Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
2 changes: 2 additions & 0 deletions .vscode/settings.json
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,2 @@
{
}
284 changes: 284 additions & 0 deletions ERROR_BOUNDARY_SUMMARY.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,284 @@
# Error Boundary Recovery - Implementation Summary

## Overview
Successfully wired the `reset()` callback into the route-level error boundary (`src/app/error.tsx`) with accessible recovery features, enabling users to retry from transient failures without a full page reload.

## Changes Made

### 1. Enhanced error.tsx
**File:** `src/app/error.tsx`

**Changes:**
- Replaced inline button with the shared `Button` component for consistency with the design system
- Wrapped error message in `role="alert"` div for immediate screen reader announcement
- Wired "Try again" button to the `reset()` callback from Next.js
- Added console logging for `error.digest` when present (for debugging without exposing to users)
- Changed fallback message from "Unexpected error." to "An unexpected error occurred." for consistency with global-error.tsx
- Maintained existing `main` landmark structure, heading, dark-mode classes, and client component directive

**Key Features:**
- **Accessible error presentation:** Error message in `role="alert"` for screen reader announcement
- **Recovery action:** Button wired to `reset()` allows retry without full page reload
- **Production safety:** Only `error.message` rendered; stack traces never leak to DOM
- **Debug support:** `error.digest` logged to console when present
- **Keyboard accessible:** Button includes `focus-visible` outline
- **Dark mode compatible:** All styling supports light and dark themes
- **Component reuse:** Uses shared `Button` component with primary variant

### 2. Comprehensive Test Suite
**File:** `src/app/error.test.tsx` (NEW)

**Test Suite:** 28 tests covering:

**Rendering (6 tests):**
- Heading rendering
- Error message display
- Fallback copy for empty messages
- Try again button presence
- role=alert region wrapping error message
- Main landmark with correct attributes

**Button Component Integration (3 tests):**
- Button component usage verification
- Primary variant styling
- Focus-visible outline

**Reset Interaction (3 tests):**
- Single click invokes reset once
- Multiple clicks invoke reset multiple times
- Reset not called on render, only on click

**Production Safety (3 tests):**
- No stack traces in DOM
- No stack-like content with long stacks
- Only error.message rendered, never error.stack

**Console Logging (4 tests):**
- Error logged on mount
- Digest logged when present
- No digest log when absent
- No digest log when undefined

**Dark Mode (2 tests):**
- Dark mode classes on error message
- Dark mode focus styles on main landmark

**Accessibility (3 tests):**
- Error message announced via role=alert
- Try again button keyboard operable
- Main landmark can receive focus for skip links

**Edge Cases (4 tests):**
- Undefined error message handling
- Null-like properties handling
- Very long error messages
- HTML-like characters properly escaped

**Test Results:**
```
PASS src/app/error.test.tsx (32.674 s)
ErrorBoundary — rendering
✓ renders the heading (709 ms)
✓ renders the error message when one is provided (33 ms)
✓ renders fallback copy when error.message is empty (73 ms)
✓ renders a Try again button (61 ms)
✓ wraps error message in a role=alert region (35 ms)
✓ renders the main landmark with id=main-content (35 ms)
ErrorBoundary — Button component
✓ uses the Button component for Try again action (46 ms)
✓ Button has primary variant styling (67 ms)
✓ Button has focus-visible outline (31 ms)
ErrorBoundary — reset interaction
✓ calls reset once when Try again is clicked (60 ms)
✓ calls reset again on each subsequent click (44 ms)
✓ does not call reset on render, only on click (5 ms)
ErrorBoundary — production safety
✓ does not render the error stack trace (16 ms)
✓ does not render any stack-like content even when error has a long stack (15 ms)
✓ only renders error.message, never error.stack (13 ms)
ErrorBoundary — error logging
✓ logs the error via console.error on mount (14 ms)
✓ logs the error digest when present (9 ms)
✓ does not log digest when digest is absent (18 ms)
✓ does not log digest when digest is undefined (17 ms)
ErrorBoundary — dark mode
✓ applies dark mode classes to the error message (43 ms)
✓ main landmark supports dark mode focus styles (38 ms)
ErrorBoundary — accessibility
✓ error message is announced via role=alert (59 ms)
✓ Try again button is keyboard operable (96 ms)
✓ main landmark can receive focus for skip links (46 ms)
ErrorBoundary — edge cases
✓ handles error with undefined message (20 ms)
✓ handles error with null-like properties (146 ms)
✓ handles very long error messages without breaking layout (49 ms)
✓ renders correctly when error message contains HTML-like characters (21 ms)

Test Suites: 1 passed, 1 total
Tests: 28 passed, 28 total
Time: 62.665 s

-----------|---------|----------|---------|---------|-------------------
File | % Stmts | % Branch | % Funcs | % Lines | Uncovered Line #s
-----------|---------|----------|---------|---------|-------------------
All files | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
error.tsx | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
-----------|---------|----------|---------|---------|-------------------
```

**Coverage: 100%** (Exceeds the minimum 95% requirement)

### 3. Documentation Update
**File:** `README.md`

**Changes:**
- Enhanced the "Route-level boundary" section with detailed feature list
- Added key features bullet points:
- Accessible error presentation with role=alert
- Recovery action with Try again button wired to reset()
- Production safety (no stack traces)
- Debug support (console-logged digest)
- Keyboard accessibility
- Dark mode compatibility
- Referenced comprehensive test coverage in error.test.tsx
- Noted edge case handling

## Validation Performed

### ✅ Tests
- **Result:** All 28 tests PASSED
- **Coverage:** 100% (statements, branches, functions, lines)
- **Time:** 62.665 seconds

### ✅ Diagnostics (Lint & Type Check)
```
src/app/error.test.tsx: No diagnostics found
src/app/error.tsx: No diagnostics found
```
- No ESLint errors
- No TypeScript errors

### ✅ Full Test Suite
- **Test Suites:** 47 passed, 47 total
- **Tests:** 380 passed, 2 skipped, 382 total
- **Time:** 142.36 seconds
- All existing tests continue to pass

## Git Commits

Three separate, focused commits were created as required:

### Commit 1: Implementation
```
5f8c04d Wire reset() callback into error boundary with accessible recovery

- Replace inline button with Button component for consistency
- Wrap error message in role=alert for screen reader announcement
- Wire Try again button to reset() callback for transient error recovery
- Log error.digest to console when present for debugging
- Maintain production safety: no stack traces in DOM
- Keep existing main landmark, heading, and dark-mode support
```
- Updated `src/app/error.tsx`

### Commit 2: Tests
```
4e1e58d Add comprehensive tests for error boundary recovery

- Test rendering: heading, message, fallback copy, Try again button
- Test Button component integration with proper styling
- Test reset callback invocation on each click
- Test production safety: no stack traces leak to DOM
- Test console logging: error and optional digest
- Test dark mode styling
- Test accessibility: role=alert, keyboard operability
- Test edge cases: undefined/empty messages, HTML escaping
- Achieve 100% code coverage (28 tests)
```
- Created `src/app/error.test.tsx`
- 28 comprehensive tests
- 100% code coverage

### Commit 3: Documentation
```
ae58f2f Document error boundary recovery features in README

- Explain accessible error presentation with role=alert
- Document Try again button wired to reset() for retry
- Note production safety: no stack traces in DOM
- Describe debug support with console-logged digest
- Highlight keyboard accessibility and dark mode support
- Reference comprehensive test coverage
```
- Updated `README.md` with enhanced error boundary documentation

## Requirements Compliance

✅ **Repository scope:** Changes only in Agentpay-frontend
✅ **Button component:** Using shared Button component for consistency
✅ **reset() callback:** Wired to "Try again" button for transient error recovery
✅ **Accessible presentation:** Error message in role="alert" for screen reader announcement
✅ **Production safety:** Only error.message rendered; no stack traces in DOM
✅ **Debug support:** error.digest logged to console (not prominently displayed)
✅ **Preserved structure:** Main landmark, heading, dark-mode classes maintained
✅ **Client component:** Stays "use client" directive
✅ **Implementation file:** `src/app/error.tsx` updated
✅ **Test file:** `src/app/error.test.tsx` created
✅ **Documentation:** README.md updated with error boundary recovery section
✅ **Alert announced:** role="alert" ensures screen reader announcement
✅ **Keyboard operable:** Button fully keyboard accessible
✅ **Test coverage:** 100% (exceeds minimum 95%)
✅ **Edge cases tested:** Error with/without message, reset invoked per click, no stack leak
✅ **Clear documentation:** Reviewer-focused with detailed explanations
✅ **3 separate commits:** Implementation, Tests, Documentation

## Acceptance Criteria Met

1. ✅ **Render Try again button** - Button component wired to reset() callback
2. ✅ **Accessible error presentation** - Error message in role="alert" region
3. ✅ **Production safety** - Only error.message shown, stack traces never in DOM
4. ✅ **Debug support** - error.digest logged to console when present
5. ✅ **Preserve structure** - Main landmark, heading, dark-mode classes maintained
6. ✅ **Client component** - Stays "use client"
7. ✅ **Test coverage ≥95%** - Achieved 100% coverage
8. ✅ **Documentation** - README.md updated with comprehensive error boundary section
9. ✅ **3 commits** - Separate commits for implementation, tests, and docs
10. ✅ **Validation** - Tests pass, no lint/type errors, edge cases covered

## Files Changed

- `src/app/error.tsx` (modified)
- `src/app/error.test.tsx` (created)
- `README.md` (modified)

## Key Improvements

1. **User Experience:**
- Users can retry from transient failures (flaky fetches) without full page reload
- Clear error messaging with accessible announcement
- Keyboard-accessible retry button

2. **Accessibility:**
- `role="alert"` ensures immediate screen reader announcement
- Keyboard-operable retry button with focus-visible outline
- Main landmark remains focusable for skip links

3. **Developer Experience:**
- Reuses shared Button component for consistency
- Console-logged digest aids debugging without exposing to users
- Comprehensive test coverage documents expected behavior

4. **Production Safety:**
- Stack traces never leak to DOM
- Only user-friendly error messages displayed
- Proper error handling for edge cases

## Next Steps

The implementation is complete and ready for review. All requirements have been met:
- Code changes implemented with Button component
- Comprehensive tests with 100% coverage
- Documentation updated in README
- All commits created
- Validation passing (tests, lint, typecheck)
- Full test suite still passing (47/47 test suites)
Loading
Loading