Skip to content

Add collaborative statistical reporting guard#559

Open
AlonePenguin wants to merge 1 commit into
SCIBASE-AI:mainfrom
AlonePenguin:codex/statistical-reporting-consistency-12
Open

Add collaborative statistical reporting guard#559
AlonePenguin wants to merge 1 commit into
SCIBASE-AI:mainfrom
AlonePenguin:codex/statistical-reporting-consistency-12

Conversation

@AlonePenguin
Copy link
Copy Markdown

@algora-pbc /claim #12
/claim #12

Summary

  • Adds collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard/, a dependency-free statistics consistency gate for collaborative manuscript export.
  • Validates sample-size parity across text/tables/figures, p-value wording and table parity, effect-size and confidence-interval consistency, figure statistic parity, locked-section statistical edits, and blocking statistical reviewer comments.
  • Includes clean/risky synthetic fixtures, deterministic tests, JSON/Markdown reports, an SVG dashboard, and a committed MP4 demo artifact.

Issue Fit

This is scoped to the Real-time Collaborative Research Editor issue #12 and is distinct from the existing broad editor, operation replay, offline conflict, notebook/kernel, reference formatting/merge, equation/figure anchor, table formula, terminology/unit consistency, accessibility, suggestion provenance, notification, private-comment export, and data-availability slices. It focuses specifically on statistical reporting consistency before collaborative manuscript export.

Validation

npm --prefix collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard run check
npm --prefix collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard run demo
npm --prefix collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard run make-demo-video
npm --prefix collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard run verify-video

Observed locally:

collaborative statistical reporting guard tests passed
Wrote collaborative statistical reporting guard reports:
- collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard/reports/clean-statistical-reporting-report.json
- collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard/reports/risky-statistical-reporting-report.json
- collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard/reports/risky-statistical-reporting-handoff.md
- collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard/reports/statistical-reporting-dashboard.svg
Wrote collaborative-statistical-reporting-guard/reports/demo.mp4
demo.mp4 verified: h264, 960x540, 4.000s, 18/1

@AlonePenguin
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@algora-pbc /claim #12

Claiming issue #12 for PR #559. The PR body already includes both @algora-pbc /claim #12 and /claim #12, plus local validation output and the committed demo MP4.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant