[focusgroup] Should listbox imply block modifier?

[lukewarlow]

After #1379 we now have some behaviours implying default modifiers. Namely toolbar, tablist, menu and menubar.

I'm wondering if listbox should imply block? The listbox aria role implies aria-orientation vertical and most listboxes are rendered vertically. Also <select size=4> navigates via vertical arrows but not horizontal arrows.

[janewman]

I have a slight preference for not adding any axis restrictions by default, but more than happy to discuss if folks don't think this fits.

[lukewarlow]

I'm curious do you have a specific thinking on why? Just so I can think it over before the meeting.

[janewman]

Just a slight preference "in general". If there is any amount of consensus in the other direction, I'm happy to make the change.

[css-meeting-bot]

The Open UI Community Group just discussed [focusgroup] Should listbox imply block modifier?, and agreed to the following:

• RESOLVED: *Do* add block modifiers by default to listbox.

The full IRC log of that discussion

<masonf> q?
<lwarlow> q?
<lwarlow> Proposed Resolution: Don't add block modifier by default to listbox.
<lwarlow> +0
<lwarlow> Proposed Resolution: *Do* add block modifiers by default to listbox.
<sarah> +1
<lwarlow> +1
<scott> +1
<lwarlow> RESOLVED: *Do* add block modifiers by default to listbox.
<masonf> topic foo

[mfreed7]

Actual meeting notes are here. (I cleaned them up manually, but if I messed something up please ping me privately and I'll correct it.)