ .../run-1/qa-08/answer.md | 181 ++++ .../run-1/qa-08/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-08/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-08/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-08/workflow_details.json | 110 +++ .../run-1/qa-09/answer.md | 64 ++ .../run-1/qa-09/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-09/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-09/trace.json | 85 ++ .../run-1/qa-09/workflow_details.json | 106 +++ .../run-1/qa-10/answer.md | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-10/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-10/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-10/trace.json | 85 ++ .../run-1/qa-10/workflow_details.json | 62 ++ .../run-1/qa-11/answer.md | 113 +++ .../run-1/qa-11/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-11/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-11/trace.json | 69 ++ .../run-1/qa-11/workflow_details.json | 208 +++++ .../run-1/qa-12/answer.md | 93 ++ .../run-1/qa-12/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-12/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-12/trace.json | 85 ++ .../run-1/qa-12/workflow_details.json | 160 ++++ .../run-1/qa-13/answer.md | 49 ++ .../run-1/qa-13/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-13/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-13/trace.json | 85 ++ .../run-1/qa-13/workflow_details.json | 163 ++++ .../run-1/qa-14/answer.md | 72 ++ .../run-1/qa-14/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-14/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-14/trace.json | 82 ++ .../run-1/qa-14/workflow_details.json | 123 +++ .../run-1/qa-15/answer.md | 26 + .../run-1/qa-15/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-15/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-15/trace.json | 90 ++ .../run-1/qa-15/workflow_details.json | 133 +++ .../run-1/qa-16/answer.md | 42 + .../run-1/qa-16/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-16/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-16/trace.json | 101 +++ .../run-1/qa-16/workflow_details.json | 58 ++ .../run-1/qa-17/answer.md | 30 + .../run-1/qa-17/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-17/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-17/trace.json | 101 +++ .../run-1/qa-17/workflow_details.json | 53 ++ .../run-1/qa-18/answer.md | 34 + .../run-1/qa-18/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-18/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-18/trace.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-18/workflow_details.json | 84 ++ .../run-1/qa-19/answer.md | 70 ++ .../run-1/qa-19/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/qa-19/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-19/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-19/workflow_details.json | 136 +++ .../run-1/qa-20/answer.md | 63 ++ .../run-1/qa-20/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-20/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-20/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-20/workflow_details.json | 100 +++ .../run-1/qa-21/answer.md | 88 ++ .../run-1/qa-21/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/qa-21/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/qa-21/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/qa-21/workflow_details.json | 100 +++ .../run-1/report.md | 806 ++++++++++++++++++ .../run-1/review-06/answer.md | 73 ++ .../run-1/review-06/evaluation.json | 61 ++ .../run-1/review-06/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/review-06/trace.json | 69 ++ .../run-1/review-06/workflow_details.json | 144 ++++ .../run-1/review-07/answer.md | 83 ++ .../run-1/review-07/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/review-07/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/review-07/trace.json | 75 ++ .../run-1/review-07/workflow_details.json | 96 +++ .../run-1/review-08/answer.md | 34 + .../run-1/review-08/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/review-08/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/review-08/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/review-08/workflow_details.json | 140 +++ .../run-1/review-09/answer.md | 84 ++ .../run-1/review-09/evaluation.json | 60 ++ .../run-1/review-09/metrics.json | 34 + .../run-1/review-09/trace.json | 77 ++ .../run-1/review-09/workflow_details.json | 95 +++ .../run-1/summary.json | 144 ++++ 172 files changed, 12898 insertions(+) create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-16/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-16/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-16/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-16/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-16/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-17/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-17/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-17/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-17/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-17/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-18/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-18/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-18/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-18/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-18/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-19/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-19/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-19/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-19/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-19/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-20/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-20/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-20/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-20/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-20/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-21/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-21/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-21/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-21/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-21/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/report.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-06/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-06/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-06/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-06/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-06/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-07/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-07/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-07/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-07/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-07/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-08/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-08/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-08/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-08/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-08/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-09/answer.md create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-09/evaluation.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-09/metrics.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-09/trace.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/review-09/workflow_details.json create mode 100644 tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/summary.json diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e25ed0ec9 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +業務トランザクションとは別のトランザクションでSQLを実行するには、`SimpleDbTransactionManager` と `SimpleDbTransactionExecutor`（JDBCラッパー使用時）または `UniversalDao.Transaction`（UniversalDAO使用時）を使います。業務トランザクションがロールバックされても、別トランザクションでコミットした更新は保持されます。 + +--- + +**方法1: JDBCラッパー (`SimpleDbTransactionExecutor`) を使う場合** + +コンポーネント設定ファイルに `SimpleDbTransactionManager` を定義します。 + +```xml + + + + + + + + +``` + +実装例： + +```java +// システムリポジトリからSimpleDbTransactionManagerを取得する +SimpleDbTransactionManager dbTransactionManager = + SystemRepository.get("update-login-failed-count-transaction"); + +// SimpleDbTransactionManagerをコンストラクタに指定して実行する +SqlResultSet resultSet = new SimpleDbTransactionExecutor(dbTransactionManager) { + @Override + public SqlResultSet execute(AppDbConnection connection) { + SqlPStatement statement = connection.prepareStatementBySqlId( + "jp.co.tis.sample.action.SampleAction#findUser"); + statement.setLong(1, userId); + return statement.retrieve(); + } +}.doTransaction(); +``` + +--- + +**方法2: UniversalDAO (`UniversalDao.Transaction`) を使う場合** + +コンポーネント設定ファイルに同様に `SimpleDbTransactionManager` を定義し、`UniversalDao.Transaction` を継承したクラスを作成します。 + +```java +private static final class FindPersonsTransaction extends UniversalDao.Transaction { + private EntityList persons; + + FindPersonsTransaction() { + // SimpleDbTransactionManagerのコンポーネント定義名を指定する + super("find-persons-transaction"); + } + + // このメソッドが自動的に別のトランザクションで実行される + @Override + protected void execute() { + persons = UniversalDao.findAllBySqlFile(Person.class, "FIND_PERSONS"); + } + + public EntityList getPersons() { + return persons; + } +} + +// 呼び出し +FindPersonsTransaction findPersonsTransaction = new FindPersonsTransaction(); +EntityList persons = findPersonsTransaction.getPersons(); +``` + +--- + +**注意点**: `SimpleDbTransactionManager` には `connectionFactory`（DB接続設定）と `transactionFactory`（トランザクション制御）の両方を設定する必要があります。各プロパティの詳細は、データベース接続設定（`libraries-database.json`）およびトランザクション制御（`libraries-transaction.json`）を参照してください。 + +参照: `libraries-database.json:s29`, `libraries-universal-dao.json:s20`, `libraries-transaction.json:s5` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..64f8df57f --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "impact-01", + "description": "バッチ処理で業務エラー時にエラーログだけは別トランザクションで必ずDBに書き込みたい。業務トランザクションがロールバックされてもログは残したい。", + "input": "業務トランザクションとは別のトランザクションでSQLを実行する方法はあるか？ロールバックされても別トランザクションの更新は残したい", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "SimpleDbTransactionManagerを使って個別トランザクションを定義する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Expected Output contains a single key fact: using SimpleDbTransactionManager to define individual transactions. The Actual Output clearly covers this fact in detail, explaining how to use SimpleDbTransactionManager for executing SQL in a separate transaction from the business transaction, including XML configuration examples and Java code examples for both JDBC wrapper and UniversalDAO approaches. The core concept of defining individual transactions with SimpleDbTransactionManager is well represented and not misrepresented." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is fully relevant to the question about executing SQL in a separate transaction from the business transaction, with no irrelevant statements detected. Great job staying focused on the topic!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 103229, + "duration_api_ms": 101388, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.42773240000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "output_tokens": 6339, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 619128, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 38568 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2054, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002234, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 6339, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 619128, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 38568, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.4254984000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e87d79837 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 103229, + "duration_api_ms": 101388, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.42773240000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "output_tokens": 6339, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 619128, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 38568 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2054, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002234, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 6339, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 619128, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 38568, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.4254984000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..aa6f7c239 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 103229, + "duration_api_ms": 101388, + "ttft_ms": 4339, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3430, + "time_to_request_ms": 1954, + "num_turns": 14, + "result": "セクション内容を確認しました。回答を生成します。\n\n**回答生成（Step 5）**\n\n**結論**: `SimpleDbTransactionManager` と `SimpleDbTransactionExecutor`（JDBCラッパー使用時）または `UniversalDao.Transaction`（UniversalDAO使用時）を使うことで、業務トランザクションとは独立した別トランザクションでSQLを実行できる。業務トランザクションがロールバックされても、別トランザクションでコミットした更新は保持される。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**方法1: JDBCラッパー (`SimpleDbTransactionExecutor`) を使う場合**\n\nコンポーネント設定ファイルに `SimpleDbTransactionManager` を定義する。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n \n\n```\n\n実装例：\n\n```java\nSimpleDbTransactionManager dbTransactionManager =\n SystemRepository.get(\"update-login-failed-count-transaction\");\n\nSqlResultSet resultSet = new SimpleDbTransactionExecutor(dbTransactionManager) {\n @Override\n public SqlResultSet execute(AppDbConnection connection) {\n SqlPStatement statement = connection.prepareStatementBySqlId(\n \"jp.co.tis.sample.action.SampleAction#findUser\");\n statement.setLong(1, userId);\n return statement.retrieve();\n }\n}.doTransaction();\n```\n\n**方法2: UniversalDAO (`UniversalDao.Transaction`) を使う場合**\n\nコンポーネント設定ファイルに同様に `SimpleDbTransactionManager` を定義する。\n\n実装例：`UniversalDao.Transaction` を継承したクラスを作成し、`execute()` メソッドにUniversalDAOを使った処理を実装する。\n\n```java\nprivate static final class FindPersonsTransaction extends UniversalDao.Transaction {\n private EntityList persons;\n\n FindPersonsTransaction() {\n super(\"find-persons-transaction\"); // コンポーネント定義の名前を指定\n }\n\n @Override\n protected void execute() {\n persons = UniversalDao.findAllBySqlFile(Person.class, \"FIND_PERSONS\");\n }\n\n public EntityList getPersons() {\n return persons;\n }\n}\n\n// 呼び出し\nFindPersonsTransaction findPersonsTransaction = new FindPersonsTransaction();\nEntityList persons = findPersonsTransaction.getPersons();\n```\n\n**注意点**: `SimpleDbTransactionManager` には、`connectionFactory`（接続設定）と `transactionFactory`（トランザクション制御）の両方を設定する必要がある。各プロパティの詳細は `libraries-database.json` の接続設定セクションおよび `libraries-transaction.json` のトランザクション制御セクションを参照。\n\n**verify確認（Step 6）**: 全てのNablarch固有の主張（`SimpleDbTransactionManager`、`SimpleDbTransactionExecutor`、`UniversalDao.Transaction`、業務トランザクションがロールバックされても別トランザクション更新が保持される点）はいずれもs29・s20のセクション内容に明示的に記載されており、PASS。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n業務トランザクションとは別のトランザクションでSQLを実行するには、`SimpleDbTransactionManager` と `SimpleDbTransactionExecutor`（JDBCラッパー使用時）または `UniversalDao.Transaction`（UniversalDAO使用時）を使います。業務トランザクションがロールバックされても、別トランザクションでコミットした更新は保持されます。\n\n---\n\n**方法1: JDBCラッパー (`SimpleDbTransactionExecutor`) を使う場合**\n\nコンポーネント設定ファイルに `SimpleDbTransactionManager` を定義します。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\n実装例：\n\n```java\n// システムリポジトリからSimpleDbTransactionManagerを取得する\nSimpleDbTransactionManager dbTransactionManager =\n SystemRepository.get(\"update-login-failed-count-transaction\");\n\n// SimpleDbTransactionManagerをコンストラクタに指定して実行する\nSqlResultSet resultSet = new SimpleDbTransactionExecutor(dbTransactionManager) {\n @Override\n public SqlResultSet execute(AppDbConnection connection) {\n SqlPStatement statement = connection.prepareStatementBySqlId(\n \"jp.co.tis.sample.action.SampleAction#findUser\");\n statement.setLong(1, userId);\n return statement.retrieve();\n }\n}.doTransaction();\n```\n\n---\n\n**方法2: UniversalDAO (`UniversalDao.Transaction`) を使う場合**\n\nコンポーネント設定ファイルに同様に `SimpleDbTransactionManager` を定義し、`UniversalDao.Transaction` を継承したクラスを作成します。\n\n```java\nprivate static final class FindPersonsTransaction extends UniversalDao.Transaction {\n private EntityList persons;\n\n FindPersonsTransaction() {\n // SimpleDbTransactionManagerのコンポーネント定義名を指定する\n super(\"find-persons-transaction\");\n }\n\n // このメソッドが自動的に別のトランザクションで実行される\n @Override\n protected void execute() {\n persons = UniversalDao.findAllBySqlFile(Person.class, \"FIND_PERSONS\");\n }\n\n public EntityList getPersons() {\n return persons;\n }\n}\n\n// 呼び出し\nFindPersonsTransaction findPersonsTransaction = new FindPersonsTransaction();\nEntityList persons = findPersonsTransaction.getPersons();\n```\n\n---\n\n**注意点**: `SimpleDbTransactionManager` には `connectionFactory`（DB接続設定）と `transactionFactory`（トランザクション制御）の両方を設定する必要があります。各プロパティの詳細は、データベース接続設定（`libraries-database.json`）およびトランザクション制御（`libraries-transaction.json`）を参照してください。\n\n参照: `libraries-database.json:s29`, `libraries-universal-dao.json:s20`, `libraries-transaction.json:s5`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"transaction\", \"database\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s29\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-handler-LoopHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-handler-LoopHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-repository.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-db-transaction-JdbcTransactionFactory.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-db-connection-DbConnectionContext.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s28\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-repository.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-transaction-TransactionFactory.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-message-reply-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-db-connection-DbConnectionContext.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-transaction-management-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s29\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "793edcf7-8829-4ad7-87c0-d40a3aead9b9", + "total_cost_usd": 0.42773240000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 38568, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 619128, + "output_tokens": 6339, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 38568 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2054, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002234, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 6339, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 619128, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 38568, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.4254984000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_018f1pPcc4qZRdSfDF1dzjF6", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for BM25 term extraction" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01RjFgazU8MW4swKmsp8TFNw", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "5c164b58-1810-4f20-ae0e-462228c8481d" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..054cab556 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-01/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,137 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "transaction", + "database" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s20", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s29", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-handler-LoopHandler.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-handler-LoopHandler.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-repository.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-db-transaction-JdbcTransactionFactory.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-db-connection-DbConnectionContext.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s28", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-repository.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-transaction-TransactionFactory.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-message-reply-handler.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-db-connection-DbConnectionContext.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-transaction-management-handler.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s29" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s20" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-transaction.json", + "section_id": "s5" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d7828279a --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +**Bean Validationのカスタムバリデータ内でDBを検索する実装は、Nablarchでは推奨されていません。** + +Nablarchの設計指針では、**DBを使った重複チェックなどの相関バリデーションは、業務アクション（リソースクラスのアクションメソッド）側で実装する**ことが求められています。 + +#### 理由 + +Bean Validation実行中は、オブジェクトの値が安全であることが保証されません。バリデーション前の未検証の値を使ってDBアクセスを行うと、**SQLインジェクション等の脆弱性の原因**となります。 + +バリデーションが完了した後、業務アクション側でバリデーション済みの安全な値を使ってDBアクセスすることで、この問題を回避できます。 + +#### RESTfulウェブサービスでの実装方針 + +1. **Bean Validationの対象**: 入力値の形式・型・必須チェックなど、DBアクセス不要なバリデーションを `@Valid` アノテーションとBean Validationで実施 +2. **DB重複チェック**: リソースクラスのアクションメソッド内で、Bean Validationが通過した後に実施 + +#### エラーメッセージの項目紐付け + +業務アクション側でDB重複チェックをしてエラーが発生した場合、特定のフィールドにエラーを紐づけたい場合は `ValidationUtil#createMessageForProperty` を使用できます。 + +```java +throw new ApplicationException( + ValidationUtil.createMessageForProperty("form.mailAddress", "duplicate.mailAddress")); +``` + +#### まとめ + +| やること | 方法 | +|----------|------| +| 形式・必須チェック | Bean Validationのアノテーション（`@NotNull`等） | +| DB重複チェック | 業務アクションのメソッド内でDB検索 | +| エラーメッセージの項目紐付け | `ValidationUtil#createMessageForProperty` | + +参照: `component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json#データベースとの相関バリデーションを行う` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bd7dfc643 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "impact-03", + "description": "REST APIで登録処理を実装している。入力されたメールアドレスがDB上で重複していないか、バリデーションの段階でチェックしたい。", + "input": "Bean Validationの中でDBに問い合わせて重複チェックしたい。カスタムバリデータでDB検索する実装でいいのか？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "データベースとの相関バリデーションはBean Validationではなく業務アクション側で実装する。Bean Validation実行中のオブジェクトの値は安全である保証がない" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output fully covers both key facts from the Expected Output: (1) database correlation validation should be implemented on the business action side rather than in Bean Validation, and (2) values during Bean Validation execution are not guaranteed to be safe. The Actual Output not only covers these facts but expands on them with additional implementation details, which does not detract from coverage of the expected facts." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is completely relevant, directly addressing the question about implementing duplicate checks via DB queries within Bean Validation using a custom validator. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 104781, + "duration_api_ms": 112519, + "num_turns": 29, + "total_cost_usd": 0.6244576, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 30, + "output_tokens": 5036, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1372927, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 35926 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 30, + "outputTokens": 5036, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1372927, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 35926, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6222306, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2022, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002227, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b357cc427 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 104781, + "duration_api_ms": 112519, + "num_turns": 29, + "total_cost_usd": 0.6244576, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 30, + "output_tokens": 5036, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1372927, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 35926 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 30, + "outputTokens": 5036, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1372927, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 35926, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6222306, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2022, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002227, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fd2d09de5 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,82 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 104781, + "duration_api_ms": 112519, + "ttft_ms": 5238, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3509, + "time_to_request_ms": 1977, + "num_turns": 29, + "result": "十分な情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n**check-answerable判定**: s12に「Bean Validationでのカスタムバリデータ経由のDB検索はSQLインジェクション脆弱性の原因となるため避けるべき」という明確なNablarch設計指針が含まれており、OKと判定します。\n\n### Answer\n\n**Bean Validationのカスタムバリデータ内でDBを検索する実装は、Nablarchでは推奨されていません。**\n\nNablarchの設計指針では、**DBを使った重複チェックなどの相関バリデーションは、業務アクション（リソースクラスのアクションメソッド）側で実装する**ことが求められています。\n\n#### 理由\n\nBean Validation実行中は、オブジェクトの値が安全であることが保証されません。バリデーション前の未検証の値を使ってDBアクセスを行うと、**SQLインジェクション等の脆弱性の原因**となります。\n\nバリデーションが完了した後、業務アクション側でバリデーション済みの安全な値を使ってDBアクセスすることで、この問題を回避できます。\n\n#### RESTfulウェブサービスでの実装方針\n\n1. **Bean Validationの対象**: 入力値の形式・型・必須チェックなど、DBアクセス不要なバリデーションを `@Valid` アノテーションとBean Validationで実施\n2. **DB重複チェック**: リソースクラスのアクションメソッド内で、Bean Validationが通過した後に実施\n\n#### エラーメッセージの項目紐付け\n\n業務アクション側でDB重複チェックをしてエラーが発生した場合、特定のフィールドにエラーを紐づけたい場合は `ValidationUtil#createMessageForProperty` を使用できます。\n\n```java\nthrow new ApplicationException(\n ValidationUtil.createMessageForProperty(\"form.mailAddress\", \"duplicate.mailAddress\"));\n```\n\n#### まとめ\n\n| やること | 方法 |\n|----------|------|\n| 形式・必須チェック | Bean Validationのアノテーション（`@NotNull`等） |\n| DB重複チェック | 業務アクションのメソッド内でDB検索 |\n| エラーメッセージの項目紐付け | `ValidationUtil#createMessageForProperty` |\n\n参照: `component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json#データベースとの相関バリデーションを行う`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"bean-validation\", \"db-double-submit\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "7d2d0a96-6729-4ac1-aa16-c78bfe71ec7d", + "total_cost_usd": 0.6244576, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 30, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 35926, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1372927, + "output_tokens": 5036, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 35926 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 30, + "outputTokens": 5036, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1372927, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 35926, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6222306, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2022, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002227, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01SuEHsSqLrDH3REvromnA3F", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cd /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search && bash scripts/bm25-search.sh bean-validation db-double-submit 2>&1" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01QRkKtq9rRvFmrCguBormtq", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash scripts/read-sections.sh \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json:s1\" 2>&1 | head -5\n# まずセクション一覧を確認\npython3 -c \"\nimport json\nwith open('component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json') as f:\n data = json.load(f)\nfor s in data.get('sections', []):\n print(s['id'], s.get('title',''))\n\"" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01Earo9dffoGSovesBndH3to", + "tool_input": { + "command": "python3 -c \"\nimport json\nwith open('component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json') as f:\n data = json.load(f)\nfor s in data.get('sections', []):\n print(s['id'], s.get('title',''))\n\"" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "77977ea0-aa5b-4217-afd6-8a08dac3270e" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..200bdfc6e --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-03/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,91 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "bean-validation", + "db-double-submit" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s20", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s12" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s20" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a0a0f3e2d --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,73 @@ +## APサーバスケールアウト時のセッションストア選択 + +**結論**: APサーバを複数台にスケールアウトする場合は **DBストア** または **HIDDENストア** を選択する。HTTPセッションストアはAPサーバごとにセッションデータを保持する仕組みのため、スケールアウト時に別途工夫が必要になる。 + +--- + +### 各ストアの特長 + +**DBストア**（保存先: データベース上のテーブル） + +| 特長 | 内容 | +|---|---| +| スケールアウト適性 | ◎ | +| APサーバ停止時 | ローリングメンテナンス等でAPサーバが停止した場合でもセッション変数の復元が可能 | +| ヒープ領域 | APサーバのヒープ領域を圧迫しない | +| 複数スレッド | 後勝ち（先に保存されたセッションのデータは消失する） | + +--- + +**HIDDENストア**（保存先: クライアントサイドの `hidden` タグ） + +| 特長 | 内容 | +|---|---| +| スケールアウト適性 | ○（ただし冗長化時は暗号化キーの設定が必要）| +| 複数タブ | 複数タブでの画面操作を許容できる | +| ヒープ領域 | APサーバのヒープ領域を圧迫しない | +| 複数スレッド | セッションのデータはそれぞれのスレッドに紐付けて保存される | + +--- + +**HTTPセッションストア**（保存先: APサーバのヒープ領域） + +| 特長 | 内容 | +|---|---| +| スケールアウト適性 | △（APサーバごとに情報を保持するため、スケールアウトを行う際に工夫が必要） | +| 向いている用途 | 認証情報のようなアプリケーション全体で頻繁に使用する情報の保持 | +| ヒープ領域 | 大量データを保存するとヒープ領域を圧迫する恐れがある | +| 複数スレッド | 後勝ち（先に保存されたセッションのデータは消失する） | + +--- + +### 選択基準 + +| 用途 | 推奨ストア | +|---|---| +| 入力～確認～完了画面間で入力情報を保持（複数タブ不可） | DBストア | +| 入力～確認～完了画面間で入力情報を保持（複数タブ可） | HIDDENストア | +| 認証情報の保持 | DBストア または HTTPセッションストア | + +--- + +### 注意点 + +- **HIDDENストアを冗長化環境で使用する場合**: デフォルトでは暗号化キーはAPサーバごとに自動生成されるため、サーバをまたいだリクエストで復号に失敗するケースがある。`AesEncryptor` を使用して明示的に暗号化/復号のキーを設定すること。 + + ```xml + + + + + + + + + + + + + ``` + +- **Redisを使用する場合**: Redisストア(Lettuce)アダプタを使用することでRedisを保存先にできる。特徴はDBストアと同じ。 + +参照: libraries-session-store.json:s2, libraries-session-store.json:s16, libraries-session-store.json:s12 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..046191e0f --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "impact-06", + "description": "本番環境でAPサーバを複数台並べて負荷分散する予定。セッション変数をサーバ間で共有する必要がある。", + "input": "APサーバを複数台にスケールアウトするとき、セッション変数の保存先はどれを選ぶべき？各ストアの特徴を知りたい", + "purpose": "仕組み・動作を理解したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "DBストアはデータベース上のテーブルに保存し、APサーバ停止時もセッション変数の復元が可能", + "HIDDENストアはクライアントサイドにhiddenタグで引き回して実現する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output covers both facts from the Expected Output checklist. It explicitly mentions that DBストア saves data to database tables ('データベース上のテーブル') and that sessions can be restored even when AP servers stop ('APサーバが停止した場合でもセッション変数の復元が可能'). It also explicitly states that HIDDENストア saves to client-side hidden tags ('クライアントサイドの `hidden` タグ'). Both required facts from the Expected Output are fully covered." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is completely relevant, directly addressing the question about session variable storage options when scaling out AP servers horizontally, and covering the characteristics of each store. Great job!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 106271, + "duration_api_ms": 121299, + "num_turns": 13, + "total_cost_usd": 0.40886155, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 14, + "output_tokens": 7045, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 567711, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 34803 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 14, + "outputTokens": 7045, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 567711, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 34803, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.40654155000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2150, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00232, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e1266b878 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 106271, + "duration_api_ms": 121299, + "num_turns": 13, + "total_cost_usd": 0.40886155, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 14, + "output_tokens": 7045, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 567711, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 34803 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 14, + "outputTokens": 7045, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 567711, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 34803, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.40654155000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2150, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00232, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..685b4ff53 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 106271, + "duration_api_ms": 121299, + "ttft_ms": 5105, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3502, + "time_to_request_ms": 2094, + "num_turns": 13, + "result": "これで回答を生成し、verify します。セクション内容はすでに取得済みなので、そのまま回答を生成します。\n\n---\n\n**回答（Step 5 生成）：**\n\n**結論**: APサーバをスケールアウトする場合は **DBストア** または **HIDDENストア** を使用する。HTTPセッションストアはAPサーバごとにデータを保持するためスケールアウト時に工夫が必要となり、原則として避けるべき。\n\n---\n\n**Verify（Step 6）**:\n\n主なNablarch固有クレームを確認：\n- 「DBストアはAPサーバ停止でも復元可能」→ s16に「ローリングメンテナンス等でアプリケーションサーバが停止した場合でもセッション変数の復元が可能」→ supported\n- 「HTTPセッションストアはスケールアウト時に工夫が必要」→ s16に「APサーバ毎に情報を保持するため、スケールアウトを行う際に工夫が必要となる」→ supported\n- 「HIDDENストアの暗号化キーはAPサーバごとに自動生成され復号失敗のケースあり」→ s12に明記 → supported\n- 選択基準テーブル全項目 → s16に明記 → supported\n\nMissing content確認: 主要な特徴・選択基準はすべて回答に含まれている。\n\n**Verify result: PASS**\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n## APサーバスケールアウト時のセッションストア選択\n\n**結論**: APサーバを複数台にスケールアウトする場合は **DBストア** または **HIDDENストア** を選択する。HTTPセッションストアはAPサーバごとにセッションデータを保持する仕組みのため、スケールアウト時に別途工夫が必要になる。\n\n---\n\n### 各ストアの特長\n\n**DBストア**（保存先: データベース上のテーブル）\n\n| 特長 | 内容 |\n|---|---|\n| スケールアウト適性 | ◎ |\n| APサーバ停止時 | ローリングメンテナンス等でAPサーバが停止した場合でもセッション変数の復元が可能 |\n| ヒープ領域 | APサーバのヒープ領域を圧迫しない |\n| 複数スレッド | 後勝ち（先に保存されたセッションのデータは消失する） |\n\n---\n\n**HIDDENストア**（保存先: クライアントサイドの `hidden` タグ）\n\n| 特長 | 内容 |\n|---|---|\n| スケールアウト適性 | ○（ただし冗長化時は暗号化キーの設定が必要）|\n| 複数タブ | 複数タブでの画面操作を許容できる |\n| ヒープ領域 | APサーバのヒープ領域を圧迫しない |\n| 複数スレッド | セッションのデータはそれぞれのスレッドに紐付けて保存される |\n\n---\n\n**HTTPセッションストア**（保存先: APサーバのヒープ領域）\n\n| 特長 | 内容 |\n|---|---|\n| スケールアウト適性 | △（APサーバごとに情報を保持するため、スケールアウトを行う際に工夫が必要） |\n| 向いている用途 | 認証情報のようなアプリケーション全体で頻繁に使用する情報の保持 |\n| ヒープ領域 | 大量データを保存するとヒープ領域を圧迫する恐れがある |\n| 複数スレッド | 後勝ち（先に保存されたセッションのデータは消失する） |\n\n---\n\n### 選択基準\n\n| 用途 | 推奨ストア |\n|---|---|\n| 入力～確認～完了画面間で入力情報を保持（複数タブ不可） | DBストア |\n| 入力～確認～完了画面間で入力情報を保持（複数タブ可） | HIDDENストア |\n| 認証情報の保持 | DBストア または HTTPセッションストア |\n\n---\n\n### 注意点\n\n- **HIDDENストアを冗長化環境で使用する場合**: デフォルトでは暗号化キーはAPサーバごとに自動生成されるため、サーバをまたいだリクエストで復号に失敗するケースがある。`AesEncryptor` を使用して明示的に暗号化/復号のキーを設定すること。\n\n ```xml\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n ```\n\n- **Redisを使用する場合**: Redisストア(Lettuce)アダプタを使用することでRedisを保存先にできる。特徴はDBストアと同じ。\n\n参照: libraries-session-store.json:s2, libraries-session-store.json:s16, libraries-session-store.json:s12\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"session-store\", \"SessionStoreHandler\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-http-access-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-jaxrs-access-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-forwarding-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-session-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-session-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s15\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-handler-SessionConcurrentAccessHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-stateless-web-app.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-handler-SessionConcurrentAccessHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "5ef25cc1-91f8-4a31-abfa-9e72a4a19450", + "total_cost_usd": 0.40886155, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 14, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 34803, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 567711, + "output_tokens": 7045, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 34803 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 14, + "outputTokens": 7045, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 567711, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 34803, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.40654155000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2150, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00232, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_017S1zPFWHZwK5nVvRhfoX1Y", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01JiNaTBeL88SdaS4z2MbhBM", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null", + "description": "Find fts-hints.md" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "6c35de0d-a577-4b74-8133-73c314cfd4c5" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2f7bcf9fb --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-06/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,137 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "session-store", + "SessionStoreHandler" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s1", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-http-access-log.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-jaxrs-access-log.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-forwarding-handler.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-session-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-session-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s15", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-handler-SessionConcurrentAccessHandler.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-stateless-web-app.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-handler-SessionConcurrentAccessHandler.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s16" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s12" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3d8cd4e56 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +**結論**: テスト時にシステム日時を任意の値に切り替えるには、`SystemTimeProvider` インターフェースを実装したクラスを作成し、テスト用のコンポーネント定義でそのクラスを差し替えます。本番とテストの切り替えは「コンポーネント定義で指定するクラスを差し替えるだけ」で実現できます。 + +**根拠**: + +Nablarch の日付管理機能は、コンポーネント定義で指定されたクラスを通じてシステム日時・業務日付を取得する仕組みになっています。そのため、コンポーネント定義を差し替えるだけで本番とテストの動作を切り替えられます。 + +**システム日時の切り替え手順** + +1. `SystemTimeProvider` インターフェースを実装したクラスを作成する（例: テスト用に固定日時を返すクラス） +2. テスト用のコンポーネント定義で `systemTimeProvider` という名前でそのクラスを登録する + +本番環境では、デフォルト実装の `BasicSystemTimeProvider` を使用します: + +```xml + + +``` + +テスト時は、このコンポーネント定義を差し替え用のクラス（任意日時を返す独自実装）に変更することで切り替えます。 + +**業務日付を切り替えたい場合** + +同様に `BusinessDateProvider` インターフェースを実装したクラスを作成し、`businessDateProvider` という名前でコンポーネント定義に登録します: + +```xml + + + + + + + + +``` + +テスト時はコンポーネント定義を差し替えることで任意の日付を返せます。 + +**注意点**: +- `BusinessDateProvider` を使う場合、`BasicApplicationInitializer` の `initializeList` への登録も必要です +- 業務日付はデータベースで管理されるため、依存モジュール `nablarch-common-jdbc` が必要です + +参照: libraries-date.json:s2, libraries-date.json:s5, libraries-date.json:s7, libraries-date.json:s12, libraries-date.json:s13 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1baafd175 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "impact-08", + "description": "テスト時にシステム日時を固定して日付依存のロジックを検証したい。本番ではOS日時を使うが、テスト時だけ差し替えたい。", + "input": "テスト時だけシステム日時を任意の日付に差し替える方法はあるか？本番とテストで切り替えたい", + "purpose": "仕組み・動作を理解したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "コンポーネント定義で指定するクラスを差し替えることでシステム日時の取得方法を切り替えられる" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output explicitly states that switching the system time in tests can be achieved by replacing the class specified in the component definition ('コンポーネント定義で指定するクラスを差し替えるだけ'), which directly covers the single expected fact in the Expected Output. The key claim is clearly present and even elaborated upon with concrete examples." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 0.8125, + "reason": "The score is 0.81 because the actual output generally addresses the question about switching system date/time for testing versus production, but it loses points for including irrelevant details such as specific configuration properties for BasicBusinessDateProvider, registration details in BasicApplicationInitializer, and dependency information for nablarch-common-jdbc. These implementation-specific details go beyond what was asked and dilute the relevance of the response." + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 75522, + "duration_api_ms": 73878, + "num_turns": 15, + "total_cost_usd": 0.38395945, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 4292, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 655139, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 32237 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1926, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002101, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 4292, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 655139, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 32237, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.38185844999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dafdd581a --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 75522, + "duration_api_ms": 73878, + "num_turns": 15, + "total_cost_usd": 0.38395945, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 4292, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 655139, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 32237 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1926, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002101, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 4292, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 655139, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 32237, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.38185844999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e9e0d5b5e --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 75522, + "duration_api_ms": 73878, + "ttft_ms": 4593, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3602, + "time_to_request_ms": 1904, + "num_turns": 15, + "result": "必要なセクション情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: テスト時にシステム日時を任意の値に切り替えるには、`SystemTimeProvider` インターフェースを実装したクラスを作成し、テスト用のコンポーネント定義でそのクラスを差し替えます。本番とテストの切り替えは「コンポーネント定義で指定するクラスを差し替えるだけ」で実現できます。\n\n**根拠**:\n\nNablarch の日付管理機能は、コンポーネント定義で指定されたクラスを通じてシステム日時・業務日付を取得する仕組みになっています。そのため、コンポーネント定義を差し替えるだけで本番とテストの動作を切り替えられます。\n\n**システム日時の切り替え手順**\n\n1. `SystemTimeProvider` インターフェースを実装したクラスを作成する（例: テスト用に固定日時を返すクラス）\n2. テスト用のコンポーネント定義で `systemTimeProvider` という名前でそのクラスを登録する\n\n本番環境では、デフォルト実装の `BasicSystemTimeProvider` を使用します:\n\n```xml\n\n\n```\n\nテスト時は、このコンポーネント定義を差し替え用のクラス（任意日時を返す独自実装）に変更することで切り替えます。\n\n**業務日付を切り替えたい場合**\n\n同様に `BusinessDateProvider` インターフェースを実装したクラスを作成し、`businessDateProvider` という名前でコンポーネント定義に登録します:\n\n```xml\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\nテスト時はコンポーネント定義を差し替えることで任意の日付を返せます。\n\n**注意点**:\n- `BusinessDateProvider` を使う場合、`BasicApplicationInitializer` の `initializeList` への登録も必要です\n- 業務日付はデータベースで管理されるため、依存モジュール `nablarch-common-jdbc` が必要です\n\n参照: libraries-date.json:s2, libraries-date.json:s5, libraries-date.json:s7, libraries-date.json:s12, libraries-date.json:s13\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"date\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-SystemTimeProvider.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BusinessDateProvider.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BasicBusinessDateProvider.json\", \"section_id\": \"s30\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-log-basic-LogContext.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-util-DateUtil.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "769cb690-3ea3-48e3-be9c-9cfc80a8ca8d", + "total_cost_usd": 0.38395945, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 32237, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 655139, + "output_tokens": 4292, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 32237 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1926, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002101, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 4292, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 655139, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 32237, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.38185844999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01Vdmg7YuPuWahs4ScFJkdf7", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md 2>/dev/null | head -100", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for page titles" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01SFjpxp4kzmziHiCwTTsYVy", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null", + "description": "Find fts-hints.md file location" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "d49dcd07-d66b-492b-8393-9464c8e2c675" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fba5dbc36 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/impact-08/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,89 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "date" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-SystemTimeProvider.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BusinessDateProvider.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BasicBusinessDateProvider.json", + "section_id": "s30", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-log-basic-LogContext.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-util-DateUtil.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s5" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s12" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s13" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6b30a4d68 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +**結論**: NablarchはOAuth2やOpenID Connectを含む認証機能をフレームワークとして組み込んでいません。認証はプロジェクト要件によって仕様が異なるため、プロジェクト側で実装する必要があります。 + +**根拠**: +Nablarchのウェブアプリケーション機能詳細には以下の通り明示されています。 + +> 認証については、プロジェクト要件により仕様が異なるため、フレームワークとしては提供していない。プロジェクト要件に合わせてPJで実装する。 + +つまり、OAuth2 / OpenID ConnectによるIDプロバイダー連携の処理（認可コードフローの実装、トークン検証、ユーザー情報取得など）はすべてプロジェクトで実装します。 + +認証後の**セッション管理**（認証情報の保持）については、Nablarchが提供するセッションストアを利用できます。 + +```xml + + + + + + + + + +``` + +なお、認証とは別に**認可（権限チェック）**については、Nablarchが `PermissionCheckHandler` による認可チェック機能を提供しています。OAuth2で認証されたユーザーの権限管理にこの仕組みを活用することは可能です。 + +**注意点**: +- OAuth2/OpenID Connectの実装（Spring Security OAuth2等のライブラリ活用を含む）はプロジェクト責任で行うため、Nablarchとの統合方法（セッションへの認証情報格納タイミング、ハンドラキューへの組み込み方）はプロジェクトで設計する必要があります。 +- セッションストアにOAuth2のトークン情報を保持する場合、DBストアを使用すると期限切れセッションが残留するため、定期削除の仕組みが別途必要です。 + +参照: +- `web-application-feature-details.json:s13`（認証） +- `web-application-feature-details.json:s14`（認可チェック） +- `libraries-session-store.json:s2`、`s8`（セッションストア） +- `handlers-permission-check-handler.json:s4`（認可チェックハンドラ） \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1db8fceb3 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "oos-impact-01", + "description": "既存システムをNablarch 6に移行するにあたり、OAuth2/OpenID Connect認証が必要かどうか影響調査している。NablarchにOAuth2/OIDCの仕組みが組み込まれているか確認したい。", + "input": "NablarchでOAuth2やOpenID Connectによる認証を実装したい。Nablarchにその仕組みは組み込まれているか？", + "purpose": "セキュリティ対応したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "NablarchにはOAuth2/OpenID Connect認証の組み込み機能がないと回答している" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output clearly states that Nablarch does not include OAuth2 or OpenID Connect authentication as a built-in framework feature ('NablarchはOAuth2やOpenID Connectを含む認証機能をフレームワークとして組み込んでいません'), which directly covers the Expected Output's single fact that Nablarch has no built-in OAuth2/OpenID Connect authentication functionality." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant to the question about implementing OAuth2 and OpenID Connect authentication in Nablarch, with no irrelevant statements detected. Great job staying focused and on-topic!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 122208, + "duration_api_ms": 120433, + "num_turns": 20, + "total_cost_usd": 0.5019105500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 21, + "output_tokens": 6391, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 894711, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 36003 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2038, + "outputTokens": 104, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002558, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 21, + "outputTokens": 6391, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 894711, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 36003, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.49935255000000006, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..84a473b54 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 122208, + "duration_api_ms": 120433, + "num_turns": 20, + "total_cost_usd": 0.5019105500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 21, + "output_tokens": 6391, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 894711, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 36003 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2038, + "outputTokens": 104, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002558, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 21, + "outputTokens": 6391, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 894711, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 36003, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.49935255000000006, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e91ac150c --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 122208, + "duration_api_ms": 120433, + "ttft_ms": 4203, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3374, + "time_to_request_ms": 1919, + "num_turns": 20, + "result": "Now I have all necessary information to generate and verify the answer.\n\n**Answer generation (Step 5):**\n\nBased on `web-application-feature-details.json:s13`, Nablarch explicitly states that **authentication is not provided as a framework feature** because specifications differ by project requirements. OAuth2/OpenID Connect authentication must be implemented by the project itself.\n\n**Verify (Step 6):**\n- Claim: \"Nablarchはフレームワークとして認証機能を提供していない\" → directly supported by `web-application-feature-details.json:s13`\n- Claim: \"認証情報の保持はセッションストアを使用できる\" → supported by `web-application-feature-details.json:s13` (links to session-store)\n- No unsupported claims. No missing required content.\n- Result: **PASS**\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: NablarchはOAuth2やOpenID Connectを含む認証機能をフレームワークとして組み込んでいません。認証はプロジェクト要件によって仕様が異なるため、プロジェクト側で実装する必要があります。\n\n**根拠**:\nNablarchのウェブアプリケーション機能詳細には以下の通り明示されています。\n\n> 認証については、プロジェクト要件により仕様が異なるため、フレームワークとしては提供していない。プロジェクト要件に合わせてPJで実装する。\n\nつまり、OAuth2 / OpenID ConnectによるIDプロバイダー連携の処理（認可コードフローの実装、トークン検証、ユーザー情報取得など）はすべてプロジェクトで実装します。\n\n認証後の**セッション管理**（認証情報の保持）については、Nablarchが提供するセッションストアを利用できます。\n\n```xml\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\nなお、認証とは別に**認可（権限チェック）**については、Nablarchが `PermissionCheckHandler` による認可チェック機能を提供しています。OAuth2で認証されたユーザーの権限管理にこの仕組みを活用することは可能です。\n\n**注意点**:\n- OAuth2/OpenID Connectの実装（Spring Security OAuth2等のライブラリ活用を含む）はプロジェクト責任で行うため、Nablarchとの統合方法（セッションへの認証情報格納タイミング、ハンドラキューへの組み込み方）はプロジェクトで設計する必要があります。\n- セッションストアにOAuth2のトークン情報を保持する場合、DBストアを使用すると期限切れセッションが残留するため、定期削除の仕組みが別途必要です。\n\n参照:\n- `web-application-feature-details.json:s13`（認証）\n- `web-application-feature-details.json:s14`（認可チェック）\n- `libraries-session-store.json:s2`、`s8`（セッションストア）\n- `handlers-permission-check-handler.json:s4`（認可チェックハンドラ）\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"authorization-permission-check\", \"OAuth2\", \"OpenID\", \"session-store\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-permission-check-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-permission-PermissionUtil.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-permission-PermissionFactory.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-permission-check-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "69985608-d07d-4eb5-a418-079b133efc66", + "total_cost_usd": 0.5019105500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 21, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 36003, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 894711, + "output_tokens": 6391, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 36003 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2038, + "outputTokens": 104, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002558, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 21, + "outputTokens": 6391, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 894711, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 36003, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.49935255000000006, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01FYDTHZ8xN9aF4SMMsMJzHj", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md 2>/dev/null | head -100", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for BM25 term lookup" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01PmLSbrskUCF2pSfLnKKSwV", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "912240ef-ed15-49cc-9c2c-4db37edc6c4f" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d25f1ed81 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-impact-01/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,147 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "authorization-permission-check", + "OAuth2", + "OpenID", + "session-store" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-permission-check-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-role-check.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-permission-PermissionUtil.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-permission-PermissionFactory.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-SessionStoreHandler.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s13" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s14" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s8" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-permission-check-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5e8ea63e0 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +この情報は知識ファイルに含まれていません。 + +--- + +**補足（知識ファイル外の情報として）:** + +Nablarch 6はJakarta EE 10ベースであり、Jakarta WebSocket（旧Java API for WebSocket）はJakarta EEの標準仕様として含まれています。しかし、**NablarchフレームワークはWebSocketに関するラッパーや専用サポートを提供していません**（Nablarchはアプリケーションサーバ提供のServlet APIを前提としており、WebSocket固有のコンポーネントはドキュメント化されていません）。 + +バッチ進捗をリアルタイム通知する代替アプローチとして、知識ファイルの範囲内では以下が確認できます： + +- **MOMメッセージングやDBキューを使った非同期処理**（進捗をDBに記録し、ポーリングで取得する構成） +- **Nablarchでの非同期処理**パターンはメール送信（常駐バッチ経由）のみが文書化されています + +WebSocketを使う場合は、Jakarta WebSocket APIをサーブレットコンテナ（Tomcatなど）の機能として直接利用することになりますが、その実装方法はNablarchの知識ファイルの対象範囲外です。 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f428cb129 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "oos-qa-01", + "description": "バッチ処理の進捗をリアルタイムにクライアントへ通知する機能を実装したい。WebSocketを使いたいが、NablarchでWebSocketが使えるか確認したい。", + "input": "バッチ処理の進捗状況をWebSocketでリアルタイムにブラウザへ通知したい。NablarchでWebSocketを使う方法はあるか？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "NablarchにはWebSocketのサポートがないと回答している" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output clearly states that Nablarch does not provide WebSocket-specific support ('NablarchフレームワークはWebSocketに関するラッパーや専用サポートを提供していません'), which directly aligns with the Expected Output's requirement of stating that Nablarch has no WebSocket support. The key fact is covered explicitly." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 0.9090909090909091, + "reason": "The score is 0.91 because the response is largely relevant to the question about using WebSocket for real-time batch progress notifications in Nablarch. However, it loses some points for including information about email sending via resident batch, which is not relevant to WebSocket or real-time progress notification functionality." + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 153583, + "duration_api_ms": 149240, + "num_turns": 17, + "total_cost_usd": 0.79733135, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 18, + "output_tokens": 7251, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1125012, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 92997 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2070, + "outputTokens": 40, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00227, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 18, + "outputTokens": 7251, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1125012, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 92997, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.79506135, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..fb1765c9b --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 153583, + "duration_api_ms": 149240, + "num_turns": 17, + "total_cost_usd": 0.79733135, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 18, + "output_tokens": 7251, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1125012, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 92997 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2070, + "outputTokens": 40, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00227, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 18, + "outputTokens": 7251, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1125012, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 92997, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.79506135, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..afcc666c0 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 153583, + "duration_api_ms": 149240, + "ttft_ms": 4592, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3847, + "time_to_request_ms": 1901, + "num_turns": 17, + "result": "セマンティック検索を実行しました。知識ファイルのindex.mdとclasses.mdを全て確認しましたが、WebSocket実装に関するページは存在しません。`sem_sections` = [] です。\n\nワークフロー Step 4 の条件: `sem_sections` が空 → `この情報は知識ファイルに含まれていません。` を出力して終了。\n\n### Answer\n\nこの情報は知識ファイルに含まれていません。\n\n---\n\n**補足（知識ファイル外の情報として）:**\n\nNablarch 6はJakarta EE 10ベースであり、Jakarta WebSocket（旧Java API for WebSocket）はJakarta EEの標準仕様として含まれています。しかし、**NablarchフレームワークはWebSocketに関するラッパーや専用サポートを提供していません**（Nablarchはアプリケーションサーバ提供のServlet APIを前提としており、WebSocket固有のコンポーネントはドキュメント化されていません）。\n\nバッチ進捗をリアルタイム通知する代替アプローチとして、知識ファイルの範囲内では以下が確認できます：\n\n- **MOMメッセージングやDBキューを使った非同期処理**（進捗をDBに記録し、ポーリングで取得する構成）\n- **Nablarchでの非同期処理**パターンはメール送信（常駐バッチ経由）のみが文書化されています\n\nWebSocketを使う場合は、Jakarta WebSocket APIをサーブレットコンテナ（Tomcatなど）の機能として直接利用することになりますが、その実装方法はNablarchの知識ファイルの対象範囲外です。\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"WebSocket\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s33\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"NG\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": true,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": []\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"N/A\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "f75e4a9b-2b02-4610-aad7-4bac40434c19", + "total_cost_usd": 0.79733135, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 18, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 92997, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1125012, + "output_tokens": 7251, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 92997 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2070, + "outputTokens": 40, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00227, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 18, + "outputTokens": 7251, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1125012, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 92997, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.79506135, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "9ae4b017-3525-4206-a1ec-59220fe98da6" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..17780b9ba --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/oos-qa-01/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "WebSocket" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s33", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "NG" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": true, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "N/A", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a8991fe76 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,64 @@ +## Nablarchバッチアプリケーションの起動方法と -requestPath の書き方 + +**結論**: Nablarchバッチアプリケーションは `java nablarch.fw.launcher.Main` コマンドで起動し、`-requestPath` オプションに「アクションのクラス名/リクエストID」を指定する。 + +--- + +**根拠**: + +**起動コマンドの例** + +```bash +java nablarch.fw.launcher.Main \ + -diConfig file:./batch-config.xml \ + -requestPath admin.DataUnloadBatchAction/BC0012 \ + -userId testUser +``` + +**必須オプション（3つ全て必須。1つでも欠けると終了コード 127 で異常終了）** + +| オプション | 説明 | +|---|---| +| `-diConfig` | システムリポジトリの設定ファイルパス | +| `-requestPath` | 実行するアクションとリクエストID | +| `-userId` | ユーザID（セッションコンテキスト変数 `user.id` に格納） | + +**-requestPath の書式** + +```properties +# 書式 +-requestPath=アクションのクラス名/リクエストID + +# 指定例 +-requestPath=com.sample.SampleBatchAction/BATCH0001 +``` + +リクエストIDは各バッチプロセスの識別子として使われる。同一のアクションクラスを複数プロセスで起動する場合の識別にも用いる。 + +**RequestPathJavaPackageMappingを使った短縮指定（任意）** + +`RequestPathJavaPackageMapping` ハンドラを設定すると、クラス名の完全修飾名ではなくベースパッケージからの相対パスで指定できる。 + +```xml + + + + +``` + +上記設定の場合、`nablarch.application.xxx.ExampleBatchAction` クラスへのディスパッチは次のように指定できる： + +``` +-requestPath=/app/action/xxx/ExampleBatchAction +``` + +--- + +**注意点**: + +- `-diConfig`、`-requestPath`、`-userId` は省略不可。いずれかが欠けると即座に異常終了（終了コード 127）する。 +- リクエストIDは必ず指定すること（`クラス名/リクエストID` の `/リクエストID` 部分は必須）。 + +--- + +参照: nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s1, nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s2, handlers-main.json:s3, handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json:s4, handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json:s5 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..40b5ff19e --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "pre-01", + "description": "NablarchバッチアプリケーションはJavaコマンドから直接起動するが、その基本的な起動方法を知りたい", + "input": "Nablarchバッチアプリケーションはどのように起動しますか？-requestPathの書き方を教えてください", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "javaコマンドから直接起動するスタンドアロンアプリケーションとして実行する", + "-requestPathコマンドライン引数でアクションのクラス名とリクエストIDを指定する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The actual output covers both expected facts. It explicitly states the application is launched via 'java nablarch.fw.launcher.Main' command (standalone application started from java command), and it clearly explains the -requestPath option format including both the action class name and request ID. Both key facts from the expected output checklist are present and well-documented in the actual output." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant, directly addressing how to launch a Nablarch batch application and explaining how to write the -requestPath parameter. No irrelevant statements were identified!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 105216, + "duration_api_ms": 102249, + "num_turns": 17, + "total_cost_usd": 0.35497524999999996, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 6521, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 708515, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 11309 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1934, + "outputTokens": 43, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002149, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 6521, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 708515, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 11309, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.35282625, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d33953bfa --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 105216, + "duration_api_ms": 102249, + "num_turns": 17, + "total_cost_usd": 0.35497524999999996, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 6521, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 708515, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 11309 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1934, + "outputTokens": 43, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002149, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 6521, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 708515, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 11309, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.35282625, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a863cd15c --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 105216, + "duration_api_ms": 102249, + "ttft_ms": 5577, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3509, + "time_to_request_ms": 2367, + "num_turns": 17, + "result": "回答を生成します（Step 5）。\n\n**結論**: Nablarchバッチアプリケーションは `java nablarch.fw.launcher.Main` コマンドで起動する。`-requestPath` には `アクションのクラス名/リクエストID` の書式で指定する。\n\n---\n\nStep 6 (verify): 生成した回答の各クレームを検証します。\n\n- `nablarch.fw.launcher.Main` を起点とする → `nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s1` および `handlers-main.json:s3` で直接支持\n- `-requestPath=アクションのクラス名/リクエストID` の書式 → `nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s2` で直接記載\n- `-diConfig`, `-requestPath`, `-userId` の3オプション必須 → `handlers-main.json:s3` で直接記載\n- `RequestPathJavaPackageMapping` の `basePath`/`basePackage` 設定 → `handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json:s4` で直接記載\n\n全クレーム支持済み、必須コンテンツの欠落なし → **PASS**\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n## Nablarchバッチアプリケーションの起動方法と -requestPath の書き方\n\n**結論**: Nablarchバッチアプリケーションは `java nablarch.fw.launcher.Main` コマンドで起動し、`-requestPath` オプションに「アクションのクラス名/リクエストID」を指定する。\n\n---\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**起動コマンドの例**\n\n```bash\njava nablarch.fw.launcher.Main \\\n -diConfig file:./batch-config.xml \\\n -requestPath admin.DataUnloadBatchAction/BC0012 \\\n -userId testUser\n```\n\n**必須オプション（3つ全て必須。1つでも欠けると終了コード 127 で異常終了）**\n\n| オプション | 説明 |\n|---|---|\n| `-diConfig` | システムリポジトリの設定ファイルパス |\n| `-requestPath` | 実行するアクションとリクエストID |\n| `-userId` | ユーザID（セッションコンテキスト変数 `user.id` に格納） |\n\n**-requestPath の書式**\n\n```properties\n# 書式\n-requestPath=アクションのクラス名/リクエストID\n\n# 指定例\n-requestPath=com.sample.SampleBatchAction/BATCH0001\n```\n\nリクエストIDは各バッチプロセスの識別子として使われる。同一のアクションクラスを複数プロセスで起動する場合の識別にも用いる。\n\n**RequestPathJavaPackageMappingを使った短縮指定（任意）**\n\n`RequestPathJavaPackageMapping` ハンドラを設定すると、クラス名の完全修飾名ではなくベースパッケージからの相対パスで指定できる。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n\n```\n\n上記設定の場合、`nablarch.application.xxx.ExampleBatchAction` クラスへのディスパッチは次のように指定できる：\n\n```\n-requestPath=/app/action/xxx/ExampleBatchAction\n```\n\n---\n\n**注意点**:\n\n- `-diConfig`、`-requestPath`、`-userId` は省略不可。いずれかが欠けると即座に異常終了（終了コード 127）する。\n- リクエストIDは必ず指定すること（`クラス名/リクエストID` の `/リクエストID` 部分は必須）。\n\n---\n\n参照: nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s1, nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s2, handlers-main.json:s3, handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json:s4, handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json:s5\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"requestPath\", \"request-path-java-package-mapping\", \"batch\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-http-request-java-package-mapping.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/mom-messaging/mom-messaging-architecture.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-Request.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-repository.json\", \"section_id\": \"s21\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-OnlineAccessLogStatistics.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-OnlineAccessLogStatistics.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-handler-HttpRequestJavaPackageMapping.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"setup/blank-project/blank-project-setup-NablarchBatch.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"setup/blank-project/blank-project-setup-NablarchBatch-Dbless.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"setup/blank-project/blank-project-setup-Jbatch.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/adapters/adapters-router-adaptor.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-main.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-HttpRequest.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-i18n-ResourcePathRule.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-02-requestunittest-delayed-send.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-main.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "4a732064-d6b5-4602-90ed-a3f50017f6f8", + "total_cost_usd": 0.35497524999999996, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 11309, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 708515, + "output_tokens": 6521, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 11309 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1934, + "outputTokens": 43, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002149, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 6521, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 708515, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 11309, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.35282625, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01PNPT4ssUrZ9GZt3t2Pz23G", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash scripts/bm25-search.sh requestPath request-path-java-package-mapping batch 2>&1 | python3 -c \"import sys,json; data=json.load(sys.stdin); [print(f'score={r[\\\"score\\\"]:.4f} {r[\\\"file\\\"]}:{r[\\\"section_id\\\"]} - {r[\\\"section_title\\\"]}') for r in data[:20]]\"", + "description": "Run BM25 search and show top 20 results" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "121aaa47-9902-4cd9-af4f-0003b7ece3e4" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0b87e3a8a --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-01/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,145 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "requestPath", + "request-path-java-package-mapping", + "batch" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-http-request-java-package-mapping.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/mom-messaging/mom-messaging-architecture.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-Request.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-repository.json", + "section_id": "s21", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-OnlineAccessLogStatistics.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-OnlineAccessLogStatistics.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-handler-HttpRequestJavaPackageMapping.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "setup/blank-project/blank-project-setup-NablarchBatch.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "setup/blank-project/blank-project-setup-NablarchBatch-Dbless.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "setup/blank-project/blank-project-setup-Jbatch.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/adapters/adapters-router-adaptor.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-main.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-HttpRequest.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-fw-web-i18n-ResourcePathRule.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-02-requestunittest-delayed-send.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json", + "section_id": "s1" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-main.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-request-path-java-package-mapping.json", + "section_id": "s5" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..994493b6a --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +**結論**: ウェブアプリケーションでの入力チェック（バリデーション）は、`@InjectForm` アノテーション（InjectFormインターセプタ）を業務アクションのメソッドに設定することで実装します。Bean Validationを使用する場合は、コンポーネント設定ファイルへの `BeanValidationStrategy` の登録が必要です。 + +--- + +**根拠**: + +**① 依存モジュールの追加** + +```xml + + com.nablarch.framework + nablarch-fw-web + + + + + com.nablarch.framework + nablarch-core-validation-ee + +``` + +**② コンポーネント設定ファイルに BeanValidationStrategy を登録** + +```xml + +``` + +**③ Formクラスに Bean Validation アノテーションを設定** + +```java +public class UserForm { + @Length(max = 10) + @SystemChar(charsetDef = "全角文字") + @Required + private String userName; + + @Length(min = 8, max = 8) + @SystemChar(charsetDef = "半角数字") + private String birthday; + + // getter、setterは省略 +} +``` + +**④ 業務アクションに `@InjectForm` と `@OnError` を設定** + +```java +@InjectForm(form = UserForm.class, prefix = "form", validate = "register") +@OnError(type = ApplicationException.class, path = "forward://registerForm.jsp") +public HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest req, ExecutionContext ctx) { + + // リクエストスコープからバリデーション済みのフォームを取得する。 + UserForm form = ctx.getRequestScopedVar("form"); + + // formを元に業務処理を行う。 +} +``` + +- `prefix = "form"` を指定すると、`form.userId` のようにプレフィックスが付いたリクエストパラメータがバリデーション対象になります。 +- バリデーション成功時は、リクエストスコープにバリデーション済みフォームが格納されます。 + +**⑤ バリデーションエラー時のメッセージ定義** + +デフォルトでは[メッセージ管理](../../component/libraries/libraries-message.json)を使用してエラーメッセージを構築します。アノテーションの `message` 属性にメッセージIDを `{...}` 形式で指定し、プロパティファイルにメッセージを定義します。 + +```properties +nablarch.core.validation.ee.Length.max.message={max}文字以内で入力してください。 +nablarch.core.validation.ee.SystemChar.message={charsetDef}を入力してください。 +``` + +--- + +**注意点**: +- `@OnError` を設定していない場合、バリデーションエラーがシステムエラー扱いになるため、必ず設定すること。 +- Bean Validationのグループを使い分けたい場合は、`@InjectForm` の `validationGroup` 属性にグループクラスを指定できます（例: `validationGroup = Create.class`）。 + +参照: `libraries-bean-validation.json:s6`, `libraries-bean-validation.json:s7`, `libraries-bean-validation.json:s16`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s2`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s3`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s4`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s5` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8a202a499 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "pre-02", + "description": "入力バリデーションの実装方法を知りたいが、バッチかWebかRESTかが不明", + "input": "入力チェック（バリデーション）の実装方法を教えてください", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "WebアプリケーションではInjectFormインターセプタを使用してバリデーションを行う" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output clearly conveys the core fact in the Expected Output: that InjectForm interceptor (via `@InjectForm` annotation) is used to perform validation in web applications. The Actual Output explicitly states this in both the conclusion and the detailed implementation steps, fully covering the single expected fact." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response perfectly addresses the question about implementing input validation (バリデーション) with no irrelevant statements. Great job staying focused and on-topic!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 93428, + "duration_api_ms": 88934, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.42539090000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 13, + "output_tokens": 5769, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 549378, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 45858 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1846, + "outputTokens": 38, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002036, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 13, + "outputTokens": 5769, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 549378, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 45858, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.42335490000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..842932084 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 93428, + "duration_api_ms": 88934, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.42539090000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 13, + "output_tokens": 5769, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 549378, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 45858 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1846, + "outputTokens": 38, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002036, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 13, + "outputTokens": 5769, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 549378, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 45858, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.42335490000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..54fcdf291 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,68 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 93428, + "duration_api_ms": 88934, + "ttft_ms": 5705, + "ttft_stream_ms": 4726, + "time_to_request_ms": 3281, + "num_turns": 14, + "result": "十分な情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: ウェブアプリケーションでの入力チェック（バリデーション）は、`@InjectForm` アノテーション（InjectFormインターセプタ）を業務アクションのメソッドに設定することで実装します。Bean Validationを使用する場合は、コンポーネント設定ファイルへの `BeanValidationStrategy` の登録が必要です。\n\n---\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**① 依存モジュールの追加**\n\n```xml\n\n com.nablarch.framework\n nablarch-fw-web\n\n\n\n\n com.nablarch.framework\n nablarch-core-validation-ee\n\n```\n\n**② コンポーネント設定ファイルに BeanValidationStrategy を登録**\n\n```xml\n\n```\n\n**③ Formクラスに Bean Validation アノテーションを設定**\n\n```java\npublic class UserForm {\n @Length(max = 10)\n @SystemChar(charsetDef = \"全角文字\")\n @Required\n private String userName;\n\n @Length(min = 8, max = 8)\n @SystemChar(charsetDef = \"半角数字\")\n private String birthday;\n\n // getter、setterは省略\n}\n```\n\n**④ 業務アクションに `@InjectForm` と `@OnError` を設定**\n\n```java\n@InjectForm(form = UserForm.class, prefix = \"form\", validate = \"register\")\n@OnError(type = ApplicationException.class, path = \"forward://registerForm.jsp\")\npublic HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest req, ExecutionContext ctx) {\n\n // リクエストスコープからバリデーション済みのフォームを取得する。\n UserForm form = ctx.getRequestScopedVar(\"form\");\n\n // formを元に業務処理を行う。\n}\n```\n\n- `prefix = \"form\"` を指定すると、`form.userId` のようにプレフィックスが付いたリクエストパラメータがバリデーション対象になります。\n- バリデーション成功時は、リクエストスコープにバリデーション済みフォームが格納されます。\n\n**⑤ バリデーションエラー時のメッセージ定義**\n\nデフォルトでは[メッセージ管理](../../component/libraries/libraries-message.json)を使用してエラーメッセージを構築します。アノテーションの `message` 属性にメッセージIDを `{...}` 形式で指定し、プロパティファイルにメッセージを定義します。\n\n```properties\nnablarch.core.validation.ee.Length.max.message={max}文字以内で入力してください。\nnablarch.core.validation.ee.SystemChar.message={charsetDef}を入力してください。\n```\n\n---\n\n**注意点**:\n- `@OnError` を設定していない場合、バリデーションエラーがシステムエラー扱いになるため、必ず設定すること。\n- Bean Validationのグループを使い分けたい場合は、`@InjectForm` の `validationGroup` 属性にグループクラスを指定できます（例: `validationGroup = Create.class`）。\n\n参照: `libraries-bean-validation.json:s6`, `libraries-bean-validation.json:s7`, `libraries-bean-validation.json:s16`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s2`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s3`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s4`, `handlers-InjectForm.json:s5`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"bean-validation\", \"nablarch-validation\", \"validation\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-code.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s18\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s25\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s23\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "32a00ee9-86fa-4726-8e5c-688ff3e7e8eb", + "total_cost_usd": 0.42539090000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 13, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 45858, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 549378, + "output_tokens": 5769, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 45858 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1846, + "outputTokens": 38, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002036, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 13, + "outputTokens": 5769, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 549378, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 45858, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.42335490000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01XfRN15XYp8fmB6Kw5CFEUt", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash scripts/bm25-search.sh bean-validation nablarch-validation validation 2>&1 | python3 -c \"import json,sys; data=json.load(sys.stdin); print(json.dumps(data[:20], ensure_ascii=False, indent=2))\"" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "de35a5d8-8e06-4a16-aa5f-4d58a1fd32b2" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..877b96d90 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-02/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,154 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "bean-validation", + "nablarch-validation", + "validation" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-code.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s20", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s18", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s25", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s23", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s6" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s16" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s5" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6ba9d8b17 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,72 @@ +**結論**: +`UniversalDao` クラスの静的メソッドを使って検索します。主キー検索は `findById`、SQLファイルを使った条件検索は `findAllBySqlFile` / `findBySqlFile` を使用します。 + +**根拠**: + +**① 主キーで1件検索** + +```java +// 1件取得（0件の場合 NoDataException） +User user = UniversalDao.findById(User.class, userId); + +// 1件取得（0件の場合 null） +User user = UniversalDao.findByIdOrNull(User.class, userId); +``` + +**② 全件取得** + +```java +EntityList users = UniversalDao.findAll(User.class); +``` + +**③ SQLファイルを使った条件検索（複数件）** + +```java +// 検索条件をBeanで渡す +Book condition = new Book(); +condition.setAuthor("Martin Fowler"); + +EntityList books = UniversalDao.findAllBySqlFile(Book.class, "FIND_BY_AUTHOR", condition); +``` + +SQLファイルに定義した SQL_ID（例: `FIND_BY_AUTHOR`）を指定し、バインド変数はBeanのプロパティとして渡します。 + +**④ SQLファイルを使った条件検索（1件）** + +```java +Book condition = new Book(); +condition.setId(1L); + +Book book = UniversalDao.findBySqlFile(Book.class, "FIND_BY_ID", condition); +``` + +**⑤ ページング** + +```java +EntityList users = UniversalDao.per(3).page(1) + .findAllBySqlFile(User.class, "FIND_ALL_USERS"); + +Pagination pagination = users.getPagination(); +``` + +`per(1ページあたりの件数).page(ページ番号)` を先に呼び出すだけで使えます。 + +**⑥ 遅延ロード（大量データ）** + +大量データを扱う場合は `defer()` を使います。`DeferredEntityList` は必ず `close()` が必要です。 + +```java +try (DeferredEntityList users + = (DeferredEntityList) UniversalDao.defer() + .findAllBySqlFile(User.class, "FIND_BY_NAME")) { + for (User user : users) { + // userを使った処理 + } +} +``` + +**注意点**: +- `findById` / `findBySqlFile` は0件の場合 `NoDataException` をスローします。0件をnullで受け取りたい場合は `findByIdOrNull` / `findBySqlFileOrNull` を使用してください。 +- 遅延ロード使用中にトランザクション制御を行うと、RDBMSによってはカーソルがクローズされてエラーとなる場合があります。 + +参照: libraries-universal-dao.json:s12, libraries-universal-dao.json:s9, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s8, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s9, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s10, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s11, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s12, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s13, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s14 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1cd36705a --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "pre-03", + "description": "UniversalDaoを使ったデータベースアクセスを知りたい。バッチやWebで共通のコンポーネントのため、must_askほど重要ではないが、処理方式が分かれば回答の精度が上がる", + "input": "UniversalDaoでデータベースのデータを検索するにはどうすればいいですか？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "SQLファイルを作成してSQL IDを指定した検索ができ、検索結果はBeanにマッピングされる" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output explicitly covers the expected fact that SQL files can be used with SQL IDs specified for searching, and that results are mapped to Beans. Section ③ shows `findAllBySqlFile` with a SQL_ID like 'FIND_BY_AUTHOR' and a Bean condition object, and section ④ shows `findBySqlFile` with 'FIND_BY_ID' mapping to a `Book` bean. The text also mentions 'バインド変数はBeanのプロパティとして渡します' confirming Bean mapping. All aspects of the expected fact are covered." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant to the question about how to search database data using UniversalDao, with no irrelevant statements detected. Great job staying focused and on-topic!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 131876, + "duration_api_ms": 130141, + "num_turns": 16, + "total_cost_usd": 0.483671, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 8283, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 691875, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39970 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1758, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.001928, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 8283, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 691875, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39970, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.48174300000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..444e51fa9 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 131876, + "duration_api_ms": 130141, + "num_turns": 16, + "total_cost_usd": 0.483671, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 8283, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 691875, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39970 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1758, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.001928, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 8283, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 691875, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39970, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.48174300000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9d78f5e90 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 131876, + "duration_api_ms": 130141, + "ttft_ms": 5826, + "ttft_stream_ms": 4302, + "time_to_request_ms": 1980, + "num_turns": 16, + "result": "回答を生成します。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**:\n`UniversalDao` クラスの静的メソッドを使って検索します。主キー検索は `findById`、SQLファイルを使った条件検索は `findAllBySqlFile` / `findBySqlFile` を使用します。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**① 主キーで1件検索**\n\n```java\n// 1件取得（0件の場合 NoDataException）\nUser user = UniversalDao.findById(User.class, userId);\n\n// 1件取得（0件の場合 null）\nUser user = UniversalDao.findByIdOrNull(User.class, userId);\n```\n\n**② 全件取得**\n\n```java\nEntityList users = UniversalDao.findAll(User.class);\n```\n\n**③ SQLファイルを使った条件検索（複数件）**\n\n```java\n// 検索条件をBeanで渡す\nBook condition = new Book();\ncondition.setAuthor(\"Martin Fowler\");\n\nEntityList books = UniversalDao.findAllBySqlFile(Book.class, \"FIND_BY_AUTHOR\", condition);\n```\n\nSQLファイルに定義した SQL_ID（例: `FIND_BY_AUTHOR`）を指定し、バインド変数はBeanのプロパティとして渡します。\n\n**④ SQLファイルを使った条件検索（1件）**\n\n```java\nBook condition = new Book();\ncondition.setId(1L);\n\nBook book = UniversalDao.findBySqlFile(Book.class, \"FIND_BY_ID\", condition);\n```\n\n**⑤ ページング**\n\n```java\nEntityList users = UniversalDao.per(3).page(1)\n .findAllBySqlFile(User.class, \"FIND_ALL_USERS\");\n\nPagination pagination = users.getPagination();\n```\n\n`per(1ページあたりの件数).page(ページ番号)` を先に呼び出すだけで使えます。\n\n**⑥ 遅延ロード（大量データ）**\n\n大量データを扱う場合は `defer()` を使います。`DeferredEntityList` は必ず `close()` が必要です。\n\n```java\ntry (DeferredEntityList users\n = (DeferredEntityList) UniversalDao.defer()\n .findAllBySqlFile(User.class, \"FIND_BY_NAME\")) {\n for (User user : users) {\n // userを使った処理\n }\n}\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n- `findById` / `findBySqlFile` は0件の場合 `NoDataException` をスローします。0件をnullで受け取りたい場合は `findByIdOrNull` / `findBySqlFileOrNull` を使用してください。\n- 遅延ロード使用中にトランザクション制御を行うと、RDBMSによってはカーソルがクローズされてエラーとなる場合があります。\n\n参照: libraries-universal-dao.json:s12, libraries-universal-dao.json:s9, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s8, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s9, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s10, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s11, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s12, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s13, javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json:s14\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"universal-dao\", \"UniversalDao\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/mom-messaging/mom-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/db-messaging/db-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s15\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-getting-started-chunk.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "858945f7-ae73-47f6-8d9a-c756af8eb8ce", + "total_cost_usd": 0.483671, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39970, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 691875, + "output_tokens": 8283, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 39970 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1758, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.001928, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 8283, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 691875, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39970, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.48174300000000003, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01C9w179Nn8yBrXhwZKVmZGU", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md | head -100", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for page title list" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01GoRueHREhy4PFyct8mJnF5", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "a18492a0-897e-483a-92e2-88c48aea5f89" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..944e7db31 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/pre-03/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,161 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "universal-dao", + "UniversalDao" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/mom-messaging/mom-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/db-messaging/db-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s15", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-getting-started-chunk.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s12" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s9" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s8" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s9" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s10" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s11" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s12" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s13" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s14" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..3ac1afa4b --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +**結論**: `UniversalDao.defer()` を先に呼び出して遅延ロードを使用することで、大量データを1件ずつ読み込めます。内部ではサーバサイドカーソルを使用しており、メモリに検索結果を全展開せずに処理できます。 + +**根拠**: + +検索時に `UniversalDao.defer()` を先に呼び出すだけで遅延ロードが有効になります。 + +```java +// try-with-resourcesを使ったclose呼び出し。 +// DeferredEntityListはダウンキャストして取得する。 +try (DeferredEntityList users + = (DeferredEntityList) UniversalDao.defer() + .findAllBySqlFile(User.class, "FIND_BY_NAME")) { + for (User user : users) { + // userを使った処理 + } +} +``` + +遅延ロードでは「ユニバーサルDAOとしては1件ずつロード」されますが、実際のメモリ使用量はJDBCのフェッチサイズに依存します。フェッチサイズの詳細はデータベースベンダー提供のマニュアルを参照してください。 + +**注意点**: + +- **必ずcloseする**: 内部でサーバサイドカーソルを使用しているため、`DeferredEntityList#close` の呼び出しが必要です。try-with-resources を使って確実にクローズしてください。 +- **トランザクション制御に注意**: 使用するRDBMSによっては、カーソルオープン中にトランザクション制御が行われるとカーソルがクローズされ、エラーになる可能性があります。回避策として、ページング（`UniversalDao.per().page()`）を使う方法もあります。 + +参照: `libraries-universal-dao.json:s9` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9ed169d3e --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-01", + "description": "バッチで10万件のデータを読み込んで加工する処理を書いている。findAllBySqlFileで全件取得したらOutOfMemoryErrorが出た。", + "input": "大量データを検索するとメモリが足りなくなる。1件ずつ読み込む方法はないか？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "UniversalDao.deferメソッドで遅延ロードを使用する", + "DeferredEntityListのcloseメソッドを呼び出す必要がある" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output covers both expected facts. It explicitly mentions using `UniversalDao.defer()` for deferred (lazy) loading, and it also explicitly states that `DeferredEntityList#close` must be called, recommending try-with-resources to ensure proper closure. Both facts from the Expected Output checklist are fully covered." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 0.8666666666666667, + "reason": "The score is 0.87 because the response mostly addresses the question about how to read large data one record at a time to avoid memory issues. However, it loses some points for including an unnecessary reference to the database vendor's manual for fetch size details, which doesn't directly help answer the question, and for including a reference citation that adds no substantive value to the answer." + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 99618, + "duration_api_ms": 97502, + "num_turns": 15, + "total_cost_usd": 0.44383935, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 5978, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 675312, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39837 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1934, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002139, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 5978, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 675312, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39837, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.44170035, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..795ca49c6 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 99618, + "duration_api_ms": 97502, + "num_turns": 15, + "total_cost_usd": 0.44383935, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 5978, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 675312, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39837 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1934, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002139, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 5978, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 675312, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39837, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.44170035, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..6f4fd7f2b --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 99618, + "duration_api_ms": 97502, + "ttft_ms": 4333, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3627, + "time_to_request_ms": 2071, + "num_turns": 15, + "result": "セクション内容から回答を生成し、verify を実行します。\n\ns9 の内容がすべてをカバーしています。\n\n**回答生成 (Step 5)**:\n\n**結論**: `UniversalDao.defer()` を先に呼び出すことで遅延ロードが有効になり、大量データを1件ずつ読み込めます。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n```java\n// try-with-resourcesを使ったclose呼び出し。\n// DeferredEntityListはダウンキャストして取得する。\ntry (DeferredEntityList users\n = (DeferredEntityList) UniversalDao.defer()\n .findAllBySqlFile(User.class, \"FIND_BY_NAME\")) {\n for (User user : users) {\n // userを使った処理\n }\n}\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n- 内部でサーバサイドカーソルを使用しているため、`DeferredEntityList#close` の呼び出しが必要（try-with-resources 推奨）\n- RDBMSによっては、カーソルオープン中にトランザクション制御を行うとカーソルがクローズされエラーになる場合がある\n\n参照: `libraries-universal-dao.json:s9`\n\n**verify (Step 6)**: 主張をs9のページ内容と照合します。\n\n- `UniversalDao.defer()` → 支持済み（s9に明記）\n- 「1件ずつロード」→ 支持済み（「ユニバーサルDAOとしては1件ずつロードする」）\n- `DeferredEntityList#close` が必要 → 支持済み（s9に明記）\n- サーバサイドカーソル使用 → 支持済み（s9に明記）\n- トランザクション制御でカーソルクローズのリスク → 支持済み（s9のImportantに明記）\n\n結果: **PASS**\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: `UniversalDao.defer()` を先に呼び出して遅延ロードを使用することで、大量データを1件ずつ読み込めます。内部ではサーバサイドカーソルを使用しており、メモリに検索結果を全展開せずに処理できます。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n検索時に `UniversalDao.defer()` を先に呼び出すだけで遅延ロードが有効になります。\n\n```java\n// try-with-resourcesを使ったclose呼び出し。\n// DeferredEntityListはダウンキャストして取得する。\ntry (DeferredEntityList users\n = (DeferredEntityList) UniversalDao.defer()\n .findAllBySqlFile(User.class, \"FIND_BY_NAME\")) {\n for (User user : users) {\n // userを使った処理\n }\n}\n```\n\n遅延ロードでは「ユニバーサルDAOとしては1件ずつロード」されますが、実際のメモリ使用量はJDBCのフェッチサイズに依存します。フェッチサイズの詳細はデータベースベンダー提供のマニュアルを参照してください。\n\n**注意点**:\n\n- **必ずcloseする**: 内部でサーバサイドカーソルを使用しているため、`DeferredEntityList#close` の呼び出しが必要です。try-with-resources を使って確実にクローズしてください。\n- **トランザクション制御に注意**: 使用するRDBMSによっては、カーソルオープン中にトランザクション制御が行われるとカーソルがクローズされ、エラーになる可能性があります。回避策として、ページング（`UniversalDao.per().page()`）を使う方法もあります。\n\n参照: `libraries-universal-dao.json:s9`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"universal-dao\", \"database\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s15\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "e3bdac58-841e-4262-92e3-280c3cccbcd4", + "total_cost_usd": 0.44383935, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39837, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 675312, + "output_tokens": 5978, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 39837 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1934, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002139, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 5978, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 675312, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39837, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.44170035, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01NiAcvwSoBNhCrxYnnmMsP6", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for page title list" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_014JPRYRdPAVCxgmngAbX9VE", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01DBA8E6kM9Kprt8ve9fdUbE", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cd /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search && bash .claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/read-sections.sh \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s9\" \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s3\" \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s12\" \\\n \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json:s6\" \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s2\" \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s11\" \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s6\" \\\n \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json:s6\" \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s24\" \\\n \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json:s15\" \\\n 2>&1", + "description": "Read top 10 BM25 sections" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "fe9dd765-b401-440f-9917-f75b79d8a833" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b1d560f12 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-01/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,79 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "universal-dao", + "database" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s15", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s9" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5366e7e06 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +**結論**: NablarchバッチでDB→集計→別テーブル書き込みを実現するには、`DatabaseRecordReader`（データリーダ）と アクションクラス（`ActionClass`）の2つを実装します。読み込み元テーブルのレコードを1件ずつ処理し、アクションクラス内の業務ロジックで集計してUniversalDao経由で書き込みます。 + +**根拠**: + +**実装構成の3要素**: + +1. **DataReader（入力）**: `DatabaseRecordReader` でDBから1件ずつレコードを読み込む +2. **アクションクラス（業務ロジック）**: `DataReader`が返すレコードをもとに集計し、結果をエンティティクラスにセットして別テーブルへ書き込む +3. **エンティティクラス**: 入力テーブル用と書き込み先テーブル用をそれぞれ用意する + +``` +// アクションクラスの構造イメージ +public class AggregationBatchAction extends BatchAction { + + // 入力DataReaderの生成 + @Override + public DataReader createReader(ExecutionContext context) { + return new DatabaseRecordReader() + .setStatement( + UniversalDao.findAllBySqlFile(InputEntity.class, "READ_TARGET_DATA"), + new Object[0] + ); + } + + // 1件ごとの業務ロジック（集計 → 書き込み） + @Override + public Result handle(SqlRow inputRecord, ExecutionContext context) { + // エンティティに変換して集計処理 + ResultEntity result = aggregateAndMap(inputRecord); + // 別テーブルへ書き込み（INSERT or UPDATE） + UniversalDao.insert(result); + return new Result.Success(); + } +} +``` + +**ハンドラキュー構成**（`batch-component-configuration.xml`）: + +```xml + + + + + + + + + + + + +``` + +**入力データがDBの場合（安全なデータ源）**: フォームクラスは不要。`SqlRow`や入力エンティティクラスから直接集計ロジックに渡せる。 + +**注意点**: +- `トランザクションループ制御ハンドラ`の`commitInterval`で適切なコミット間隔を設定しないと、大量データ処理時にメモリ・ロック問題が発生しやすい +- 集計結果の書き込みが INSERT/UPDATE のどちらかによって、バッチ実行前のテーブルクリア処理（初期化）が必要になる場合がある +- 定期起動（ジョブスケジューラ等）との連携はNablarch外の仕組み（cron, Jenkins等）で行う + +参照: nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s3, nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s4, nablarch-batch-application-design.json:s1, nablarch-batch-feature-details.json:s4 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..06901c22e --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-02", + "description": "検索条件に合致するレコードを取得して別テーブルに集計結果を書き込む月次の定期処理を作りたい。DBからDBへのパターン。", + "input": "DBからデータを読み込んで集計し、結果を別テーブルに書き込む定期処理を作りたい。どういう構成で実装すればいい？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "DatabaseRecordReaderでデータベースからデータを読み込む", + "BatchActionを継承したアクションクラスを実装する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output explicitly covers both expected facts. It mentions `DatabaseRecordReader` as the data reader for reading records from the database (fact 1), and it implements `BatchAction` as the base class for the action class (`AggregationBatchAction extends BatchAction`), directly addressing fact 2. Both facts from the Expected Output checklist are clearly 'covered' in the Actual Output." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response directly and completely addresses the question about implementing a batch process that reads data from a DB, aggregates it, and writes results to another table. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 150641, + "duration_api_ms": 147750, + "num_turns": 28, + "total_cost_usd": 0.67871235, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 26, + "output_tokens": 8480, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1219372, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 48905 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2054, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0022289999999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 26, + "outputTokens": 8480, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1219372, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 48905, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6764833499999999, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..92623df60 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 150641, + "duration_api_ms": 147750, + "num_turns": 28, + "total_cost_usd": 0.67871235, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 26, + "output_tokens": 8480, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1219372, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 48905 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2054, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0022289999999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 26, + "outputTokens": 8480, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1219372, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 48905, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6764833499999999, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ac7d56476 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 150641, + "duration_api_ms": 147750, + "ttft_ms": 4664, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3634, + "time_to_request_ms": 1982, + "num_turns": 28, + "result": "必要な情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: NablarchバッチでDB→集計→別テーブル書き込みを実現するには、`DatabaseRecordReader`（データリーダ）と アクションクラス（`ActionClass`）の2つを実装します。読み込み元テーブルのレコードを1件ずつ処理し、アクションクラス内の業務ロジックで集計してUniversalDao経由で書き込みます。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**実装構成の3要素**:\n\n1. **DataReader（入力）**: `DatabaseRecordReader` でDBから1件ずつレコードを読み込む\n2. **アクションクラス（業務ロジック）**: `DataReader`が返すレコードをもとに集計し、結果をエンティティクラスにセットして別テーブルへ書き込む\n3. **エンティティクラス**: 入力テーブル用と書き込み先テーブル用をそれぞれ用意する\n\n```\n// アクションクラスの構造イメージ\npublic class AggregationBatchAction extends BatchAction {\n\n // 入力DataReaderの生成\n @Override\n public DataReader createReader(ExecutionContext context) {\n return new DatabaseRecordReader()\n .setStatement(\n UniversalDao.findAllBySqlFile(InputEntity.class, \"READ_TARGET_DATA\"),\n new Object[0]\n );\n }\n\n // 1件ごとの業務ロジック（集計 → 書き込み）\n @Override\n public Result handle(SqlRow inputRecord, ExecutionContext context) {\n // エンティティに変換して集計処理\n ResultEntity result = aggregateAndMap(inputRecord);\n // 別テーブルへ書き込み（INSERT or UPDATE）\n UniversalDao.insert(result);\n return new Result.Success();\n }\n}\n```\n\n**ハンドラキュー構成**（`batch-component-configuration.xml`）:\n\n```xml\n\n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n\n\n \n\n```\n\n**入力データがDBの場合（安全なデータ源）**: フォームクラスは不要。`SqlRow`や入力エンティティクラスから直接集計ロジックに渡せる。\n\n**注意点**:\n- `トランザクションループ制御ハンドラ`の`commitInterval`で適切なコミット間隔を設定しないと、大量データ処理時にメモリ・ロック問題が発生しやすい\n- 集計結果の書き込みが INSERT/UPDATE のどちらかによって、バッチ実行前のテーブルクリア処理（初期化）が必要になる場合がある\n- 定期起動（ジョブスケジューラ等）との連携はNablarch外の仕組み（cron, Jenkins等）で行う\n\n参照: nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s3, nablarch-batch-architecture.json:s4, nablarch-batch-application-design.json:s1, nablarch-batch-feature-details.json:s4\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"nablarch-batch\", \"database\", \"universal-dao\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-getting-started-nablarch-batch.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-nablarch-batch-error-process.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-application-design.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-getting-started-nablarch-batch.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "8965a137-6970-4aa1-8e29-6650591e7230", + "total_cost_usd": 0.67871235, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 26, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 48905, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1219372, + "output_tokens": 8480, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 48905 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2054, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0022289999999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 26, + "outputTokens": 8480, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1219372, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 48905, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6764833499999999, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01C6pRHX2g9qyM9kopjXQEtN", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md | head -100", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for BM25 term extraction" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_011FiNxd9cnYc6k1LJaiU39A", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null", + "description": "Find fts-hints.md file" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "196b106e-0e69-4ad3-b8b1-9f3b4742ba63" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a2d91cf8d --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-02/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,100 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "nablarch-batch", + "database", + "universal-dao" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-getting-started-nablarch-batch.json", + "section_id": "s1", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-nablarch-batch-error-process.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-architecture.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-application-design.json", + "section_id": "s1" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/nablarch-batch/nablarch-batch-getting-started-nablarch-batch.json", + "section_id": "s1" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e314d0669 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +**結論**: ウェブアプリケーションで2つの入力項目の一致チェック（相関バリデーション）を行うには、フォームクラスに `@AssertTrue` アノテーションを付けたメソッドを定義し、`Objects.equals()` で2項目を比較する。 + +--- + +**根拠**: + +`@AssertTrue` アノテーションをフォームのメソッドに付け、2つのフィールドを比較するロジックを実装する。 + +```java +public class SampleForm { + private String mailAddress; + + private String confirmMailAddress; + + @AssertTrue(message = "{compareMailAddress}") + public boolean isEqualsMailAddress() { + return Objects.equals(mailAddress, confirmMailAddress); + } +} +``` + +ウェブアプリケーションでBean Validationを使うには、コンポーネント設定ファイルに `BeanValidationStrategy` を定義し、アクションクラスに `@InjectForm` インターセプタを使用する。 + +```xml + +``` + +--- + +**注意点**: + +- Jakarta Bean Validationはバリデーションの実行順序を保証しないため、項目単体のバリデーションよりも前に相関バリデーションが呼び出される場合がある。そのため、相関バリデーション内で予期せぬ例外が発生しないようロジックを実装する必要がある。 +- **任意項目の場合**（どちらかが未入力の可能性がある場合）は、未入力時にバリデーションをスキップする処理を追加すること。 + +```java +@AssertTrue(message = "{compareMailAddress}") +public boolean isEqualsMailAddress() { + if (StringUtil.isNullOrEmpty(mailAddress) || StringUtil.isNullOrEmpty(confirmMailAddress)) { + // どちらかが未入力の場合は相関バリデーションを実施しない（バリデーションOKとする） + return true; + } + return Objects.equals(mailAddress, confirmMailAddress); +} +``` + +--- + +参照: libraries-bean-validation.json:s11, libraries-bean-validation.json:s16 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..40f0b1646 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-03", + "description": "会員登録フォームで、メールアドレスと確認用メールアドレスの一致チェックが必要。Nablarchの入力チェックの仕組みでどうやるのかわからない。", + "input": "2つの入力項目が一致しているかチェックしたい。メールアドレスと確認用メールアドレスの相関バリデーションのやり方を教えてほしい", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "Jakarta Bean Validationの@AssertTrueを使って相関バリデーションを行う" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output clearly covers the Expected Output fact that Jakarta Bean Validation's @AssertTrue annotation is used to perform correlation validation (相関バリデーション). The Actual Output not only mentions @AssertTrue explicitly but also provides detailed code examples and additional context about its usage, fully addressing the core claim in the Expected Output." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant, directly addressing the question about correlation validation between email address and confirmation email address fields. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 180485, + "duration_api_ms": 179787, + "num_turns": 22, + "total_cost_usd": 0.6411656499999999, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 21, + "output_tokens": 11849, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 975138, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 44943 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2110, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00229, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 21, + "outputTokens": 11849, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 975138, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 44943, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.63887565, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..df334fddb --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 180485, + "duration_api_ms": 179787, + "num_turns": 22, + "total_cost_usd": 0.6411656499999999, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 21, + "output_tokens": 11849, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 975138, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 44943 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2110, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00229, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 21, + "outputTokens": 11849, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 975138, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 44943, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.63887565, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..2cf363070 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 180485, + "duration_api_ms": 179787, + "ttft_ms": 5513, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3470, + "time_to_request_ms": 1928, + "num_turns": 22, + "result": "必要な情報が揃いました。Step 3の判定：\n\nBM25上位10セクションは、文字種バリデーション・OpenAPI対応・カスタムアノテーション追加など間接的なセクションのみで、「2項目の一致チェック」の実装方法を直接示すセクションがないため → **check-answerable: NG**\n\nStep 4（semantic search相当）：`libraries-bean-validation.json:s11`（相関バリデーションを行う）が該当。メールアドレスと確認用メールアドレスの一致チェックの実装例が含まれている。\n\nStep 5・6：s11とs16のセクションを使って回答を生成し、検証します。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: ウェブアプリケーションで2つの入力項目の一致チェック（相関バリデーション）を行うには、フォームクラスに `@AssertTrue` アノテーションを付けたメソッドを定義し、`Objects.equals()` で2項目を比較する。\n\n---\n\n**根拠**:\n\n`@AssertTrue` アノテーションをフォームのメソッドに付け、2つのフィールドを比較するロジックを実装する。\n\n```java\npublic class SampleForm {\n private String mailAddress;\n\n private String confirmMailAddress;\n\n @AssertTrue(message = \"{compareMailAddress}\")\n public boolean isEqualsMailAddress() {\n return Objects.equals(mailAddress, confirmMailAddress);\n }\n}\n```\n\nウェブアプリケーションでBean Validationを使うには、コンポーネント設定ファイルに `BeanValidationStrategy` を定義し、アクションクラスに `@InjectForm` インターセプタを使用する。\n\n```xml\n\n```\n\n---\n\n**注意点**:\n\n- Jakarta Bean Validationはバリデーションの実行順序を保証しないため、項目単体のバリデーションよりも前に相関バリデーションが呼び出される場合がある。そのため、相関バリデーション内で予期せぬ例外が発生しないようロジックを実装する必要がある。\n- **任意項目の場合**（どちらかが未入力の可能性がある場合）は、未入力時にバリデーションをスキップする処理を追加すること。\n\n```java\n@AssertTrue(message = \"{compareMailAddress}\")\npublic boolean isEqualsMailAddress() {\n if (StringUtil.isNullOrEmpty(mailAddress) || StringUtil.isNullOrEmpty(confirmMailAddress)) {\n // どちらかが未入力の場合は相関バリデーションを実施しない（バリデーションOKとする）\n return true;\n }\n return Objects.equals(mailAddress, confirmMailAddress);\n}\n```\n\n---\n\n参照: libraries-bean-validation.json:s11, libraries-bean-validation.json:s16\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"bean-validation\", \"nablarch-validation\", \"validation\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-code.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s18\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s25\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s23\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"NG\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": true,\n \"selected_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "1628e0fd-b3b7-49ed-b9f7-7e79c1343b9e", + "total_cost_usd": 0.6411656499999999, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 21, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 44943, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 975138, + "output_tokens": 11849, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 44943 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2110, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00229, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 21, + "outputTokens": 11849, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 975138, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 44943, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.63887565, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_016FSPWCw2Uej6q2iiQ7yono", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for BM25 term extraction" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01Fh1cjhCUP6wVx6mxPWjB99", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "bda2b662-ed67-4c08-8190-f14f40614333" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cc1d24bf3 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-03/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,145 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "bean-validation", + "nablarch-validation", + "validation" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-code.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s20", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s18", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s25", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s23", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "NG" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": true, + "selected_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s11" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s16" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..f194c4d61 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +**結論**: Bean ValidationのFormクラスの単体テストは、`nablarch.test.core.db.EntityTestSupport` を継承したテストクラスを作成し、テストデータをExcelファイルに定義することで行います。テストクラスは3種のテストメソッド（文字種・文字列長精査、単項目精査、項目間精査）を組み合わせて実装します。 + +**根拠**: + +**1. テストクラスの作成** + +以下の条件を満たすテストクラスを作成します。 + +- パッケージはテスト対象のForm/Entityと同じ +- クラス名は `
Test` +- `EntityTestSupport` を継承 + +```java +package com.nablarch.example.app.web.form; // テスト対象と同じパッケージ + +import nablarch.test.core.db.EntityTestSupport; +import org.junit.Test; + +public class UserRegistrationFormTest extends EntityTestSupport { + + private static final Class TARGET_CLASS = UserRegistrationForm.class; + + /** 文字種および文字列長の単項目精査テスト */ + @Test + public void testCharsetAndLength() { + String sheetName = "testCharsetAndLength"; + String id = "charsetAndLength"; + testValidateCharsetAndLength(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName, id); + } + + /** 単項目精査テスト（文字種・文字列長以外） */ + @Test + public void testSingleValidation() { + String sheetName = "testSingleValidation"; + String id = "singleValidation"; + testSingleValidation(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName, id); + } + + /** 項目間精査テスト（@AssertTrueなど） */ + @Test + public void testWholeFormValidation() { + String sheetName = "testWholeFormValidation"; + testBeanValidation(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName); + } + + /** setter/getter テスト */ + @Test + public void testSetterAndGetter() { + String sheetName = "testSetterAndGetter"; + String id = "setterAndGetter"; + testSetterAndGetter(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName, id); + } +} +``` + +**2. テストデータ（Excelファイル）の準備** + +テストデータはテストクラスと**同じディレクトリ・同じ名前**（拡張子 `.xlsx`）で配置します。 + +- `testCharsetAndLength` シート（文字種・文字列長精査）: + +| propertyName | allowEmpty | min | max | messageIdWhenNotApplicable | 半角英字 | 半角数字 | 全角ひらがな | … | +|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| +| userName | false | 1 | 10 | {nablarch.core.validation.ee.SystemChar.message} | x | x | x | … | + +- `testWholeFormValidation` シート（項目間精査）には `testShots`（テストケース表）と `params`（入力パラメータ表）の2つのIDで定義します。 + +**3. テスト用コンポーネント設定ファイル** + +`EntityTestConfiguration` に `BeanValidationTestStrategy` を指定します。 + +```xml + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +``` + +**注意点**: +- `testValidateCharsetAndLength` と `testSingleValidation` は、**プロパティとして別のFormを保持するForm（ネストForm）には使用できません**。その場合は独自に精査処理のテストを実装してください。 +- 一般的なFormのsetter/getterテストは、リクエスト単体テストで実施できるため、クラス単体テストでは省略可能です（Entityは必須）。 + +参照: `testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json:s2`, `s3`, `s4`, `s5`, `s6`, `s7`, `s8`, `s9`, `s10`, `s11`, `s12`, `s13`, `s14`, `s16`, `s17` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e7f4d58b7 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-04", + "description": "Bean Validationに対応したFormクラスの単体テストを書きたい。文字種や桁数のテストケースをどう準備すればいいかわからない。", + "input": "Bean ValidationのFormクラスの単体テストを書きたい。テストクラスの作り方とテストデータの準備方法を教えてほしい", + "purpose": "テストを書きたい", + "expected_facts": [ + "EntityTestSupportを継承してテストクラスを作成する", + "テストデータはExcelファイルに記述する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output covers both key facts from the Expected Output: (1) it explicitly states that the test class should inherit from `EntityTestSupport` (`nablarch.test.core.db.EntityTestSupport`), and (2) it clearly states that test data should be defined in Excel files (same directory and name as the test class, with `.xlsx` extension). Both expected facts are fully present in the Actual Output, with additional detailed implementation guidance provided." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 0.9333333333333333, + "reason": "The score is 0.93 because the response was largely relevant to the question about writing unit tests for Bean Validation Form classes, covering test class creation and test data preparation. However, it slightly missed the mark by including a statement about Entity setter/getter tests, which falls outside the scope of the question focused specifically on Bean Validation Form class unit tests." + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 127506, + "duration_api_ms": 124603, + "num_turns": 24, + "total_cost_usd": 0.7122782500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 24, + "output_tokens": 8509, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1220485, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 57693 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1902, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002077, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 24, + "outputTokens": 8509, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1220485, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 57693, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.7102012500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..02e8433f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 127506, + "duration_api_ms": 124603, + "num_turns": 24, + "total_cost_usd": 0.7122782500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 24, + "output_tokens": 8509, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1220485, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 57693 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1902, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002077, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 24, + "outputTokens": 8509, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1220485, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 57693, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.7102012500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..cd6dd01f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 127506, + "duration_api_ms": 124603, + "ttft_ms": 4163, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3244, + "time_to_request_ms": 1954, + "num_turns": 24, + "result": "十分な情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: Bean ValidationのFormクラスの単体テストは、`nablarch.test.core.db.EntityTestSupport` を継承したテストクラスを作成し、テストデータをExcelファイルに定義することで行います。テストクラスは3種のテストメソッド（文字種・文字列長精査、単項目精査、項目間精査）を組み合わせて実装します。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**1. テストクラスの作成**\n\n以下の条件を満たすテストクラスを作成します。\n\n- パッケージはテスト対象のForm/Entityと同じ\n- クラス名は `Test`\n- `EntityTestSupport` を継承\n\n```java\npackage com.nablarch.example.app.web.form; // テスト対象と同じパッケージ\n\nimport nablarch.test.core.db.EntityTestSupport;\nimport org.junit.Test;\n\npublic class UserRegistrationFormTest extends EntityTestSupport {\n\n private static final Class TARGET_CLASS = UserRegistrationForm.class;\n\n /** 文字種および文字列長の単項目精査テスト */\n @Test\n public void testCharsetAndLength() {\n String sheetName = \"testCharsetAndLength\";\n String id = \"charsetAndLength\";\n testValidateCharsetAndLength(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName, id);\n }\n\n /** 単項目精査テスト（文字種・文字列長以外） */\n @Test\n public void testSingleValidation() {\n String sheetName = \"testSingleValidation\";\n String id = \"singleValidation\";\n testSingleValidation(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName, id);\n }\n\n /** 項目間精査テスト（@AssertTrueなど） */\n @Test\n public void testWholeFormValidation() {\n String sheetName = \"testWholeFormValidation\";\n testBeanValidation(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName);\n }\n\n /** setter/getter テスト */\n @Test\n public void testSetterAndGetter() {\n String sheetName = \"testSetterAndGetter\";\n String id = \"setterAndGetter\";\n testSetterAndGetter(TARGET_CLASS, sheetName, id);\n }\n}\n```\n\n**2. テストデータ（Excelファイル）の準備**\n\nテストデータはテストクラスと**同じディレクトリ・同じ名前**（拡張子 `.xlsx`）で配置します。\n\n- `testCharsetAndLength` シート（文字種・文字列長精査）:\n\n| propertyName | allowEmpty | min | max | messageIdWhenNotApplicable | 半角英字 | 半角数字 | 全角ひらがな | … |\n|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|\n| userName | false | 1 | 10 | {nablarch.core.validation.ee.SystemChar.message} | x | x | x | … |\n\n- `testWholeFormValidation` シート（項目間精査）には `testShots`（テストケース表）と `params`（入力パラメータ表）の2つのIDで定義します。\n\n**3. テスト用コンポーネント設定ファイル**\n\n`EntityTestConfiguration` に `BeanValidationTestStrategy` を指定します。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n- `testValidateCharsetAndLength` と `testSingleValidation` は、**プロパティとして別のFormを保持するForm（ネストForm）には使用できません**。その場合は独自に精査処理のテストを実装してください。\n- 一般的なFormのsetter/getterテストは、リクエスト単体テストで実施できるため、クラス単体テストでは省略可能です（Entityは必須）。\n\n参照: `testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json:s2`, `s3`, `s4`, `s5`, `s6`, `s7`, `s8`, `s9`, `s10`, `s11`, `s12`, `s13`, `s14`, `s16`, `s17`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"bean-validation\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-code.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/about-nablarch/about-nablarch-jakarta-ee.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"NG\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": true,\n \"selected_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "65b8cfb1-a603-47e6-b3ef-846a5f5a3b96", + "total_cost_usd": 0.7122782500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 24, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 57693, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1220485, + "output_tokens": 8509, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 57693 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1902, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002077, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 24, + "outputTokens": 8509, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1220485, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 57693, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.7102012500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01Cn3NPCrNV6YAQ2ihP3hJ18", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for BM25 term extraction" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_019Rz3sQv1CejuZTDCYfw7ME", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "95d6819e-dedd-42bf-b195-bab44045aee9" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7c7401858 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-04/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,265 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "bean-validation" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s20", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-code.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/about-nablarch/about-nablarch-jakarta-ee.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "NG" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": true, + "selected_sections": [ + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s1", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s5" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s6" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s8" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s9" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s10" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s11" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s12" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s13" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s14" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s16" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s17" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..db7b6ed56 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +**結論**: RESTfulウェブサービスでJSONを受け取ってDBに登録するには、アクションクラスのメソッドに`@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)`と`@Valid`アノテーションを設定し、引数で受け取ったBeanを`UniversalDao.insert()`でDBに登録する。 + +**根拠**: + +アクションクラスの実装例: + +```java +@POST +@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON) +@Valid +public HttpResponse save(Person person) { + UniversalDao.insert(person); + return new HttpResponse(); +} +``` + +- `@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)` を指定すると、リクエストボディ変換ハンドラ（`BodyConvertHandler`）が `application/json` に対応した `BodyConverter` でリクエストボディを `Person` オブジェクトに変換する。 +- `@Valid` を付けると、`JaxRsBeanValidationHandler` がFormに対してBean Validationを実行する。バリデーションエラー時は後続処理に委譲せず `ApplicationException` を送出する。 +- `UniversalDao.insert(person)` でDBへの登録を行う。 + +ユニバーサルDAOのコンポーネント設定（コンポーネント定義ファイルへの追加が必要）: + +```xml + + +``` + +**注意点**: + +- `BodyConvertHandler` はルーティングアダプタよりも後ろに設定すること（アクションクラスのアノテーション情報を元に変換処理を行うため）。 +- `JaxRsBeanValidationHandler` は `BodyConvertHandler` よりも後ろに設定すること（`BodyConvertHandler` が変換したBeanに対してバリデーションを行うため）。 +- ユニバーサルDAOを使用するには、データベースアクセス（JDBCラッパー）の設定に加えて `BasicDaoContextFactory` の設定が必要。 + +参照: handlers-body-convert-handler.json:s5, handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json:s3, handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json:s4, libraries-universal-dao.json:s6 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..de7995b59 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-05", + "description": "REST APIで登録処理を実装したい。クライアントからJSONを受け取ってDBに登録する基本的な流れを知りたい。", + "input": "REST APIでJSONを受け取ってDBに登録する処理を作りたい", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "Formクラスでクライアントから送信された値を受け付ける", + "プロパティは全てString型で宣言する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 0.0, + "reason": "The Expected Output contains two specific facts: (1) Form classes receive values sent from clients, and (2) all properties should be declared as String type. The Actual Output discusses RESTful web services receiving JSON, using @Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON), @Valid annotations, and UniversalDao.insert() for DB registration. It mentions a 'Person' object but does not mention declaring all properties as String type, nor does it explicitly describe a Form class for receiving client-submitted values in the way described in the Expected Output. Neither of the two expected facts are clearly present in the Actual Output, resulting in near-zero coverage." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant to the input, directly addressing the request to create a process for receiving JSON via REST API and registering it to a database. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 154669, + "duration_api_ms": 152534, + "num_turns": 23, + "total_cost_usd": 0.58824015, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 18, + "output_tokens": 9205, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 793838, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 55985 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1846, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002016, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 18, + "outputTokens": 9205, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 793838, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 55985, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.58622415, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..0d1ca2d23 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 154669, + "duration_api_ms": 152534, + "num_turns": 23, + "total_cost_usd": 0.58824015, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 18, + "output_tokens": 9205, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 793838, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 55985 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1846, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002016, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 18, + "outputTokens": 9205, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 793838, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 55985, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.58622415, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1dba0ed97 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,96 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 154669, + "duration_api_ms": 152534, + "ttft_ms": 5351, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3726, + "time_to_request_ms": 2115, + "num_turns": 23, + "result": "これで十分な情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n**Step 3 (check-answerable)**: `handlers-body-convert-handler.json:s5` および `handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json:s4` にJSON受信→DB登録の具体的な実装例が含まれているため、**OK**。\n\n**Step 6 (verify)**: 全クレームがソースセクションで裏付けられているため **PASS**。\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: RESTfulウェブサービスでJSONを受け取ってDBに登録するには、アクションクラスのメソッドに`@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)`と`@Valid`アノテーションを設定し、引数で受け取ったBeanを`UniversalDao.insert()`でDBに登録する。\n\n**根拠**:\n\nアクションクラスの実装例:\n\n```java\n@POST\n@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)\n@Valid\npublic HttpResponse save(Person person) {\n UniversalDao.insert(person);\n return new HttpResponse();\n}\n```\n\n- `@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)` を指定すると、リクエストボディ変換ハンドラ（`BodyConvertHandler`）が `application/json` に対応した `BodyConverter` でリクエストボディを `Person` オブジェクトに変換する。\n- `@Valid` を付けると、`JaxRsBeanValidationHandler` がFormに対してBean Validationを実行する。バリデーションエラー時は後続処理に委譲せず `ApplicationException` を送出する。\n- `UniversalDao.insert(person)` でDBへの登録を行う。\n\nユニバーサルDAOのコンポーネント設定（コンポーネント定義ファイルへの追加が必要）:\n\n```xml\n\n\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n\n- `BodyConvertHandler` はルーティングアダプタよりも後ろに設定すること（アクションクラスのアノテーション情報を元に変換処理を行うため）。\n- `JaxRsBeanValidationHandler` は `BodyConvertHandler` よりも後ろに設定すること（`BodyConvertHandler` が変換したBeanに対してバリデーションを行うため）。\n- ユニバーサルDAOを使用するには、データベースアクセス（JDBCラッパー）の設定に加えて `BasicDaoContextFactory` の設定が必要。\n\n参照: handlers-body-convert-handler.json:s5, handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json:s3, handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json:s4, libraries-universal-dao.json:s6\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"universal-dao\", \"create-example\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-create-example.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "f5f42be1-4e6f-4bba-8f9c-098820bb0be0", + "total_cost_usd": 0.58824015, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 18, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 55985, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 793838, + "output_tokens": 9205, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 55985 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1846, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002016, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 18, + "outputTokens": 9205, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 793838, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 55985, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.58622415, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01661HDQMk7kspdTMiWQmjX9", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01SVfGpEnq3GHJAjL449pssG", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01WjrLVvUKyN4HXmeeGa2WiY", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cd /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search && bash scripts/bm25-search.sh universal-dao create-example jaxrs 2>&1 | head -100" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01X2BXumWnJWepynRuTKzMUL", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/bm25-search.sh universal-dao create-example jaxrs 2>&1 | head -100" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01HSABAz3s9AWaPY2dMWTRi4", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/bm25-search.sh universal-dao create-example jaxrs" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "01bd2409-fd05-4497-8760-148dc235f4c8" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..58899a82b --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-05/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "universal-dao", + "create-example" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-create-example.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "partial" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json", + "section_id": "s5" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-body-convert-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s6" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..dbfd3a2e7 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,64 @@ +入力画面と確認画面のJSPを共通化するには、Nablarchのカスタムタグを使います。確認画面のJSPに `` の1行を書くだけで、入力画面のJSPをそのまま確認画面として流用できます。 + +**結論**: `n:confirmationPage` タグを使うことで、入力画面のJSPを確認画面で再利用でき、重複した実装を大幅に削減できます。 + +--- + +**根拠**: + +入力項目のカスタムタグ（`n:text`、`n:checkbox`、`n:select` 等）は、同じJSP記述のままで確認画面向けの表示に自動的に切り替わります。共通化に使用するタグは以下の4つです。 + +| タグ | 役割 | +|---|---| +| `n:confirmationPage` | 確認画面のJSPで入力画面JSPのパスを指定して共通化を有効化 | +| `n:forInputPage` | 入力画面でのみ表示したい部分（例：確認ボタン）を囲む | +| `n:forConfirmationPage` | 確認画面でのみ表示したい部分（例：戻る・登録ボタン）を囲む | +| `n:ignoreConfirmation` | 確認画面でも入力UI表示を維持したい部分に指定（例：チェックボックスを確認画面でもチェック欄で表示したい場合） | + +**入力画面のJSP（input.jsp）**: +```jsp + + +
+ + +
+
+ + +
+
+ + +
+ +
+ + + + + + + +
+ +``` + +**確認画面のJSP（confirm.jsp）**: +```jsp + + +``` + +--- + +**注意点**: +- `n:plainHidden` タグ（画面遷移の状態受け渡し用）および `n:hiddenStore` タグ（セッションストアのデータ受け渡し用）は、入力・確認画面のどちらでも出力されます。 +- 入力～確認～完了画面間で入力情報を保持する場合、**複数タブ操作を許容しない**ときはDBストア、**許容する**ときはHIDDENストア（`n:hiddenStore` タグを使用）を選択してください。 + +--- + +参照: `libraries-tag.json:s23`, `libraries-session-store.json:s9` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a8d0400eb --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-06", + "description": "Web画面で入力画面と確認画面をそれぞれ別のJSPで作っている。同じフォーム項目を2回書くのが面倒。共通化する方法があると聞いた。", + "input": "入力画面と確認画面のJSPを共通化して実装を減らす方法はあるか？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "confirmationPageタグで確認画面のJSPに入力画面のJSPへのパスを指定して共通化する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The actual output clearly covers the expected fact: using the `n:confirmationPage` tag in the confirmation page JSP to specify the path to the input page JSP for sharing/common use. This is explicitly demonstrated both in the explanation and in the code example (``). The expected output's single core fact is fully present in the actual output." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 0.875, + "reason": "The score is 0.88 because the actual output mostly addresses the question about commonizing input and confirmation screen JSPs to reduce implementation. However, it includes some irrelevant details about DB store and HIDDEN store selection, which relate to how input information is retained rather than directly addressing the JSP commonization implementation method." + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 101964, + "duration_api_ms": 99422, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.41480335000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "output_tokens": 6004, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 619072, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 36501 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1918, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002098, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 6004, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 619072, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 36501, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.41270535, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..05b5162b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 101964, + "duration_api_ms": 99422, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.41480335000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "output_tokens": 6004, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 619072, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 36501 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1918, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002098, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 6004, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 619072, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 36501, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.41270535, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7604d133a --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 101964, + "duration_api_ms": 99422, + "ttft_ms": 4230, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3546, + "time_to_request_ms": 2129, + "num_turns": 14, + "result": "答えを検証します。Step 2でクレームを確認するため、セクション内容と回答を突き合わせます。\n\n回答に含まれるNablarch固有のクレームを確認します：\n\n1. `n:confirmationPage path=\"./input.jsp\"` - セクションs23に明記 ✅\n2. `n:forInputPage` タグ - セクションs23に明記 ✅\n3. `n:forConfirmationPage` タグ - セクションs23に明記 ✅\n4. `n:ignoreConfirmation` タグ - セクションs23に明記 ✅\n5. `n:plainHidden` と `n:hiddenStore` は入力・確認両方で出力 - セクションs23に明記 ✅\n6. 複数タブ許容しない→DBストア、許容する→HIDDENストア - セクションs9に明記 ✅\n7. コードブロックの内容 - セクションs23のコードと一致 ✅\n\nStep 3 MUST コンテンツの確認：\n- セクションs23の全ての必要情報（4タグ、実装例）は回答に含まれている ✅\n\nverify結果: **PASS**\n\n### Answer\n\n入力画面と確認画面のJSPを共通化するには、Nablarchのカスタムタグを使います。確認画面のJSPに `` の1行を書くだけで、入力画面のJSPをそのまま確認画面として流用できます。\n\n**結論**: `n:confirmationPage` タグを使うことで、入力画面のJSPを確認画面で再利用でき、重複した実装を大幅に削減できます。\n\n---\n\n**根拠**:\n\n入力項目のカスタムタグ（`n:text`、`n:checkbox`、`n:select` 等）は、同じJSP記述のままで確認画面向けの表示に自動的に切り替わります。共通化に使用するタグは以下の4つです。\n\n| タグ | 役割 |\n|---|---|\n| `n:confirmationPage` | 確認画面のJSPで入力画面JSPのパスを指定して共通化を有効化 |\n| `n:forInputPage` | 入力画面でのみ表示したい部分（例：確認ボタン）を囲む |\n| `n:forConfirmationPage` | 確認画面でのみ表示したい部分（例：戻る・登録ボタン）を囲む |\n| `n:ignoreConfirmation` | 確認画面でも入力UI表示を維持したい部分に指定（例：チェックボックスを確認画面でもチェック欄で表示したい場合） |\n\n**入力画面のJSP（input.jsp）**:\n```jsp\n\n \n
\n \n \n
\n
\n \n \n
\n
\n \n \n
\n \n
\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n
\n\n```\n\n**確認画面のJSP（confirm.jsp）**:\n```jsp\n\n\n```\n\n---\n\n**注意点**:\n- `n:plainHidden` タグ（画面遷移の状態受け渡し用）および `n:hiddenStore` タグ（セッションストアのデータ受け渡し用）は、入力・確認画面のどちらでも出力されます。\n- 入力～確認～完了画面間で入力情報を保持する場合、**複数タブ操作を許容しない**ときはDBストア、**許容する**ときはHIDDENストア（`n:hiddenStore` タグを使用）を選択してください。\n\n---\n\n参照: `libraries-tag.json:s23`, `libraries-session-store.json:s9`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"n:form\", \"n:input\", \"tag\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s23\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s25\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-keitai-access-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s23\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "39f46692-0a56-49b4-908f-dd80adaec939", + "total_cost_usd": 0.41480335000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 36501, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 619072, + "output_tokens": 6004, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 36501 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1918, + "outputTokens": 36, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002098, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 6004, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 619072, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 36501, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.41270535, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01TrxFnEiTfFDsBGVxVbq9da", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for page title lookup" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01QCkiQgU4beKWxZiBE5vx1K", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null", + "description": "Find fts-hints.md file" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "8c919fef-d350-49dd-8a58-65c7c55f1632" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..977051a51 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-06/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "n:form", + "n:input", + "tag" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s23", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s25", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-keitai-access-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s23" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-session-store.json", + "section_id": "s9" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s8" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1a7333f26 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +**結論**: NablarchのデータバインドライブラリとObjectMapperFactoryを使用する。`@Csv`アノテーションを付与したJava BeansクラスをObjectMapperFactory.create()に渡し、mapper.read()をループで呼び出すことでCSVを1件ずつJava Beansとして読み込める。 + +**根拠**: + +**Step 1: Maven依存の追加** + +```xml + + com.nablarch.framework + nablarch-common-databind + +``` + +**Step 2: Java Beansクラスに@Csvアノテーションを定義** + +```java +@Csv(type = Csv.CsvType.DEFAULT, properties = {"age", "name"}, headers = {"年齢", "氏名"}) +public class Person { + private Integer age; + private String name; + + // getter、setterは省略。 +} +``` + +`Csv.CsvType.DEFAULT`以外のフォーマットが必要な場合は、`@CsvFormat`を併用して個別に指定できる（文字コード・区切り文字・クォートモードなど）。 + +**Step 3: ObjectMapperでCSVを1件ずつ読み込む** + +```java +try (ObjectMapper mapper = ObjectMapperFactory.create(Person.class, inputStream)) { + Person person; + while ((person = mapper.read()) != null) { + // Java Beansオブジェクトごとの処理を記述 + } +} catch (InvalidDataFormatException e) { + // 読み込んだデータのフォーマットが不正な場合の処理を記述 +} +``` + +**注意点**: +- 外部から受け付けたCSVを読み込む場合、不正なデータを業務エラーとして通知するためにJava Beansのプロパティは**全てString型**で定義すること。 +- ObjectMapperは必ずclose（またはtry-with-resources）すること。閉じないとリソースリークが発生する。 + +参照: libraries-data-bind.json:s5, libraries-data-bind.json:s7, libraries-data-bind.json:s15 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1e85434b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-07", + "description": "バッチ処理でCSVファイルの各行をJava Beansにマッピングして読み込みたい。データバインドの使い方がわからない。", + "input": "CSVファイルの各行をJava Beansオブジェクトとして1件ずつ読み込みたい。どう実装する？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "ObjectMapperFactory#createで生成したObjectMapperを使用してデータを読み込む" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output clearly covers the expected fact that ObjectMapperFactory#create is used to generate an ObjectMapper for reading data. The code example explicitly shows `ObjectMapperFactory.create(Person.class, inputStream)` and `mapper.read()` being used to read CSV data, which directly aligns with the single expected fact in the Expected Output." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant, directly addressing how to read each row of a CSV file as Java Beans objects one by one. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 68282, + "duration_api_ms": 66203, + "num_turns": 11, + "total_cost_usd": 0.2934626, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 9, + "output_tokens": 3989, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 341862, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 34364 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1982, + "outputTokens": 39, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0021769999999999997, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 9, + "outputTokens": 3989, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 341862, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 34364, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.2912856, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..ab5b7cff7 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 68282, + "duration_api_ms": 66203, + "num_turns": 11, + "total_cost_usd": 0.2934626, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 9, + "output_tokens": 3989, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 341862, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 34364 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1982, + "outputTokens": 39, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0021769999999999997, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 9, + "outputTokens": 3989, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 341862, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 34364, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.2912856, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8e7a512ae --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 68282, + "duration_api_ms": 66203, + "ttft_ms": 4874, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3866, + "time_to_request_ms": 2161, + "num_turns": 11, + "result": "セクションの内容から回答を生成します。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: NablarchのデータバインドライブラリとObjectMapperFactoryを使用する。`@Csv`アノテーションを付与したJava BeansクラスをObjectMapperFactory.create()に渡し、mapper.read()をループで呼び出すことでCSVを1件ずつJava Beansとして読み込める。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**Step 1: Maven依存の追加**\n\n```xml\n\n com.nablarch.framework\n nablarch-common-databind\n\n```\n\n**Step 2: Java Beansクラスに@Csvアノテーションを定義**\n\n```java\n@Csv(type = Csv.CsvType.DEFAULT, properties = {\"age\", \"name\"}, headers = {\"年齢\", \"氏名\"})\npublic class Person {\n private Integer age;\n private String name;\n\n // getter、setterは省略。\n}\n```\n\n`Csv.CsvType.DEFAULT`以外のフォーマットが必要な場合は、`@CsvFormat`を併用して個別に指定できる（文字コード・区切り文字・クォートモードなど）。\n\n**Step 3: ObjectMapperでCSVを1件ずつ読み込む**\n\n```java\ntry (ObjectMapper mapper = ObjectMapperFactory.create(Person.class, inputStream)) {\n Person person;\n while ((person = mapper.read()) != null) {\n // Java Beansオブジェクトごとの処理を記述\n }\n} catch (InvalidDataFormatException e) {\n // 読み込んだデータのフォーマットが不正な場合の処理を記述\n}\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n- 外部から受け付けたCSVを読み込む場合、不正なデータを業務エラーとして通知するためにJava Beansのプロパティは**全てString型**で定義すること。\n- ObjectMapperは必ずclose（またはtry-with-resources）すること。閉じないとリソースリークが発生する。\n\n参照: libraries-data-bind.json:s5, libraries-data-bind.json:s7, libraries-data-bind.json:s15\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"data-bind\", \"data-format\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-format-definition.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s15\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "37244903-6ce8-4dd6-9607-98a68401b9ce", + "total_cost_usd": 0.2934626, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 9, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 34364, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 341862, + "output_tokens": 3989, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 34364 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1982, + "outputTokens": 39, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0021769999999999997, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 9, + "outputTokens": 3989, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 341862, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 34364, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.2912856, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01W7fwz4Zu3P8V4DTDtxdT3W", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json | python3 -c \"import json,sys; d=json.load(sys.stdin); [print(f's{i}: {s[\\\"title\\\"]}') for i,s in enumerate(d['sections'], 1)]\" 2>/dev/null || python3 -c \"\nimport json\nwith open('component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json') as f:\n d = json.load(f)\nfor s in d.get('sections', []):\n print(s.get('id',''), s.get('title',''))\n\"", + "description": "List all sections in libraries-data-bind.json" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "edce18ed-c0ba-434f-b8fb-9ca2db31e458" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e9e5e3f19 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-07/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,62 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "data-bind", + "data-format" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-format-definition.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s5" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s15" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c9f63d7c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,181 @@ +Nablarchで日本語と英語を切り替える多言語化は、主に「メッセージ管理の多言語化」と「スレッドコンテキストへの言語設定」の2つの柱で実現します。 + +--- + +## 1. 言語別プロパティファイルの作成 + +デフォルトのプロパティファイル（日本語）と、言語別のファイルを用意します。ファイル名は `messages_言語.properties` とします。 + +``` +src/main/resources/messages.properties # デフォルト（日本語） + messages_en.properties # 英語 +``` + +```properties +# messages.properties（日本語） +label.user.name=ユーザ名 +errors.required=入力してください。 +``` + +```properties +# messages_en.properties（英語） +label.user.name=User Name +errors.required=This field is required. +``` + +> **注意:** `messages.properties` が存在しない場合はエラーになります。必ず作成してください。 + +--- + +## 2. PropertiesStringResourceLoader の設定 + +コンポーネント設定ファイルで `PropertiesStringResourceLoader` にサポートする言語を設定します。**`defaultLocale` は必ず明示的に設定してください**（未設定だとOSの設定に依存し、障害の原因になります）。 + +```xml + + + + + + + en + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +``` + +メッセージ取得時にどの言語を使うかは `ThreadContext#getLanguage` の値で決まります。 + +--- + +## 3. スレッドコンテキストへの言語設定 + +### 基本設定（リクエスト毎に言語を初期化） + +`ThreadContextHandler` に `LanguageAttribute` を追加します。 + +```xml + + + + + + + + + + + +``` + +### ユーザが言語を選択できる場合（クッキーまたはセッションで保持） + +言語選択をクッキーで保持する場合は `LanguageAttributeInHttpCookie` を使用します。 + +```xml + + + + + +``` + +言語を切り替えるリンクをJSPで実装します。 + +```jsp + + English + + + + 日本語 + + +``` + +ユーザが選択した言語をクッキーとスレッドコンテキストに保存するハンドラを実装します。 + +```java +public class I18nHandler implements HttpRequestHandler { + public HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest request, ExecutionContext context) { + String language = request.getParamMap().containsKey("user.language") + ? request.getParam("user.language")[0] : null; + if (StringUtil.hasValue(language)) { + // クッキーとスレッドコンテキストに言語を設定 + // （サポート対象外の言語が指定された場合は設定しない） + LanguageAttributeInHttpUtil.keepLanguage(request, context, language); + } + return context.handleNext(request); + } +} +``` + +--- + +## 4. 画面でメッセージ・ラベルを出力する + +### JSPで `` タグを使用 + +```jsp + + + + + +``` + +--- + +## 5. JSPファイル自体を言語で切り替える場合 + +メッセージだけでなくJSPファイル全体を言語別にしたい場合は、`HttpResponseHandler` の `contentPathRule` を設定します。 + +```xml + + + + + + +``` + +ディレクトリ構成例： +``` +コンテキストルート/ +├── en/ +│ └── user/search.jsp +└── ja/ + └── user/search.jsp +``` + +--- + +## まとめ + +| やりたいこと | 使うもの | +|---|---| +| メッセージ・ラベルを言語別に定義 | `messages.properties` / `messages_en.properties` | +| メッセージの言語切り替え設定 | `PropertiesStringResourceLoader`（`locales`、`defaultLocale`） | +| リクエスト毎の言語初期化 | `ThreadContextHandler` + `LanguageAttribute` | +| ユーザによる言語選択 | `LanguageAttributeInHttpCookie` / `LanguageAttributeInHttpSession` + `LanguageAttributeInHttpUtil` | +| JSPでのメッセージ出力 | `` タグ | +| JSPファイル自体の切り替え | `HttpResponseHandler` + `DirectoryBasedResourcePathRule` | \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a42e312cf --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-08", + "description": "エラーメッセージや画面ラベルを多言語対応したい。日本語と英語で切り替えられるようにしたい。", + "input": "メッセージやラベルを日本語と英語で切り替えたい。多言語化の方法を教えてほしい", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "言語ごとのプロパティファイルを用意しサポートする言語をlocalesに設定する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output comprehensively covers the expected fact that language-specific property files should be prepared and supported languages set in 'locales'. Section 1 explicitly shows creating language-specific property files (messages.properties and messages_en.properties), and Section 2 shows the PropertiesStringResourceLoader configuration with the 'locales' property listing supported languages. Both key facts from the Expected Output are present and accurately represented." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant, directly addressing the question about how to switch messages and labels between Japanese and English for multilingual support. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 90674, + "duration_api_ms": 88056, + "num_turns": 16, + "total_cost_usd": 0.44559860000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 5585, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 684327, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 41194 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1830, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 5585, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 684327, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 41194, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.44359860000000007, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a778826d6 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 90674, + "duration_api_ms": 88056, + "num_turns": 16, + "total_cost_usd": 0.44559860000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "output_tokens": 5585, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 684327, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 41194 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1830, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 5585, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 684327, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 41194, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.44359860000000007, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..b5c89dfbd --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 90674, + "duration_api_ms": 88056, + "ttft_ms": 4257, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3214, + "time_to_request_ms": 1909, + "num_turns": 16, + "result": "十分な情報が揃いました。check-answerable: OK。回答を生成します。\n\n### Answer\n\nNablarchで日本語と英語を切り替える多言語化は、主に「メッセージ管理の多言語化」と「スレッドコンテキストへの言語設定」の2つの柱で実現します。\n\n---\n\n## 1. 言語別プロパティファイルの作成\n\nデフォルトのプロパティファイル（日本語）と、言語別のファイルを用意します。ファイル名は `messages_言語.properties` とします。\n\n```\nsrc/main/resources/messages.properties # デフォルト（日本語）\n messages_en.properties # 英語\n```\n\n```properties\n# messages.properties（日本語）\nlabel.user.name=ユーザ名\nerrors.required=入力してください。\n```\n\n```properties\n# messages_en.properties（英語）\nlabel.user.name=User Name\nerrors.required=This field is required.\n```\n\n> **注意:** `messages.properties` が存在しない場合はエラーになります。必ず作成してください。\n\n---\n\n## 2. PropertiesStringResourceLoader の設定\n\nコンポーネント設定ファイルで `PropertiesStringResourceLoader` にサポートする言語を設定します。**`defaultLocale` は必ず明示的に設定してください**（未設定だとOSの設定に依存し、障害の原因になります）。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n \n \n \n en\n \n \n \n \n \n \n\n\n\n \n\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\nメッセージ取得時にどの言語を使うかは `ThreadContext#getLanguage` の値で決まります。\n\n---\n\n## 3. スレッドコンテキストへの言語設定\n\n### 基本設定（リクエスト毎に言語を初期化）\n\n`ThreadContextHandler` に `LanguageAttribute` を追加します。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\n### ユーザが言語を選択できる場合（クッキーまたはセッションで保持）\n\n言語選択をクッキーで保持する場合は `LanguageAttributeInHttpCookie` を使用します。\n\n```xml\n\n\n \n \n\n```\n\n言語を切り替えるリンクをJSPで実装します。\n\n```jsp\n\n English\n \n\n\n 日本語\n \n\n```\n\nユーザが選択した言語をクッキーとスレッドコンテキストに保存するハンドラを実装します。\n\n```java\npublic class I18nHandler implements HttpRequestHandler {\n public HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest request, ExecutionContext context) {\n String language = request.getParamMap().containsKey(\"user.language\")\n ? request.getParam(\"user.language\")[0] : null;\n if (StringUtil.hasValue(language)) {\n // クッキーとスレッドコンテキストに言語を設定\n // （サポート対象外の言語が指定された場合は設定しない）\n LanguageAttributeInHttpUtil.keepLanguage(request, context, language);\n }\n return context.handleNext(request);\n }\n}\n```\n\n---\n\n## 4. 画面でメッセージ・ラベルを出力する\n\n### JSPで `` タグを使用\n\n```jsp\n\n\n\n\n\n```\n\n---\n\n## 5. JSPファイル自体を言語で切り替える場合\n\nメッセージだけでなくJSPファイル全体を言語別にしたい場合は、`HttpResponseHandler` の `contentPathRule` を設定します。\n\n```xml\n\n\n\n\n \n\n```\n\nディレクトリ構成例：\n```\nコンテキストルート/\n├── en/\n│ └── user/search.jsp\n└── ja/\n └── user/search.jsp\n```\n\n---\n\n## まとめ\n\n| やりたいこと | 使うもの |\n|---|---|\n| メッセージ・ラベルを言語別に定義 | `messages.properties` / `messages_en.properties` |\n| メッセージの言語切り替え設定 | `PropertiesStringResourceLoader`（`locales`、`defaultLocale`） |\n| リクエスト毎の言語初期化 | `ThreadContextHandler` + `LanguageAttribute` |\n| ユーザによる言語選択 | `LanguageAttributeInHttpCookie` / `LanguageAttributeInHttpSession` + `LanguageAttributeInHttpUtil` |\n| JSPでのメッセージ出力 | `` タグ |\n| JSPファイル自体の切り替え | `HttpResponseHandler` + `DirectoryBasedResourcePathRule` |\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"message\", \"lang\", \"language\", \"ThreadContext\", \"LanguageAttribute\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-http-response-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s15\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s31\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-handler-threadcontext-HttpLanguageAttribute.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-handler-threadcontext-LanguageAttributeInHttpSession.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-handler-threadcontext-LanguageAttributeInHttpCookie.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-http-response-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s31\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "4ee1f7f9-0853-40b8-8dcb-5fabefb431bd", + "total_cost_usd": 0.44559860000000007, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 16, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 41194, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 684327, + "output_tokens": 5585, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 41194 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1830, + "outputTokens": 34, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 16, + "outputTokens": 5585, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 684327, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 41194, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.44359860000000007, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01TPWC2Ws6AQ3RuXL1neK5Tn", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01MpyB2xnuuT5x6QAvpKu8pw", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "74395f46-a74c-485c-a8e1-1accab7cfe7a" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..143d7c31e --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-08/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,110 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "message", + "lang", + "language", + "ThreadContext", + "LanguageAttribute" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-http-response-handler.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s15", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s31", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-handler-threadcontext-HttpLanguageAttribute.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "partial" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-handler-threadcontext-LanguageAttributeInHttpSession.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "partial" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-web-handler-threadcontext-LanguageAttributeInHttpCookie.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "partial" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s8" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s11" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-thread-context-handler.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-http-response-handler.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s31" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..140653b78 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,64 @@ +**結論**: NablarchはOS日時（システム日時）と業務日付を独立して管理する機能を提供しています。業務日付の取得には `BusinessDateUtil`、OS日時の取得には `SystemTimeUtil` を使い、それぞれ別のコンポーネントで管理します。 + +**根拠**: + +Nablarchの日付管理機能では、コンポーネント定義で指定するクラスを差し替えるだけで取得方法を切り替えられます。 + +**1. 業務日付の設定（DBで管理）** + +業務日付はデータベースのテーブルで管理します。テーブルは「区分（PK）」と「日付（yyyyMMdd形式）」の2カラム構成で、複数の区分（例: 締め処理ごとに異なる業務日付）を管理できます。 + +```xml + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +``` + +**2. システム日時の設定（OS日時）** + +```xml + +``` + +**3. アプリケーションコードからの取得** + +- 業務日付: `BusinessDateUtil` を使用 +- システム日時(OS日時): `SystemTimeUtil` を使用 + +**4. 業務日付の更新（締め処理後の日付更新）** + +```java +// SystemRepositoryからBasicBusinessDateProviderを取得する +BusinessDateProvider provider = SystemRepository.get("businessDateProvider"); + +// setDateメソッドを呼び出し、更新する（区分ごとに更新可能） +provider.setDate(segment, date); +``` + +**5. バッチ再実行時の業務日付上書き** + +バッチ処理の再実行時など、特定プロセスのみ業務日付を変更したい場合はシステムプロパティで上書きできます。 + +``` +-DBasicBusinessDateProvider.batch=20160317 +``` + +**注意点**: +- 業務日付管理機能を使用するには `nablarch-common-jdbc` モジュールが追加で必要です。 +- `BasicBusinessDateProvider` は初期化対象リスト（`initializeList`）への登録が必要です。忘れると起動時にエラーになります。 +- 業務日付は `defaultSegment` で指定した区分がデフォルトで使用されます。締め処理ごとに異なる業務日付を管理する場合は区分値を明示的に指定して取得・更新してください。 + +参照: `libraries-date.json:s2`, `libraries-date.json:s3`, `libraries-date.json:s5`, `libraries-date.json:s6`, `libraries-date.json:s7`, `libraries-date.json:s8`, `libraries-date.json:s9`, `libraries-date.json:s10` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a383232f6 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-09", + "description": "締め処理で業務日付を使いたい。OS日時ではなく業務上の日付を取得する方法がわからない。", + "input": "OS日時ではなく業務上の日付を取得する方法はあるか？締め処理でシステム日時と業務日付を分けて管理したい", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "BusinessDateUtilを使用して業務日付を取得する", + "業務日付管理機能はデータベースで複数の業務日付を管理し、BasicBusinessDateProviderの設定が必要" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output covers both facts present in the Expected Output. It explicitly mentions using `BusinessDateUtil` to retrieve business dates, and it describes how the business date management feature manages multiple business dates in a database using `BasicBusinessDateProvider` configuration (including table structure, segment management, and component setup). Both expected facts are fully addressed." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant, directly addressing the question about obtaining business dates separate from OS datetime and managing the distinction between system datetime and business dates in closing processes. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 80963, + "duration_api_ms": 78730, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.38651325000000003, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "output_tokens": 5124, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 609740, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 33227 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1910, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002085, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 5124, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 609740, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 33227, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.38442825, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8104c707d --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 80963, + "duration_api_ms": 78730, + "num_turns": 14, + "total_cost_usd": 0.38651325000000003, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "output_tokens": 5124, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 609740, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 33227 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1910, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002085, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 5124, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 609740, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 33227, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.38442825, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..4ee2e416f --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 80963, + "duration_api_ms": 78730, + "ttft_ms": 6137, + "ttft_stream_ms": 5137, + "time_to_request_ms": 2163, + "num_turns": 14, + "result": "十分な情報が揃いました。Step 5: 回答を生成します。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: NablarchはOS日時（システム日時）と業務日付を独立して管理する機能を提供しています。業務日付の取得には `BusinessDateUtil`、OS日時の取得には `SystemTimeUtil` を使い、それぞれ別のコンポーネントで管理します。\n\n**根拠**:\n\nNablarchの日付管理機能では、コンポーネント定義で指定するクラスを差し替えるだけで取得方法を切り替えられます。\n\n**1. 業務日付の設定（DBで管理）**\n\n業務日付はデータベースのテーブルで管理します。テーブルは「区分（PK）」と「日付（yyyyMMdd形式）」の2カラム構成で、複数の区分（例: 締め処理ごとに異なる業務日付）を管理できます。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n\n\n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\n**2. システム日時の設定（OS日時）**\n\n```xml\n\n```\n\n**3. アプリケーションコードからの取得**\n\n- 業務日付: `BusinessDateUtil` を使用\n- システム日時(OS日時): `SystemTimeUtil` を使用\n\n**4. 業務日付の更新（締め処理後の日付更新）**\n\n```java\n// SystemRepositoryからBasicBusinessDateProviderを取得する\nBusinessDateProvider provider = SystemRepository.get(\"businessDateProvider\");\n\n// setDateメソッドを呼び出し、更新する（区分ごとに更新可能）\nprovider.setDate(segment, date);\n```\n\n**5. バッチ再実行時の業務日付上書き**\n\nバッチ処理の再実行時など、特定プロセスのみ業務日付を変更したい場合はシステムプロパティで上書きできます。\n\n```\n-DBasicBusinessDateProvider.batch=20160317\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n- 業務日付管理機能を使用するには `nablarch-common-jdbc` モジュールが追加で必要です。\n- `BasicBusinessDateProvider` は初期化対象リスト（`initializeList`）への登録が必要です。忘れると起動時にエラーになります。\n- 業務日付は `defaultSegment` で指定した区分がデフォルトで使用されます。締め処理ごとに異なる業務日付を管理する場合は区分値を明示的に指定して取得・更新してください。\n\n参照: `libraries-date.json:s2`, `libraries-date.json:s3`, `libraries-date.json:s5`, `libraries-date.json:s6`, `libraries-date.json:s7`, `libraries-date.json:s8`, `libraries-date.json:s9`, `libraries-date.json:s10`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"date\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BusinessDateProvider.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BasicBusinessDateProvider.json\", \"section_id\": \"s30\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-SystemTimeProvider.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BasicSystemTimeProvider.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-util-DateUtil.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-log-basic-LogContext.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-date.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "8c6ce4e1-48e0-4786-ab7f-3805e80098c7", + "total_cost_usd": 0.38651325000000003, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 15, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 33227, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 609740, + "output_tokens": 5124, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 33227 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1910, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002085, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 15, + "outputTokens": 5124, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 609740, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 33227, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.38442825, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_013FXRU3SgrUWhWARBZS6WTq", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md | grep -i -E \"date|time|business|system|日付|業務|システム|clock|timer\" | head -50", + "description": "Search fts-hints.md for date/time related page titles" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01FLaGLr1txs1D58wWuvFjwu", + "tool_input": { + "command": "grep -i -E \"date|time|business|system|日付|業務|システム|clock|timer|SystemTime|BusinessDate\" /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md | head -50", + "description": "Search fts-hints.md for date/time related page titles" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01FQgFDsYqXSonSp5hJXVpkk", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null", + "description": "Find fts-hints.md file" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "6e96243d-197e-4504-a398-439bc5bb2959" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9608d1031 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-09/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "date" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BusinessDateProvider.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BasicBusinessDateProvider.json", + "section_id": "s30", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-SystemTimeProvider.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-date-BasicSystemTimeProvider.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-util-DateUtil.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-core-log-basic-LogContext.json", + "section_id": "s8", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s5" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s6" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s8" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s9" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-date.json", + "section_id": "s10" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..11ee583b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +**結論**: SQLファイル内で `$if(プロパティ名) {SQL文の条件}` という特殊構文を使うことで、入力があった項目だけをwhere句の条件に含める動的SQLを実現できます。Javaコード側では `prepareParameterizedSqlStatementBySqlId` で Beanを渡すだけで、Nablarchが自動的に条件の組み立てを行います。 + +**根拠**: + +**可変条件の記述ルール** + +可変条件は `$if(プロパティ名) {SQL文の条件}` で記述します。プロパティ値が以下の場合にその条件が除外されます: + +- 配列や `java.util.Collection` の場合: null またはサイズが 0 +- それ以外の型（String 等）: null または空文字列 + +制約: +- **使用できるのは `where` 句のみ** +- `$if` の中に `$if` は使用できない + +**SQLの記述例** + +`userName` と `userKbn` が可変条件の例: + +```none +select + user_id, + user_name, + user_kbn +from + user +where + $if (userName) {user_name like :userName%} + and $if (userKbn) {user_kbn in ('1', '2')} + and birthday = :birthday +``` + +**Java実装例** + +`userName` だけ値が設定されている場合、`userKbn` の条件は自動的に除外されます: + +```java +// beanを生成しプロパティに値を設定 +UserEntity entity = new UserEntity(); +entity.setUserName("なまえ"); + +// DbConnectionContextからデータベース接続を取得する +AppDbConnection connection = DbConnectionContext.getConnection(); + +// SQLIDを元にステートメントを生成する +// 2番めの引数には、条件を持つBeanオブジェクトを指定する。 +// このBeanオブジェクトの状態を元にSQLの可変条件の組み立てが行われる。 +ParameterizedSqlPStatement statement = connection.prepareParameterizedSqlStatementBySqlId( + "jp.co.tis.sample.action.SampleAction#insertUser", entity); + +// entityのプロパティの値をバインド変数に設定しSQLが実行される +SqlResultSet result = statement.retrieve(entity); +``` + +**注意点**: + +- この機能はウェブアプリケーションの検索画面のように**ユーザの入力内容によって検索条件が変わる場合**に使うものです。条件だけが異なる複数のSQLを共通化するために使用するものではありません。安易に共通化すると、SQL変更時に思わぬ不具合を埋め込む原因になるため、**必ずSQLを複数定義してください**。 +- in句の条件を可変にしたい場合は、名前付きパラメータの末尾に `[]` を付け（例: `:userKbn[]`）、`$if` と組み合わせて使用します。 + +参照: libraries-database.json:s6, libraries-database.json:s21, libraries-database.json:s22 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..a428cbdb0 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-10", + "description": "検索画面でユーザーの入力に応じて条件が変わるSQLを書きたい。名前が入力されたら名前で絞り、入力されなければ全件取得したい。", + "input": "ユーザーの入力内容によって検索条件が変わるSQLを書きたい。入力がある項目だけ条件に含める方法はあるか？", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "$if構文で可変条件を記述する。プロパティ値がnullや空文字列の場合に条件が除外される" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output fully covers the expected facts. The Expected Output states two key facts: (1) $if構文で可変条件を記述する — this is clearly present in the Actual Output with detailed examples of the syntax. (2) プロパティ値がnullや空文字列の場合に条件が除外される — this is explicitly stated in the Actual Output under the exclusion conditions (null or empty string for non-collection types). Both facts are present and semantically equivalent, with the Actual Output providing additional detail beyond the expected minimum." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 0.95, + "reason": "The score is 0.95 because the response is largely relevant and effectively addresses how to write dynamic SQL that conditionally includes search criteria based on user input. However, it loses a small amount of points due to one contradictory statement suggesting that dynamic SQL increases the need for multiple SQLs, which is actually the opposite of what dynamic SQL is designed to do, making that statement irrelevant and slightly misleading to the user's question." + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 145180, + "duration_api_ms": 140571, + "num_turns": 25, + "total_cost_usd": 0.6489161000000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 25, + "output_tokens": 7478, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1189747, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 47336 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2062, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002237, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 25, + "outputTokens": 7478, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1189747, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 47336, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6466791000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..e6d43df42 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 145180, + "duration_api_ms": 140571, + "num_turns": 25, + "total_cost_usd": 0.6489161000000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 25, + "output_tokens": 7478, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1189747, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 47336 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2062, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002237, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 25, + "outputTokens": 7478, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1189747, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 47336, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6466791000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..9de7fe6c4 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 145180, + "duration_api_ms": 140571, + "ttft_ms": 5290, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3557, + "time_to_request_ms": 2138, + "num_turns": 25, + "result": "十分な情報が揃いました。BM25 で見つかったセクション（`s6`, `s21`）の内容から回答を生成し、verify します。\n\n**セクション選定（BM25 結果上位20件から質問関連を選別）:**\n\n- `component/libraries/libraries-database.json:s6` — 動的SQL概要（high）\n- `component/libraries/libraries-database.json:s21` — 可変条件を持つSQLを実行する（high）\n- `component/libraries/libraries-database.json:s22` — in句の条件数が可変（high）\n\nこれらのセクション内容から回答を生成します。\n\n**verify チェック:**\n- 「`$if(プロパティ名) {SQL文の条件}` という記法で可変条件を記述する」→ s21 で直接述べられている ✅\n- 「`where` 句のみで使用可能」「`$if` 内に `$if` は使用できない」→ s21 の制約セクションに明記 ✅\n- 「プロパティ値が null または空文字の場合は条件が除外される」→ s21 に明記 ✅\n- `ParameterizedSqlPStatement` と `prepareParameterizedSqlStatementBySqlId` → s21 の実装例にそのまま記載 ✅\n- in句に `[]` を使う記法 → s22 に明記 ✅\n\nmissing content チェック: s21 の Important 注意事項（条件共通化目的で使うべきでない）が回答に含まれるべき → 含める。\n\n**verify 結果: PASS**\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: SQLファイル内で `$if(プロパティ名) {SQL文の条件}` という特殊構文を使うことで、入力があった項目だけをwhere句の条件に含める動的SQLを実現できます。Javaコード側では `prepareParameterizedSqlStatementBySqlId` で Beanを渡すだけで、Nablarchが自動的に条件の組み立てを行います。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**可変条件の記述ルール**\n\n可変条件は `$if(プロパティ名) {SQL文の条件}` で記述します。プロパティ値が以下の場合にその条件が除外されます:\n\n- 配列や `java.util.Collection` の場合: null またはサイズが 0\n- それ以外の型（String 等）: null または空文字列\n\n制約:\n- **使用できるのは `where` 句のみ**\n- `$if` の中に `$if` は使用できない\n\n**SQLの記述例**\n\n`userName` と `userKbn` が可変条件の例:\n\n```none\nselect\n user_id,\n user_name,\n user_kbn\nfrom\n user\nwhere\n $if (userName) {user_name like :userName%}\n and $if (userKbn) {user_kbn in ('1', '2')}\n and birthday = :birthday\n```\n\n**Java実装例**\n\n`userName` だけ値が設定されている場合、`userKbn` の条件は自動的に除外されます:\n\n```java\n// beanを生成しプロパティに値を設定\nUserEntity entity = new UserEntity();\nentity.setUserName(\"なまえ\");\n\n// DbConnectionContextからデータベース接続を取得する\nAppDbConnection connection = DbConnectionContext.getConnection();\n\n// SQLIDを元にステートメントを生成する\n// 2番めの引数には、条件を持つBeanオブジェクトを指定する。\n// このBeanオブジェクトの状態を元にSQLの可変条件の組み立てが行われる。\nParameterizedSqlPStatement statement = connection.prepareParameterizedSqlStatementBySqlId(\n \"jp.co.tis.sample.action.SampleAction#insertUser\", entity);\n\n// entityのプロパティの値をバインド変数に設定しSQLが実行される\nSqlResultSet result = statement.retrieve(entity);\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n\n- この機能はウェブアプリケーションの検索画面のように**ユーザの入力内容によって検索条件が変わる場合**に使うものです。条件だけが異なる複数のSQLを共通化するために使用するものではありません。安易に共通化すると、SQL変更時に思わぬ不具合を埋め込む原因になるため、**必ずSQLを複数定義してください**。\n- in句の条件を可変にしたい場合は、名前付きパラメータの末尾に `[]` を付け（例: `:userKbn[]`）、`$if` と組み合わせて使用します。\n\n参照: libraries-database.json:s6, libraries-database.json:s21, libraries-database.json:s22\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"libraries-database\", \"universal-dao\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s21\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s22\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s21\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-database.json\", \"section_id\": \"s22\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "adb3cdba-c838-443d-a5fe-0afcf7842795", + "total_cost_usd": 0.6489161000000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 25, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 47336, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1189747, + "output_tokens": 7478, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 47336 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2062, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002237, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 25, + "outputTokens": 7478, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1189747, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 47336, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.6466791000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01QzArhGjwRWmcfxKmBcePzw", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for BM25 term lookup" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_018WY7AHRqbesfEFMPWMsoYe", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash scripts/bm25-search.sh universal-dao 2>&1 | python3 -c \"import json,sys; data=json.load(sys.stdin); [print(d['file'], d['section_id'], d['section_title'], d['score']) for d in data[:20]]\"", + "description": "Search for universal-dao term and show top results" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01VrwmC6PqxG9PCG3SHmzRtK", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash scripts/find-file.sh \"libraries-database\" 2>&1", + "description": "Find the libraries-database knowledge file" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "2f9df616-ff9b-4f13-b840-ab5f7eba8818" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..081cbabe9 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-10/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,62 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "libraries-database", + "universal-dao" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s21", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s22", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "partial" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "partial" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s6" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s21" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-database.json", + "section_id": "s22" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..24f1b648c --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,113 @@ +**結論** + +ウェブアプリケーションのエラー処理は、主に **HTTPエラー制御ハンドラ**（`HttpErrorHandler`）がハンドラキュー上で例外を捕捉し、例外の種類に応じたログ出力とエラー画面へのレスポンス生成を行う仕組みになっています。エラー画面への遷移先は `@OnError` インターセプタやハンドラで定義します。 + +--- + +**根拠** + +## 1. HTTPエラー制御ハンドラによる例外処理とログ出力 + +`HttpErrorHandler` がハンドラキューの後続で発生した例外を捕捉し、例外の種類に応じて以下のように処理します。 + +| 例外クラス | ログレベル | HTTPステータス | 補足 | +|---|---|---|---| +| `NoMoreHandlerException` | INFO | 404 | 処理すべきアクションが存在しない場合 | +| `HttpErrorResponse` | ログ出力なし | `HttpErrorResponse` のステータスコード | 業務例外（バリデーションエラーなど）のため出力しない | +| `Result.Error` | 設定による（FATAL） | `Error#getStatusCode()` | `writeFailureLogPattern` に設定した正規表現がステータスコードにマッチした場合にFATALログ | +| `StackOverflowError` | FATAL | 500 | データや実装バグに起因するため障害通知 | +| 上記以外 | FATAL | 500 | 予期しない例外として障害扱い | + +`HttpErrorResponse` の原因例外が `ApplicationException`（バリデーションエラーなど）の場合は、ログ出力を行わず、メッセージ情報を `ErrorMessages` に変換してリクエストスコープ（デフォルトキー: `errors`）に設定します。これによりViewでエラーメッセージを表示できます。 + +```xml + + + + +``` + +## 2. エラー画面への遷移先の指定方法 + +遷移先の指定には3つの方法があります。 + +**① アクションメソッドの `@OnError` アノテーション（個別指定）** + +```java +@OnError(type = ApplicationException.class, path = "/WEB-INF/view/project/index.jsp") +public HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest request, ExecutionContext context) { + // 業務処理 +} +``` + +**② カスタムハンドラによる一括定義（システム共通のエラーページ）** + +全アクションに共通の遷移先を設定する場合は、個別のアノテーション指定ではなくハンドラで定義します。漏れや指定ミスを防止できます。 + +```java +public class ExampleErrorForwardHandler implements Handler { + @Override + public Object handle(Object data, ExecutionContext context) { + try { + return context.handleNext(data); + } catch (NoDataException e) { + throw new HttpErrorResponse(404, "/WEB-INF/view/common/errorPages/pageNotFoundError.jsp", e); + } catch (OptimisticLockException e) { + throw new HttpErrorResponse(400, "/WEB-INF/view/common/errorPages/optimisticLockError.jsp", e); + } + } +} +``` + +**③ `HttpErrorHandler` のデフォルトページ設定（ステータスコード別）** + +```xml + + + + + + + + + +``` + +> ただし、③よりも `web.xml` の `` 要素で設定することが推奨されています。`web.xml` に設定しない場合、エラー発生箇所によってはウェブサーバのデフォルトエラーページが表示される可能性があります。 + +## 3. 障害ログの出力方針 + +HTTPエラー制御ハンドラがFATALログとして出力する障害ログは、以下の方針で出力されます。 + +| ログの種類 | ログレベル | ロガー名 | 出力先 | +|---|---|---|---| +| 障害通知ログ | FATAL / ERROR | MONITOR | 監視専用ファイル（monitor.log） | +| 障害解析ログ | FATAL / ERROR | クラス名 | アプリケーションログ（app.log） | + +`app-log.properties` でデフォルトの障害コードとメッセージを設定します。 + +```properties +failureLogFormatter.defaultFailureCode=MSG99999 +failureLogFormatter.defaultMessage=an unexpected exception occurred. +failureLogFormatter.notificationFormat=fail_code = [$failureCode$] $message$ +failureLogFormatter.analysisFormat=fail_code = [$failureCode$] $message$\nInput Data :\n$data$ +``` + +アプリケーションから明示的に障害ログを出力する場合は `FailureLogUtil` を使用します。 + +```java +try { + // 業務処理 +} catch (UserNotFoundException e) { + FailureLogUtil.logError(e, inputData, "USER_NOT_FOUND"); +} +``` + +--- + +**注意点** + +- `@OnError` は1つの例外クラスに対して1つの遷移先しか指定できません。同じ例外クラスで複数の遷移先が必要な場合は、アクションメソッド内で `try-catch` を使用して `HttpErrorResponse` をスローしてください。 +- `HttpErrorHandler` のデフォルトページ設定を使う場合も、`web.xml` 側への設定が必要です（二重設定になりますが必須）。 + +参照: handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json:s4, handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json:s5, handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json:s6, web-application-feature-details.json:s16, web-application-forward-error-page.json:s1, web-application-forward-error-page.json:s2, libraries-failure-log.json:s1, libraries-failure-log.json:s3, handlers-on-error.json:s3 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..bf6438460 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-11", + "description": "Webアプリケーションのエラーハンドリング。HttpErrorHandler + OnError でエラー画面に遷移する仕組みを知りたい。", + "input": "エラーが発生したときにエラー画面を表示したり、ログを出力する仕組みはどうなっている？", + "purpose": "仕組み・動作を理解したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "HttpErrorHandlerが例外種別に応じたステータスコードのレスポンスを返し、ApplicationExceptionのエラーメッセージをリクエストスコープに設定する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The actual output covers both key facts in the expected output: (1) HttpErrorHandler processes exceptions and returns responses with appropriate status codes based on exception type (clearly shown in the table mapping exception classes to HTTP status codes), and (2) ApplicationException error messages are converted to ErrorMessages and set in the request scope (explicitly stated as 'メッセージ情報をErrorMessagesに変換してリクエストスコープ（デフォルトキー: errors）に設定します'). Both expected facts are fully covered." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant, directly addressing the question about error screen display and logging mechanisms when errors occur. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 143233, + "duration_api_ms": 140264, + "num_turns": 16, + "total_cost_usd": 0.8238074000000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 17, + "output_tokens": 8338, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 958713, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 109022 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2030, + "outputTokens": 42, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0022400000000000002, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 17, + "outputTokens": 8338, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 958713, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 109022, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.8215674000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..df0219f35 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 143233, + "duration_api_ms": 140264, + "num_turns": 16, + "total_cost_usd": 0.8238074000000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 17, + "output_tokens": 8338, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 958713, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 109022 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2030, + "outputTokens": 42, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0022400000000000002, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 17, + "outputTokens": 8338, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 958713, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 109022, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.8215674000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8604d9602 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 143233, + "duration_api_ms": 140264, + "ttft_ms": 4700, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3812, + "time_to_request_ms": 2161, + "num_turns": 16, + "result": "収集した情報を元に回答を生成します。\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**\n\nウェブアプリケーションのエラー処理は、主に **HTTPエラー制御ハンドラ**（`HttpErrorHandler`）がハンドラキュー上で例外を捕捉し、例外の種類に応じたログ出力とエラー画面へのレスポンス生成を行う仕組みになっています。エラー画面への遷移先は `@OnError` インターセプタやハンドラで定義します。\n\n---\n\n**根拠**\n\n## 1. HTTPエラー制御ハンドラによる例外処理とログ出力\n\n`HttpErrorHandler` がハンドラキューの後続で発生した例外を捕捉し、例外の種類に応じて以下のように処理します。\n\n| 例外クラス | ログレベル | HTTPステータス | 補足 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| `NoMoreHandlerException` | INFO | 404 | 処理すべきアクションが存在しない場合 |\n| `HttpErrorResponse` | ログ出力なし | `HttpErrorResponse` のステータスコード | 業務例外（バリデーションエラーなど）のため出力しない |\n| `Result.Error` | 設定による（FATAL） | `Error#getStatusCode()` | `writeFailureLogPattern` に設定した正規表現がステータスコードにマッチした場合にFATALログ |\n| `StackOverflowError` | FATAL | 500 | データや実装バグに起因するため障害通知 |\n| 上記以外 | FATAL | 500 | 予期しない例外として障害扱い |\n\n`HttpErrorResponse` の原因例外が `ApplicationException`（バリデーションエラーなど）の場合は、ログ出力を行わず、メッセージ情報を `ErrorMessages` に変換してリクエストスコープ（デフォルトキー: `errors`）に設定します。これによりViewでエラーメッセージを表示できます。\n\n```xml\n\n\n \n\n```\n\n## 2. エラー画面への遷移先の指定方法\n\n遷移先の指定には3つの方法があります。\n\n**① アクションメソッドの `@OnError` アノテーション（個別指定）**\n\n```java\n@OnError(type = ApplicationException.class, path = \"/WEB-INF/view/project/index.jsp\")\npublic HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest request, ExecutionContext context) {\n // 業務処理\n}\n```\n\n**② カスタムハンドラによる一括定義（システム共通のエラーページ）**\n\n全アクションに共通の遷移先を設定する場合は、個別のアノテーション指定ではなくハンドラで定義します。漏れや指定ミスを防止できます。\n\n```java\npublic class ExampleErrorForwardHandler implements Handler {\n @Override\n public Object handle(Object data, ExecutionContext context) {\n try {\n return context.handleNext(data);\n } catch (NoDataException e) {\n throw new HttpErrorResponse(404, \"/WEB-INF/view/common/errorPages/pageNotFoundError.jsp\", e);\n } catch (OptimisticLockException e) {\n throw new HttpErrorResponse(400, \"/WEB-INF/view/common/errorPages/optimisticLockError.jsp\", e);\n }\n }\n}\n```\n\n**③ `HttpErrorHandler` のデフォルトページ設定（ステータスコード別）**\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n\n```\n\n> ただし、③よりも `web.xml` の `` 要素で設定することが推奨されています。`web.xml` に設定しない場合、エラー発生箇所によってはウェブサーバのデフォルトエラーページが表示される可能性があります。\n\n## 3. 障害ログの出力方針\n\nHTTPエラー制御ハンドラがFATALログとして出力する障害ログは、以下の方針で出力されます。\n\n| ログの種類 | ログレベル | ロガー名 | 出力先 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| 障害通知ログ | FATAL / ERROR | MONITOR | 監視専用ファイル（monitor.log） |\n| 障害解析ログ | FATAL / ERROR | クラス名 | アプリケーションログ（app.log） |\n\n`app-log.properties` でデフォルトの障害コードとメッセージを設定します。\n\n```properties\nfailureLogFormatter.defaultFailureCode=MSG99999\nfailureLogFormatter.defaultMessage=an unexpected exception occurred.\nfailureLogFormatter.notificationFormat=fail_code = [$failureCode$] $message$\nfailureLogFormatter.analysisFormat=fail_code = [$failureCode$] $message$\\nInput Data :\\n$data$\n```\n\nアプリケーションから明示的に障害ログを出力する場合は `FailureLogUtil` を使用します。\n\n```java\ntry {\n // 業務処理\n} catch (UserNotFoundException e) {\n FailureLogUtil.logError(e, inputData, \"USER_NOT_FOUND\");\n}\n```\n\n---\n\n**注意点**\n\n- `@OnError` は1つの例外クラスに対して1つの遷移先しか指定できません。同じ例外クラスで複数の遷移先が必要な場合は、アクションメソッド内で `try-catch` を使用して `HttpErrorResponse` をスローしてください。\n- `HttpErrorHandler` のデフォルトページ設定を使う場合も、`web.xml` 側への設定が必要です（二重設定になりますが必須）。\n\n参照: handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json:s4, handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json:s5, handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json:s6, web-application-feature-details.json:s16, web-application-forward-error-page.json:s1, web-application-forward-error-page.json:s2, libraries-failure-log.json:s1, libraries-failure-log.json:s3, handlers-on-error.json:s3\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"failure-log\", \"log\", \"http-access-log\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-http-access-log-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s19\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s28\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-access-log-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/adapters/adapters-log-adaptor.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-operator-notice-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-progress-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-integration-doma-NablarchJdbcLogger.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"NG\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": true,\n \"selected_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-global-error-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-global-error-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-on-error.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-on-error.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-on-error.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "200d39e7-b08a-41a6-9826-0a6a0846600b", + "total_cost_usd": 0.8238074000000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 17, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 109022, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 958713, + "output_tokens": 8338, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 109022 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 2030, + "outputTokens": 42, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0022400000000000002, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 17, + "outputTokens": 8338, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 958713, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 109022, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.8215674000000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_013ng6zucgAQ6Kbacm6HHpFt", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for page title lookup" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "a2c9ed87-38de-4271-a09c-2fe028a76cf2" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..d8af81cdb --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-11/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,208 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "failure-log", + "log", + "http-access-log" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-http-access-log-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s19", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s28", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-access-log-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/adapters/adapters-log-adaptor.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s20", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-log.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-operator-notice-log.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-progress-log.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-integration-doma-NablarchJdbcLogger.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "NG" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": true, + "selected_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-global-error-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-global-error-handler.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "partial" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json", + "section_id": "s1", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json", + "section_id": "s1", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-on-error.json", + "section_id": "s3", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-on-error.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "partial" + } + ] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json", + "section_id": "s5" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-HttpErrorHandler.json", + "section_id": "s6" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s16" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json", + "section_id": "s1" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-forward-error-page.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json", + "section_id": "s1" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-failure-log.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-on-error.json", + "section_id": "s3" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..86ab246c2 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,93 @@ +**結論**: ウェブアプリケーションでは、`@InjectForm` + `@OnError` アノテーションでバリデーションエラー時の遷移先を指定し、JSP側で `` カスタムタグを使ってエラーメッセージを表示します。エラーメッセージ本文は `messages.properties` に定義します。 + +--- + +**根拠**: + +**① メッセージをプロパティファイルに定義する** + +`messages.properties` にメッセージIDとメッセージ文字列を定義します。 + +```properties +# Bean Validationアノテーションに対応したメッセージ +nablarch.core.validation.ee.Length.max.message={max}文字以内で入力してください。 +nablarch.core.validation.ee.Required.message=必ず入力してください。 + +# 業務ロジック内で使用するメッセージ +errors.login.alreadyExist=入力されたログインIDは既に登録されています。別のログインIDを入力してください。 +``` + +**② コンポーネント設定ファイルに BeanValidationStrategy を定義する** + +```xml + +``` + +**③ アクションに @InjectForm と @OnError を設定する** + +`@OnError` でバリデーションエラー時の遷移先を指定しないと、エラーがシステムエラー扱いになるため必須です。 + +```java +@InjectForm(form = UserForm.class, prefix = "form", validate = "register") +@OnError(type = ApplicationException.class, path = "forward://registerForm.jsp") +public HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest req, ExecutionContext ctx) { + // バリデーション成功後の処理 + UserForm form = ctx.getRequestScopedVar("form"); + // ... +} +``` + +**④ JSP で `` タグを使ってエラーメッセージを表示する** + +バリデーションエラーがあると `@OnError` で指定した画面に遷移し、`` タグがエラーメッセージを表示します。 + +```jsp +<%@ taglib prefix="n" uri="http://tis.co.jp/nablarch" %> + + +
+ + + +
+
+ + + +
+ + +``` + +**⑤ 業務ロジック内でエラーを返したい場合（特定項目への紐付け）** + +アクション内でデータベースとの相関チェックなど手動でエラーを発生させる場合は、`ValidationUtil.createMessageForProperty` と `ApplicationException` を使います。 + +```java +throw new ApplicationException( + ValidationUtil.createMessageForProperty("form.mailAddress", "duplicate.mailAddress")); +``` + +メッセージIDのみで特定項目に紐付けない場合は `MessageUtil` を使います。 + +```java +Message message = MessageUtil.createMessage(MessageLevel.ERROR, "errors.login.alreadyExist"); +throw new ApplicationException(message); +``` + +--- + +**注意点**: +- `@OnError` を設定しないとバリデーションエラーがシステムエラー扱いになるため、必ず設定すること +- `BeanValidationStrategy` を `validationStrategy` という名前でコンポーネント定義することが必須 +- `` の `name` 属性には、対応する入力項目の `name` 属性と同じ値（例: `form.userId`）を指定する + +参照: +- `libraries-bean-validation.json:s7` +- `libraries-bean-validation.json:s16` +- `handlers-InjectForm.json:s3` +- `handlers-InjectForm.json:s4` +- `libraries-tag.json:s8` +- `libraries-bean-validation.json:s13` +- `libraries-message.json:s7` +- `libraries-message.json:s9` \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..1feced8ec --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-12", + "description": "Webアプリケーションでバリデーションエラー時のレスポンス。エラーメッセージをリクエストスコープに設定して入力画面に戻す。", + "input": "入力チェックでエラーがあったときに、エラーメッセージをユーザーに返す方法を教えてほしい", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "エラー表示タグでリクエストスコープのエラーメッセージを表示する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 0.6, + "reason": "The Expected Output states a single fact: 'エラー表示タグでリクエストスコープのエラーメッセージを表示する' (display error messages in request scope using error display tags). The Actual Output does cover this concept — it explains using `` custom tags in JSP to display validation error messages, which corresponds to using error display tags to show request-scoped error messages. However, the Actual Output goes far beyond this single expected fact with extensive additional detail about message properties files, BeanValidationStrategy configuration, @InjectForm/@OnError annotations, and manual exception throwing. The core expected fact is addressed, but the specific phrasing about 'リクエストスコープ' (request scope) is not explicitly mentioned in the Actual Output." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant, directly addressing how to return error messages to users when input validation errors occur. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 173164, + "duration_api_ms": 172586, + "num_turns": 31, + "total_cost_usd": 0.8103508500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 31, + "output_tokens": 9602, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1593007, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 49645 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1982, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0021569999999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 31, + "outputTokens": 9602, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1593007, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 49645, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.8081938500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..7ed07ef44 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 173164, + "duration_api_ms": 172586, + "num_turns": 31, + "total_cost_usd": 0.8103508500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 31, + "output_tokens": 9602, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1593007, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 49645 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1982, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0021569999999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 31, + "outputTokens": 9602, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1593007, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 49645, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.8081938500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..58c2fee19 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 173164, + "duration_api_ms": 172586, + "ttft_ms": 5686, + "ttft_stream_ms": 4305, + "time_to_request_ms": 2103, + "num_turns": 31, + "result": "回答を生成します。\n\n収集したセクション内容をもとに、ウェブアプリケーションにおけるバリデーションエラー時のエラーメッセージ返却方法を整理します。\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: ウェブアプリケーションでは、`@InjectForm` + `@OnError` アノテーションでバリデーションエラー時の遷移先を指定し、JSP側で `` カスタムタグを使ってエラーメッセージを表示します。エラーメッセージ本文は `messages.properties` に定義します。\n\n---\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**① メッセージをプロパティファイルに定義する**\n\n`messages.properties` にメッセージIDとメッセージ文字列を定義します。\n\n```properties\n# Bean Validationアノテーションに対応したメッセージ\nnablarch.core.validation.ee.Length.max.message={max}文字以内で入力してください。\nnablarch.core.validation.ee.Required.message=必ず入力してください。\n\n# 業務ロジック内で使用するメッセージ\nerrors.login.alreadyExist=入力されたログインIDは既に登録されています。別のログインIDを入力してください。\n```\n\n**② コンポーネント設定ファイルに BeanValidationStrategy を定義する**\n\n```xml\n\n```\n\n**③ アクションに @InjectForm と @OnError を設定する**\n\n`@OnError` でバリデーションエラー時の遷移先を指定しないと、エラーがシステムエラー扱いになるため必須です。\n\n```java\n@InjectForm(form = UserForm.class, prefix = \"form\", validate = \"register\")\n@OnError(type = ApplicationException.class, path = \"forward://registerForm.jsp\")\npublic HttpResponse handle(HttpRequest req, ExecutionContext ctx) {\n // バリデーション成功後の処理\n UserForm form = ctx.getRequestScopedVar(\"form\");\n // ...\n}\n```\n\n**④ JSP で `` タグを使ってエラーメッセージを表示する**\n\nバリデーションエラーがあると `@OnError` で指定した画面に遷移し、`` タグがエラーメッセージを表示します。\n\n```jsp\n<%@ taglib prefix=\"n\" uri=\"http://tis.co.jp/nablarch\" %>\n\n\n
\n \n \n \n
\n
\n \n \n \n
\n \n\n```\n\n**⑤ 業務ロジック内でエラーを返したい場合（特定項目への紐付け）**\n\nアクション内でデータベースとの相関チェックなど手動でエラーを発生させる場合は、`ValidationUtil.createMessageForProperty` と `ApplicationException` を使います。\n\n```java\nthrow new ApplicationException(\n ValidationUtil.createMessageForProperty(\"form.mailAddress\", \"duplicate.mailAddress\"));\n```\n\nメッセージIDのみで特定項目に紐付けない場合は `MessageUtil` を使います。\n\n```java\nMessage message = MessageUtil.createMessage(MessageLevel.ERROR, \"errors.login.alreadyExist\");\nthrow new ApplicationException(message);\n```\n\n---\n\n**注意点**:\n- `@OnError` を設定しないとバリデーションエラーがシステムエラー扱いになるため、必ず設定すること\n- `BeanValidationStrategy` を `validationStrategy` という名前でコンポーネント定義することが必須\n- `` の `name` 属性には、対応する入力項目の `name` 属性と同じ値（例: `form.userId`）を指定する\n\n参照:\n- `libraries-bean-validation.json:s7`\n- `libraries-bean-validation.json:s16`\n- `handlers-InjectForm.json:s3`\n- `handlers-InjectForm.json:s4`\n- `libraries-tag.json:s8`\n- `libraries-bean-validation.json:s13`\n- `libraries-message.json:s7`\n- `libraries-message.json:s9`\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"bean-validation\", \"nablarch-validation\", \"message\", \"tag\", \"validation\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-code.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s20\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json\", \"section_id\": \"s18\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s25\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s10\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s3\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-tag.json\", \"section_id\": \"s8\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s13\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-message.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "cb7db456-79f9-4804-ad4d-353c3c7052a4", + "total_cost_usd": 0.8103508500000001, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 31, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 49645, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1593007, + "output_tokens": 9602, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 49645 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1982, + "outputTokens": 35, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.0021569999999999996, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 31, + "outputTokens": 9602, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1593007, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 49645, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.8081938500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01GZngpu9eKu4FZUUw7sk12P", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md 2>/dev/null | head -100", + "description": "Read FTS hints file for BM25 term extraction" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01BTEMNxAN7t6TcBfyLZtFfp", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null", + "description": "Find fts-hints.md file" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01Fm6yGJYgBJSxmQkFoPmwRU", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash scripts/bm25-search.sh bean-validation nablarch-validation message tag validation 2>/dev/null | python3 -c \"import json,sys; data=json.load(sys.stdin); [print(d['file'], d['section_id'], d['score']) for d in data[:20]]\"", + "description": "Get top 20 BM25 results" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "a8d5a2b1-352e-4ee3-8a38-f049712021e5" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..de5925ef4 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-12/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,160 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "bean-validation", + "nablarch-validation", + "message", + "tag", + "validation" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-code.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/testing-framework/testing-framework-01-entityUnitTestWithBeanValidation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-data-bind.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s20", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "development-tools/toolbox/toolbox-NablarchOpenApiGenerator.json", + "section_id": "s18", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s25", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-nablarch-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s10", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s16" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s3" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-InjectForm.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-tag.json", + "section_id": "s8" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s13" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s7" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-message.json", + "section_id": "s9" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..c21b1a626 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,49 @@ +**結論**: RESTfulウェブサービスでフォームデータをDBに登録するには、フォームクラスを作成し、リソース（アクション）クラスで `@POST` + `@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)` + `@Valid` を組み合わせたメソッドを実装して、`BeanUtil.createAndCopy` でフォームをエンティティに変換後、`UniversalDao.insert` でDBに登録する。 + +**根拠**: + +**① フォームクラスの作成** + +クライアントから送信されたJSON値を受け付けるフォームを作成する。 + +```java +public class ProjectForm implements Serializable { + + @Required + @Domain("projectName") + private String projectName; + + // ゲッタ及びセッタは省略 +} +``` + +**② 業務アクションメソッドの実装** + +```java +@Path("/projects") +public class ProjectAction { + + @POST + @Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON) + @Valid + public HttpResponse save(ProjectForm project) { + UniversalDao.insert(BeanUtil.createAndCopy(Project.class, project)); + return new HttpResponse(HttpResponse.Status.CREATED.getStatusCode()); + } +} +``` + +実装のポイント: +- `@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)` でJSON形式のリクエストを受け付ける +- `@Valid` アノテーションでリクエストのバリデーションを実行する（Jakarta RESTful Web Services Bean Validationハンドラが処理） +- `BeanUtil.createAndCopy` でフォームをエンティティクラスに変換する +- `UniversalDao.insert` でエンティティをDBに登録する +- 戻り値にはリソース作成完了（ステータスコード `201`）を表す `HttpResponse` を返却する +- `@Path` + `@POST` でURLとのマッピングを定義する + +**注意点**: + +- フォームのプロパティは**全てString型**で宣言する（バリデーション・型変換の都合上） +- バリデーションエラー時のレスポンスはJakarta RESTful Web Services Bean Validationハンドラが自動で返却する + +参照: restful-web-service-getting-started-create.json:s1, handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json:s4 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..848efe594 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,60 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-13", + "description": "REST APIでフォームから受け取ったデータをDBに登録する処理を実装したい。", + "input": "フォームから受け取ったデータをDBに登録する処理の実装パターンを知りたい", + "purpose": "実装したい", + "expected_facts": [ + "REST APIではFormクラスで値を受け付け、@Validでバリデーション後にUniversalDao.insertで登録する" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output covers all key facts present in the Expected Output: using a Form class to receive values, applying @Valid for validation, and using UniversalDao.insert for registration. Additionally, the Actual Output provides detailed implementation examples and annotations (@POST, @Consumes, BeanUtil.createAndCopy) that support and expand on the expected facts without contradicting any of them. Full coverage of expected facts is achieved." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the response is perfectly relevant to the input, directly addressing the implementation patterns for registering form data into a database. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 312433, + "duration_api_ms": 307032, + "num_turns": 31, + "total_cost_usd": 1.1392308999999998, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 26, + "output_tokens": 19856, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1467853, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 106360 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1902, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002107, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 26, + "outputTokens": 19856, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1467853, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 106360, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 1.1371239, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..5cf76fadc --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 312433, + "duration_api_ms": 307032, + "num_turns": 31, + "total_cost_usd": 1.1392308999999998, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 26, + "output_tokens": 19856, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1467853, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 106360 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1902, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002107, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 26, + "outputTokens": 19856, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1467853, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 106360, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 1.1371239, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..175753b09 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 312433, + "duration_api_ms": 307032, + "ttft_ms": 6256, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3824, + "time_to_request_ms": 2488, + "num_turns": 31, + "result": "これで必要な情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n**BM25検索整理**:\n- fts-hintsから抽出したターム: `universal-dao`、`UniversalDao`、`create-example`\n- 最初のBM25検索で上位20件にRESTful登録機能セクションは含まれていない\n- check-answerable: NG（universal-dao ライブラリドキュメントは含まれるが、RESTful固有の実装パターンなし）\n- セマンティック検索相当の探索で `restful-web-service-getting-started-create.json:s1` を発見\n\n答案を生成し、verifyを実行します（読み込み済みのsections_contentから確認します）:\n\n全クレームの検証：\n- `@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)` → getting-started-create:s1 に記載 ✅\n- `@Valid` アノテーションでバリデーション → getting-started-create:s1 / jaxrs-bean-validation-handler:s4 に記載 ✅\n- `BeanUtil.createAndCopy` でエンティティに変換 → getting-started-create:s1 に記載 ✅\n- `UniversalDao.insert` でDB登録 → getting-started-create:s1 に記載 ✅\n- `@Path` / `@POST` でURLマッピング → getting-started-create:s1 に記載 ✅\n- ステータスコード 201 → getting-started-create:s1 に記載 ✅\n- フォームのプロパティは全てString型 → getting-started-create:s1 に記載 ✅\n\nverify: **PASS**\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: RESTfulウェブサービスでフォームデータをDBに登録するには、フォームクラスを作成し、リソース（アクション）クラスで `@POST` + `@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)` + `@Valid` を組み合わせたメソッドを実装して、`BeanUtil.createAndCopy` でフォームをエンティティに変換後、`UniversalDao.insert` でDBに登録する。\n\n**根拠**:\n\n**① フォームクラスの作成**\n\nクライアントから送信されたJSON値を受け付けるフォームを作成する。\n\n```java\npublic class ProjectForm implements Serializable {\n\n @Required\n @Domain(\"projectName\")\n private String projectName;\n\n // ゲッタ及びセッタは省略\n}\n```\n\n**② 業務アクションメソッドの実装**\n\n```java\n@Path(\"/projects\")\npublic class ProjectAction {\n\n @POST\n @Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)\n @Valid\n public HttpResponse save(ProjectForm project) {\n UniversalDao.insert(BeanUtil.createAndCopy(Project.class, project));\n return new HttpResponse(HttpResponse.Status.CREATED.getStatusCode());\n }\n}\n```\n\n実装のポイント:\n- `@Consumes(MediaType.APPLICATION_JSON)` でJSON形式のリクエストを受け付ける\n- `@Valid` アノテーションでリクエストのバリデーションを実行する（Jakarta RESTful Web Services Bean Validationハンドラが処理）\n- `BeanUtil.createAndCopy` でフォームをエンティティクラスに変換する\n- `UniversalDao.insert` でエンティティをDBに登録する\n- 戻り値にはリソース作成完了（ステータスコード `201`）を表す `HttpResponse` を返却する\n- `@Path` + `@POST` でURLとのマッピングを定義する\n\n**注意点**:\n\n- フォームのプロパティは**全てString型**で宣言する（バリデーション・型変換の都合上）\n- バリデーションエラー時のレスポンスはJakarta RESTful Web Services Bean Validationハンドラが自動で返却する\n\n参照: restful-web-service-getting-started-create.json:s1, handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json:s4\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"universal-dao\", \"UniversalDao\", \"create-example\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s12\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s14\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/db-messaging/db-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/mom-messaging/mom-messaging-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s15\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s24\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s16\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s11\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-getting-started-chunk.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json\", \"section_id\": \"s7\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"NG\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": true,\n \"selected_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-getting-started-create.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"partial\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-getting-started-create.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json\", \"section_id\": \"s4\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json\", \"section_id\": \"s17\"},\n {\"file\": \"component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "e9f678be-b349-4782-b5c8-0014a1c069d3", + "total_cost_usd": 1.1392308999999998, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 26, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 106360, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 1467853, + "output_tokens": 19856, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 106360 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1902, + "outputTokens": 41, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.002107, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 26, + "outputTokens": 19856, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 1467853, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 106360, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 1.1371239, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_019Scv5ZaAYseePjZQ4DxKpC", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/ 2>/dev/null || ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/", + "description": "List scripts directory" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01AtDb8Wf6cVMm2E9kezfr1P", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md | head -100", + "description": "Read FTS hints file" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_014zpMGaRCJ5NT5Ey32oMnd3", + "tool_input": { + "command": "find /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search -name \"fts-hints.md\" 2>/dev/null", + "description": "Find fts-hints.md" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "b030e621-c68d-470c-b6f9-d62e0b90ff81" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..02fc8d8c2 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-13/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,163 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "universal-dao", + "UniversalDao", + "create-example" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s12", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s14", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/web-application/web-application-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/http-messaging/http-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/db-messaging/db-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/mom-messaging/mom-messaging-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s15", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s24", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s16", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-authorization-permission-check.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s11", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-getting-started-chunk.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "javadoc/javadoc-nablarch-common-dao-UniversalDao.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "guide/biz-samples/biz-samples-03.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "processing-pattern/jakarta-batch/jakarta-batch-feature-details.json", + "section_id": "s7", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "NG" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": true, + "selected_sections": [ + { + "file": "processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-getting-started-create.json", + "section_id": "s1", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17", + "relevance": "partial" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "partial" + } + ] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "processing-pattern/restful-web-service/restful-web-service-getting-started-create.json", + "section_id": "s1" + }, + { + "file": "component/handlers/handlers-jaxrs-bean-validation-handler.json", + "section_id": "s4" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-bean-validation.json", + "section_id": "s17" + }, + { + "file": "component/libraries/libraries-universal-dao.json", + "section_id": "s5" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..51ffa3a13 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,72 @@ +**結論**: Nablarch 5から6へのバージョンアップ時、Jakarta EE 10対応として必要なアプリケーションへの変更は主に4点です。(1) Java EEの依存関係をJakarta EEに変更、(2) `javax.*` 名前空間を `jakarta.*` に置換、(3) XMLファイルのスキーマ指定をJakarta EE 10のスキーマに変更、(4) JSPのタグライブラリネームスペースを変更。また、Jakarta EE 10に対応したアプリケーションサーバへの移行が必要です。 + +**根拠**: + +Jakarta EE 9から名前空間が `javax.*` から `jakarta.*` に変更されており、後方互換性が維持されません。そのため以下の対応がすべて必要となります。 + +**① Java EEの依存関係をJakarta EEに変更する（pom.xml）** + +Java EE APIの`dependency`をJakarta EE対応のものに変更します。バージョン管理にはJakarta EE BOMの利用が推奨されています。 + +```xml + + + + jakarta.platform + jakarta.jakartaee-bom + 10.0.0 + pom + import + + + +``` + +**② javax名前空間をjakarta名前空間に変更する（Javaソースコード・設定ファイル・JSP）** + +`import`文のコンパイルエラー箇所を修正した後、プロジェクト全体を `javax` でGrep検索し、Java EEの名前空間である箇所を `jakarta` に置換します。 + +```java +// 修正前 +import javax.validation.ConstraintValidator; + +// 修正後 +import jakarta.validation.ConstraintValidator; +``` + +なお、`javax.crypto.SecretKeyFactory` のような標準ライブラリの `javax` は変更不要です。Java EEの名前空間かどうかは、ガイド末尾の「Java EEとJakarta EEの仕様の対応表」を参照してください。 + +**③ XMLスキーマ指定をJakarta EE 10のスキーマに変更する（web.xml等）** + +```xml + + + + + +``` + +**④ タグライブラリのネームスペースをJakarta EE 10のネームスペースに変更する（JSP）** + +```jsp +<%-- 修正前 --%> +<%@ taglib prefix="c" uri="http://java.sun.com/jsp/jstl/core" %> + +<%-- 修正後 --%> +<%@ taglib prefix="c" uri="jakarta.tags.core" %> +``` + +**注意点**: +- 変更対象の`dependency`は `groupId` 等から機械的に判断できないため、含まれるクラスや `artifactId` から個別に判断が必要です。 +- `javax` のGrep検索は、コンパイルエラーにならないJSPや設定ファイルにも漏れが生じやすいため、プロジェクト全体を対象に実施してください。 +- プロジェクトによっては不要な手順がある場合があります（例：ウェブ固有の手順はバッチプロジェクトでは不要）。 + +参照: migration-migration.json:s2, migration-migration.json:s5, migration-migration.json:s9, migration-migration.json:s26, migration-migration.json:s27, migration-migration.json:s28, migration-migration.json:s33, releases-nablarch6-releasenote-6.json:s2 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/evaluation.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/evaluation.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8d99d8213 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/evaluation.json @@ -0,0 +1,61 @@ +{ + "scenario_id": "qa-14", + "description": "Nablarch 5から6にバージョンアップする際に、Jakarta EE 10対応でアプリケーションに影響がないか調べたい。パッケージ名の変更など後方互換に影響する変更点を知りたい。", + "input": "Nablarch 5からNablarch 6にバージョンアップするとき、Jakarta EE 10対応でアプリケーションに影響がある変更は何か？", + "purpose": "バージョンアップしたい", + "expected_facts": [ + "Jakarta EE 10に対応しており、Jakarta EE 10対応のアプリケーションサーバで動作させる必要がある", + "Java EEの仕様名およびパッケージ名がJakarta EEのものに変更されている" + ], + "scores": { + "answer_correctness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The Actual Output covers both facts from the Expected Output. It explicitly mentions that Jakarta EE 10 compatible application servers are required ('Jakarta EE 10に対応したアプリケーションサーバへの移行が必要'), addressing the first expected fact. It also thoroughly covers the second fact about Java EE specification names and package names being changed to Jakarta EE equivalents, explaining the namespace change from `javax.*` to `jakarta.*` with detailed code examples. Both key facts are present and not contradicted." + }, + "answer_relevancy": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is fully relevant to the question about changes affecting applications when upgrading from Nablarch 5 to Nablarch 6 with Jakarta EE 10 support. No irrelevant statements were found!" + }, + "faithfulness": { + "score": 1.0, + "reason": "The score is 1.00 because the actual output is perfectly faithful to the retrieval context with no contradictions found!" + } + }, + "diagnostics": { + "search_sections": [] + }, + "metrics": { + "duration_ms": 157896, + "duration_api_ms": 154984, + "num_turns": 20, + "total_cost_usd": 0.5553177499999999, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 19, + "output_tokens": 10360, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 825965, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39971 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1950, + "outputTokens": 46, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00218, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 19, + "outputTokens": 10360, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 825965, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39971, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.5531377500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/metrics.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/metrics.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..8888df398 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/metrics.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "duration_ms": 157896, + "duration_api_ms": 154984, + "num_turns": 20, + "total_cost_usd": 0.5553177499999999, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 19, + "output_tokens": 10360, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 825965, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39971 + }, + "model_usage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1950, + "outputTokens": 46, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00218, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 19, + "outputTokens": 10360, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 825965, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39971, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.5531377500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/trace.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/trace.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..828c0a9a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/trace.json @@ -0,0 +1,82 @@ +{ + "type": "result", + "subtype": "success", + "is_error": false, + "api_error_status": null, + "duration_ms": 157896, + "duration_api_ms": 154984, + "ttft_ms": 4938, + "ttft_stream_ms": 3631, + "time_to_request_ms": 2215, + "num_turns": 20, + "result": "十分な情報が揃いました。回答を生成します。\n\n**処理方式**: null（全般的な移行ガイドに関する質問）\n**目的**: バージョンアップしたい\n\n---\n\n### Answer\n\n**結論**: Nablarch 5から6へのバージョンアップ時、Jakarta EE 10対応として必要なアプリケーションへの変更は主に4点です。(1) Java EEの依存関係をJakarta EEに変更、(2) `javax.*` 名前空間を `jakarta.*` に置換、(3) XMLファイルのスキーマ指定をJakarta EE 10のスキーマに変更、(4) JSPのタグライブラリネームスペースを変更。また、Jakarta EE 10に対応したアプリケーションサーバへの移行が必要です。\n\n**根拠**:\n\nJakarta EE 9から名前空間が `javax.*` から `jakarta.*` に変更されており、後方互換性が維持されません。そのため以下の対応がすべて必要となります。\n\n**① Java EEの依存関係をJakarta EEに変更する（pom.xml）**\n\nJava EE APIの`dependency`をJakarta EE対応のものに変更します。バージョン管理にはJakarta EE BOMの利用が推奨されています。\n\n```xml\n\n \n \n jakarta.platform\n jakarta.jakartaee-bom\n 10.0.0\n pom\n import\n \n \n\n```\n\n**② javax名前空間をjakarta名前空間に変更する（Javaソースコード・設定ファイル・JSP）**\n\n`import`文のコンパイルエラー箇所を修正した後、プロジェクト全体を `javax` でGrep検索し、Java EEの名前空間である箇所を `jakarta` に置換します。\n\n```java\n// 修正前\nimport javax.validation.ConstraintValidator;\n\n// 修正後\nimport jakarta.validation.ConstraintValidator;\n```\n\nなお、`javax.crypto.SecretKeyFactory` のような標準ライブラリの `javax` は変更不要です。Java EEの名前空間かどうかは、ガイド末尾の「Java EEとJakarta EEの仕様の対応表」を参照してください。\n\n**③ XMLスキーマ指定をJakarta EE 10のスキーマに変更する（web.xml等）**\n\n```xml\n\n\n\n\n\n```\n\n**④ タグライブラリのネームスペースをJakarta EE 10のネームスペースに変更する（JSP）**\n\n```jsp\n<%-- 修正前 --%>\n<%@ taglib prefix=\"c\" uri=\"http://java.sun.com/jsp/jstl/core\" %>\n\n<%-- 修正後 --%>\n<%@ taglib prefix=\"c\" uri=\"jakarta.tags.core\" %>\n```\n\n**注意点**:\n- 変更対象の`dependency`は `groupId` 等から機械的に判断できないため、含まれるクラスや `artifactId` から個別に判断が必要です。\n- `javax` のGrep検索は、コンパイルエラーにならないJSPや設定ファイルにも漏れが生じやすいため、プロジェクト全体を対象に実施してください。\n- プロジェクトによっては不要な手順がある場合があります（例：ウェブ固有の手順はバッチプロジェクトでは不要）。\n\n参照: migration-migration.json:s2, migration-migration.json:s5, migration-migration.json:s9, migration-migration.json:s26, migration-migration.json:s27, migration-migration.json:s28, migration-migration.json:s33, releases-nablarch6-releasenote-6.json:s2\n\n<<>>\n```json\n{\n \"step2\": {\n \"bm25_terms\": [\"Jakarta\", \"EE\", \"migration\"],\n \"bm25_sections\": [\n {\"file\": \"about/about-nablarch/about-nablarch-jakarta-ee.json\", \"section_id\": \"s1\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s33\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2（5u25からの変更点）.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s28\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6-releasenote-6.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json\", \"section_id\": \"s39\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2（5u25からの変更点）.json\", \"section_id\": \"s50\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s27\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s6\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\", \"relevance\": \"high\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s26\", \"relevance\": \"high\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step3\": {\n \"check_answerable_result\": \"OK\"\n },\n \"step4\": {\n \"ran\": false,\n \"selected_sections\": []\n },\n \"step5\": {\n \"sections_used\": [\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s5\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s9\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s26\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s27\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s28\"},\n {\"file\": \"about/migration/migration-migration.json\", \"section_id\": \"s33\"},\n {\"file\": \"releases/releases/releases-nablarch6-releasenote-6.json\", \"section_id\": \"s2\"}\n ]\n },\n \"step6\": {\n \"verify_result\": \"PASS\",\n \"regenerated\": false\n }\n}\n```\n<<>>", + "stop_reason": "end_turn", + "session_id": "6c88717e-13ce-448d-81f4-52aba2e58039", + "total_cost_usd": 0.5553177499999999, + "usage": { + "input_tokens": 19, + "cache_creation_input_tokens": 39971, + "cache_read_input_tokens": 825965, + "output_tokens": 10360, + "server_tool_use": { + "web_search_requests": 0, + "web_fetch_requests": 0 + }, + "service_tier": "standard", + "cache_creation": { + "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, + "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 39971 + }, + "inference_geo": "", + "iterations": [], + "speed": "standard" + }, + "modelUsage": { + "jp.anthropic.claude-haiku-4-5-20251001-v1:0": { + "inputTokens": 1950, + "outputTokens": 46, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 0, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 0, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.00218, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + }, + "jp.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6": { + "inputTokens": 19, + "outputTokens": 10360, + "cacheReadInputTokens": 825965, + "cacheCreationInputTokens": 39971, + "webSearchRequests": 0, + "costUSD": 0.5531377500000001, + "contextWindow": 200000, + "maxOutputTokens": 32000 + } + }, + "permission_denials": [ + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01FEuB9vvbzaVHF9jrfSVU2X", + "tool_input": { + "command": "cat /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/fts-hints.md" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_01T9JaSYtT2ix4MJ4JokZRoZ", + "tool_input": { + "command": "ls /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/scripts/" + } + }, + { + "tool_name": "Bash", + "tool_use_id": "toolu_bdrk_018nw7gXfGNjCtGehNowhDxk", + "tool_input": { + "command": "bash /home/tie303177/work/nabledge-dev/.claude/worktrees/text-search/.claude/skills/nabledge-6/scripts/bm25-search.sh Jakarta EE 2>&1 | python3 -c \"\nimport json, sys\ndata = json.load(sys.stdin)\nprint(json.dumps(data[:20], ensure_ascii=False, indent=2))\n\"" + } + } + ], + "terminal_reason": "completed", + "fast_mode_state": "off", + "uuid": "57faba5b-b041-48db-860f-7112fb8e6589" +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/workflow_details.json b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/workflow_details.json new file mode 100644 index 000000000..38593f262 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-14/workflow_details.json @@ -0,0 +1,123 @@ +{ + "step2": { + "bm25_terms": [ + "Jakarta", + "EE", + "migration" + ], + "bm25_sections": [ + { + "file": "about/about-nablarch/about-nablarch-jakarta-ee.json", + "section_id": "s1", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s33", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2（5u25からの変更点）.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s28", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6-releasenote-6.json", + "section_id": "s2", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2 (6u1からの変更点).json", + "section_id": "s39", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6u2-releasenote-6u2（5u25からの変更点）.json", + "section_id": "s50", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s5", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s27", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s6", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s9", + "relevance": "high" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s26", + "relevance": "high" + } + ] + }, + "step3": { + "check_answerable_result": "OK" + }, + "step4": { + "ran": false, + "selected_sections": [] + }, + "step5": { + "sections_used": [ + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s2" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s5" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s9" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s26" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s27" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s28" + }, + { + "file": "about/migration/migration-migration.json", + "section_id": "s33" + }, + { + "file": "releases/releases/releases-nablarch6-releasenote-6.json", + "section_id": "s2" + } + ] + }, + "step6": { + "verify_result": "PASS", + "regenerated": false + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/answer.md b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/answer.md new file mode 100644 index 000000000..638c3e909 --- /dev/null +++ b/tools/benchmark/results/20260626-1108-stabilization-bm25/run-1/qa-15/answer.md @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +**結論**: Nablarchのカスタムタグは**デフォルトでHTMLエスケープを行う**ため、`writeタグ`などの通常のカスタムタグを使用している限り、XSSの主因となるHTMLエスケープ漏れを防げます。ただし、JavaScriptへのエスケープはNablarchでは提供されておらず、`rawWriteタグ`や`prettyPrintタグ`（非推奨）を使用する際はXSSリスクが発生します。 + +--- + +**根拠**: + +**通常のカスタムタグ（writeタグ等）はHTMLエスケープ済み** + +JSPでEL式（`${...}`）を使って値を出力するとHTMLエスケープされませんが、Nablarchのカスタムタグはデフォルトでエスケープします。カスタムタグを使って実装している限り、HTMLエスケープ漏れを防げます。 + +**HTMLエスケープなしで出力するカスタムタグ（使用注意）** + +以下の2つのタグはHTMLエスケープを行わないため、XSS対策として別途考慮が必要です。 + +| タグ | 説明 | リスク | +|------|------|--------| +| `prettyPrintタグ` | 許可されたHTMLタグをエスケープせず出力 | **非推奨**。`